Genetic Counseling: Ethical Scenarios and Mitochondrial DNA

1. Genetic Counseling Genetic counseling is a communication process where individuals and families receive guidance on genetic conditions, risk assessments, and testing options KEY ASPECTS ​ Risk assessment: Estimating the likelihood of a genetic condition. ​ Education: Explaining inheritanc...

1. Genetic Counseling Genetic counseling is a communication process where individuals and families receive guidance on genetic conditions, risk assessments, and testing options KEY ASPECTS ​ Risk assessment: Estimating the likelihood of a genetic condition. ​ Education: Explaining inheritance patterns, genetic testing and available medical options. ​ Counseling: Providing emotional and ethical support. 4 Ethical Principles in Genetic Counseling 1.​ Autonomy – Patients have the right to make their own choices about genetic testing and disclosure. 2.​ Beneficence – The counselor must act in the best interests of the patient. 3.​ Non-maleficence – "Do no harm"; genetic information should be communicated carefully to avoid unnecessary distress. 4.​ Justice – Fair and equal access to genetic counseling services Confidentiality vs. Duty to Warn ​ Confidentiality: A patient’s genetic information should be protected unless they consent to sharing it. ​ Duty to Warn: If a genetic condition poses serious harm to family members, some ethical and legal guidelines may support disclosure without patient consent. Key Legal Cases & Guidelines ✅ Pate v. Threlkel – Physicians must inform patients about genetic risks so they can warn ✅ Safer v. Estate of Pack – Doctors may need to take additional steps to ensure relatives relatives.​ ✅ ASGH Guidelines: Supports disclosure without consent is only allowed if the condition is are informed if a serious risk exists.​ life-threatening and preventable Misattributed Paternity & Ethical Dilemmas ​ Misattributed paternity: Occurs when genetic testing reveals that the presumed father is not the biological father. Ethical Conflict: Should the Counselor Disclose This Information? ✅ ​ Option 1: Tell the Father​ ✅ Truth-telling (Autonomy)​ ✅ The father might need to know for legal and emotional reasons.​ Medical history accuracy for the child. ❌ ​ Option 2: Do NOT Tell the Father​ ❌ Mother’s right to confidentiality.​ ❌ Disclosure could cause significant family harm (Non-Maleficence).​ Professional guidelines recommend NOT disclosing without the mother's consent​ 2. Y Chromosome & Sex Determination Genetic Sex Determination ​ XX = Female, XY = Male in mammals. ​ The SRY gene on the Y chromosome is the master switch for male development. Testis Development (Male) 1.​ SRY activates SOX9 → Forms Sertoli cells ○​ Sertoli cells organize testis cords and suppress ovarian development by inhibiting β-catenin. 2.​ Sertoli cells produce AMH (Anti-Müllerian Hormone) → Causes Müllerian duct degeneration (prevents uterus formation) 3.​ Leydig cells produce testosterone → Promotes Wolffian duct development (forms male reproductive organs: ​ Epididymis (sperm storage) ​ Vas deferens (sperm transport) ​ Seminal vesicles (semen fluid production) 4.​ 5α-Reductase converts testosterone into DHT (Dihydrotestosterone) → Forms external male genitalia (Penis, Scrotum, Prostate gland) Ovary Development (Female) 1.​ No SRY Gene Activation → The bipotential gonads do not receive the male-determining signal. 2.​ WNT4 and RSPO1 (key signaling molecules) are expressed → activate β-catenin, which is crucial in ovarian development. 3.​ β-catenin blocks SOX9 → Prevents Sertoli cell formation and blocks testis development. 4.​ Granulosa cells support ovarian follicles. 5.​ No Anti-Müllerian Hormone (AMH) is produced = The Müllerian ducts remain and develop into: -​ Fallopian tubes -​ Uterus -​ Upper Vagina 6.​ No testosterone is produced → Wolffian ducts degenerate Sex Reversal: How It Happens Sex reversal occurs when an individual has chromosomes of one sex but develops characteristics of the opposite sex. Causes of Sex Reversal 1.​ SRY Gene Mutations – If SRY is missing or non-functional, an XY individual may develop as female. 