Chitosan Nanoparticle Delivery Systems for Sustainable Agriculture PDF
Document Details
Uploaded by pepinos
Brock University
2015
Prem Lal Kashyap, Xu Xiang, Patricia Heiden
Tags
Related
- Chitosan cross-linked poly(acrylic acid) hydrogels: Drug release control and mechanism PDF
- Chitosan: Structure, Properties, and Importance in Environmental Cleanup PDF
- Kinetics, Absorption, and Diffusion of Crosslinked Chitosan Hydrogels PDF
- Slow Delivery of a Nitrification Inhibitor to Soil Using Chitosan Hydrogel PDF
- Chitosan Hydrogels & Glutaraldehyde-Crosslinked Counterparts (PDF)
- Drug Release Study of Chitosan-Based Nanoparticles PDF
Summary
This article reviews chitosan nanoparticle-based delivery systems for sustainable agriculture, focusing on their use in delivering agrochemicals and genetic materials. The authors discuss different production strategies for chitosan nanoparticles, including emulsion cross-linking, ionotropic gelation, and precipitation, and explore their applications in pesticide delivery, fertilizer delivery, and plant transformation. The study highlights the potential of these systems for enhancing agricultural productivity while minimizing environmental impacts.
Full Transcript
International Journal of Biological Macromolecules 77 (2015) 36–51 Contents lists available at ScienceDirect International Journal of Biolo...
International Journal of Biological Macromolecules 77 (2015) 36–51 Contents lists available at ScienceDirect International Journal of Biological Macromolecules journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/ijbiomac Review Chitosan nanoparticle based delivery systems for sustainable agriculture Prem Lal Kashyap a,b,∗ , Xu Xiang b , Patricia Heiden b a ICAR-National Bureau of Agriculturally Important Microorganisms (NBAIM), Mau, Uttar Pradesh 275101, India b Michigan Technological University (MTU), Houghton, MI 49931, USA a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t Article history: Development of technologies that improve food productivity without any adverse impact on the ecosys- Received 18 October 2014 tem is the need of hour. In this context, development of controlled delivery systems for slow and sustained Received in revised form 3 February 2015 release of agrochemicals or genetic materials is crucial. Chitosan has emerged as a valuable carrier Accepted 16 February 2015 for controlled delivery of agrochemicals and genetic materials because of its proven biocompatibility, Available online 5 March 2015 biodegradability, non-toxicity, and adsorption abilities. The major advantages of encapsulating agro- chemicals and genetic material in a chitosan matrix include its ability to function as a protective reservoir Keywords: for the active ingredients, protecting the ingredients from the surrounding environment while they are Chitosan Encapsulation in the chitosan domain, and then controlling their release, allowing them to serve as efficient gene deliv- Agriculture ery systems for plant transformation or controlled release of pesticides. Despite the great progress in Plant protection the use of chitosan in the area of medical and pharmaceutical sciences, there is still a wide knowledge Controlled release gap regarding the potential application of chitosan for encapsulation of active ingredients in agriculture. Nanoparticles Hence, the present article describes the current status of chitosan nanoparticle-based delivery systems in agriculture, and to highlight challenges that need to be overcome. © 2015 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved. Contents 1. Introduction.......................................................................................................................................... 37 1.1. Chitosan in crop production and protection.................................................................................................. 37 1.2. Chitosan as a promising delivery system..................................................................................................... 41 1.3. Strategies for production of chitosan nanoparticles.......................................................................................... 41 1.4. Emulsion cross-linking........................................................................................................................ 41 1.5. Emulsion-droplet coalescence................................................................................................................ 44 1.6. Ionotropic gelation............................................................................................................................ 44 1.7. Precipitation................................................................................................................................... 44 1.8. Reverse micelles.............................................................................................................................. 44 1.9. Seiving method................................................................................................................................ 44 1.10. Spray drying................................................................................................................................. 45 1.11. Strategies for loading active ingredient into chitosan nanoparticles....................................................................... 45 1.12. Release kinetics of active ingredients from chitosan nanoparticles........................................................................ 45 2. Applications of chitosan nanoparticles as a delivery system........................................................................................ 46 2.1. Pesticide delivery for crop protection........................................................................................................ 46 2.2. Fertilizer delivery for balanced and sustained nutrition..................................................................................... 46 2.3. Herbicide delivery for weed eradication..................................................................................................... 47 2.4. Micronutrient delivery for crop growth promotion.......................................................................................... 47 ∗ Corresponding author at: ICAR-National Bureau of Agriculturally Important Microorganisms (NBAIM), Mau, Uttar Pradesh 275103. E-mail address: [email protected] (P.L. Kashyap). http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ijbiomac.2015.02.039 0141-8130/© 2015 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved. P.L. Kashyap et al. / International Journal of Biological Macromolecules 77 (2015) 36–51 37 2.5. Soil health improvement..................................................................................................................... 47 2.6. Delivery of genetic material for plant transformation....................................................................................... 47 3. Conclusions........................................................................................................................................... 48 References............................................................................................................................................ 48 1. Introduction nanoparticles [65,66]. Chitosan has also known for its broad spec- trum antimicrobial and insecticidal activities [67,68]. Further, it is The biggest challenge faced by agricultural researchers is to biodegradable giving non-toxic residues with its rate of degrada- produce sufficient quantity and quality of food to feed the ever tion corresponding to molecular mass and degree of deacetylation increasing global population without degrading the soil health and [69,70]. However, the low solubility of bulk chitosan in aqueous agro-ecosystem. It has been estimated that global food production media limits its wide spectrum activity as an antimicrobial agent. must increase by 70–100% by 2050 to meet the demand of the Therefore, various strategies have been employed to enhance its growing population explosion. Agricultural production contin- antifungal potential. Chitosan is able to chelate various organic ues to be challenged by a large number of insect pests, diseases, and inorganic compounds, making it well-suited for improving the and weeds accounting for 40% losses to the tune of US $2000 bil- stability, solubility and biocidal activity of chelated fungicides or lion per year. To manage these losses and enhance productivity, other pesticides. For example, copper (Cu) compounds are well farmers are making excessive and indiscriminate use of agrochem- known for their antifungal nature and have been used with chi- icals which leads to deterioration of soil health, degradation of tosan for antibacterial and antifungal activities. The majority of the agro-ecosystems, residue problems, environmental pollution and research on chitosan