Podcast
Questions and Answers
What is a primary requirement for authors who include copyrighted material in their manuscript?
What is a primary requirement for authors who include copyrighted material in their manuscript?
- They must attribute it to a different author.
- They must obtain permission to use it. (correct)
- They must create the material themselves.
- They must provide a summary of the material.
In Open Access (OA) publications, who typically retains copyright?
In Open Access (OA) publications, who typically retains copyright?
- The authors (correct)
- The general public
- The publishing company
- The journal editor
Which of the following is NOT a criterion for authorship?
Which of the following is NOT a criterion for authorship?
- Providing technical assistance during research (correct)
- Accountability for all aspects of the work
- Substantial contributions to the design of the work
- Final approval of the version to be published
What is a common practice among authors concerning accountability for a manuscript?
What is a common practice among authors concerning accountability for a manuscript?
What distinguishes Open Access journals from subscription-based journals?
What distinguishes Open Access journals from subscription-based journals?
Which statement accurately defines the role of acknowledgments in a manuscript?
Which statement accurately defines the role of acknowledgments in a manuscript?
What constitutes a breach of scientific ethics among authors?
What constitutes a breach of scientific ethics among authors?
What is a potential measure to enhance the detection of falsified data during the peer review process?
What is a potential measure to enhance the detection of falsified data during the peer review process?
What is NOT a criterion for authorship according to standards of conduct?
What is NOT a criterion for authorship according to standards of conduct?
Which of the following does NOT indicate a significant contribution to authorship?
Which of the following does NOT indicate a significant contribution to authorship?
Which of the following responsibilities does NOT fall under authorship?
Which of the following responsibilities does NOT fall under authorship?
Which situation best exemplifies 'salami science'?
Which situation best exemplifies 'salami science'?
What impact does the pressure to publish have on scientists?
What impact does the pressure to publish have on scientists?
What is the final step in the authorship process outlined in the standards?
What is the final step in the authorship process outlined in the standards?
Which activity is considered an essential part of the authorship responsibilities?
Which activity is considered an essential part of the authorship responsibilities?
Which of the following roles clearly qualifies as an author?
Which of the following roles clearly qualifies as an author?
What primary ethical concern arises from Dr. Wolanski's use of patient images in his presentation?
What primary ethical concern arises from Dr. Wolanski's use of patient images in his presentation?
What action should Dr. Jeris consider taking regarding the misuse of images by Dr. Wolanski?
What action should Dr. Jeris consider taking regarding the misuse of images by Dr. Wolanski?
In Professor Duarte's case, is an Institutional Review Board (IRB) approval necessary for the use of leftover blood serum?
In Professor Duarte's case, is an Institutional Review Board (IRB) approval necessary for the use of leftover blood serum?
What must Professor Duarte ensure regarding students' serum use for research?
What must Professor Duarte ensure regarding students' serum use for research?
Which of the following would be an appropriate response to an animal rights activist arguing against animal use in research?
Which of the following would be an appropriate response to an animal rights activist arguing against animal use in research?
Which ethical principle was violated by Dr. Wolanski when he displayed patient images?
Which ethical principle was violated by Dr. Wolanski when he displayed patient images?
What aspect of informed consent was potentially overlooked in Professor Duarte's lab exercise?
What aspect of informed consent was potentially overlooked in Professor Duarte's lab exercise?
How might Dr. Wolanski’s actions impact patient trust in clinical research?
How might Dr. Wolanski’s actions impact patient trust in clinical research?
What is Dr. Ripka primarily concerned about regarding Myron's disclosure of his animal-use training status?
What is Dr. Ripka primarily concerned about regarding Myron's disclosure of his animal-use training status?
Which of the following actions would have been more appropriate for Dr. Ripka concerning Myron's situation?
Which of the following actions would have been more appropriate for Dr. Ripka concerning Myron's situation?
What potential ethical issue arises from your advisor's instructions to continue with the generalization testing despite the rats' health concerns?
What potential ethical issue arises from your advisor's instructions to continue with the generalization testing despite the rats' health concerns?
How should the weight loss and growths on the animals be classified in terms of animal welfare?
How should the weight loss and growths on the animals be classified in terms of animal welfare?
What could be a justification for your advisor's decision to continue the study despite the rats' conditions?
What could be a justification for your advisor's decision to continue the study despite the rats' conditions?
What primary role does the Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee serve in research involving animals?
