Podcast
Questions and Answers
What are the two opposing theoretical perspectives regarding business planning (BP) in entrepreneurship?
What are the two opposing theoretical perspectives regarding business planning (BP) in entrepreneurship?
One perspective suggests BP fosters decision speed and resource efficiency, while the other argues it can lead to cognitive rigidities and limited flexibility.
Why is there inconsistency in empirical research on the planning-performance relationship?
Why is there inconsistency in empirical research on the planning-performance relationship?
The research findings vary because they draw from heterogeneous samples, including both new and established firms, and lack systematic integration.
What is meant by cognitive rigidities, and how can they affect entrepreneurship?
What is meant by cognitive rigidities, and how can they affect entrepreneurship?
Cognitive rigidities refer to fixed patterns of thinking that can limit an entrepreneur's strategic flexibility and adaptability in decision-making.
What role do universities and BP competitions play in fostering entrepreneurship?
What role do universities and BP competitions play in fostering entrepreneurship?
Signup and view all the answers
How does Evidence-Based Approach (EBA) aim to enhance the understanding of BP's impact on performance?
How does Evidence-Based Approach (EBA) aim to enhance the understanding of BP's impact on performance?
Signup and view all the answers
What are the moderating factors analyzed in the paper that affect the relationship between BP and firm performance?
What are the moderating factors analyzed in the paper that affect the relationship between BP and firm performance?
Signup and view all the answers
Explain the risks associated with type one errors in the context of BP research.
Explain the risks associated with type one errors in the context of BP research.
Signup and view all the answers
What potential drawbacks can arise from focusing too much on business planning?
What potential drawbacks can arise from focusing too much on business planning?
Signup and view all the answers
What are the implications of high uncertainty and missing information on the benefits of business planning (BP) for new firms?
What are the implications of high uncertainty and missing information on the benefits of business planning (BP) for new firms?
Signup and view all the answers
How does the concept of uncertainty avoidance (UA) influence business planning outcomes?
How does the concept of uncertainty avoidance (UA) influence business planning outcomes?
Signup and view all the answers
In what ways does business planning contribute to effective resource utilization?
In what ways does business planning contribute to effective resource utilization?
Signup and view all the answers
What activities should firms prioritize in their initial years according to the implications of business planning?
What activities should firms prioritize in their initial years according to the implications of business planning?
Signup and view all the answers
What role does meta-analysis serve in understanding business planning and performance relationships?
What role does meta-analysis serve in understanding business planning and performance relationships?
Signup and view all the answers
Explain the principle of 'bird in the hand' in the context of effectuation.
Explain the principle of 'bird in the hand' in the context of effectuation.
Signup and view all the answers
What does the 'affordable loss' principle suggest about entrepreneurial risk-taking?
What does the 'affordable loss' principle suggest about entrepreneurial risk-taking?
Signup and view all the answers
How can unexpected events become valuable opportunities according to effectuation principles?
How can unexpected events become valuable opportunities according to effectuation principles?
Signup and view all the answers
What limitation is noted regarding Hofstede's cultural dimensions in relation to business planning?
What limitation is noted regarding Hofstede's cultural dimensions in relation to business planning?
Signup and view all the answers
What key insights are gained from the legitimization benefits of written business planning?
What key insights are gained from the legitimization benefits of written business planning?
Signup and view all the answers
What was the final sample size for studies included in the meta-analysis regarding business planning?
What was the final sample size for studies included in the meta-analysis regarding business planning?
Signup and view all the answers
Why is close execution of a business plan not beneficial per se?
Why is close execution of a business plan not beneficial per se?
Signup and view all the answers
What does the 'crazy quilt' principle emphasize in entrepreneurial strategy?
What does the 'crazy quilt' principle emphasize in entrepreneurial strategy?
Signup and view all the answers
How does the written business plan create symbolic benefits for entrepreneurs?
How does the written business plan create symbolic benefits for entrepreneurs?
Signup and view all the answers
What methodological approaches were utilized in the literature search for the study?
What methodological approaches were utilized in the literature search for the study?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the significance of entrepreneurs taking their product to the nearest potential customer?
What is the significance of entrepreneurs taking their product to the nearest potential customer?
Signup and view all the answers
How can entrepreneurs control their future without needing to predict it?
How can entrepreneurs control their future without needing to predict it?
Signup and view all the answers
What are the potential negative outcomes of early internationalization for a firm's survival?
What are the potential negative outcomes of early internationalization for a firm's survival?
Signup and view all the answers
What does the research aim to resolve regarding early internationalization and firm survival?
What does the research aim to resolve regarding early internationalization and firm survival?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the relationship between intangible assets and a firm's internationalization strategy?
What is the relationship between intangible assets and a firm's internationalization strategy?
Signup and view all the answers
Why is managerial experience important in the context of internationalization?
Why is managerial experience important in the context of internationalization?
Signup and view all the answers
How do older firms face challenges in the context of early internationalization?
How do older firms face challenges in the context of early internationalization?
Signup and view all the answers
What implications do early stages of internationalization have on firm capabilities?
What implications do early stages of internationalization have on firm capabilities?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the significance of hiring managers with international experience for a new venture?
What is the significance of hiring managers with international experience for a new venture?
Signup and view all the answers
What does the S-curve hypothesis imply regarding international diversification and firm performance?
What does the S-curve hypothesis imply regarding international diversification and firm performance?
Signup and view all the answers
What is meant by organizational imprinting in the process of internationalization?
What is meant by organizational imprinting in the process of internationalization?
Signup and view all the answers
In the context of internationalization, how do capabilities developed affect later stages of a firm?
In the context of internationalization, how do capabilities developed affect later stages of a firm?
Signup and view all the answers
What framework aims to explain the influence of internationalization on firm's survival and growth?
What framework aims to explain the influence of internationalization on firm's survival and growth?
Signup and view all the answers
Why do managers need to take a long-term view of internationalization?
Why do managers need to take a long-term view of internationalization?