nanoparticles in agricultural research studied pesticide resistance in insects and pathogens. Hence, there is an their biocidal and antagonistic effects on bacteria and fungi, and urgent need to change the manner in which we use agrochem- gave encouraging results [71–73]. Chitosan-based nanocompos- icals. Changes can include (i) judicious deployment of pesticide ite films, especially silver-containing ones, showed antimicrobial and fertilizer, (ii) rapid and precise detection of pathogens and activity against several pathogens , but some effect was also pests, as well as pesticides and nutrient levels, and (iii) promoting observed with chitosan films alone. Other studies investigated soil health by agrochemical degradation. In this context, nano- the use of chitosan–PVA hydrogels for antimicrobial and food pack- technology has emerged as a technological advancement that can aging applications [76–78]. The combination of silver nanoparticles transform agriculture and allied sectors by providing with novel within a chitosan–PVA polymeric material also emerged as one tools for the molecular management of biotic and abiotic stresses, of the most promising candidates for new antimicrobial materials rapid disease detection and enhancing the ability of plants to absorb. Recently, application of chitosan particles loaded with copper nutrients or pesticides [3–5]. Besides this, nanobiotechnology can has been reported in waste water treatment [79,80]. Considering also improve our understanding of crop biology and thus can poten- the growing interest, and recent advances, in chitosan-based nano- tially enhance crop yields or their nutritional values. Nanosensors materials in medical and pharmacological applications, the purpose and nano-based smart delivery systems are some of the nanotech- of this article is to review the current and ongoing research and nology applications that are currently employed in the agricultural developmental efforts into chitosan nanoparticles as a delivery sys- industry to aid with combating crop pathogens, minimizing nutri- tem, with particular focus on describing methods that would be ent losses in fertilization, improving crop productivity through suitable for promoting crop productivity. optimized water and nutrient management as well as to enhance the efficiency of pesticides at lower dosage rates [6,7]. Nanotech- 1.1. Chitosan in crop production and protection nology derived devices are also being explored in the field of plant breeding and genetic transformation [8,9]. Table 1 describes There have been several reports describing the use of chitosan some of the advancements made in the field of agricultural nano- for biotic and abiotic stress management in agriculture [73,81–85]. technology. Among all these advancements, encapsulating active Table 3 lists some of the applications of chitosan in crop pro- ingredients, such as fertilizers, herbicides, fungicides, insecticides, duction and protection. For the first time, Allan and Hadwiger and micronutrients in controlled release matrices is one of the most described the application of chitosan as an antimicrobial promising and viable options for tackling current challenges in the agent. This has led to the exploitation of its antimicrobial potential area of agricultural sustainability and food security in the face of in various sectors of agriculture. Since the 1980s, the study of climate change. It has been shown that encapsulation of active chitosan has been shift from a general sewage treatment agent ingredients in nanoparticles enhances the efficacy of chemical to plant growth regulator, soil conditioner, vegetables and fruits ingredients, reducing their volatilization, and decreasing toxicity antistaling agent, and seed coating agent, especially in the crop and environmental contamination. disease management. Several studies showed that chitosan is not Chitosan has emerged as one of the most promising polymers only an antimicrobial agent but also an effective elicitor of plant for the efficient delivery of agrochemicals and micronutrients in systemic acquired resistance to pathogens [73,82,84,131]. This nanoparticles (Fig. 1; Table 2). The enhanced efficiency and effi- polymer has been reported to be the enhancer and regulator of cacy of nanoformulations are due to higher surface area, induction plant growth, development and yield [85,132,133]. Chitosan has of systemic activity due to smaller particle size and higher mobility, been demonstrated to induce plant defences in tomato [87,89], and lower toxicity due to elimination of organic solvents in com- cucumber , chilli seeds , strawberry fruits and rose parison to conventionally used pesticides and their formulations shrubs. Chitosan can activate innate immunity by stimulating [62,63]. Chitosan nanoparticles have been investigated as a car- hydrogen peroxide (H2 O2 ) production in rice [134,135], induce rier for active ingredient delivery for various applications (Fig. 1) a defense response by nitric oxide (NO) pathways in tobacco owing to their biocompatibility, biodegradability, high perme- [136,137], promote the development and drought resistance of ability, cost-effectiveness, non-toxicity and excellent film forming coffee , support the synthesis of phytoalexin , impact the ability. Over the past three decades, various procedures like jasmonic acid–ethylene (JA/ET) signaling marker in oilseed rape cross-linking, emulsion formation, coacervation, precipitation and , cause changes in protein phosphorylation , activate self-assembly, etc. have been employed to synthesize chitosan mitogen-activated protein kinases (MAPKs) and trigger 38 P.L. Kashyap et al. / International Journal of Biological Macromolecules 77 (2015) 36–51 Table 1 Major advancements of nanotechnology in agriculture. Year Advancement/application(s) Institute(s)/company Reference 2003 Soil binder product based, on a nano-siliica component, to US based company (ETC Group, 2004) prevent soil runoff and allow seeds blended into the product to germinate 2005 Inorganic Zn–Al layered double hydroxide (ZAL) nanocomposite Advanced Materials Laboratory, Institute of Advanced based controlled release of herbicide Technology (ITMA), Malaysia (2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetate (2,4-D)) 2006 Rapid analysis of pirimicarb residues in vegetables using University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong SAR, China. molecularly imprinted polymers (methacrylic acid with carboxyl functional groups) as recognition elements 2006 Nano-TiO2 on glassy carbon electrode to detect parathion Wuhan University, Wuhan, China; Chinese Academy of Sciences, (pesticide) residue in vegetables Beijing, China 2006 Porous hollow silica nanoparticles (PHSNs) for controlled Beijing University of Chemical Technology, Beijing, China delivery system for water-soluble pesticide (validamycin) 2006 Filters coated with TiO2 nanoparticles for the photocatalytic University of Ulster, UK degradation of agrochemicals in contaminated waters 2007 Pesticide detection with aliposome-based nano-biosensor University of Crete, GR 2007 Mesoporus silica nanoparticles transporting DNA to transform Iowa State university, US plant cells 2008 Primo MAXX® , nano emulsions as plant growth regulator and Syngenta Crop Protection, Greensboro, NC stress alleviator 2008 Starch nanoparticles conjugated with fluorescent material Université de Perpignan via Domitia, Perpignan, France; Institute transporting DNA to transform plant cells for Bioengineering of Catalonia, Barcelone, Spain 2008 Nanofibres from wheat straw and soy hulls for Canadian Universities and Ontario Ministry of Agriculture, Food bio-nanocomposite production and Rural Affairs, CA 2009 PEG coated nanoparticles loaded with garlic essential oil for Huazhong Agricultural University, Wuhan, China control of storage pests (Tribolium castaneum) 2009 Cadmium telluride quantum dots (CdTe QDs) to detect 2, Central Food Technological Research Institute, Mysore, India. 