2.​ SOX9 Overexpression – If SOX9 is active without SRY, an XX individual may develop male characteristics. 3.​ Androgen Insensitivity Syndrome (AIS) – 46,XY individuals have male chromosomes but do not respond to testosterone → develop female traits. 4.​ 5α-Reductase Deficiency – XY individuals lack DHT, causing ambiguous genitalia at birth but normal male development at puberty. 3. Mitochondrial DNA & Disease Prevention Mitochondrial Inheritance ​ Mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) is only inherited from the mother because sperm mitochondria are destroyed after fertilization amd Mutations in mtDNA cause energy production disorders. Mitochondrial Diseases & Treatments Common Mitochondrial Disorders, Causes & Effects Disease Cause Effects Leigh Syndrome mtDNA mutations Neurological decline, affecting ATP muscle weakness, production respiratory failure MELAS (Mitochondrial Encephalopathy, mtDNA mutations Muscle weakness, Lactic Acidosis, and Stroke-like affecting energy strokes, seizures, lactic Episodes) metabolism acid buildup Kearns-Sayre Syndrome Large-scale mtDNA Progressive muscle deletions weakness, vision loss, heart problems LHON (Leber’s Hereditary Optic mtDNA mutations Sudden vision loss, Neuropathy) affecting nerve cells primarily in males Mitochondrial Replacement Therapy (MRT) Goal: Prevent mtDNA diseases by replacing faulty mitochondria. 1. Pronuclear Transfer (PNT): performed after fertilization (zygote stage) -​ Cheaper -​ Higher risk of mutant mtDNA carryover -​ More commonly done, higher success rates -​ More controversial since the original embryo is discarded. 1.​ Egg Collection & Fertilization ○​ The mother’s egg is fertilized with the father’s sperm (creating a zygote). ○​ A donor’s egg is also fertilized with sperm (creating another zygote with healthy mitochondria). 2.​ Nuclear Transfer ○​ The nuclear DNA is removed from both embryos. ○​ The mother’s nuclear DNA is inserted into the donor embryo, which has healthy mitochondria. 3.​ Embryo Development & Implantation ○​ The reconstructed embryo is allowed to develop for a few days.  ○​ The healthy embryo is implanted into the mother’s uterus. ✅ Outcome: The baby has nuclear DNA from the mother and father but mitochondria from the donor, eliminating mtDNA diseases. 2. Spindle Transfer (MST): performed before fertilization (oocyte stage) ​ Steps: Step 1: Extract nuclear DNA from the mother’s egg. Step 2: Transfer it into a donor egg (which has healthy mitochondria but no nuclear DNA). Step 3: Fertilize the modified egg with sperm. -​ More expensive -​ Difficult requires careful manipulation -​ Mutant mtDNA carryover is minimized. -​ Less controversial as it does not involve destroying an embryo. 3. MITO-Porter System The MITO-Porter system is a nanotechnology-based drug delivery system that targets mitochondria to treat diseases. How MITO-Porter Works ​ Uses liposomal carriers (fat-based nanoparticles) to deliver healthy mtDNA into diseased cells (directly to mitochondria) ​ Still experimental but a potential cure for mitochondrial diseases. Other Potential Mitochondrial Treatments Treatment Method How it Works Gene Therapy Inserts functional mtDNA into affected cells. Stem Cell Therapy Uses stem cells to generate healthy mitochondria. Exercise & Diet Helps improve mitochondrial function. Antioxidant Therapy Reduces oxidative stress in mitochondria. Ethical Concerns with Mitochondrial Replacement Therapy 1.​ "Three-Parent Baby" Controversy – MRT results in a child with DNA from three people (mother, father, and mitochondrial donor). 2.​ Long-Term Effects Unknown – MRT is a new procedure, and long-term effects are not fully understood. 3.​ Embryo Modification – Some people worry that MRT is a step toward genetic engineering or designer babies. 4.​ Religious Views – Some faiths oppose embryo manipulation due to concerns about altering natural conception. 