Signup and view all the answers
What role do structural inertia and rigidities play for firms entering new markets?
What role do structural inertia and rigidities play for firms entering new markets?
Signup and view all the answers
What are the two main types of establishment mode choices (EMC) examined in the research?
What are the two main types of establishment mode choices (EMC) examined in the research?
Signup and view all the answers
Explain the importance of the Resource-Based View (RBV) in the context of EMC.
Explain the importance of the Resource-Based View (RBV) in the context of EMC.
Signup and view all the answers
What is cultural distance (CD) and why is it significant to a firm's EMC?
What is cultural distance (CD) and why is it significant to a firm's EMC?
Signup and view all the answers
What are the components of the VRIN framework?
What are the components of the VRIN framework?
Signup and view all the answers
Identify two types of resources categorized under knowledge-based and experience-based resources.
Identify two types of resources categorized under knowledge-based and experience-based resources.
Signup and view all the answers
Discuss the methodological approach taken in the meta-analysis of EMC.
Discuss the methodological approach taken in the meta-analysis of EMC.
Signup and view all the answers
What was a key finding validated in the study regarding EMC?
What was a key finding validated in the study regarding EMC?
Signup and view all the answers
How does structural integration affect post-merger innovation capabilities?
How does structural integration affect post-merger innovation capabilities?
Signup and view all the answers
Describe the concept of interdependence in relation to structural integration.
Describe the concept of interdependence in relation to structural integration.
Signup and view all the answers
What implications does the research suggest for managers when choosing an EMC?
What implications does the research suggest for managers when choosing an EMC?
Signup and view all the answers
What limitation was identified regarding the categorization of resources in the study?
What limitation was identified regarding the categorization of resources in the study?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the significance of common ground in the context of post-merger integration?
What is the significance of common ground in the context of post-merger integration?
Signup and view all the answers
How is the 'loss of autonomy effect' relevant in technology acquisitions?
How is the 'loss of autonomy effect' relevant in technology acquisitions?
Signup and view all the answers
What was a key gap in prior EMC studies identified in the research?
What was a key gap in prior EMC studies identified in the research?
Signup and view all the answers
What are the two types of coordination mentioned in contrast with each other?
What are the two types of coordination mentioned in contrast with each other?
Signup and view all the answers
How does common ground influence the likelihood of structural integration in technology acquisitions?
How does common ground influence the likelihood of structural integration in technology acquisitions?
Signup and view all the answers
What hypothesis is proposed regarding common ground in acquisitions?
What hypothesis is proposed regarding common ground in acquisitions?
Signup and view all the answers
What research methodology is used for the sample in this study?
What research methodology is used for the sample in this study?
Signup and view all the answers
What years does the data cover for the 207 acquisitions studied?
What years does the data cover for the 207 acquisitions studied?
Signup and view all the answers
Name at least two major firms from which extensive interviews were obtained?
Name at least two major firms from which extensive interviews were obtained?
Signup and view all the answers
What are two critical control variables mentioned in the study?
What are two critical control variables mentioned in the study?
Signup and view all the answers
Why is it difficult for firms to profit from innovation according to the discussed content?
Why is it difficult for firms to profit from innovation according to the discussed content?
Signup and view all the answers
What is one advantage of having a strong appropriability regime?
What is one advantage of having a strong appropriability regime?
Signup and view all the answers
List one formal and one informal IP protection measure.
List one formal and one informal IP protection measure.
Signup and view all the answers
What distinguishes incremental innovation from radical innovation?
What distinguishes incremental innovation from radical innovation?
Signup and view all the answers
What strategy did Merck employ to alter the appropriability regime?
What strategy did Merck employ to alter the appropriability regime?
Signup and view all the answers
What is a potential risk associated with the openness in innovation?
What is a potential risk associated with the openness in innovation?
Signup and view all the answers
How do the authors view technological interdependence in relation to structural integration?
How do the authors view technological interdependence in relation to structural integration?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the duty of beneficence as described in the context of individual actions?
What is the duty of beneficence as described in the context of individual actions?
Signup and view all the answers
List two factors that influence how a company should respond to social issues.
List two factors that influence how a company should respond to social issues.
Signup and view all the answers
According to Instrumental Stakeholder Theory (IST), what two ethical norms can lead to improved financial performance?
According to Instrumental Stakeholder Theory (IST), what two ethical norms can lead to improved financial performance?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the key limitation noted in IST literature regarding ethical stakeholder management?
What is the key limitation noted in IST literature regarding ethical stakeholder management?
Signup and view all the answers
Define an 'Arm's Length Relationship' in the context of stakeholder management.
Define an 'Arm's Length Relationship' in the context of stakeholder management.
Signup and view all the answers
What does the concept of 'bounded self-interest' imply in stakeholder relationships?
What does the concept of 'bounded self-interest' imply in stakeholder relationships?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the primary mechanism through which firms create value for stakeholders, according to the conclusion drawn?
What is the primary mechanism through which firms create value for stakeholders, according to the conclusion drawn?
Signup and view all the answers
Identify one reason why close relationship capabilities with stakeholders are considered rare.
Identify one reason why close relationship capabilities with stakeholders are considered rare.
Signup and view all the answers
What are two characteristics that make close relationship capabilities difficult to imitate?
What are two characteristics that make close relationship capabilities difficult to imitate?
Signup and view all the answers
What does the acronym CSRE stand for in the context of stakeholder management strategies?
What does the acronym CSRE stand for in the context of stakeholder management strategies?
Signup and view all the answers
According to Milton Friedman, what is the primary goal of a firm?
According to Milton Friedman, what is the primary goal of a firm?
Signup and view all the answers
What does stakeholder theory propose about the firm's responsibility?
What does stakeholder theory propose about the firm's responsibility?
Signup and view all the answers
What are the two main concerns raised in the neoclassical view on organizations?
What are the two main concerns raised in the neoclassical view on organizations?
Signup and view all the answers
Name one normative reason to respect stakeholders according to Donaldson and Preston.