4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid (2, 4-D), (herbicide) 2009 Methyl parathion and chlorpyrifos residue detection using nano Institute of Animal Reproduction and Food Research, Tuwima, size polyaniline matrix with SWCNT, single stranded DNA and Poland enzyme 2009 Nano-sensor for early detection of grain spoilage during storage University of Manitoba, Winnipeg 2009 Pesticide detection using gold nanoparticles based dipstick Central Food Technological Research Institute, Mysore, India. competitive immuno-assay 2009 Fluorescence silica nanoparticles in combination with antibody MingDao University, Taiwan; National Chung-Hsing University, to detect Xanthomonas axonopodis pv. Vesicatoria in Taiwan solanaceaous crops 2010 Soil-enhancer product, based on a nano-clay component, for Geohumus-Frankfurt, DE water retention and release 2010 Pesticide detection using nano-Au/nafion composite in Beijing University of Technology, China vegetables (cabbage, spinach, lettuce) 2010 Carbon nanotube (CNT) conjugated with INF24 oligonucleotides Universidad de Chile, Chile to reduce the bean rust disease severity 2010 Magnetic carbon coated nanoparticles as smart agrochemical IFAPA, Centro Alameda del Obispo, Área de Mejora y Biotecnología, delivery system Córdoba, Spain; CSIC-Universidad de Zaragoza, Spain; CSIC, Instituto de Agricultura Sostenible, Alameda Córdoba, Spain 2010 Polyhydroxybutyrate-co-hydroxyvalerate microspheres as UNESP—Univ. Estadual Paulista, Brazil; UNICAMP, Cidade controlled release herbicide delivery system for atrazine Universitária Zeferino, Brazil; University of Sorocaba, Sorocaba, SP, Brazil 2010 Pathogen detection (Tilletia indica) using nano-gold based G.B Pant University of Agri. & Tech., Pantnagar, India; National immunosensors based on surface plasmon resonance (SPR) Physical Laboratory, New Delhi, India 2010 Pathogen (Sclerotinia sclerotiorum) detection based on Huazhong University of Science and Technology, Hubei China; electrochemical sensor, using modified gold electrode with Chinese Academy of Agricultural Sciences-Key Laboratory for copper nanoparticle to monitor the levels of salicylic acid in oil Genetic Improvement of Oil Crops, China seeds 2011 Amino-functionalized nanocomposite with Ningbo Municipal Center for Disease Control and Prevention, tetra-ethylene-pent-amine for organochlorine and Zhejiang, China. organophosphorus pesticides in cabbage 2011 Optical sensor for the detection of pesticides (Dipel, Siven 85% Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia, Malaysia WP) in water using ZnCdSe Quantum dots films 2012 Neem oil (Azadirachta indica) nanoemulsion as larvicidal agent VIT University, India 2012 Macronutrient fertilizers coated with zinc oxide nanoparticles University of Adelaide, AU CSIRO Land and Water, AU Kansas State University, US 2012 Amphotericin B nanodisks (AMB-NDs) for the treatment of Área de Mejora y Biotecnología, Córdoba, Spain fungal pathogens in chickpea and wheat plants 2013 Pheromone nanogel for the efficient management of fruit-fly Indian Institute of Science (IIS), Bangalore, India; National Bureau of Agriculturally Important Insects (NBAII), India 2013 1-Naphthylacetic acid silica conjugated nanospheres for control China Agricultural University, China release and as a plant growth regulator 2014 Nanoformulation based on chitosan/tripolyphosphate UNESP—Univ. Estadual Paulista, Brazil; UNICAMP, Cidade nanoparticles loaded with paraquat herbicide for control release Universitária Zeferino, Brazil; University of Sorocaba, Sorocaba, and eco-friendly weed management SP, Brazil and Max Rubner Institut, Karlsruhe, Germany 2014 Poly(epsilon-caprolactone) nanoparticles containing atrazine UNESP—Univ. Estadual Paulista, Brazil; UNICAMP, Cidade herbicide as an alternative technique to control weeds and Universitária Zeferino, Brazil; reduce damage to the environment P.L. Kashyap et al. / International Journal of Biological Macromolecules 77 (2015) 36–51 39 Fig. 1. Strategies for the production of chitosan naoparticles and their applications as a delivery system in agriculture. Table 2 Some examples of active ingredients encapsulated in chitosan-based controlled release matrices in agriculture. Matrices Method Active ingredient Characteristics Reference(s) Cu-chitosan nanoparticles Ionic gelation CuSO4 Enhanced antifungal activity against Alternaria alternate, Macrophomina phaseolina and Rhizoctonia solani ␣-Fe3 O4 -CS nanocomposite film Cross-linking ␣-Fe3 O4 Heavy metals monitoring with low detection limit Chitosan microspheres Emulsion cross-linking Urea Controlled release of the urea fertilizer Chitosan–PVA hydrogel Cross-linking Silver nanoaprticles Size of 13 nm; exhibits good antibacterial activity Alginate reinforced chitosan and Cross-linking Imazaquin (Herbicide) Porous spherical beads of 2.31 mm size; sustained starch beads slow release of active material Composite gel Cross-linking Atrazine (Herbicide) and Sustained release of active material in water for imidacloprid 572 h for atrazine and 24 h for imidacloprid, respectively Chitosan microspheres Emulsion cross-linking Auxins (Agrochemical) Chitosan microspheres extended action of auxin release (up to 120 h) Chitosan microspheres Cross-linking Paraquat (Herbicide) Sustained release of active material in water for 8 h Chitosan–silver nanoparticles Cross-linking Silver nanoparticles Pesticide removal for extended periods composite micro-beads Chitosan-coated NPK compound Urea, calcium phosphate and Size of 78 nm; controlled release of the NPK fertilizer potassium chloride fertilizer Chitosan hydrogels Cross-linking Potassium nitrate (KNO3 ) and Hydrogel in the form of circular pads with 2 mm in Dihydrogen ammonium thickness and 120 mm in diameter; controlled phosphate [(NH4 )2 HPO4 ] release of the potassium fertilizer; enhanced up to 25% water retention of the soil Chitosan microcapsules Precipitation 3-Hydroxy-5-methylisoxazole Size of 5 m; sustained release of active material (Herbicide) in water for 80–160 h Chitosan gel beads (with acetic or Cross-linking Atrazine (Herbicide) and urea Extended release period of atrazine to 7 months; propionic anhydride) (Fertilizer) chitosan-coated urea beads extended action of urea release (up to 180 h) Beauvericin–chitosan Ionic gelation Beauvericin (Pesticidal Improved pesticidal activity against groundnut nanoparticles cyclodepsipeptide) defoliator Spodoptera litura Alginate–chitosan microcrystals Self-assembly Imidacloprid (Insecticide) A novel photodegradable insecticide; controlled and sustained release of midacloprid; showed toxicity against Martianus dermestoides adults Chitosan nanoparticles + chitosan – Dichlorprop (Herbicide) Enhanced toxicity to fresh water green algae and slow release of Dichlorprop Chitosan microspheres Coacervation–cross-linking Brassinosteroids (Hormones) Controlled delivery of brassinosteroids with biological activity as agrochemicals Chitosan – Dichlorprop (Herbicide) Controlled and slow release of dichlorprop Chitosan nanoparticles – Hexavalent chromium (Metal) Effective agent for in situ subsurface environment remediation N-(octadecanol-1-glycidyl Reverse micelle Rotenone (Insecticide) Useful as a prospective carrier for control released ether)-O-sulfate chitosan agrochemical (NOSCS) micelle Chitosan – 1-Naphthylacetic acid Controlled and slow release of 1-Naphthylacetic (Hormone) acid –, Not mentioned. 40 P.L. Kashyap et al. / International Journal of Biological Macromolecules 77 (2015) 36–51 Table 3 Principal studies reported in the literature involving chitosan use for plant growth promotion and protection from 1984 to 2015. Year Plant/crop Effect/impact of chitosan application Reference 1984 Pea Antifungal activity against Fusarium solani due to synthesis and elicitation of pisatin phytoalexin 1992 Tomato Enhanced resistance of tomato plants to the crown and root rot pathogen Fusarium oxysporum f. sp. radicis-lycopersici 1992 Strawberry Antifungal activity against postharvest pathogens 1994 Tomato Induction of systemic resistance to Fusarium crown and root rot 1998 Celery Reduction in the incidence and severity of Fusarium yellows 2001 Pepper Enhanced biomass production and yield by decreasing transpiration and water use by 26–43% 2001 Maize Induction in endogenous hormone content, alpha-amylase activity and chlorophyll content in seedling leaves 2002 Mulberry Enhancement in respiration rate of germination seeds, root vigor, chlorophyll, protein content and peroxidase in seedlings as well as nitrate reductase and amylase activities 2002 Cucumber, Chilli, pumpkin, Increment in the seed germination rate and cabbage 2002 Peanut Enhancement in the energy of germination and germination percentage 2002 Soybean Enhancement in growth and yield 2003 Cucumber Containment of gray mold infection in plants caused by Botyrtis cinerea 2003 Potato Enhancement in yield and late blight resistance by Arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi band chitosan sprays 2004 Rose shrubs Enhanced resistance against foliar diseases 2004 Date palm Antifungal activity against Fusarium oxysporum f. sp. albedinis and elicitor of defence reactions 2005 Maize Increased in plant vigor 2006 Chilli Enhanced resitance against Colletotrichum sp.; promote of seedling growth 2006 Grapevine Induction of plant defence system against gray mold and downy mildew 2007 Rice (Oryza sativa) Induction of defence response against Pyricularia grisea 2007 Papaya Antifungal activity against anthracnose and improvement in quality retention of papaya during storage 2008 Tobacco Elicitation of callose apposition and abscisic acid accumulation in response to Tobacco necrosis virus attack 2008 Pearl millet Enhanced seed germination and seedling vigor 2009 Maize Increased chilling tolerance of maize seedlings and induced higher activities of antioxidative enzymes 2010 Pear Elevated defense-related enzymes activity 