What primary role does the Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee serve in research involving animals?
Which factor is most relevant to consider when determining the appropriateness of animal use in the study?
Which factor is most relevant to consider when determining the appropriateness of animal use in the study?
What was the primary goal of the drug discrimination study mentioned in your lab's research?
What was the primary goal of the drug discrimination study mentioned in your lab's research?
What should be the primary consideration when deciding whether to continue the experiment after discovering some rats are paralyzed or dead?
What should be the primary consideration when deciding whether to continue the experiment after discovering some rats are paralyzed or dead?
What impact might continuing the experiment have on the remaining rats?
What impact might continuing the experiment have on the remaining rats?
In the context of animal research, what is a critical step when unexpected adverse effects are discovered?
In the context of animal research, what is a critical step when unexpected adverse effects are discovered?
What is the potential consequence of prioritizing Tom's dissertation completion over animal welfare?
What is the potential consequence of prioritizing Tom's dissertation completion over animal welfare?
What should be the focus of Myron Castillo's training in the context of animal handling?
What should be the focus of Myron Castillo's training in the context of animal handling?
When Myron is bitten by a rat during an injection, what should be his immediate priority?
When Myron is bitten by a rat during an injection, what should be his immediate priority?
How can practicing surgical procedures improve outcomes in animal research?
How can practicing surgical procedures improve outcomes in animal research?
What ethical responsibilities do researchers have when adverse outcomes are observed in subjects?
What ethical responsibilities do researchers have when adverse outcomes are observed in subjects?
Which of the following is NOT a responsibility of the attending veterinarian?
Which of the following is NOT a responsibility of the attending veterinarian?
In the context of animal research, which element is essential for justifying the non-use of analgesics?
In the context of animal research, which element is essential for justifying the non-use of analgesics?
When conducting a literature search for alternatives to animal use, which of the following must be included?
When conducting a literature search for alternatives to animal use, which of the following must be included?
What is the primary consideration for the principal investigator when planning a study involving animal subjects?
What is the primary consideration for the principal investigator when planning a study involving animal subjects?
Which factor is least likely to be a concern when developing the housing conditions for research animals?
Which factor is least likely to be a concern when developing the housing conditions for research animals?
What percentage of the time should a legitimate alternative method be found when conducting literature searches?
What percentage of the time should a legitimate alternative method be found when conducting literature searches?
Which responsibility does the Principal Investigator NOT have regarding animal welfare?
Which responsibility does the Principal Investigator NOT have regarding animal welfare?
Which requirement is crucial for the training of staff involved in animal care?
Which requirement is crucial for the training of staff involved in animal care?
Which requirement is crucial for the ethical validity of research involving human subjects?
Which requirement is crucial for the ethical validity of research involving human subjects?
What is the role of nonscientific members in an Institutional Review Board (IRB)?
What is the role of nonscientific members in an Institutional Review Board (IRB)?
Why must consent be informed in research involving human subjects?
Why must consent be informed in research involving human subjects?
Under what condition can coercion occur during recruitment for clinical trials?
Under what condition can coercion occur during recruitment for clinical trials?
What is a primary concern regarding the selection of subjects for research studies?
What is a primary concern regarding the selection of subjects for research studies?
Which practice is essential for maintaining confidentiality of subjects’ records?
Which practice is essential for maintaining confidentiality of subjects’ records?
In which scenario is informed consent considered valid?
In which scenario is informed consent considered valid?
What specific requirement exists when participants in research are incompetent individuals?
What specific requirement exists when participants in research are incompetent individuals?
What ethical violation was primarily committed during the NIH study in Guatemala?
What ethical violation was primarily committed during the NIH study in Guatemala?
Which principle of human subject research was most likely violated by Dr. Wolanski when showing patient images without consent?
Which principle of human subject research was most likely violated by Dr. Wolanski when showing patient images without consent?
What was the primary ethical concern about the use of prisoners and soldiers in the NIH study?
What was the primary ethical concern about the use of prisoners and soldiers in the NIH study?
Which phase of clinical trials focuses primarily on assessing the safety of a new drug in a small group?
Which phase of clinical trials focuses primarily on assessing the safety of a new drug in a small group?
If a researcher fails to maintain confidentiality of participant data, which aspect of ethical research is compromised?
If a researcher fails to maintain confidentiality of participant data, which aspect of ethical research is compromised?
What aspect of the informed consent process is essential but often overlooked in research studies?
