Podcast
Questions and Answers
What is one of Borg's primary goals regarding machine utilization?
What is one of Borg's primary goals regarding machine utilization?
To make efficient use of Google's fleet of machines.
How does Borg reduce correlated failures in task management?
How does Borg reduce correlated failures in task management?
By spreading tasks of a job across failure domains like machines and racks.
What is the significance of increasing utilization by a few percentage points?
What is the significance of increasing utilization by a few percentage points?
It can result in savings of millions of dollars.
What does the left column of the cells in the provided figure represent?
What does the left column of the cells in the provided figure represent?
What would be the effect of segregating prod and non-prod workloads?
What would be the effect of segregating prod and non-prod workloads?
In the context of Borg, what is meant by 'overhead from segregation'?
In the context of Borg, what is meant by 'overhead from segregation'?
Why is it important to limit the allowed rate of task disruptions?
Why is it important to limit the allowed rate of task disruptions?
What do the graphs in the figure illustrate about additional machines needed?
What do the graphs in the figure illustrate about additional machines needed?
What role do priorities play in Borg's resource management?
What role do priorities play in Borg's resource management?
What is the purpose of the Borg name service (BNS)?
What is the purpose of the Borg name service (BNS)?
How does Borg handle the situation when more work arrives than can be accommodated?
How does Borg handle the situation when more work arrives than can be accommodated?
Explain the cascading effect of preemption in Borg.
Explain the cascading effect of preemption in Borg.
What specific bands does Borg define for priority tasks?
What specific bands does Borg define for priority tasks?
Why are tasks in the production priority band disallowed to preempt one another?
Why are tasks in the production priority band disallowed to preempt one another?
How does Borg utilize Chubby for managing job information?
How does Borg utilize Chubby for managing job information?
What is the format used to reach a specific task in Borg?
What is the format used to reach a specific task in Borg?
What is the purpose of specifying a resource limit in a job?
What is the purpose of specifying a resource limit in a job?
How does Borg respond to tasks that try to exceed their allocated resources?
How does Borg respond to tasks that try to exceed their allocated resources?
What issue can arise when users request more resources than their tasks require?
What issue can arise when users request more resources than their tasks require?
In what situation might a task need to use all its resources?
In what situation might a task need to use all its resources?
What does the 1ms threshold in scheduling delays signify?
What does the 1ms threshold in scheduling delays signify?
What percentage of the time did threads wait longer than 5ms for CPU access, according to the data?
What percentage of the time did threads wait longer than 5ms for CPU access, according to the data?
What can be inferred from the latency-sensitive tasks being represented on the left side of the bar chart?
What can be inferred from the latency-sensitive tasks being represented on the left side of the bar chart?
What is indicated by the error bars in the scheduling data?
What is indicated by the error bars in the scheduling data?
What mechanism does the Borglet use to dynamically adjust resource caps for tasks?
What mechanism does the Borglet use to dynamically adjust resource caps for tasks?
Why do some users inflate their resource requests in Borg?
Why do some users inflate their resource requests in Borg?
What scheduling mechanism is mentioned as requiring tuning to support both low latency and high utilization?
What scheduling mechanism is mentioned as requiring tuning to support both low latency and high utilization?
What is one way the Borglet mitigates the effects of persistent load imbalances?
What is one way the Borglet mitigates the effects of persistent load imbalances?
What approach does the Borglet take when tasks consume too many resources?
What approach does the Borglet take when tasks consume too many resources?
What recent developments are being focused on to improve the performance of the Borglet?
What recent developments are being focused on to improve the performance of the Borglet?
What are cpusets used for in the context of the Borglet?
What are cpusets used for in the context of the Borglet?
What type of resource interference can still occur among tasks despite Borglet’s control?
What type of resource interference can still occur among tasks despite Borglet’s control?
What is the primary approach Borg takes towards debugging information for users?
What is the primary approach Borg takes towards debugging information for users?
What challenge does Borg face when it comes to deprecating features?
What challenge does Borg face when it comes to deprecating features?
What tools does Borg provide to handle the volume of debugging data?
What tools does Borg provide to handle the volume of debugging data?
How does Kubernetes relate to Borg in terms of introspection techniques?
How does Kubernetes relate to Borg in terms of introspection techniques?
What mechanism does Kubernetes use to record events?
What mechanism does Kubernetes use to record events?
Who were the primary designers and implementers of the initial Borgmaster?
Who were the primary designers and implementers of the initial Borgmaster?