2010 Grape Direct antifungal activity against Botrytis bunch rot and induction of defense-related enzymes activities 2010 Sweet cherry Maintained quality attributes and extended the postharvest life by inducing defense-related enzymes activities 2010 Mango Combined effects of postharvest heat treatment and chitosan coating on quality and antimicrobial properties of fresh cut mangoes 2011 Hypericum perforatum Produced xanthone-rich extracts with antifungal activity 2011 Tomato Accumulated phosphatidic acid and nitric oxide 2011 Apricot Direct inhibition activity against fruit rot 2011 Radish Promoted the uptake of nutrients, nitrogen, potassium and phosphorous, decreased cadmium concentration 2011 Barley Induced stomatal closure 2012 Okra Foliar application of chitosan (100 ppm) enhanced growth and fruit yield 2012 Sycamore Enhanced the production of H2 O2 and nitric oxide 2012 Rice Sheath blight induced activity of defense-related enzymes 2013 Ajowan (Carum copticum) Improvement in the germination and growth performance of ajowan (Carum copticum) under salt stress 2013 Safflower and sunflower Elevated activity of antioxidant enzymes 2013 Rice Showed positive and promising effects in increasing rice yield and inhibiting brown backed rice plant-hoppers 2013 Watermelon Direct killing effect and protection from fruit blotch disease 2013 Peach Reduced brown rot infection and enhanced antioxidant and defense-related enzymes 2013 Pine Up-regulated the expression level of defense-related enzymes and Pitch canker 2013 Camellia Accumulated H2 O2 , defense-related enzymes, and soluble protein and Anthracnose 2013 Broccoli Antimicrobial coating served as carriers for bioactive compounds 2014 Tomato Alternatives fungicide for controlling Fusarium crown and root rot 2015 Wheat Potential application as a plant growth regulator defense-related gene expression. Even applied on plants could increase the germination rate of cucumber, chilli, pumpkin together with biological control agents, chitosan enhanced the and cabbage. Manjunatha et al. reported that seed priming efficacy in the control of pathogens [144,145]. Soil amendment with chitosan enhances seed germination and seedling vigor in with chitosan has frequently been shown to control Fusarium pearl millet. Further, it is also noticed that seed priming with acidic wilts [90,146,147] and gray molds [97,103] in a number of crops. chitosan solutions improved the maize vigor. Similarly, It is interesting to note that these studies show chitosan to be rice seedlings treated with chitosan induced defense responses fungistatic against both biotrophic and necrotrophic pathogens. against the rice blast pathogen, Magnaporthe grisea by inducing Besides this, another one of the most important bioactivity of the production of the phytoalexins (sakuranetin and monilactone chitosan on plants is stimulation of seed germination in response A) in leaves. Moreover, chitosan also stimulated the growth to abiotic stress. In peanut, seed coated with chitosan enhance the and yield of rice along with reinforcing the defense response. energy of germination and germination percentage. Dzung In addition, other studies also supported a role of chitosan in and Thang suggested that chitosan could enhance growth and modulating the plant response to several abiotic stresses including yield in soybean. Seed soaked with chitosan increased germination salt and water stress [121,138,150]. For instance, Boonlertnirun rate, length and weight of hypocotyls and radicle in rapeseed. et al. found that chitosan treatments had a significant effect Chandrkrachang also found that the application of chitosan on the growth or yield of drought-stressed rice plants compared to P.L. Kashyap et al. / International Journal of Biological Macromolecules 77 (2015) 36–51 41 Table 4 Pros and cons of various strategies used for the synthesis of chitosan encapsulated active compounds. Strategies Pros Cons Reference(s) Ionotropic gelation Simple and mild procedure; no chemical Release of active ingredient depends on [66,158–162] cross-linking; reduce the possible toxic side molecular weight, degree of deacetylation, and effects of chemicals or reagents used in the concentration of chitosan procedure; and better control of degradation kinetics Emulsion cross-linking High drug loading efficiency; controlled Tedious process, uses harsh crosslinking [40,66,159,161,163] release with improved bioavailability; and agents, problem of reactivity of active agent easy to control particle size with cross-linking agent, and challenge of complete removal of unreacted cross-linking agent Emulsion-droplet coalescence High loading efficiency and smaller particle Particle size depends on the degree of [66,164] size deacetylation of chitosan. The decreased degree of deacetylation increases particle size which in turn decreases drug content Precipitation Efficient control of particle size and drug Partial protection of the loaded active agent [40,159] release; and avoids the use of toxic organic from nuclease degradation solvents Reverse micellar method Thermodynamically stable particle size with Tedious and laborious process [40,66] suitable polydispersity index; and narrow size distribution with smaller particle size Sieving method Simple procedure and can be easily scaled up Irregular particle shape Spray drying method High drug stability, good entrapment Particle size depends on size of nozzle, spray [40,159] efficiency, prolonged drug release attributes flow rate, pressure inlet air temperature; and and useful method to prepare powder encapsulation efficiency depends on the formulation molecular weight of chitosan control plants. It is interesting to note that the effect was greatest of molecular weights (500–1400 kDa) and degrees of acetylation. when chitosan was applied before the onset of stressful conditions. Chitosan’s amine group also readily lends itself to other chem- Bittelli et al. also noticed that the water use of pepper plants ical modifications. Chitosan easily absorbs to plant surfaces (e.g. treated with chitosan reduced by 26–43%, with no significant leaf and stems), which helps to prolong the contact time between change in biomass production or yield. These findings indicate agrochemicals and the target absorptive surface. Chitosan nanopar- that chitosan has potential to be developed as an antitranspirant in ticles are known to facilitate active molecule or compound uptake agricultural situations where excessive water loss is undesirable. through the cell membrane. The absorption enhancing effect of chi- Recently, chitosan coatings have emerged as an ideal alterna- tosan nanoparticles improves the molecular bioavailability of the tive to chemically synthesized pesticides. It has been reported to active ingredients contained within the nanoparticles. Taken reduce the growth of decay and induced resistance in the host together, these advantages indicate that chitosan has a bright future tissue. Chitosan can also help to protect the safety of edi- as a drug delivery system in the field of sustainable agriculture. ble products. The protection of fresh cut broccoli with chitosan against E. coli and Listeria monocytogenes was assisted with bioac- 1.3. Strategies for production of chitosan nanoparticles tive components such as bee pollen and extracts from propolis and pomegranate. Chitosan protection by exclusion occurs with Chitosan nanoparicles can be synthesized by various techniques soybean seed treatments. In this case the major advantage was pro- viz., emulsion cross-linking, emulsion-droplet coalescence, precip- tection from insects such as agarotis, ypsilon, soybean pod borer, itation, ionotropic gelation, reverse micelles and sieving through and soybean aphids. Additionally, the treatment was also accom- nano-scaled controlled release devices. A comparison of these tech- panied by increases in seed germination, plant growth and soybean niques, their merits and demerits are summarized in Table 4. The yield. From the above points, it is clear that the chitosan products selection of methods for chitosan nanoparticles synthesis depends are more effective and can be used in a numbers of ways to reduce on requirements such as the particle size and shape, thermal sta- disease levels and enhance crop productivity in a eco-friendly and bility, release time of the active ingredients, and residual toxicity sustainable manner. of the final product. 