What aspect of the informed consent process is essential but often overlooked in research studies?
What is a significant consequence of violating human subjects research practices?
What is a significant consequence of violating human subjects research practices?
What type of violation is committed when personal identifiers of participants are disclosed in research presentations?
What type of violation is committed when personal identifiers of participants are disclosed in research presentations?
What is an essential element of informed consent according to ethical research guidelines?
What is an essential element of informed consent according to ethical research guidelines?
Which principle is violated if a researcher does not protect the privacy of research subjects?
Which principle is violated if a researcher does not protect the privacy of research subjects?
Why must research involving human subjects be registered in a publicly accessible database?
Why must research involving human subjects be registered in a publicly accessible database?
What should a researcher prioritize to achieve the principle of beneficence?
What should a researcher prioritize to achieve the principle of beneficence?
In Professor Duarte's case, what is necessary before using any leftover blood sera for research?
In Professor Duarte's case, what is necessary before using any leftover blood sera for research?
What ethical principle ensures that the benefits and burdens of research are equally distributed among populations?
What ethical principle ensures that the benefits and burdens of research are equally distributed among populations?
Which specific characteristic must participants possess to engage in medical research ethically?
Which specific characteristic must participants possess to engage in medical research ethically?
What constitutes an undesirable consequence that researchers must detect and remove?
What constitutes an undesirable consequence that researchers must detect and remove?
What ethical concern arises from continuing the study despite health issues in the animals?
What ethical concern arises from continuing the study despite health issues in the animals?
What should be the primary action taken regarding the animals showing tumor-like growths?
What should be the primary action taken regarding the animals showing tumor-like growths?
Which ethical principle is most directly violated by ignoring the animals' adverse health conditions?
Which ethical principle is most directly violated by ignoring the animals' adverse health conditions?
What is likely to be the main consequence of documenting research in Chinese before translating to English?
What is likely to be the main consequence of documenting research in Chinese before translating to English?
Why might sloppy record keeping be considered scientific misconduct?
Why might sloppy record keeping be considered scientific misconduct?
What is the role of the Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee in this situation?
What is the role of the Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee in this situation?
What obligation does the researcher have if significant health concerns arise during a study?
What obligation does the researcher have if significant health concerns arise during a study?
What major issue could arise from the principal investigator taking data to a new institution?
What major issue could arise from the principal investigator taking data to a new institution?
Study Notes
Authorship and Publication Ethics
- Authorship must be based on intellectual and conceptual contributions.
- Technical assistance is not grounds for authorship.
- Authorship criteria:
- Substantial contributions to the conception, design, data acquisition, analysis, or interpretation
- Drafting or revising work for intellectual content
- Final approval of the published version
- Agreement to be accountable for the work's accuracy and integrity.
- Scientific publication reports new findings, credits other scientists, and enables replication of work.
- The pressure to publish helps scientists compete for grants, promotions, and professional recognition.
- Salami science refers to the publication of related results in separate, fragmented pieces.
- Many journals require authors to obtain permission to use copyrighted material.
- Open access (OA) publications use a variety of copyright models.
- Acknowledgements recognize individuals who contributed to the work but do not meet authorship criteria, such as technical assistance or editorial help.
Case Studies
Case 7
- Professor Duarte wants to gather baseline control data for research projects using blood sera from 100 medical students.
- Students were asked if they wanted to opt out of their sera being used, but no one objected.
- Is this ethically acceptable?
- Do students need informed consent, and is an IRB-approved protocol necessary?
Case 8
- A graduate student is working on a project involving administering nerve toxins to rats.
- The protocol has been approved by the IACUC.
- Several rats become paralyzed or dead.
- The lab director is out of town, and the senior graduate student advises continuing the experiment to avoid delays and potential harm to results.
- The student faces a dilemma: continue the experiment despite potential harm to more rats or stop the experiment and inform the IACUC, potentially causing disfavor from the senior student.
Case 9
- Myron Castillo, a graduate student, is bitten by a rat while performing injections.
- He has not completed animal-use training or been screened for allergies, as instructed.
- Dr. Ripka instructs him to go to a community hospital ER but discourages him from going to the student health clinic, fearing it will lead to sanctions on her animal use authorization.
- Is Dr. Ripka's advice ethical?
- What should she have done?
Case 10
- A graduate student working on a drug discrimination study notices tumors and weight loss in rats.