What role does the master play in the Borg system?
What role does the master play in the Borg system?
What is the purpose of using tools like Elasticsearch/Kibana and Fluentd in Kubernetes?
What is the purpose of using tools like Elasticsearch/Kibana and Fluentd in Kubernetes?
What is the primary function of Apollo's opportunistic execution feature?
What is the primary function of Apollo's opportunistic execution feature?
How does Apache Mesos manage resource allocation differently from Borg?
How does Apache Mesos manage resource allocation differently from Borg?
What is a unique aspect of YARN as a cluster manager in comparison to others?
What is a unique aspect of YARN as a cluster manager in comparison to others?
What challenges do large-scale server clusters face according to the studies analyzed?
What challenges do large-scale server clusters face according to the studies analyzed?
In what year did Alibaba's Fuxi system start running, and what type of workloads does it support?
In what year did Alibaba's Fuxi system start running, and what type of workloads does it support?
What prediction capabilities do Apollo nodes provide regarding task scheduling?
What prediction capabilities do Apollo nodes provide regarding task scheduling?
How do DRF and Borg differ in terms of resource allocation strategies?
How do DRF and Borg differ in terms of resource allocation strategies?
What optimization goal do the Mesos developers have for their system?
What optimization goal do the Mesos developers have for their system?
How do users initiate job operations in Borg, and what is one common tool used for this?
How do users initiate job operations in Borg, and what is one common tool used for this?
Describe the nature of updates made to a running job configuration in Borg.
Describe the nature of updates made to a running job configuration in Borg.
What features of BCL facilitate job configuration adjustments in Borg?
What features of BCL facilitate job configuration adjustments in Borg?
What is the significance of rolling updates in Borg job management?
What is the significance of rolling updates in Borg job management?
Explain the task lifecycle states within the Borg system as mentioned in the diagram.
Explain the task lifecycle states within the Borg system as mentioned in the diagram.
What are the primary characteristics that define a cluster in a datacenter?
What are the primary characteristics that define a cluster in a datacenter?
Describe the role of a Borg job and its associated properties.
Describe the role of a Borg job and its associated properties.
What strategies does Borg use to manage heterogeneous machines within a cell?
What strategies does Borg use to manage heterogeneous machines within a cell?
Explain the difference between hard and soft constraints in the context of a Borg job.
Explain the difference between hard and soft constraints in the context of a Borg job.
What is the significance of defining task resource requirements independently in Borg?
What is the significance of defining task resource requirements independently in Borg?
How does Borg minimize the overhead associated with virtualization in its workload management?
How does Borg minimize the overhead associated with virtualization in its workload management?
What role does task monitoring play in Borg’s operation?
What role does task monitoring play in Borg’s operation?
Identify one key reason why Borg prefers statically linked programs.
Identify one key reason why Borg prefers statically linked programs.
What is a potential problem that can occur due to task preemption in Borg?
What is a potential problem that can occur due to task preemption in Borg?
Explain why quota is significant in Borg's job scheduling.
Explain why quota is significant in Borg's job scheduling.
What signal do tasks in Borg use to request clean termination before a forceful kill?
What signal do tasks in Borg use to request clean termination before a forceful kill?
How does Borg utilize fine-grained priorities in its task management?
How does Borg utilize fine-grained priorities in its task management?
What happens to jobs with insufficient quota in Borg?
What happens to jobs with insufficient quota in Borg?
How does Borg define priority for tasks, and what is its effect on resource allocation?
How does Borg define priority for tasks, and what is its effect on resource allocation?
Discuss the significance of the Borg name service (BNS) in task management.
Discuss the significance of the Borg name service (BNS) in task management.
What occurs when an alloc in Borg must be relocated to another machine?
What occurs when an alloc in Borg must be relocated to another machine?
What is the purpose of an alloc set in Borg?
What is the purpose of an alloc set in Borg?
Why might users overbuy quota in Borg?
Why might users overbuy quota in Borg?
What role does Chubby play in Borg's resource and task management?
What role does Chubby play in Borg's resource and task management?
What are the potential consequences for jobs when workload exceeds available resources in Borg?
What are the potential consequences for jobs when workload exceeds available resources in Borg?
What happens to tasks that are in the monitoring and production priority bands in Borg?
What happens to tasks that are in the monitoring and production priority bands in Borg?
How does Borg's priority system impact the running of production-priority jobs?
How does Borg's priority system impact the running of production-priority jobs?