1.2. Chitosan as a promising delivery system 1.4. Emulsion cross-linking Chitosan is one of the most widely used polymers in the field Emulsions are a standard process leading to nanoparticulate of drug delivery. Its attractiveness relies on its useful structural phases, while cross-linking is a common way to stabilize a par- and biological properties [154,155], which include a cationic char- ticle structure and to manipulate the controlled-release properties acter, solubility in aqueous acidic media, and biodegradability. of that particle. Altering the cross-linking degree of a particle Chitosan has a low solubility at physiological pH of 7.4 as it is modifies an agrochemical’s permeability through it. Cross-linking a weak base (pKa 6.2–7). Chitosan is synthesized by removing enhances the mechanical strength of the final particle by introduc- the acetate moiety from chitin through amide hydrolysis under ing a three-dimensional network structure into the nano-emulsion. alkaline conditions (concentrated NaOH) or through enzymatic The process begins when a chitosan solution is emulsified in hydrolysis in the presence of chitin deacetylase. Chitosan’s an oil phase (water-in-oil emulsion). The chitosan phase is first amine groups readily complex with a variety of oppositely charged stabilized by a suitable surfactant, and is then reacted with an polymers such as poly(acrylic acid), sodium salt of poly(acrylic appropriate cross linking agent (e.g. formaldehyde, glutaraldehyde, acid), carboxymethyl cellulose, xanthan, carrageenan, alginate and genipin, glyoxal, etc.). This is followed by washing and drying of pectin, etc.. Chitosan also provides considerable flexibility the resulting nanoparticles. This method is schematically for development of formulation, as it is available in wide range represented in Fig. 2(A). The particle size is mainly determined 42 P.L. Kashyap et al. / International Journal of Biological Macromolecules 77 (2015) 36–51 Fig. 2. Schematic representation of various methods for the synthesis of chitosan nanoparticles. (A) Emulsion cross-linking; (B) emulsion-droplet coalescence; (C) ionotropic gelation; (D) precipitation; (E) reverse micelles; (F) sieving; and (G) spray drying. The term ‘drug’ is used to represent an agrochemical compound, micronutrient and genetic material, etc. P.L. Kashyap et al. / International Journal of Biological Macromolecules 77 (2015) 36–51 43 Fig. 2. (Continued ). by the size of the emulsion droplet, which in turn is dependent somewhat tedious and the use of harsh, and often expensive, cross- on the type of surfactant, degree of crosslinking and the stirring linking agents can induce undesirable chemical reactions with the speed. The molecular weight and concentration of chitosan active agent. Recently, Fan et al. studied the synthesis and also affect the preparation and performance of the nanoparti- controlled release characteristics of auxin-loaded chitosan micro- cles [40,167]. The major drawback of this method is that it is spheres using a cross-linker. They found that the cumulative release 44 P.L. Kashyap et al. / International Journal of Biological Macromolecules 77 (2015) 36–51 of the auxins from the particles reached a maximum (60%) after CS chains and impels the formation of irregular and smaller size about 120 h. They also observed that maximum encapsulation effi- nanoparticle cores. At even higher  ratios, the very low concen- ciency was significantly influenced by the type of cross-linker, tration of TPP results in low nanoparticle core densities because of cross-linking time and the oil/water phase ratio. Based on these the increased distance between successive H-links, ultimately lead- results this procedure is suitable to prepare chitosan nanoparticles ing to an increased nanoparticle size. Besides this, a recent work on for prolonged controlled release of compounds, possibly spanning chitosan/TPP nanoparticles has also established that the concentra- weeks or months, and do so with greater safety to non-target orga- tion of acetic acid used to dissolve chitosan and the temperature at nisms. which the cross-linking process occurs, strongly affect the size dis- tribution of the obtained nanoparticles. Fàbregasa et al. 1.5. Emulsion-droplet coalescence found that the stirring speed during ionic gelation significantly affect reaction yield. Therefore, manipulation of this parameter can This method follows the principles of emulsion by cross-linking be used to give some control over size range that is obtained to favor but uses precipitation techniques [168,169]. An emulsion is first the maximum yield of nanoparticles of desired size. prepared by dispersing chitosan solution and liquid paraffin oil. The active ingredient and a sodium hydroxide solution are combined 1.7. Precipitation and added to the first emulsion to produce additional droplets. High-speed mixing is then used to generate collisions between This method is quite simple. Chitosan nanoparticles are pro- the different droplets, randomly combining them and precipitating duced by blowing a chitosan solution into an alkaline solution [e.g. particles of small size. The particle size depends primarily on NaOH(aq) ] or methanol. The blowing is accomplished with a com- the degree of deacetylation of chitosan. Generally, at lower degree pressed air nozzle, thereby forming the coacervate particles. These of deacetylation, large size particles with less ability to retain the are separated and purified by filtration and followed by washing active ingredients are obtained. The pictorial representation with hot and cold water. The method is schematically repre- of the method is shown in Fig. 2B. Using this procedure, Toku- sented in Fig. 2D. Generally, various parameters viz., compressed air mistu et al. synthesized gadopentetic acid loaded chitosan pressure, spray nozzle diameter and chitosan concentration affects nanoparticles (452 nm) with 45% drug loading efficiency. A similar the particle shape and size. Although this method is simple, cross- methodology has been adopted by Anto et al. to encapsulate linking is required to enhance the particle stability, and even then 5-fluorouracil. Interestingly, when two emulsions with equal outer particles have weak mechanical strength and irregular morphol- phase are mixed together, droplets of each collide randomly and ogy. coalesce, resulting in final droplets with uniform content. 1.8. Reverse micelles 1.6. Ionotropic gelation This method uses a thermodynamically stable mixture of water, The chitosan nanoparticles produced through this method are oil and lipophilic surfactant. Using this method, it is possible to stable, non-toxic and organic solvent free [41,48,169–172]. It is obtain very small polymeric nanoparticles (≤10 nm) with a uniform very simple, and employs the use of oppositely charged complexes distribution compared with other methods. The size, polydisper- (polyanions) to bond to the oppositely charged amino groups of chi- sity and thermodynamic stability of the particles are maintained tosan (NH3 + ). Tripolyphosphate (TPP) is the most commonly used in a dynamic equilibrium system. Briefly, the method consists of ionic cross-linker, and relies on electrostatic interaction instead of preparing a surfactant solution (e.g. sodium bis(ethyl hexyl) sul- chemical cross-linking, avoiding the possible toxicity of reagents fosuccinate or cetyl trimethylammonium bromide) in an organic and other adverse reactions. However, the cross-linking is pH- solvent (e.g. n-hexane), to which a chitosan solution and the active dependent. In this procedure, chitosan is dissolved in a weak acidic ingredient are added under constant stirring, forming a transpar- medium and added drop wise under constant stirring to an aqueous ent mini- or micro-emulsion. Subsequently, a cross-linking agent solution containing the other reagents (Fig. 2C). Due to the com- (e.g. glutaraldehyde) is added and the system is maintained under plexation between oppositely charged species, chitosan undergoes constant agitation. The organic solvent is then evaporated, pro- ionic gelation and the spherical nanoparticles precipitate. The ducing a dry and transparent mass that is dispersed in water. A chitosan/TPP molar ratio largely controls the mean diameter of the salt is then added to this system, which precipitates the surfac- nanoparticles, which can also affect the drug release characteristics. tant. The resulting mixture is centrifuged and the supernatant, Interestingly, the mechanism of nanoparticle formation through containing nanoparticles loaded with the active substance, is col- ionic gelation is well described by several workers [174,175]. It has lected. The nanoparticles are separated by dialysis and lyophilized been suggested that all ionic groups of TPP participated in interac- to obtain a dry powder. The method is schematically repre- tions with chitosan amine groups. The ion pairs, formed through sented in Fig. 2E. Brunel et al. used a reverse micellar method the negatively charged TPP with the protonated amine function- to prepare chitosan nanoparticles. They emphasized that chitosan ality of chitosan in ionotropic gelation provided chitosan with an of low molecular weight is preferable to achieve better control over amphoteric character, which enhanced the protein adhesion and particle size and distribution. This may be due to a reduction in subsequently accelerated the attachment of anchorage dependant the viscosity