Podcast
Questions and Answers
What are the two senses of law?
What are the two senses of law?
Descriptive and Normative
What does the descriptive sense of law focus on?
What does the descriptive sense of law focus on?
The letter of the law, or just the facts.
According to Hans Kelsen, a law that fails to regulate political and social life is defective.
According to Hans Kelsen, a law that fails to regulate political and social life is defective.
True (A)
What is the primary purpose of politics?
What is the primary purpose of politics?
What is law defined as?
What is law defined as?
What does the primitive view of politics focus on solving?
What does the primitive view of politics focus on solving?
What is law defined as in terms of its function?
What is law defined as in terms of its function?
What does the example of Nazi Germany illustrate about the nature of law?
What does the example of Nazi Germany illustrate about the nature of law?
According to John Searle, what are the two types of rules?
According to John Searle, what are the two types of rules?
How do regulative rules differ from constitutive rules?
How do regulative rules differ from constitutive rules?
The action regulated by regulative rules must exist before the rule is introduced.
The action regulated by regulative rules must exist before the rule is introduced.
What is the primary element of constitutive rules?
What is the primary element of constitutive rules?
Freedom is limited by regulative rules, but not by constitutive rules.
Freedom is limited by regulative rules, but not by constitutive rules.
What key question concerning the Constitution relates to the division between regulative and constitutive rules?
What key question concerning the Constitution relates to the division between regulative and constitutive rules?
According to John Searle, the Constitution can be considered both a regulative and a constitutive rule.
According to John Searle, the Constitution can be considered both a regulative and a constitutive rule.
Rights are considered constitutive rules because they define the limits of freedom, but not as regulative rules.
Rights are considered constitutive rules because they define the limits of freedom, but not as regulative rules.
What is the primary topic of debate concerning law?
What is the primary topic of debate concerning law?
What is the core question addressed in the dilemma of Lex and Phil?
What is the core question addressed in the dilemma of Lex and Phil?
What are the two main solutions to the dilemma of Lex and Phil?
What are the two main solutions to the dilemma of Lex and Phil?
What is the Grundnorm, according to Hans Kelsen?
What is the Grundnorm, according to Hans Kelsen?
What is the core principle of Legal Positivism?
What is the core principle of Legal Positivism?
What are the three principles of legal positivism, according to Thomas Hobbes?
What are the three principles of legal positivism, according to Thomas Hobbes?
What are the five key assumptions of Legal Positivism?
What are the five key assumptions of Legal Positivism?
What is the key difference between 'justice' and 'just' in the context of natural law?
What is the key difference between 'justice' and 'just' in the context of natural law?
According to Thomas Hobbes' Contract Theory, justice and injustice are determined by laws created by the sovereign.
According to Thomas Hobbes' Contract Theory, justice and injustice are determined by laws created by the sovereign.
Hobbes believed that the state of nature is a state of peace and harmony.
Hobbes believed that the state of nature is a state of peace and harmony.
What is the primary reason for the existence of the state of nature according to Hobbes?
What is the primary reason for the existence of the state of nature according to Hobbes?
What is the key feature of the sovereign in Hobbes' theory?
What is the key feature of the sovereign in Hobbes' theory?
What is the ultimate source of conflict in the state of nature according to Hobbes?
What is the ultimate source of conflict in the state of nature according to Hobbes?
Humans have the power and capacity to make moral judgments in the state of nature, according to Hobbes.
Humans have the power and capacity to make moral judgments in the state of nature, according to Hobbes.
Thomas Hobbes believed that the sovereign power is absolute and limitless.
Thomas Hobbes believed that the sovereign power is absolute and limitless.
According to John Austin's Command Theory of Law, all laws must be backed by sanctions.
According to John Austin's Command Theory of Law, all laws must be backed by sanctions.
John Austin believed that laws should be based on moral principles.
John Austin believed that laws should be based on moral principles.
H.L.A. Hart argued that the concept of sovereign's habitual obedience is problematic to explain the source of law.
H.L.A. Hart argued that the concept of sovereign's habitual obedience is problematic to explain the source of law.
What is the primary argument that H.L.A. Hart raises against John Austin's Command Theory of Law?
What is the primary argument that H.L.A. Hart raises against John Austin's Command Theory of Law?
H.L.A. Hart's criticism of John Austin's theory focuses on what key element of the theory?
H.L.A. Hart's criticism of John Austin's theory focuses on what key element of the theory?
Both John Austin and H.L.A. Hart believed that the source of law lies in the sovereign's power.
Both John Austin and H.L.A. Hart believed that the source of law lies in the sovereign's power.
According to H.L.A. Hart, primary rules govern behavior, while secondary rules govern the creation and enforcement of primary rules.
According to H.L.A. Hart, primary rules govern behavior, while secondary rules govern the creation and enforcement of primary rules.
What are three types of secondary rules, according to H.L.A. Hart?
What are three types of secondary rules, according to H.L.A. Hart?