4. Romanov Case Study The Romanov family was executed, and scientists used mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) analysis to confirm their identities. Explain how mitochondrial DNA testing was used to confirm the identity of the Romanov family Mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) Analysis ​ mtDNA is inherited only from the mother, making it a reliable tool for identifying maternal relatives. ​ Scientists compared mtDNA from the bones to living maternal relatives, including Prince Philip (Queen Elizabeth II’s husband). ​ The mtDNA sequences matched, confirming that the remains belonged to the Romanov family. Heteroplasmy as Additional Evidence ​ Heteroplasmy is when a person has two different mtDNA sequences in the same cell. ​ Tsar Nicholas II had a unique mtDNA heteroplasmy, which was also found in his brother Grand Duke Georgij Romanov. ​ This provided strong evidence that the remains were indeed Nicholas II’s. Key Findings ✅ mtDNA was compared to living relatives (Prince Philip) confirming the Romanov family’s ✅ Heteroplasmy (variation in mtDNA sequences) confirmed the identity of the remains​. identity.​ Why This Case Matters ​ First major use of mtDNA sequencing for forensic identification. ​ Showed that mtDNA can be traced through maternal lineage over centuries. 5. Ethical Scenarios in Genetic Testing Example: Should a Genetic Counselor Disclose a BRCA Mutation? ​ A patient is BRCA1 positive (high breast cancer risk) but refuses to tell her daughter. ​ Ethical dilemma: Should the counselor disclose? ✅ Reasons to Inform: ​ Daughter could get tested & take preventive measures (mastectomy, early screening). ​ Serious harm prevention (Beneficence). ❌ Reasons NOT to Inform: ​ Patient autonomy & confidentiality must be respected. ​ No legal requirement for disclosure in some cases. Legal Perspective: ​ (ASHG) allows disclosure if the condition is life-threatening and the patient refuses to inform relatives. You are given a case where a woman has a genetic disorder and does not want her child tested. What are the legal, social, and religious issues associated with this scenario? Legal Issues ✅ Confidentiality vs. Duty to Warn → Should the counselor override the mother’s decision to ✅ Informed Consent → Laws require parental consent for testing minors.​ protect the child?​ ✅ Discrimination Risk → Could genetic test results affect the child’s insurance or employment in the future? Social Issues ✅ Family Stress → Knowing a child has a genetic disorder can cause emotional and ✅ Cultural Beliefs → Some cultures view genetic testing as unnecessary or unethical.​ financial strain.​ ✅ Stigma → A positive result may lead to social discrimination. Religious Issues ✅ Sanctity of Life → Some religious groups believe genetic testing interferes with divine ✅ Reproductive Choices → Some faiths oppose abortion based on genetic test results.​ will.​ ✅ Confidentiality vs. Family Obligation → Some religious traditions emphasize family responsibility over privacy. Ethical Guidelines to Apply ✅ Autonomy – Respect the mother’s right to refuse testing.​ ✅ Beneficence – Consider whether testing could benefit the child.​ ✅ Non-Maleficence – Ensure that withholding information does not cause harm. Multiple Choice Questions & Answers 1. What is the main goal of genetic counseling? ✅ Answer: c) Helping individuals understand and adapt to genetic risks. 2. What ethical principle supports a patient’s right to refuse genetic testing? ✅ Answer: c) Autonomy 3. Which legal case ruled that physicians have a duty to warn at-risk family members? ✅ Answer: b) Pate v. Threlkel 4. What key gene drives testis development? ✅ Answer: c) SRY 5. What prevents the development of female reproductive organs in males? ✅ Answer: a) Anti-Müllerian Hormone (AMH) 6. What mitochondrial replacement technique is done before fertilization? ✅ Answer: b) Spindle Transfer 7. How was the Romanov family identified? ✅ Answer: b) mtDNA analysis 8. What does the MITO-Porter system do? ✅ Answer: b) Delivers healthy mtDNA to cells. 9. Which ethical principle supports disclosure of genetic risks to family members? ✅ Answer: b) Beneficence 10. What is a key ethical concern in prenatal genetic testing? ✅ Answer: c) Selective abortion & reproductive rights