of the internal aqueous phase or entanglement of the cells. Recently, Koukaras et al. provided insights into the polymer chains during the process. In recent times, this method intermolecular interactions responsible for the ionic cross-linking has been use for enzyme immobilization and to encapsulate during ionotropic gelation by means of all electron density func- oligonucleotides. To date, despite some of the advantages, the tional theory. They reported that the maximum-interaction relative use of this method to produce chitosan nanoparticles is limited, due configurations of TPP and chitosan oligomers depended on the pri- to the difficulty of isolating the nanoparticles and need to use a large mary ionic cross-linking types (H-, M- and T-links). In all three of the quantity of organic solvent. linking types, there is a high degree of correspondence between chi- tosan monomers and TPP polyanions, and thus, these correspond 1.9. Seiving method to low  (and ␣) ratios. As a result, at low  ratios, the high con- centration of TPP permits the formation of dense H-links. At high This method involves the cross-linking of an aqueous acidic  (and ␣) ratios, the dihedral bias deters the formation of parallel solution of chitosan using glutaraldehyde. The cross-linked P.L. Kashyap et al. / International Journal of Biological Macromolecules 77 (2015) 36–51 45 chitosan is then passed through a sieve with suitable mesh size 1.12. Release kinetics of active ingredients from chitosan to obtain microparticles. The microparticles are then washed nanoparticles with sodium hydroxide (0.1 N) solution to remove the unreacted glutataraldehyde and dried at 40 ◦ C. This method does not The release of an active ingredient from chitosan-based parti- seem to be being extensively researched for agricultural use. The cles depends upon the morphology, size, density, and extent and method is schematically shown in Fig. 2F. rate of cross-linking of the particles, as well as the physicochemical properties of the drug. If any adjuvant is used this can also affect the release rate. Studies showed that under in vitro conditions, the 1.10. Spray drying release of an active ingredient is affected by pH, solvent polarity, and the presence of enzymes in the dissolution media [188,189]. This method is extensively used for the production of matri- Generally, the release of drug from chitosan particles occurs by ces to produce dry powders, granules and pellets from chitosan one, or a combination of three different mechanisms: (i) an osmot- solutions and suspensions. The technique is quite versatile ically driven burst mechanism, (ii) a diffusion mechanism, and (iii) and can be used for drugs with high or low heat-sensitivity and erosion or degradation of the polymer. In agricultural systems the with high or low water solubility, and hydrophilic or hydropho- release mechanisms are by diffusion release and/or degradation bic polymers. This procedure is inexpensive and employs release. The diffusion release mechanism includes several steps a single step to produce small-sized particles that are typically viz., (i) penetration of water into particulate system, which causes micro-sized, and then these particles are often reformulate into swelling of the matrix; (ii) conversion of a glassy polymer into a suspensions, capsules or tablets. This technique uses a chi- plasticized or rubbery swollen matrix, and (iii) diffusion of com- tosan solution in acetic acid, to which the active ingredient and the pound from the swollen matrix. cross-linking agent (glutaraldehyde or sodium tripolyphosphate) The original active ingredient content contained in chitosan par- are consecutively added (Fig. 2G). The resulting solution is atom- ticles is determined in different ways, but the release from the ized through a hot air stream, causing flash evaporation of the chitosan particles, is typically measured from particles placed in solvent to form the desired particles. The important parame- phosphate buffer saline (PSB; pH 7.4) and kept in a thermostatic ters to modulate particle size in this process are the type of needle, incubator at 37 ◦ C. Specified volumes of the buffered medium are flow speed of the compressed air, air temperature and degree of removed at regular intervals from the sample being analyzed, and cross-linking. This method can be used to synthesize particles that same amount of fresh buffer is added back into the flask to with or without cross-linking, and has been used to prepare chi- keep the total solution volume constant throughout the duration tosan micro-particles for the delivery of cimetidine, famotidine and of the study. The aliquot of removed sample is then filtered and nizatidine. Recently, Tokárová et al. used spray-dried the transparent filtrate is analyzed. The quantity of active ingre- chitosan microcarriers for the delivery of silver nanoparticles. dient in the aliquot is typically determined by spectroscopic or chromatographic methods. 1.11. Strategies for loading active ingredient into chitosan Diffusion release of active ingredient is typical for hydrophilic nanoparticles polymers that form hydrogels (e.g. polyvinyl alcohol), while dif- fusion and degradation release occurs with chitosan. It is not Loading active ingredient into nanoparticulate systems can be uncommon to observe an initial “burst” release of active ingre- done at the time of preparation of particles (incorporation) or after dient from particles that predominantly release active ingredient the formation of particles (incubation). In these systems, the active by diffusion or degradation. This happens due to the adsorption ingredient is physically embedded within the matrix or adsorbed of active ingredients onto the surface of the particles. Once this on the surface. Various techniques have been developed to improve burst is exhausted, a slow and steady release is observed that accel- the efficiency of loading the active ingredient, but the efficiency erates if and when the particle matrix begins to degrade. Kweon largely depends on the method of preparation and the physico- and Kang synthesized chitosan–polyvinylalcohol (PVA) par- chemical properties of the substance. Loading efficiency is generally ticles to study the compound release mechanism of the active maximized when the substance is incorporated during the forma- ingredient under various conditions. They calculated the diffusion tion of particles, while incubations typically give a much lower controlled release by analysis of the linear relationship between degree of incorporation. However, the degree of incorporation is the amount of active ingredient released and the square root of also influenced by the specific process parameters such as exact the time. Jamnongkan and Kaewpirom demonstrated potas- method of preparation, presence of additives (e.g. cross linking sium release kinetics and water retention of controlled-release agent, surfactant stabilizers, etc.), and agitation intensity. fertilizers based on chitosan hydrogels is through a quasi-Fickian Both hydrophillic and hydrophobic compounds can be loaded into diffusion mechanism. Similarly, Jameela et al. obtained a good chitosan-based particulate systems. Water-soluble compounds are correlation fit for the cumulative drug released vs. square root of mixed with chitosan solution to form a homogeneous mixture, and time, demonstrating that the drug release from the microsphere then, particles can be produced by any of the methods described matrix is diffusion-controlled and obeys the Higuchi equation earlier in the section. Water-insoluble compounds that precipitate. It was demonstrated that the rate of release depends upon in the acidic chitosan solutions can be incorporated after particle the size of microspheres. Orienti et al. studied the correlation preparation by soaking the preformed particles with a saturated between matrix erosion and release kinetics of indomethacin- solution of the active ingredient. Water-insoluble drugs can also loaded chitosan microspheres. Release kinetics was correlated be loaded using a multiple emulsion technique. In this method, with the concentration of chitosan in the microsphere and pH of compound is dissolved into a suitable solvent and then emulsi- the release medium. Nam and Park have demonstrated the fied in the chitosan solution to form an oil-in-water type emulsion. in vitro release test of drug loaded chitosan microspheres. Agni- Sometimes, compounds can be dispersed within a chitosan solution hotri and Aminabhavi also analyzed the dynamic swelling by using a surfactant to form a suspension. The oil in water (o/w) data of chitosan microparticles and concluded that with increase emulsions or suspensions prepared in this manner can be further in cross-linking, swelling of chitosan microparticles decreases. emulsified into liquid paraffin to get oil-water-oil multiple emul- Recently, Khan and Ranjha studied the swelling behavior of