Name one normative reason to respect stakeholders according to Donaldson and Preston.
Signup and view all the answers
What is the role of the 'nexus of contracts' in the neoclassical view?
What is the role of the 'nexus of contracts' in the neoclassical view?
Signup and view all the answers
How does stakeholder theory challenge Friedman's traditional view?
How does stakeholder theory challenge Friedman's traditional view?
Signup and view all the answers
What is a key aspect of the descriptive approach to stakeholder theory?
What is a key aspect of the descriptive approach to stakeholder theory?
Signup and view all the answers
What is meant by systematic efforts to fool participants in a business context?
What is meant by systematic efforts to fool participants in a business context?
Signup and view all the answers
What type of research seeks to clarify how corporate actions affect stakeholders?
What type of research seeks to clarify how corporate actions affect stakeholders?
Signup and view all the answers
According to the proposed inductive normative theory, what should be the starting point for actions?
According to the proposed inductive normative theory, what should be the starting point for actions?
Signup and view all the answers
What are the five areas of inquiry proposed for descriptive research in stakeholder engagement?
What are the five areas of inquiry proposed for descriptive research in stakeholder engagement?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the fundamental argument against firms being involved in addressing social misery?
What is the fundamental argument against firms being involved in addressing social misery?
Signup and view all the answers
What does the term 'equivocal response' refer to in corporate social responsibility?
What does the term 'equivocal response' refer to in corporate social responsibility?
Signup and view all the answers
Why is it important for firms to evaluate their responses to social misery?
Why is it important for firms to evaluate their responses to social misery?
Signup and view all the answers
What does an instrumental approach to stakeholder theory investigate?
What does an instrumental approach to stakeholder theory investigate?
Signup and view all the answers
What are the benefits of customers experiencing an SST failure in isolation compared to when observed by other customers?
What are the benefits of customers experiencing an SST failure in isolation compared to when observed by other customers?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the importance of situational awareness in service recovery during SST failures?
What is the importance of situational awareness in service recovery during SST failures?
Signup and view all the answers
Define related diversification and its significance in corporate strategy.
Define related diversification and its significance in corporate strategy.
Signup and view all the answers
What are economies of scope and provide an example of their application?
What are economies of scope and provide an example of their application?
Signup and view all the answers
What are the three tests a diversification move must pass to justify shareholder value?
What are the three tests a diversification move must pass to justify shareholder value?
Signup and view all the answers
How does the design of a self-service area impact customer preferences during service recovery?
How does the design of a self-service area impact customer preferences during service recovery?
Signup and view all the answers
What managerial implications arise from the research on SST failures?
What managerial implications arise from the research on SST failures?
Signup and view all the answers
Why might firms choose to diversify when they face diminishing growth prospects in their current industry?
Why might firms choose to diversify when they face diminishing growth prospects in their current industry?
Signup and view all the answers
What role does the presence of other customers play in the preferred type of service recovery in SST situations?
What role does the presence of other customers play in the preferred type of service recovery in SST situations?
Signup and view all the answers
Explain the concept of strategic fit and its significance for organizations.
Explain the concept of strategic fit and its significance for organizations.
Signup and view all the answers
What is the main assertion of the Service Dominant Logic regarding value creation?
What is the main assertion of the Service Dominant Logic regarding value creation?
Signup and view all the answers
According to Media Richness Theory, what are the characteristics that media should have to be effective?
According to Media Richness Theory, what are the characteristics that media should have to be effective?
Signup and view all the answers
How does Channel Expansion Theory define the perceived richness of a medium?
How does Channel Expansion Theory define the perceived richness of a medium?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the relationship between self-service and personal service usage according to Hypothesis H1?
What is the relationship between self-service and personal service usage according to Hypothesis H1?
Signup and view all the answers
How does the duration of a customer’s relationship with a provider affect their likelihood of defection?
How does the duration of a customer’s relationship with a provider affect their likelihood of defection?
Signup and view all the answers
What limitation does the study identify concerning the focus on one firm?
What limitation does the study identify concerning the focus on one firm?
Signup and view all the answers
What do the authors suggest managers should allow for new customers regarding service channels?
What do the authors suggest managers should allow for new customers regarding service channels?
Signup and view all the answers
How can customer behavior during a self-service failure impact their recovery preferences?
How can customer behavior during a self-service failure impact their recovery preferences?
Signup and view all the answers
What conflicting findings exist regarding customer preferences after a self-service failure?
What conflicting findings exist regarding customer preferences after a self-service failure?
Signup and view all the answers
What could future research on this topic explore according to the limitations mentioned?
What could future research on this topic explore according to the limitations mentioned?
Signup and view all the answers
What effect does high reliance on technology-based self-service have on customer retention?
What effect does high reliance on technology-based self-service have on customer retention?
Signup and view all the answers
How are active customers defined for the purpose of the study’s analysis?
How are active customers defined for the purpose of the study’s analysis?
Signup and view all the answers
What does the study's conclusion imply about the best way to retain customers?
What does the study's conclusion imply about the best way to retain customers?
Signup and view all the answers
What does self-monitoring theory suggest about customer behavior in social situations?
What does self-monitoring theory suggest about customer behavior in social situations?
Signup and view all the answers
What is one financial driver that supports servitization in businesses?
What is one financial driver that supports servitization in businesses?
Signup and view all the answers
Why might sales teams be resistant to selling services in a servitization strategy?
Why might sales teams be resistant to selling services in a servitization strategy?
Signup and view all the answers
How can separation between product and service businesses impact a company's service performance?
How can separation between product and service businesses impact a company's service performance?
Signup and view all the answers
What role do customer insights play in the servitization process?
What role do customer insights play in the servitization process?
Signup and view all the answers
Identify one strategic driver that encourages companies to servitize.
Identify one strategic driver that encourages companies to servitize.
Signup and view all the answers
What limitation is noted regarding the sample in studies about servitization?
What limitation is noted regarding the sample in studies about servitization?
Signup and view all the answers
What is one potential implication of managers adopting a service strategy?
