Podcast
Questions and Answers
Which of the following is classified as natural fruits?
Which of the following is classified as natural fruits?
- Grass (correct)
- Rents
- Rice
- Sugar cane
When does a creditor acquire real rights over the fruits of the thing?
When does a creditor acquire real rights over the fruits of the thing?
- Once the obligation to deliver arises
- After the fruit is produced
- Once the thing has been delivered (correct)
- At the perfection of the contract
Under what condition does the obligation to deliver fruits arise from a contract?
Under what condition does the obligation to deliver fruits arise from a contract?
- When the buyer pays the price
- At the perfection of the contract (correct)
- When the creditor makes a request
- When the fruit is harvested
Civil fruits are derived from which of the following?
Civil fruits are derived from which of the following?
In the case of a suspensive condition, when does the obligation to deliver arise?
In the case of a suspensive condition, when does the obligation to deliver arise?
If a horse gave birth to a colt while sold but not yet delivered, who has the right to the colt?
If a horse gave birth to a colt while sold but not yet delivered, who has the right to the colt?
Which type of fruits are resulting specifically from human cultivation and labor?
Which type of fruits are resulting specifically from human cultivation and labor?
What does 'perfection' refer to in the context of obligations?
What does 'perfection' refer to in the context of obligations?
What distinguishes fraud from negligence?
What distinguishes fraud from negligence?
What kind of waiver is considered valid in cases of fraud?
What kind of waiver is considered valid in cases of fraud?
How does the liability for negligence differ from that of fraud in court?
How does the liability for negligence differ from that of fraud in court?
What is true about the responsibility arising from negligence?
What is true about the responsibility arising from negligence?
Why is a waiver for an action for future fraud deemed void?
Why is a waiver for an action for future fraud deemed void?
What must occur for a debtor to be considered in delay regarding a positive obligation?
What must occur for a debtor to be considered in delay regarding a positive obligation?
Which of the following correctly defines negligence as a ground for liability?
Which of the following correctly defines negligence as a ground for liability?
In which scenario would fraud be established?
In which scenario would fraud be established?
What is a critical requirement for establishing delay (mora) by the debtor?
What is a critical requirement for establishing delay (mora) by the debtor?
Which action constitutes contravention of the terms of an obligation?
Which action constitutes contravention of the terms of an obligation?
In a scenario where a taxi driver is reckless leading to a passenger's injury, what term best describes the liability of the taxi owner?
In a scenario where a taxi driver is reckless leading to a passenger's injury, what term best describes the liability of the taxi owner?
If a debtor fails to respond to a reminder about their obligation but subsequently fulfills it, are they considered to be in delay?
If a debtor fails to respond to a reminder about their obligation but subsequently fulfills it, are they considered to be in delay?
Which best summarizes the grounds for liability due to fraud?
Which best summarizes the grounds for liability due to fraud?
When does B acquire ownership or real right in the case of the horse delivery?
When does B acquire ownership or real right in the case of the horse delivery?
What happens if S sells the horse to C in good faith before delivering to B?
What happens if S sells the horse to C in good faith before delivering to B?
What can a creditor do if the debtor fails to comply with a specific real obligation?
What can a creditor do if the debtor fails to comply with a specific real obligation?
What characterizes a generic real obligation?
What characterizes a generic real obligation?
If S sells his piano to B for $20,000 and refuses to deliver it, what is B’s remedy?
If S sells his piano to B for $20,000 and refuses to deliver it, what is B’s remedy?
Which of the following is true regarding remedies in a generic real obligation?
Which of the following is true regarding remedies in a generic real obligation?
What is an alternative remedy available to a creditor when a debtor fails to fulfill a specific obligation?
What is an alternative remedy available to a creditor when a debtor fails to fulfill a specific obligation?
What is the creditor's responsibility in a situation involving multiple claims on the same item?
What is the creditor's responsibility in a situation involving multiple claims on the same item?
What can be ordered if an obligation is poorly performed?
What can be ordered if an obligation is poorly performed?
In what circumstance cannot a specific performance be ordered in a personal obligation?