What role does the SIGKILL signal play in task management within Borg?
What role does the SIGKILL signal play in task management within Borg?
What is the significance of the stable naming convention in Borg for job monitoring?
What is the significance of the stable naming convention in Borg for job monitoring?
How does Borg's capability system enhance user privileges and operational control?
How does Borg's capability system enhance user privileges and operational control?
How does the Borg system handle resource allocation between multiple tasks?
How does the Borg system handle resource allocation between multiple tasks?
Flashcards
Job Priority
Job Priority
A numerical value assigned to a job, determining its access to resources. Higher priority jobs can preempt lower priority jobs.
Preemption
Preemption
The act of interrupting and terminating a lower-priority job to allocate resources to a higher-priority job.
Priority Bands
Priority Bands
Categories of job priorities, for example, monitoring or production, to manage resource allocation.
Quota
Quota
Signup and view all the flashcards
Borg Name Service (BNS)
Borg Name Service (BNS)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Task Location in Borg
Task Location in Borg
Signup and view all the flashcards
Task Monitoring
Task Monitoring
Signup and view all the flashcards
Job Naming Scheme
Job Naming Scheme
Signup and view all the flashcards
Utilization in Borg
Utilization in Borg
Signup and view all the flashcards
Correlated failures (in Borg)
Correlated failures (in Borg)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Task disruption rate (in Borg)
Task disruption rate (in Borg)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Workload segregation (in Borg)
Workload segregation (in Borg)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Additional machines needed (segregation)
Additional machines needed (segregation)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Cell (in Borg)
Cell (in Borg)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Overhead from segregation
Overhead from segregation
Signup and view all the flashcards
Percentage of cell (in charts)
Percentage of cell (in charts)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Resource Limits
Resource Limits
Signup and view all the flashcards
Task Resource Usage
Task Resource Usage
Signup and view all the flashcards
Quota limits
Quota limits
Signup and view all the flashcards
Resource Reclamation
Resource Reclamation
Signup and view all the flashcards
Scheduling Delays
Scheduling Delays
Signup and view all the flashcards
CPU Utilization
CPU Utilization
Signup and view all the flashcards
Latency-sensitive tasks
Latency-sensitive tasks
Signup and view all the flashcards
Batch tasks
Batch tasks
Signup and view all the flashcards
Borglet
Borglet
Signup and view all the flashcards
Resource Container
Resource Container
Signup and view all the flashcards
Resource Caps
Resource Caps
Signup and view all the flashcards
CFS (Completely Fair Scheduler)
CFS (Completely Fair Scheduler)
Signup and view all the flashcards
LS tasks
LS tasks
Signup and view all the flashcards
NUMA-aware
NUMA-aware
Signup and view all the flashcards
Apollo
Apollo
Signup and view all the flashcards
Opportunistic Execution
Opportunistic Execution
Signup and view all the flashcards
Prediction Matrix
Prediction Matrix
Signup and view all the flashcards
Apache Mesos
Apache Mesos
Signup and view all the flashcards
DRF
DRF
Signup and view all the flashcards
YARN
YARN
Signup and view all the flashcards
Alibaba's Fuxi
Alibaba's Fuxi
Signup and view all the flashcards
Borg's Debugging Philosophy
Borg's Debugging Philosophy
Signup and view all the flashcards
Borg's Debugging Tools
Borg's Debugging Tools
Signup and view all the flashcards
Kubernetes's Introspection Techniques
Kubernetes's Introspection Techniques
Signup and view all the flashcards
Kubernetes's Unified Event Recording
Kubernetes's Unified Event Recording
Signup and view all the flashcards
Borg Master's Role
Borg Master's Role
Signup and view all the flashcards
Borg's User-Centric Design
Borg's User-Centric Design
Signup and view all the flashcards
Borg's Self-Help Approach
Borg's Self-Help Approach
Signup and view all the flashcards
The Importance of Debugging Tools
The Importance of Debugging Tools
Signup and view all the flashcards
Cluster (Borg)
Cluster (Borg)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Job (Borg)
Job (Borg)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Task (Borg)
Task (Borg)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Heterogeneity in a Cell
Heterogeneity in a Cell
Signup and view all the flashcards
Borg's Role in Resource Allocation
Borg's Role in Resource Allocation
Signup and view all the flashcards
Constraints (Borg)
Constraints (Borg)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Borg's Avoidance of Virtualization
Borg's Avoidance of Virtualization
Signup and view all the flashcards
Job States
Job States
Signup and view all the flashcards
Update in Borg
Update in Borg
Signup and view all the flashcards
Task Disruption
Task Disruption
Signup and view all the flashcards
Jobs vs. Tasks
Jobs vs. Tasks
Signup and view all the flashcards
Task Rescheduling
Task Rescheduling
Signup and view all the flashcards
Task Preemption
Task Preemption
Signup and view all the flashcards
Task Notification
Task Notification
Signup and view all the flashcards
Borg Alloc
Borg Alloc
Signup and view all the flashcards
Alloc Set
Alloc Set
Signup and view all the flashcards
Admission Control
Admission Control
Signup and view all the flashcards
Production Priority
Production Priority
Signup and view all the flashcards
Task Location
Task Location
Signup and view all the flashcards
Cell
Cell
Signup and view all the flashcards
Study Notes
Borg Cluster Management at Google
-
Borg is a cluster manager at Google that handles hundreds of thousands of jobs from many applications, across numerous clusters with tens of thousands of machines each.