What is one potential implication of managers adopting a service strategy?
Signup and view all the answers
Explain the concept of the product-service paradox in the context of servitization.
Explain the concept of the product-service paradox in the context of servitization.
Signup and view all the answers
What is meant by related diversification?
What is meant by related diversification?
Signup and view all the answers
How does related diversification create strategic fits within a company's value chain?
How does related diversification create strategic fits within a company's value chain?
Signup and view all the answers
What distinguishes unrelated diversification from related diversification?
What distinguishes unrelated diversification from related diversification?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the dominant logic of firms pursuing unrelated diversification?
What is the dominant logic of firms pursuing unrelated diversification?
Signup and view all the answers
What are attractive acquisition targets for companies pursuing unrelated diversification?
What are attractive acquisition targets for companies pursuing unrelated diversification?
Signup and view all the answers
What does the research suggest about the relationship between intangible assets and types of diversification?
What does the research suggest about the relationship between intangible assets and types of diversification?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the ‘diversification discount’ and who is it most applicable to?
What is the ‘diversification discount’ and who is it most applicable to?
Signup and view all the answers
What role does absorptive capacity play in corporate diversification?
What role does absorptive capacity play in corporate diversification?
Signup and view all the answers
How can internal growth strategies impact a firm's valuation compared to acquisitions?
How can internal growth strategies impact a firm's valuation compared to acquisitions?
Signup and view all the answers
What is indicated by the inverted U-shaped relationship in diversification-performance?
What is indicated by the inverted U-shaped relationship in diversification-performance?
Signup and view all the answers
According to the findings, how does resource flexibility relate to diversification types?
According to the findings, how does resource flexibility relate to diversification types?
Signup and view all the answers
How were physical resources, intangible assets, and financial resources measured in the context of diversification?
How were physical resources, intangible assets, and financial resources measured in the context of diversification?
Signup and view all the answers
What is meant by the term 'conglomerate discount'?
What is meant by the term 'conglomerate discount'?
Signup and view all the answers
What factors can influence a firm's decision to diversify into related or unrelated businesses?
What factors can influence a firm's decision to diversify into related or unrelated businesses?
Signup and view all the answers
Why are firms with more diversification often rewarded with value premiums?
Why are firms with more diversification often rewarded with value premiums?
Signup and view all the answers
Study Notes
Business Planning and Performance
- Entrepreneurship education emphasizes the importance of business plans (BP) and their writing.
- BP competitions are major tools to boost entrepreneurship and regional growth globally.
- Investors typically require start-ups to submit BPs before considering investments.
- Two competing theoretical perspectives exist:
- BPs facilitate firm growth by speeding up decision-making and optimizing resource usage. Goal-setting promotes identifying effective steps to achieve those goals.
- BPs can hinder activities like resource attainment or organizational development, leading to cognitive rigidity, organizational inertia, and limited strategic flexibility.
- Existing research on the planning-performance relationship in entrepreneurship is inconsistent, with findings showing negative, null, or positive correlations.
- Research is heterogeneous, including both new and established small firms, neglecting contextual differences between them.
- The external validity and generalizability of findings are questionable without a systematic integration of individual empirical findings.
- Reliant on studies suggesting a positive BP influence without considering contradicting evidence increases the risk of Type I errors – incorrectly assuming a positive BP impact on performance when it doesn't exist.
- A meta-analysis was conducted to address the limitations of individual findings and narrative reviews.
- Individual findings can be skewed by cognitive/normative biases, sampling and measurement issues, stochastic effects, or questionable external validity.
- Narrative reviews often contain stereotypes and biases.
- Meta-analysis is a systematic evaluation of existing empirical findings, originating from medical research.
- This particular meta-analysis aimed:
- To explore the overall relationship between business planning and performance.
- To identify specific contexts where planning-based approaches lead to better performance.
- Moderating factors considered include the firm's stage of development, the type of business planning employed, and the cultural context.
- The study's findings offer valuable insights regarding information requirements for effective planning, the limitations of planning in complex and unpredictable situations, and understanding whether the "liability of newness" can be addressed through BPs.
- It also explores how the legitimization and symbolic benefits of a written BP compare with the learning benefits gained during the business planning process, and how the functions of business planning vary for individuals in different cultural environments.
- The study provided overall support for the idea that BP is a value-creating activity BUT not universally beneficial.
- The findings challenge the common belief that BP is crucial for new firms, specifically demonstrating that:
- High uncertainty and information shortages reduce the positive impact of BP on the performance of new firms.
- Higher levels of uncertainty avoidance diminish the advantages of BP.
- Strict adherence to BPs can hinder strategic flexibility and adaptability to change.
- Benefits of BP stem from both its symbolic and learning aspects.
- The study suggests:
- Basic BP activities are sufficient for firms in their early years.
- Allocate resources towards activities that gather information, reduce uncertainty, and promote learning.
- Extensive pre-planning detached from market interaction and feedback appears detrimental.
- Mental preparedness and willingness to adjust BPs are crucial.
- Close execution of BPs might not be beneficial in itself.
- The study acknowledges potential overlapping between new and established firms and limitations in using Hofstede's four-dimensional culture concept, which oversimplifies cultural diversity and complexity.
- It also highlights that while meta-analysis quantifies the strength of relationships, it doesn't prove causality.
Causation and Effectuation
- This section explores an alternative perspective to traditional business planning in the context of ventures with unknowns:
- How do you price products/services when the market is undefined?
- How do you make pricing decisions for a non-existing firm?
- How do you hire for an organization that doesn't exist?
- How do you attract applicants to a non-existent company whose existence depends on acquiring talent?
- How do you value firms in an industry that didn't exist before and is still newly forming?
- How do you establish a capitalist economy from a former communist one?
- Causation: The concept of causation assumes a known goal or effect and focuses on the selection of means to achieve that effect.
- Effectuation: The concept of effectuation starts with a set of available means and seeks to discover possible effects that can be achieved with those means.