What is the primary function of H.L.A. Hart's Rules of Recognition?
What is the primary function of H.L.A. Hart's Rules of Recognition?
H.L.A. Hart argued that the legal system rests on the foundation of primary rules, as opposed to the traditional view of the sovereign's power.
H.L.A. Hart argued that the legal system rests on the foundation of primary rules, as opposed to the traditional view of the sovereign's power.
John Locke borrowed from Thomas Hobbes' what idea to develop his theory of Natural Law?
John Locke borrowed from Thomas Hobbes' what idea to develop his theory of Natural Law?
What is Locke's primary focus in his theory of Natural Law?
What is Locke's primary focus in his theory of Natural Law?
What is Locke's State of Nature characterized by?
What is Locke's State of Nature characterized by?
According to Locke, humans are born with the inherent capacity to judge what is right and wrong.
According to Locke, humans are born with the inherent capacity to judge what is right and wrong.
John Locke's theory of Natural Law emphasizes the importance of a sovereign authority for the protection of individual rights.
John Locke's theory of Natural Law emphasizes the importance of a sovereign authority for the protection of individual rights.
Locke believed that the state of nature is a state of war.
Locke believed that the state of nature is a state of war.
According to Locke, the existence of the state of nature necessitates the existence of a sovereign authority for the protection of individual rights.
According to Locke, the existence of the state of nature necessitates the existence of a sovereign authority for the protection of individual rights.
What is the primary reason that individuals leave the state of nature to form a society, according to Locke?
What is the primary reason that individuals leave the state of nature to form a society, according to Locke?
The state's legitimacy is dependent on the protection and preservation of individual rights in Locke's theory.
The state's legitimacy is dependent on the protection and preservation of individual rights in Locke's theory.
In Locke's theory, the sovereign authority is considered to be above the law.
In Locke's theory, the sovereign authority is considered to be above the law.
Locke believed that individuals have an absolute right to rebel against a government that violates their natural rights.
Locke believed that individuals have an absolute right to rebel against a government that violates their natural rights.
According to Locke, the primary purpose of government is to protect the individual's conception of the good.
According to Locke, the primary purpose of government is to protect the individual's conception of the good.
Ronald Dworkin's view of the Constitution is similar to a set of rules, as opposed to a collection of principles.
Ronald Dworkin's view of the Constitution is similar to a set of rules, as opposed to a collection of principles.
Ronald Dworkin's view of the Constitution is considered to be a form of anti-positivism.
Ronald Dworkin's view of the Constitution is considered to be a form of anti-positivism.
What is the primary distinction between Dworkin's 'principles' and 'rules' in the context of law interpretation?
What is the primary distinction between Dworkin's 'principles' and 'rules' in the context of law interpretation?
According to Ronald Dworkin, the interpretation of law requires balancing competing principles, as opposed to applying strict rules.
According to Ronald Dworkin, the interpretation of law requires balancing competing principles, as opposed to applying strict rules.
Dworkin's legal philosophy is based on the idea of "original intent" or "originalism", where the interpretation of the law is guided by the original intent of the lawmakers.
Dworkin's legal philosophy is based on the idea of "original intent" or "originalism", where the interpretation of the law is guided by the original intent of the lawmakers.
Dworkin's legal philosophy emphasizes the importance of moral reasoning and judgment in the interpretation of law.
Dworkin's legal philosophy emphasizes the importance of moral reasoning and judgment in the interpretation of law.
Dworkin's "living constitutionalism" approach emphasizes the importance of a flexible and evolving interpretation of the Constitution.
Dworkin's "living constitutionalism" approach emphasizes the importance of a flexible and evolving interpretation of the Constitution.
What is the primary distinction between public law and private law?
What is the primary distinction between public law and private law?
What are some key examples of public law?
What are some key examples of public law?
What are some key examples of private law?
What are some key examples of private law?
The concept of public law has been consistent throughout history, without significant changes in its focus and scope.
The concept of public law has been consistent throughout history, without significant changes in its focus and scope.
What is the central distinction between public law and private law in Roman Antiquity?
What is the central distinction between public law and private law in Roman Antiquity?
What were two major areas of focus in medieval law?
What were two major areas of focus in medieval law?
The focus of modern public law has shifted to understanding the relationship between individuals and the state.
The focus of modern public law has shifted to understanding the relationship between individuals and the state.
The concept of “popular sovereignty” emphasizes individual rights and due process.
The concept of “popular sovereignty” emphasizes individual rights and due process.
“Democratic” governments prioritize collective will over individual rights.
“Democratic” governments prioritize collective will over individual rights.
Hans Kelsen's theory of norms emphasizes the content of norms, as opposed to their form.
Hans Kelsen's theory of norms emphasizes the content of norms, as opposed to their form.
What is the primary focus of Hans Kelsen's 'Stufenbau' or Hierarchy of Norms?
What is the primary focus of Hans Kelsen's 'Stufenbau' or Hierarchy of Norms?
