Lecture 1 notes.docx
Transcript
Reading 1 and 2 Notes: (Article 1) - VIOLENCE by john Lawrence The author begins by discussing the various forms of violence, including physical, structural, and symbolic violence, and highlights the interconnected nature of these manifestations within society. Lawrence argues that violence is not s...
Reading 1 and 2 Notes: (Article 1) - VIOLENCE by john Lawrence The author begins by discussing the various forms of violence, including physical, structural, and symbolic violence, and highlights the interconnected nature of these manifestations within society. Lawrence argues that violence is not solely a result of individual actions, but is also deeply rooted in larger social structures and power dynamics. The article delves into the role of violence in maintaining and challenging social order, as well as its impact on marginalized and oppressed groups. Lawrence emphasizes the importance of understanding the underlying causes of violence and addressing systemic issues to effectively combat it. The author also examines the relationship between violence and social change, shedding light on how violent resistance can emerge as a response to injustice and oppression. Furthermore, the article discusses the limitations of traditional approaches to violence, calling for a more comprehensive and nuanced understanding that encompasses both overt and covert forms of violence. Lawrence also explores the ethical and moral implications of violence, presenting thought-provoking insights on the complexities of moral judgment in the context of violent acts. In conclusion, the article offers a thought-provoking analysis of violence from a sociological perspective, emphasizing the need to consider the broader social, political, and cultural factors that contribute to its existence. It calls for a more holistic approach to addressing violence, one that goes beyond individual behavior to encompass the larger structural and systemic forces at play. Overall, the article provides valuable insights into the complexities of violence and its implications for society. (Article 2) - Typologizing Violence: A Blackian Perspective by Mark Cooney "Typologizing Violence: A Blackian Perspective" likely delves into violence through the lens of Blackian sociology, a theoretical framework that emphasizes social structures and their impact on behavior. The article might propose a typology or classification system for understanding violence within the context of societal structures and cultural influences. It may explore how social systems, inequalities, and power dynamics contribute to the manifestation of violence. The Blackian perspective might highlight the role of social structures in shaping individual behaviors, motivations, and the perpetuation of violent acts. The article could present a framework that categorizes violence based on social, cultural, or structural dimensions, aiming to provide insights into the origins, forms, and implications of violence within broader societal contexts. It likely emphasizes the influence of social systems on shaping and perpetuating various types of violent behaviors, contributing to a nuanced understanding of violence from a sociological standpoint rooted in Blackian sociology. Lecture 1: Different Types of Violence • Discussion regarding alternative definitions of violence Various perspectives exist regarding what constitutes violence. Some definitions focus solely on physical harm, while others include psychological, emotional, or structural harm. It's often debated whether violence should be limited to direct actions or expanded to encompass systemic or societal injustices. • Humans’ “fascination” with violence There might be discussions exploring why humans are drawn to violence in various forms—whether in media, entertainment, or real-life events. This fascination could be attributed to psychological factors, societal conditioning, or the evolutionary need to understand and respond to threats. • Violence versus abuse While violence typically refers to the use of physical force causing injury or harm, abuse often involves a pattern of behavior aiming to control, dominate, or mistreat someone emotionally, psychologically, or physically. Discussions may highlight the nuances between isolated violent acts and ongoing abusive behaviors within relationships or systems. • Different “purposes” of violence Violence can serve different objectives, ranging from asserting power and control to seeking social change or expressing frustration. Discussions might explore these varied motives behind violent actions and their societal or individual implications. • Morality versus moralism Morality refers to principles of right and wrong, while moralism involves imposing one's moral standards on others. Discussions could revolve around how moral judgments influence perceptions and justifications of violence, and whether societal norms shape these perspective. • Main “types” of violence Discussions often categorize violence into several types, such as physical, psychological, structural, symbolic, or systemic violence. Each type entails distinct characteristics and implications, contributing to a nuanced understanding of violent phenomena in different contexts. Moralistic Violence: This type of violence is often rooted in a moralistic framework. It involves acts perceived as morally justified or sanctioned based on certain beliefs, principles, or ideologies. Individuals or groups may engage in moralistic violence convinced that their actions are morally right or necessary to uphold specific moral standards. Predatory Violence: Predatory violence typically involves acts perpetrated with the intent to exploit, dominate, or gain control over others. It often lacks moral or ethical justification and is driven by motives such as power, dominance, or personal gain. This form of violence can be seen in crimes such as robbery, mugging, or acts of aggression solely for material or personal benefit. Weberian “Ideal Types”: This categorization, inspired by Max Weber's sociological theories, involves constructing abstract models or ideal types to understand social phenomena. In the context of violence, these ideal types might be hypothetical constructs that represent different pure or extreme forms of violence, aiding in conceptual analysis and understanding rather than directly observable or real instances. Recreational and Ritualistic Violence: Recreational violence refers to violent activities engaged in for pleasure, entertainment, or recreation. This might include extreme sports or simulated combat. Ritualistic violence, on the other hand, is tied to cultural or religious rituals and ceremonies where violence is performed as part of a traditional practice or symbolic act rather than for aggression or harm. Each of these types represents different facets or categorizations of violence, shedding light on diverse motivations, contexts, and purposes behind violent actions observed in various societal settings.