-
Effectuation Principles
-
"Bird in the hand": Expert entrepreneurs begin with their existing resources:
- Who they are
- What they know
- Who they know
- They leverage these resources to imagine possibilities and take action.
- Goals emerge through imagination, aspirations, and interactions during the process.
-
"Affordable loss": Entrepreneurs focus on what they're willing to lose (affordable loss), rather than what they expect to gain.
- Affordable loss depends on the individual, not the venture.
- This approach reduces reliance on predictions and promotes the development of opportunities with lower perceived failure costs, generating future options.
-
"Lemonade": Unexpected events can be opportunities. Entrepreneurs embrace surprises and leverage them into advantages.
- Traditional BP often views surprises negatively, as worst-case scenarios.
- Effectuation removes reliance on predetermined "markets," allowing surprises to create valuable opportunities.
-
"Crazy quilt": Partnerships are prioritized over competition.
- Traditional BP often emphasizes competition over collaboration.
- Competitive analyses have limited value when markets are undefined.
- Entrepreneurs connect with potential customers and build strategic networks, shaping both the venture's direction and potential markets.
-
"Pilot in the plane": Entrepreneurs focus on controlling their environment.
- Effectuation recognizes that the future is molded by human action.
- It emphasizes understanding and collaborating with individuals involved in shaping the future.
-
"Bird in the hand": Expert entrepreneurs begin with their existing resources:
Early Internationalization and Firm Performance
- Early internationalizers challenge traditional internationalization theories.
- Traditional theories suggest internationalization is an incremental process starting late in the firm's life cycle.
- Early internationalization potentially has negative consequences for firm survival.
- Early internationalization in technology-intensive industries can accelerate firm growth.
- Existing frameworks for internationalization timing, such as the Process Theory of Internationalization (PTI) and the Internalization Theory (INV), don’t adequately explain the impact of early internationalization on survival and growth.
- The paper aims to:
- Develop a framework analyzing the influence of internationalization on firm survival and growth, based on the dynamic capabilities view of the firm.
- Explain why early internationalization affects new ventures' growth and survival differently.
- Build upon organizational survival literature and theorize that age at internationalization, managerial experience, and resource fungibility moderate the influence of internationalization on survival and growth.
- The study suggests:
- Existing frameworks highlight the importance of experience, learning, and knowledge, while overlooking enablers and constraints for early internationalization.
- Early internationalization differentiates between growth and survival outcomes.
- Initial stages of internationalization can be challenging, as developing necessary capabilities and lacking positional advantages can threaten survival.
- Later stages allow capabilities developed during the internationalization process to contribute to organizational adaptability and growth.
- Early capability development and imprinting enable rapid growth.
- Managers can leverage routines from other settings to overcome time and cost barriers to capability development in new markets, substituting organizational experience with their own management experience.
- The study's implications for practice are:
- Early internationalization is a risk for entrepreneurs seeking long-term self-employment.
- Internationalization increases the chances of building a venture with high potential.
- Experiences gained from failures before establishing successful ventures can improve the chances of future success.
- Older firms face learning disadvantages with elevated costs of capability development.
- Firms need to overcome structural inertia and rigidities to learn about new markets and adapt routines and resource configurations.
- Hiring managers with international experience enhances venture growth and survival prospects.
International Diversification and Firm Performance
- The relationship between international diversification and firm performance is complex, with benefits and costs involved.
- The study sought to:
- Synthesize previous research on geographical diversification and firm performance.
- Develop a theoretical framework integrating asset-based internalization advantages with other internationalization costs and benefits over time.
- Examine how internationalization motives affect the performance outcomes of geographical diversification strategies.
- Empirically test the theoretical model using longitudinal data from 1,489 Japanese firms and their internationalization activities.
- Intangible assets (IA) like technological know-how, patents, management skills, brands, and goodwill positively moderate the exploitation benefits of a firm’s internationalization strategy.
- IA development requires considerable resources, but their value is not proportionate to the resources invested.
- Firms with more IA achieve higher returns from their foreign direct investment (FDI) by optimizing scale and scope economies in their IA exploitation.
- The study found that:
- IA enhance the benefits of geographical expansion by firms.
- The findings suggest that researchers should:
- Consider a broader range of samples when analyzing strategic questions.
- Managers should adopt a long-term perspective on internationalization and develop capabilities for managing complexity.
Foreign Establishment Mode Choice
- The study focused on the choice of foreign market entry modes, specifically acquisition versus greenfield investment, both resource-intensive.
- Existing research on establishment mode choice (EMC) has limitations:
- While firms vary in their resources, previous research has focused only on a single resource at a time.
- The influence of resources on EMC has diverse theoretical explanations and inconclusive empirical findings.
- The specific conditions under which resources affect firm EMC remain unclear.
- The research draws upon the resource-based view (RBV), which emphasizes managing valuable, rare, inimitable, and non-substitutable resources to achieve sustainable competitive advantages.
- However, context-dependency of the RBV is crucial, as unfamiliar environments create information deficits that affect resource management.
- Cultural distance (CD) between the home and host countries hinders information flow between markets, acting as a significant source of such deficits.
- Specific types of resources become especially valuable in the presence of CD.
- This meta-analysis aimed to:
- Analyze the impact of knowledge-based and experience-based resources on a firm's EMC.
- Examine how the relationship varies with CD.
- Conduct a meta-analysis to determine overall trends and effect sizes based on a wide range of empirical studies.
- The contributions of this meta-analysis:
- To provide a framework based on the RBV, explaining how firms utilize existing resources and seek new ones through their EMC.
- To address inconclusive findings by focusing on the relationship between diverse resource types and EMC, considering the boundary condition of cultural distance.
- Resources were categorized as:
- Knowledge-based resources: Technological resources, marketing resources.
- Experience-based resources: General international experience, host country experience, acquisition experience, greenfield experience.
- The study found that:
- Both knowledge-based and experience-based resources influence a firm's EMC choice.
- CD moderates the relationship between knowledge-based/experience-based resources and EMC.