-
Borg optimizes resource utilization through admission control, efficient task packing, over-commitment, and machine sharing with process-level isolation.
-
High availability is ensured through features that minimize fault recovery time and scheduling policies that reduce correlated failures.
-
A declarative job specification language, name service integration, real-time job monitoring, and system behavior analysis tools simplify user interaction.
User Perspective
-
Borg users are Google developers and system administrators (SREs) managing applications and services.
-
Workflows are submitted as jobs, with each job composed of one or more tasks implementing the same program.
-
Each job operates within a Borg cell, a set of managed machines.
-
The workload comprises:
- Long-running, stable services for user-facing applications (Gmail, Docs, search) and internal infrastructure.
- Batch jobs requiring seconds to days to complete, less sensitive to performance fluctuations.
Workload and Clusters
-
Clusters consist of machines in a single datacenter building.
-
Cells are larger clusters that typically include several clusters and focus on specific application types.
-
Machines in cells are heterogeneous (CPU, RAM, disk, etc.).
-
Borg hides resource management and failure handling details, letting users focus on application development.
-
Borg enables reliable and highly available application operation across thousands of machines.
Jobs and Tasks
-
Jobs are defined by: name, owner, and the number of tasks.
-
Tasks are represented as Linux processes within a container.
-
Jobs may have resource constraints concerning processor architecture, OS versions, or external IPs.
-
Constraints can be either hard or soft (preferences).
-
Jobs can be deferred until a prior job finishes.
Priority, Quota, and Admission
-
Each job has a priority.
-
High-priority tasks can preempt lower-priority tasks.
-
Priorities are defined for monitoring, production, batch, and best-effort workloads.
-
Quota limits resources available to users at a given priority within a given timeframe.
-
Quota is an admission control mechanism, not scheduling.
-
Jobs lacking sufficient quota are rejected.
Naming and Monitoring
-
Tasks are given unique names (including cell, job, and task number).
-
These names are used by the Borg naming service (BNS).
-
Borg provides task hostname and port information in a consistent store.
-
System status and task health information are reported by Borg.
Borg Architecture
-
The Borg architecture comprises a Borgmaster (controller) and Borglets (agents).
-
The Borgmaster manages client RPCs, handles all system objects, and offers a web UI.
-
Borglets run on each machine and manage local resources and state reporting.
-
Checkpoint data and logs are stored in a highly available Paxos-based store.
Scheduling
-
The scheduler in Borgmaster takes tasks from the pending queue.
-
Jobs are assigned tasks when sufficient available resources meet constraints.
-
The scheduler prioritizes tasks based on priority and allocates machines efficiently.
-
It proactively handles machine and network failures.
Availability
-
Borg ensures system availability and redundancy through failure handling mechanisms.
-
Tasks are proactively rescheduled or restarted on new machines.
-
Correlated failures are minimized.
-
User applications are expected to be resilient, using techniques like replication and checkpoints.
Isolation
-
Borg isolates tasks through Linux cgroups.
-
Separating tasks physically prevents interference.
Performance
-
Performance interference is mitigated by sharing resources and minimizing machine contention.
-
Resource reclamation strategies reclaim underused resources.
-
Optimized scheduling techniques minimize task wait times.
Scalability
-
Borg's architecture scales to thousands of machines and supports high arrival rates.
-
Techniques include a distributed state store, sharded functions, and separate scheduling processes.
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.