- The advisor instructs the student to continue the experiment, arguing that stopping would waste time and resources.
- The advisor also claims the animals are fine and will be euthanized soon.
- Is the advisor's decision ethically sound?
- Is it appropriate to continue the experiment despite the rats' health concerns?
Drug Discovery and Development
- Two main approaches to drug discovery: animal research & human research
- Animal research often precedes human research
- Human research requires several ethical considerations
Unethical Experiments
- One example of unethical experiment: The Guatemala Study by NIH from 1946-1948
- During the study, prisoners and soldiers were intentionally infected with syphilis and other venereal diseases for the purpose of studying the effects of penicillin
- No informed consent was obtained from participants
- Most participants did not receive treatment for the diseases
- U.S. government apologized to Guatemalan government officially in 2010
Human Clinical Trials
- Clinical trials have distinct phases to efficiently gather data:
- Assessment of safety & best dose
- Testing for effectiveness & side effects
- Large scale study of effectiveness & side effects
- Evaluating long-term safety, effectiveness, and optimal use
Case Studies
- Case 6: A researcher uses a patient's image and name in a presentation, raising privacy concerns
- Case 7: A professor wants to keep leftover blood samples from a lab exercise, needing informed consent and IRB approval.
- Case 9: A lab observes tumor growth in animals, raising questions about ethical treatment of animals
- Case 11: A graduate student keeps notes in Chinese, highlighting the importance of clear communication and language barriers in scientific research
General Principles in Human Research
- Informed consent is mandatory, free from coercion, with the ability to withdraw at any time
- Minimize physical, mental discomfort, harm, and danger
- Confidentiality is essential, respecting any commitments made
- Researcher must detect and remove any undesirable consequences
- Protect privacy and confidentiality of research subjects
- Voluntary participation by individuals capable of giving informed consent
- Research involving human subjects must be registered in a publicly accessible database (e.g., ClinicalTrials.gov)
IRB (Institutional Review Board)
- IRB approves and oversees research on human subjects
- Composed of at least five members, including one non-scientific member and one non-affiliated member
- Ensures ethical and technical validity of research
- Determines the risk-to-benefit ratio and monitors data for subject safety
- Ensures adequate plans to protect privacy and confidentiality
- Promotes equitable subject selection
Informed Consent
- Essential for ethical participation
- Subject must be competent to understand consequences and make independent decisions
- Consent must be voluntary and free from coercion
- All risks must be disclosed, and procedures must be understood
- A relative or friend witnesses the signature on the consent form
Human Experimentation with Special Populations
- Incompetent persons with mental illness: Legally responsible persons provide consent, and safeguards for participants are required
- Prisoners: Only certain types of federally sponsored research are permitted, with benefits outweighing the risks, and fair selection is crucial
Animal Research
- Assume human pain equals animal pain
- IACUC (Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee) reviews painful procedures, ensuring alternatives, analgesics, anesthesia, and consultation with a veterinarian
- Clear methods for euthanasia are crucial
- IACUC verifies that the PI (Principal Investigator) has considered alternatives to animal use, employed analgesics and anesthetics, and consulted with a veterinarian
Principal Investigator Responsibilities
- Selecting appropriate species, strain, and model
- Minimizing the number of animals used
- Minimizing pain and distress
- Considering alternatives
- Defining study goals and humane endpoints
- Using acceptable methods of euthanasia
Animal Care Guidelines
- Details qualifications and training of animal care staff
- Establishes an occupational health program for personnel interacting with animals
- Specifies space requirements, temperature, humidity, noise levels, bedding, water, sanitation, waste disposal, and separation by species
- Disease control, animal door sizes, ceiling heights, floor drains, and storage areas for food and bedding are outlined
- Provides training for staff involved in animal care and research
Scientific Record Keeping
- Accurate and complete records are crucial for ethical research
- Records should be consistent and clear
- Data should be accessible and protected from unauthorized access
- Electronic record keeping can enhance data security and integrity
Scientific Misconduct
- Sloppy or incomplete record keeping can contribute to scientific misconduct
- Electronic record keeping can both enhance and complicate the detection of scientific misconduct
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.
Related Documents
Description
Test your knowledge on the ethical principles of authorship and publication in scientific research. This quiz explores criteria for authorship, the impact of publication pressures, and important aspects of scientific integrity. Understanding these concepts is crucial for maintaining accountability in scientific work.