Integrating Acquired Capabilities
- Mergers and acquisitions can inadvertently hinder innovation within organizations.
- Post-merger integration is crucial for success. This involves integrating formerly independent organizational units.
- The process of integration can pose a significant challenge, potentially diminishing the very innovative capabilities that made the acquired company attractive in the first place.
- Interdependence often motivates structural integration, but pre-existing common ground offers an alternative approach for achieving coordination.
- Prior research on post-merger integration has focused more on its consequences than its causes.
- This study explores potential downsides of structural integration in technology-based acquisitions, highlighting the short-term and long-term costs involved:
- Short-term costs:
- Processes associated with structural integration introduce costs.
- Long-term costs:
- Loss of autonomy, reduced productivity, decreased motivation, free riding.
- Agency theory suggests that structural integration weakens the link between reward and effort by increasing the number of other individuals whose actions affect unit performance.
- Changes can alter valuable organizational routines within the acquired company, potentially undermining its innovative capabilities.
- Short-term costs:
- The study offers critical insights into the challenges and potential pitfalls of structural integration in technology acquisitions, particularly in terms of innovation preservation and the potential disruption of valuable organizational routines.
Structural Integration in Acquisitions
- Structural integration is a way to achieve coordination between acquiring and target firms, especially when there is significant interdependence between them.
- Interdependence refers to the value of one activity depending on how another activity is performed.
-
Types of Interdependence:
- Pooled: Activities can be performed independently but share resources (eg., marketing, development, training, operations)
- Sequential: Activities are performed in a specific order, where the output of one becomes the input of the next (eg., analyze, design, develop, test)
- Reciprocal: Activities are highly dependent on each other, requiring continuous communication and adjustment (eg., complex product development)
Common Ground and Structural Integration
- Common ground refers to shared knowledge, beliefs, and suppositions between individuals.
- While structural integration relies on formal mechanisms like procedures and goals, common ground facilitates informal coordination.
- Common ground can minimize disruption effects that accompany structural integration as it doesn't require changes to the formal organization.
Hypothesis:
- Hypothesis 1: Structural integration is more likely in technology acquisitions when the acquisition targets a specific component technology rather than a standalone product.
- Hypothesis 2: High levels of common ground between individuals from acquiring and acquired firms decrease the likelihood of structural integration in component technology acquisitions.
Sample and Data
- The study used an event study methodology looking at acquisitions of established firms.
- The focus was on the information technology hardware industry due to its high acquisition activity and access to interview data at key companies (Intel, Cisco Systems, Hewlett Packard).
- Data included 207 acquisitions by 49 acquirers between 1988 and 1998.
Other Measures
- Component vs. Standalone Technology: Determined by export coding and inter-rater reliability.
- Common Ground: Measured by pre-acquisition patenting activity of the acquiring and acquired firms in the same technology classes.
- Control Variables: Factors like target size, age, quality; product market relatedness; acquirer size, acquisition experience, and R&D intensity.
Implications for Theory and Practice
- Theory: Interdependence helps explain structural integration in technology acquisitions, highlighting the role of knowledge overlap and absorptive capacity in acquiring non-overlapping knowledge.
- Practice: Developing common ground can balance the need for integration with preserving autonomy in acquisitions.
Why Innovation is Difficult to Monetize
- Research and Development (R&D) Costs: Innovative development is expensive.
-
Pioneering Disadvantages:
- First movers often face uncertainty in finding a market fit.
- Initial products are prone to imperfections.
-
Fast followers and late entrants:
- Benefit from avoiding early customer support burdens.
- Can leverage competitor data for product improvements and quality control.
- Imitation and Price Competition: Competitors can copy successful innovations at lower costs.
-
Lack of Complementary Assets:
- The PFI Framework highlights the need for essential assets (eg., marketing, distribution, legal) to complement innovation for successful commercialization.
Appropriability Regimes
- An appropriability regime describes the ability of a firm to capture the value generated by its innovation.
- Complete Appropriation: Occurs when competitors cannot use or copy the innovation, maximizing the innovator's value share and bargaining power.
Asset Types and Value Capturing
-
Asset Types:
- Intangible Assets: Patents, copyrights, trademarks, trade secrets, human capital.
- Tangible Assets: Infrastructure, resources, equipment.
- Who Benefits: Value capture is influenced by the nature and control of assets, as well as appropriability regimes.
- James, Leiblein and Lu's Value Capture Model identifies factors like appropriability, asset specificity, and firm capabilities that determine how value is captured.
Formal and Informal IP Protection
-
Formal IP Protection:*
- Patents: Protect inventions.
- Copyrights: Protect creative works.
- Design Rights: Protect aesthetic features.
- Breeders Rights: Protect new plant varieties.
- Trademarks: Protect brand names and logos.
- Legal Contracts: Enforce agreements.
-
Informal IP Protection:*
- Complexity: Complicated processes difficult to replicate.
- Lead-time Advantage: First-mover advantage.
- Trade Secrets: Confidential information.
- Human Resources: Skilled employees as a competitive advantage.
- Psychological Contracts: Informal agreements based on trust and mutual understanding.
- Reputational Assets: Strong brand image.
- Design-in Switching Costs: Customers are reluctant to switch to alternatives.
- Lock-in Raw Materials/Suppliers: Exclusive access to key resources.
- Cannibalization Concerns: Avoiding competition from own innovations.
Open Innovation: Breadth and Depth of Search
- Open Innovation involves seeking ideas and resources from external sources.
-
Risks:
- External parties may exploit resources.
- Protecting proprietary knowledge may be difficult.
Incremental vs. Radical Innovation
- Incremental Innovation: Minor improvements on existing products or services.
- Radical Innovation: Significant advancements creating new knowledge and technologies.
Merck's Appropriability Strategy: "Property-Preempting Investments"
- Merck, known for its cardiovascular drugs, aimed to secure its future R&D by preemptively making gene sequences publicly available.
- This prevented the privatization of genetic information that could have hindered its future research objectives.