sions. The resulting droplets can be hardened by using a suitable chitosan/poly(vinyl alcohol) hydrogels as a function of pH, poly- cross-linking agent. meric compositions and degree of cross-linking. They noticed that 46 P.L. Kashyap et al. / International Journal of Biological Macromolecules 77 (2015) 36–51 swelling increased by increasing poly(vinyl alcohol) contents in used as carriers of the essential oil of Lippia sidoides, which pos- the structure of hydrogels at higher pH. They also observed that sesses insecticidal properties. The findings indicated the suitability the cross-linking ratio was inversely related with the swelling of chitosan for use as matrices to carry bioinsecticides designed to of hydrogels. Similar results were also described by Martínez- control the proliferation of insect larvae. Similarly, microcapsules Ruvalcaba et al. , where drug release increased with increasing of alginate and chitosan were prepared, characterized, and evalu- drug contents in the hydrogels, while release of drug decreased ated as a carrier system for imidacloprid. The particles obtained as the ratio of crosslinking agent increased in the hydrogel struc- were stable and imidacloprid was encapsulated with an efficiency ture owing to strong physical entanglements between polymers. of around 82%. In release assays, it was shown that the release It is also important to note that the release rate of drugs from time of the encapsulated insecticide was up to eight times longer, hydrophilic matrices based on chitosan is greatly affected by compared to the free insecticide, and that alterations in the con- changes in pH. The increase in release rates could be due to an centrations of alginate and chitosan affected the release profile. In associated increase in the fluid-filled cavities created by dissolu- another independent study, Quiñones et al. described the use tion and diffusion of the drug particles near the surface, which in of chitosan microspheres to carry synthetic analogs of brassinos- turn results in an increase in the permeability of the drug. teroids and diosgenin derivatives. The release kinetics assay using water revealed that the least efficiently encapsulated steroids were released fastest from the particles. These results demonstrate that 2. Applications of chitosan nanoparticles as a delivery molecular modifications can be used to design effective systems for system the delivery and release of agrochemicals. Besides this, amphiphilic derivative of chitosan, N-(octadecanol-1-glycidyl ether)-O-sulfate 2.1. Pesticide delivery for crop protection chitosan has been evaluated as a carrier for the insecticide rotenone. The polymeric micelles formed were spherical, with a size The difficulties in controlling pests along with concern about the range of between 167 and 204 nm, and the nanoparticles were indiscriminate use of pesticides in agriculture have been the subject formed by self-assembly in aqueous solution. The encapsulation of of intense debate and discussion. The pressure to devise alternative rotenone increased its solubility in water 1300-fold, while in vitro methods of pest control, to reduce the dependency on synthetic release assays demonstrated that the nanoparticles provided sus- pesticides and reduce residue problem, is rising steadily. There tained release of the insecticide. The properties of nanomicelles are several examples of slow release of encapsulated agrochemi- based on NOSCS enable them to be used as carriers to encapsulate cals by polymeric nanoparticles. For example, Liu et al. used and subsequently release insoluble pesticides employed in agri- polyvinylpyridine and polyvinylpyridine-co-styrene nanoparticles culture. Feng and Peng synthesized a new compound based to control release of tebuconazole and chlorothalonil fungicides on chitosan, using carboxymethyl chitosan (CM-C) with ricinoleic for solid wood preservation. That method has given near quan- acid (RA) for use as a carrier of the biopesticide azadirachtin (AZA). titative incorporation of the active ingredient. A few years later The particles presented good polydispersion, with a size range of polymeric nanocapsules were described as vehicles for the pesti- 200–500 nm, as well as smooth spherical morphology and high zeta cides ivermectin and acetamiprid , while Wang et al. potential. The AZA encapsulation efficiency was 56%, and the par- used nanosized inorganic particles such as TiO2 , SiO2 , Fe2 O3 , or ticles were able to release the pesticide over a period of 11 days. Al2 O3 as pesticide carriers for increased bioactivity and reduc- The use of the carrier assisted the solubilization in water of this tion in residues. Boehm et al. obtained stable polymeric lipid-soluble pesticide, and could therefore offer advantages in agri- nanospheres (135 nm) with 3.5% encapsulation rate and despite cultural applications. the low active ingredient content, this formulation yielded signif- icant improvements in the bioavailability of the insecticide (RPA 2.2. Fertilizer delivery for balanced and sustained nutrition 107382) to plants. These researchers also performed biological studies on cotton plants infested with aphids to estimate the The extent and quality of plant growth is largely dependent direct contact efficacy of nanosphere formulations on insects. The on the quantity of fertilizer and water. So, improvement in crop nanosphere formulations performed better than the classical sus- outcomes requires improved utilization of water resources and pension to manage the infestation. It is important to note that the fertilizer nutrients. It is estimated that about 40–70% of nitrogen, developed nanosphere formulations are not better than the clas- 80–90% of phosphorus, and 50–70% of potassium of the applied sical suspension in terms of speed of action and sustained release. fertilizers is lost to the environment and cannot be absorbed by Nevertheless, nanosphere formulation performed better than the the intended plants. This is not only a substantial monetary and classical suspension to enhance the systemicity of the active ingre- resource loss but also results in serious environmental pollution dient and improve its penetration through the plant. It has been [50,205]. Several recent research studies have been published reported that nanoparticles loaded with essential garlic oil are that describe the use of superabsorbent polymers to enhance effective against Tribolium castaneum. It has also been reported germination and crop growth under arid and desert environments. that aluminosilicate-filled nanotubes stick to plant surfaces while The results are encouraging, and show that use of such materials the nanoscale aluminosilicate particles leach from the nanotubes can reduce water consumption in irrigation, and reduce the plant and subsequently stick to the surface hair of insect pests. These death rate [206,207]. An optimized combination of slow release particles ultimately enter the body and influence certain physio- fertilizers and superabsorbent polymers may not only significantly logical functions [200,201]. Recently, a pesticide company released improve plant nutrition and yields, but might be a method to an aqueous dispersion formulated with nano-sized biocide (Ban- mitigate the stressed environmental impact, reduce water losses ner MAXX® from Syngenta) having a broad spectrum systemic to evaporation, and reduce irrigation frequency. Indeed, the fungicidal action. The active ingredient controls leaf spots, blights, development of slow release fertilizers from chitosan nano- or rusts and powdery mildew diseases on various horticultural and microparticles is a relatively new concept to reduce fertilizer con- ornamental crops [17,202]. At present, there are several reports sumption and to minimize environmental pollution. With these available regarding the production and use of chitosan nanoparti- principles in mind, Wu et al. developed a chitosan-coated cles as a delivery matrix for the release of pesticides in agriculture. NPK compound fertilizer with both controlled-release and water- As an example, Paula et al. prepared and characterized micro- retention capabilities, by using an inner coating of chitosan, and an spheres composed of chitosan and cashew tree gum, which were outer coating was poly (acrylic acid-co acrylamide) [P(AA-co-AM)], P.L. Kashyap et al. / International Journal of Biological Macromolecules 77 (2015) 36–51 47 which is a superabsorbent polymer. It was observed that the prod- the enantioselective bioavailability of the herbicide, which could uct showed a slow controlled release of the nutrients. The nutrients be of use in environmental protection applications. released did not exceed 75% on the 30th day. Furthermore, chitosan is a readily biodegradable material, while the P(AA-co-AM) can 2.4. Micronutrient delivery for crop growth promotion also be degraded in soil, so neither the matrix polymers nor their degraded products were