In what circumstance cannot a specific performance be ordered in a personal obligation?
What is the outcome if the personal qualifications of the debtor are crucial to the obligation?
What is the outcome if the personal qualifications of the debtor are crucial to the obligation?
If a debtor refuses to comply with his obligation to perform a specific task, what can happen?
If a debtor refuses to comply with his obligation to perform a specific task, what can happen?
What action should be taken if the obligation consists of 'not doing' something and the debtor violates this?
What action should be taken if the obligation consists of 'not doing' something and the debtor violates this?
Which scenario illustrates that a third party cannot perform an obligation due to the debtor's personal qualifications?
Which scenario illustrates that a third party cannot perform an obligation due to the debtor's personal qualifications?
If a debtor performs an obligation poorly but it is still possible to remedy it, what action can the creditor take?
If a debtor performs an obligation poorly but it is still possible to remedy it, what action can the creditor take?
What is a possible consequence if obligations involve personal qualifications and are performed by someone else?
What is a possible consequence if obligations involve personal qualifications and are performed by someone else?
Study Notes
Rights and Obligations of Creditors
- Creditors are entitled to the fruits of the delivered object from the time the obligation arises, but do not gain real rights until delivery occurs.
- Types of fruits include:
- Natural Fruits: Spontaneous products from soil and offspring of animals (e.g., grass, fruits, trees).
- Industrial Fruits: Produced through cultivation or human labor (e.g., sugar cane, vegetables).
- Civil Fruits: Derived from legal relations (e.g., rent, lease payments).
Timing of Obligation to Deliver Fruits
- The obligation to deliver fruits typically arises upon contract perfection or when the contract is agreed upon by both parties.
- In cases of suspensive conditions or periods, the obligation arises upon fulfillment of those conditions.
- In contracts of sale, the obligation to deliver arises even if subject to suspensive conditions if the price is paid.
- Obligations arising from law, quasi-contracts, or delicts follow specific legal provisions.
Examples of Rights to Fruits
- Example illustrated: If a horse is sold and gives birth to a colt before delivery, the buyer (B) is entitled to the colt under certain conditions, including timely delivery.
- Exception: If the seller (S) sells the horse to a third party in good faith before delivery to B, that party obtains ownership.
Creditor's Remedies
- For specific real obligations (determinate things), creditors can:
- Demand specific performance or fulfillment with a right to damages.
- Demand rescission or cancellation, also with a right to damages.
- Seek damages when fulfillment is the only practical remedy.
- In generic real obligations (generic things), performance can be undertaken by a third party.
Personal and Real Obligations
- Personal obligations cannot be enforced through specific performance due to potential involuntary servitude.
- In personal obligations where the debtor's qualifications are crucial, damages are the only remedy if non-performance occurs.
- If the debtor breaches a negative obligation (not to act), non-compliance exists, but delays can’t occur.
Grounds for Liability
- Liability for damages arises from:
- Fraud: Intentional evasion of fulfilling obligations.
- Negligence: Carelessness that impedes the fulfillment of obligations.
- Delay (Mora): Failure to perform on due date after demand.
- Contravention of Terms: Any violation of contract terms.
Fraud vs. Negligence
- Fraud involves intent to cause harm; negligence does not intend harm.
- Waivers of liability for future fraud are not valid, while negligence waivers may be allowed.
- Fraud requires clear proof; negligence may be inferred from contractual breaches.
Responsibilities Related to Fraud and Negligence
- Fraud: Liability is absolute, with a waiver for future fraud deemed invalid.
- Negligence: Liability can be adjusted by courts based on the circumstances.
Key Examples
- In a case of fraud, delivering inferior goods constitutes liability for damages.
- Negligence example: A taxi driver’s recklessness leads to liability for the injuries of a passenger.
- Contractual violations allow landlords to ejected tenants and recover damages accordingly.
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.
Related Documents
Description
Explore the principles of creditor rights and the different kinds of fruits as defined in civil law. This quiz delves into natural and industrial fruits, and the conditions under which creditors can claim them. Test your knowledge on obligations and rights related to property.