Strengthening Appropriability Regimes: IP at Standard-Setting Bodies
- Firms play a key role in setting industry standards, influencing the design and adoption of technologies.
- This can influence intellectual property rights and appropriability regimes.
Shareholder vs. Stakeholder Orientated Growth
- Milton Friedman's View: Firms should primarily focus on profit maximization for shareholders, who can then decide how to allocate their returns to societal interests.
- Stakeholder Theory (Freeman, 1984): Challenges the shareholder-centric view, arguing that firms need to consider the interests of all stakeholders (including employees, customers, suppliers, communities) for sustainable profit and survival.
Margolis & Walsh's View on Social Initiatives
- Organizations are often pressured to address social issues.
- Traditionally, the "Nexus of Contracts" view argues that corporations are primarily legal entities that focus on contractual obligations.
- This perspective challenges the legitimacy of companies responding to social issues, assuming that only governments should address societal problems.
Two Concerns with Corporate Social Initiatives
- Misappropriation: Managers may misuse company resources for personal gains or purposes unrelated to shareholder interests.
- Misallocation: Resources may be diverted to social initiatives, potentially hindering their use for more profitable or efficient activities.
Types of Stakeholder Theory
- Descriptive Stakeholder Theory: Analyzes how managers actually consider and respond to stakeholder interests.
- Normative Stakeholder Theory: Examines whether managers should consider stakeholders beyond shareholders and the ethical justification for doing so.
- Instrumental Stakeholder Theory (IST): Investigates the financial consequences of considering stakeholder interests, suggesting that ethical stakeholder relationships can lead to improved performance.
Donaldson and Preston's Normative Reasons for Respecting Stakeholders
- Employee Dignity and Self-Efficacy: Recognizing the inherent worth and capabilities of employees.
- Principles of Fairness and Reciprocity: Acting justly with stakeholders.
- Fundamental Rights: Protecting basic human rights.
- Respect for the Intrinsic Worth of Human Beings: Valuing individuals’ dignity and autonomy.
The Antinomy of Profit and Service
- The tension between prioritizing profit and serving societal interests is a common challenge for firms.
-
Two Avenues of Response:
- Invalidation: Rejecting the idea that these goals are inherently in conflict.
- Reconciliation: Seeking ways to balance profit and social responsibility.
Towards a Normative Stakeholder Theory of the Firm
- A normative stakeholder theory aims to clarify conflicting considerations and understand their ethical weight in specific situations.
Five Areas of Inquiry for Descriptive Research on Corporate Social Responsibility
- Identifying Stimuli: Understanding which social issues attract attention.
- Generating Response Options: Exploring various approaches to addressing social issues.
- Evaluating Options: Analyzing criteria used to assess corporate social responsibility initiatives.
- Implementation: Examining how companies implement their social responsibility efforts.
- Consequences: Evaluating the actual impact of corporate social responsibility on beneficiaries.
Response Types: Equivocal, Ambivalent, and Ambidextrous
- Equivocal Response: Uncertainty or indecision in addressing social issues.
- Ambivalent Response: Exhibiting mixed emotions or conflicting views on social responsibility.
- Ambidextrous Response: Adopting both profit-oriented and socially responsible strategies.
An Inductive Approach to Normative Theory
- This approach starts with a specific situation and asks how one should act, focusing on the relevant considerations, duties, and concerns involved.
The Duty to Aid and Respond
- Corporations may have a duty to respond to social issues when:
- They contribute to the conditions causing these problems.
- They benefit from detrimental or unjust circumstances.
- The principle of beneficence applies, suggesting an obligation to help those in need.
Determining a Company's Response
- Factors influencing a company's response to social issues:
- The nature of the problem.
- The characteristics of the company.
- The company's relationship to the problem.
- The potential impact of the company's response.
Conclusion: Understanding Conditions for Societal Benefits
- Before assuming a direct link between a firm's social and financial performance, it's essential to understand the conditions under which corporate efforts actually benefit society.
Instrumental Stakeholder Theory (IST)
- IST argues that ethical stakeholder relationships can lead to improved financial performance.
- IST highlights the potential for fairness, trustworthiness, loyalty, care, and respect to drive positive outcomes.
Challenges to IST: Unanswered Questions
- Rarity and Imitability: Do ethical stakeholder relationships create resources that are rare and difficult for competitors to imitate?
- Sunny Side Bias: Does the focus on benefits ignore the potential costs of close stakeholder relationships?
- Context Dependency: Do ethical stakeholder management strategies always lead to higher financial performance, or are there contextual factors that influence their efficacy?
Arm's Length vs. Integrated Relationships
- Arm's Length Relationship: Characterized by low relationship investment, trust, and minimal expectations of future interaction.
- Integrated Relationship: Involves high levels of connection, trust, and commitment across organizational boundaries.
Bosse, Philips, and Harrison's Stakeholder Reciprocity and Firm Performance
- The authors challenge the self-interested maximizer model of economic theory.
- They propose that "homo reciprocans" (reciprocating individuals) are more representative of human behavior, as people assess fairness and reciprocate by rewarding those they deem fair and punishing those they deem unfair.
- Reciprocity is essential for value creation and distribution, as firms create value by distributing it to stakeholders who act fairly.
Fairness Dimensions
- Distributive Fairness: Perceptions of fairness in the allocation of resources and benefits.
- Procedural Fairness: Perceptions of fairness in the procedures used to make decisions.
- Interactional Fairness: Perceptions of fairness in the treatment of individuals during social interactions.
Rent, Reciprocity, and Stakeholders
- Firms generate "rents" when they can compensate all stakeholders for their contributions and provide some with additional gains.
- The reciprocity of fairness is central to creating and distributing these rents.
CSRE vs. ALRE Strategies
- CSRE (Close Stakeholder Relationship Engagement) Strategies: Emphasize building close, trusting relationships with their stakeholders.
- ALRE (Arm's Length Relationship Engagement) Strategies: Maintain more transactional, less committed relationships with stakeholders.