harmful to the soil. We believe that such It is a well known fact that micronutrients like manganese, products have a great potential as eco-friendly nano-fertilizers, boron, copper, iron, chlorine, molybdenum, and zinc promote opti- especially in drought-prone regions with limited water availability. mum plant growth. Steady increases in crop yields following the In similar efforts, Corradini et al. explored the possibility of 1960s ‘green revolution’ has progressively depleted the level of utilizing chitosan nanoparticles for slow release of NPK fertilizer, essential micronutrients like zinc, iron and molybdenum in the while Hussain et al. reported controlled release of urea from soil. Farming practices, such as liming acid soils, contribute chitosan microspheres. Although preparation of nanoparticles as to micronutrient deficiencies in crops by decreasing the availabil- controlled release devices may be more costly than simple broad ity. Foliar application of micronutrients is now a common application of fertilizer, it is clear that these materials can not only agricultural practice and is shown to enhance its uptake by the synchronize the release of nitrogen, phosphorous and potassium leaves. Nanoformulations of micronutrients may be used fertilizer for their optimum uptake by crops, but they can also to spray crops for enhanced foliar uptake, or nanomaterials with prevent undesirable nutrient losses to soil, water, and air. This has micronutrients may be used as a soil addition for their slow release the compensatory benefits of requiring less use of fertilizers, as to promote plant growth and improve soil health. For an well as undesirable environmental impact. Nevertheless, because example, Tao et al. synthesized chitosan modified with 1- of the “upfront” higher costs, it is clear that if the materials in naphthylacetic acid, which is an important plant growth hormone. development are to become commercial successes, they will need The results indicated that the release of the 1-naphthylacetic acid to offer better value to growers by reducing the overall cost of was strongly dependent on pH and temperature, and could con- fertilizer, and enhance crop productivity. tinue for 55 days at pH 12 and 60 ◦ C. Despite this dependence, the formulation offers potential for the slow release of plant growth hormones. 2.3. Herbicide delivery for weed eradication 2.5. Soil health improvement Every year approximately 10–15% the principal food production is lost due to weeds and other plant competition. In recent decades, The installation of nanosensors in farmers’ fields is being applied there has been an alarming increase in the use of herbicides to man- to enable the real time monitoring of soil conditions and the early age the weeds that are responsible for these losses. Each year 47.5% detection of potential problems such as nutrient depletion or insuf- of the total pesticides that are used have been applied to crops to ficient water. In this context, nanosensors can help to extend manage these pests. The heavy use of herbicides has given the new practices of precision farming by detecting and rectifying rise to serious environmental and public health problems. Problems agronomic problems in a very short time span. Nanomaterials, such arising from the herbicides currently in use are attributed to their as hydrogels and zeolites, were reported to be useful for improving chemical stability, solubility, bioavailability, photodegradation and the water-holding capacity of soil and to absorb environ- soil sorption. In addition, transfer of these agents to aquatic sys- mental contaminants. Recently, efforts have been made to tems affects water quality, resulting in adverse impacts to humans, develop a nanoparticle modified chitosan sensor for the determina- other biota, and the wider environment. In this sense, controlled tion of heavy metals. The biosensor is based on the combination release formulations of herbicides have become a necessity, since of chitosan cross-linked with glutaraldehyde modified with para- they often increase herbicide efficacy at reduced doses. Recently, magnetic Fe3 O4. The ␣-Fe3 O4 /CS nanocomposite film, which can be Silva et al. used alginate/chitosan nanoparticles as a carrier sys- easily prepared, exhibits high accumulation ability for the deter- tem for paraquat application. They demonstrated that association mination and removal of heavy metals (arsenic, lead, and nickel) of paraquat with alginate/chitosan nanoparticles alters the release and ‘reports’ the process by an electrical response. Agnihotri et al. profile of the herbicide, as well as its interaction with the soil, and developed a novel antimicrobial chitosan–PVA-based hydro- hence this system could be an effective means of reducing negative gel, which can behave both as a nanoreactor and an immobilizing impacts caused by paraquat. Similarly, Grillo and co-workers matrix for silver nanoparticles (AgNPs) with promising antibacte- prepared and evaluated chitosan/tripolyphosphate nanoparticles rial applications. as carrier systems to paraquat herbicides. The results showed that the nanoparticles were able to decrease the herbicide toxicity. 2.6. Delivery of genetic material for plant transformation In another study, Celis et al. used bionanocomposite mate- rial based on chitosan and clay (montmorillonite) as an adsorbent The biggest challenge for gene delivery in agricultural crops is for the herbicide clopyralid present in an aqueous solution or in the plant cell wall. Traditional gene transfer methods in plants a mixture of water and soil. The bionanocomposites showed good such as Agrobacterium-mediated gene transfer, electroporation, herbicide adsorption capacity at pH levels at which the anionic form PEG-mediated gene transfer, particle gun bombardment, etc., are of the active principle and the cationic form of chitosan predomi- costly, labor intensive and cause significant perturbation to the nated. Removal of the herbicide from aqueous solution was more growth of cells. In addition, these methods have very low effi- effective when a higher concentration of chitosan was used in the ciency (0.01–20% efficiency). Nevertheless that has been relatively bionanocomposite. At slightly acid pH, the composites effectively successful for genetic transformation of dicots. Hence, there adsorbed clopyralid from soil. The use of this type of formulation is interest in utilizing novel delivery systems for the develop- could help to limit the mobility of anionic pesticides in the environ- ment of successful transformants. Nanotechnology has shown its ment, reducing risks of contamination of surface and subterranean value in the genetic modification of plants by introducing new water bodies. Wen et al. studied the bioavailability of the chi- genes with a corresponding crop improvement. This system has ral herbicide dichlorprop to the green alga Chlorella pyrenoidosa, in significant advantages in comparison to conventional and tradi- the absence and presence of chitosan nanoparticles. These observa- tional gene transformation tactics. Firstly, nanoparticle approaches tions provided a clear indication that chitosan was able to modify are applicable to both monocot and dicot plants, irrespective of 48 P.L. Kashyap et al. / International Journal of Biological Macromolecules 77 (2015) 36–51 tissue or organ type. Secondly, they can be used to overcome transformations. There are some mixed results with regard to gene transgenic silencing via regulating the DNA copies combined with delivery via chitosan nanoparticles, but given the potential advan- nanoparticles. Thirdly, nanoparticles can be easily functionalized tages of chitosan nanoparticles to assist in the delivery of genetic for further enhancement of transformation efficiency, if needed. material to design new and improved plant genotypes, chitosan Finally, nanoparticle-mediated multigene transformation is possi- will continue to be an important research topic. And, there is a real ble without involving traditional methods that require complex potenital to use DNA-coated chitosan nanoparticles as a nanocar- carriers. Overall, these key features make nanoparticles excel- rier in a gene gun system, for bombardment of plant cells and tis- lent gene carriers for the genetic engineering of crops. Zinc oxide sues to achieve efficient and targeted gene transfer, in near future. nanoparticles and carbon nanotubes were both reported to pen- etrate tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum) seed tissues and plant 3. Conclusions roots, indicating that new nutrient delivery systems can be devel- oped by exploiting the nanoscale porous domains of the plant Application of chitosan based nanoparticles in agriculture is surfaces. Gene transfer by bombardment of DNA-absorbed still in a nascent stage. Encouraging and promising results are on gold particles has also been successfully harnessed for the already being achieved