Why Close Relationship Capability is Rare and Difficult to Imitate
-
Rarity:
- Arm's length relationships are more common.
- Managers may lack motivation to adopt CSRE norms.
- CSRE strategies may be difficult to complement with existing resources.
- Finding suitable stakeholder partners for close relationships can be challenging.
-
Imitability:
- Path Dependency: The history of a firm's relationships influences its current capabilities.
- Causal Ambiguity: It may be difficult to pinpoint the exact reasons for success in building close relationships.
- Social Complexity: Organizational trust and commitment are built over time through complex social interactions.
Limitations to the Literature
- Dichotomy: Treating stakeholder engagement as solely a dichotomy between CSRE and ALRE may oversimplify reality.
- Focus on Dyadic Relationships and Groups: Research often focuses on one-on-one relationships or stakeholder groups, neglecting wider network effects.
- Cultural Feasibility: Strategies may be culturally dependent, varying between collectivistic and individualistic cultures.
- Measurement Problems: Challenges exist in accurately measuring the constructs of stakeholder engagement and reciprocity.
- Dependent Variables: Financial performance may not be the only relevant outcome measure, considering other factors like stakeholder well-being and happiness.
Scherer, Wunderlich, and Von Wangenheim's Research on Self-Service
-
Theories:
- Service Dominant Logic: Value is co-created between service providers and customers.
- Media Richness Theory: Media richness influences how well information and complex tasks can be communicated.
- Channel Expansion Theory: A customer's perception of media richness depends on their personal experience with it.
-
Value Propositions:
- Rich, Personal Service Channels: Best for complex and ambiguous tasks.
- Lean, Standardized Self-Service Channels: Suitable for simple and repetitive tasks.
-
Hypotheses:
- H1 (U-Shaped Relationship): The ratio of self-service to personal service usage impacts customer defection, with high levels of either leading to higher defection rates and intermediate levels leading to lower rates.
- H2 (Time as Moderator): The length of customer relationship moderates the impact of the self-service ratio on defection.
Study Design: Sample, Analyses, & Conclusion
- Sample: Data from a European car manufacturer and roadside assistance service provider, including customer usage data.
- Analyses: Testing the hypotheses using statistical methods.
- Conclusion: The study supported the hypotheses, demonstrating the complex relationship between self-service, personal service, and customer defection.
Customer Preferences in Self Service Failure Recovery
- Customers experiencing an SST failure in isolation prefer employees to completely take over the transaction after the failure.
- Customers experiencing an SST failure in the presence of other customers prefer employees to correct the problem and let them complete the transaction.
- The design of a self-service area can influence the preferred type of service recovery.
- The "self" in self-service refers to the customer's ability to complete a transaction independently.
Diversification
- Diversification is a corporate strategy to enter a new market or industry while creating a new product for that market.
- Firms diversify when they have excess resources, capabilities, and core competencies that can be applied to new markets.
- Diminishing growth prospects in the current industry can lead to diversification.
- Cost saving opportunities can be achieved through diversification.
- Capturing strategic fits, capturing financial economies, spreading business risk, and leveraging brand name are motivations for diversification.
Economies of Scope
- Economies of scope exist when a firm expands the variety or scope of its activities.
- Examples include:
- A lumber company selling chipped bark for lawn decoration.
- A finance company using financial data to produce marketing reports.
- A slaughterhouse inventing hot dogs.
Strategic Fit
- Strategic fit is measured by how well an organization matches its resources and capabilities with opportunities in the external environment.
Diversification Tests
- A diversification move must pass three tests:
- The industry attractiveness test.
- The cost of entry test.
- The better off test.
Diversification Decisions
- Decisions regarding the level and degree of diversification, the number and relatedness of businesses, and the mode of diversification must be made when deciding to diversify.
Related Diversification
- Related diversification involves diversifying into businesses with technological similarity.
- Firms can leverage existing technical know-how to gain an advantage in related diversification.
Unrelated Diversification
- Unrelated diversification involves diversifying into businesses with no strategic fit, no meaningful value chain, and no unifying strategic theme.
- Companies with undervalued assets, companies in financial distress, and companies with bright prospects but limited capital are attractive acquisition targets for unrelated diversification.
Resource Profile and Diversification (Chatterjee and Wernerfelt, 1991)
- They proposed that firms deploy their resources to markets expected to yield the most profits.
- Intangible assets contribute to related diversification.
- Internal funds or unused debt capacity favor unrelated diversification.
- Equity capital favors related diversification.
Organizational Learning and Corporate Diversification Performance (Andreou et al., 2016)
- Diversification, on average, destroys shareholder value.
- There is a value discount for single-business firms that diversify once.
- Firms with more diversifications achieve value premiums.
- Firms that diversify through internal growth perform better than firms that pursue acquisitions.
Drivers of Servitization
- Financial drivers:
- Higher profit margin.
- Less sensitivity to price-based competition.
- More resistance to economic cycles.
- Strategic drivers:
- Differentiating manufacturing offerings.
- Sustainable competitive advantage.
- Marketing drivers:
- Total cost of ownership.
- Services induce repeat sales.
- Customer insights enable the development of tailored solutions.
Separating or Integrating Product and Service Business (Oliva, Gebauer, & Brann, 2012)
- Separating service organizations supports service strategy deployment in product manufacturing firms.
- A separate service organization enables firms to engage directly with customer practices and processes.
Key Findings
- Customers prefer complete employee involvement in service recovery when they are alone.
- They prefer employee support but retain control when others are present.
- Diversification can be beneficial but must be strategically considered.
- Intangible assets favor related diversification.
- Internal growth outperforms acquisitions in diversification.
- A separate service organization can enhance service performance.
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.
Description
This quiz explores the theoretical perspectives of business planning in entrepreneurship and examines the relationship between planning and performance. Key concepts such as cognitive rigidities, moderating factors, and the role of universities in fostering entrepreneurship are discussed. Test your understanding of various risks and implications concerning business planning in uncertain environments.