According to Hans Kelsen, the Grundnorm is a concrete and empirically verifiable principle.
According to Hans Kelsen, the Grundnorm is a concrete and empirically verifiable principle.
According to Hans Kelsen, the state is a political organization that is organized based on principles.
According to Hans Kelsen, the state is a political organization that is organized based on principles.
What is the key difference between a political organization and a legal order, according to Hans Kelsen?
What is the key difference between a political organization and a legal order, according to Hans Kelsen?
Kelsen believed that the state should be governed by a single, overarching principle.
Kelsen believed that the state should be governed by a single, overarching principle.
According to Kelsen, changes to the legal system can only be made through legal means.
According to Kelsen, changes to the legal system can only be made through legal means.
Kelsen believed that the law is the product of the people's will.
Kelsen believed that the law is the product of the people's will.
According to Carl Schmitt, the sovereign is the one who decides on the exception.
According to Carl Schmitt, the sovereign is the one who decides on the exception.
Carl Schmitt agreed with the concept of a “global legal order” as a positive development.
Carl Schmitt agreed with the concept of a “global legal order” as a positive development.
What is the primary challenge that a 'global legal order' poses, according to Carl Schmitt?
What is the primary challenge that a 'global legal order' poses, according to Carl Schmitt?
Schmitt believed that the constitution is a product of human will, rather than falling from trees.
Schmitt believed that the constitution is a product of human will, rather than falling from trees.
According to Schmitt, the state exists before the constitution, and the constitution is a product of the state's creation.
According to Schmitt, the state exists before the constitution, and the constitution is a product of the state's creation.
Schmitt believed that the constitution is a mere product of political decision, rather than a reflection of shared values within society.
Schmitt believed that the constitution is a mere product of political decision, rather than a reflection of shared values within society.
According to Schmitt, the constitution is a collection of legal rules.
According to Schmitt, the constitution is a collection of legal rules.
Schmitt believed that the existence of the state presupposes the concept of the political.
Schmitt believed that the existence of the state presupposes the concept of the political.
According to John Rawls, the 'original position' is a hypothetical scenario where individuals are able to know their own personal status and social position.
According to John Rawls, the 'original position' is a hypothetical scenario where individuals are able to know their own personal status and social position.
Flashcards
Descriptive Sense of Law
Descriptive Sense of Law
Law as it IS, focusing on facts and the letter of the law, without considering its moral implications.
Normative Sense of Law
Normative Sense of Law
Law as it SHOULD BE, prescribing how reality ought to be, regardless of whether it's always followed.
Efficacy of Law (Kelsen)
Efficacy of Law (Kelsen)
A law's effectiveness in regulating political and social life. A law that is habitually infringed is defective.
Politics (Core Purpose)
Politics (Core Purpose)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Politics (Schmitt's View)
Politics (Schmitt's View)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Law's Function (Elementary View)
Law's Function (Elementary View)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Law's Role in Society
Law's Role in Society
Signup and view all the flashcards
Regulative Rules
Regulative Rules
Signup and view all the flashcards
Constitutive Rules
Constitutive Rules
Signup and view all the flashcards
Rights as Constitutive Rules
Rights as Constitutive Rules
Signup and view all the flashcards
Constitutions: Regulative or Constitutive?
Constitutions: Regulative or Constitutive?
Signup and view all the flashcards
Lex and Phil: The Problem of Law's Origin
Lex and Phil: The Problem of Law's Origin
Signup and view all the flashcards
Hans Kelsen's Grundnorm
Hans Kelsen's Grundnorm
Signup and view all the flashcards
Legal Positivism
Legal Positivism
Signup and view all the flashcards
Legal Positivism: Focus on Origin
Legal Positivism: Focus on Origin
Signup and view all the flashcards
Thomas Hobbes: Contract Theory
Thomas Hobbes: Contract Theory
Signup and view all the flashcards
Hobbesian State of Nature
Hobbesian State of Nature
Signup and view all the flashcards
Hobbesian Sovereign: Absolute Power
Hobbesian Sovereign: Absolute Power
Signup and view all the flashcards
John Austin: Command Theory of Law
John Austin: Command Theory of Law
Signup and view all the flashcards
H.L.A. Hart: Primary Rules
H.L.A. Hart: Primary Rules
Signup and view all the flashcards
H.L.A. Hart: Secondary Rules
H.L.A. Hart: Secondary Rules
Signup and view all the flashcards
H.L.A. Hart: Rules of Recognition
H.L.A. Hart: Rules of Recognition
Signup and view all the flashcards
John Locke: State of Nature
John Locke: State of Nature
Signup and view all the flashcards
Locke's 2nd Treatise of Government
Locke's 2nd Treatise of Government
Signup and view all the flashcards
Locke's View: Sovereign NOT Above Law
Locke's View: Sovereign NOT Above Law
Signup and view all the flashcards
Contemporary Natural Law (Dworkin)
Contemporary Natural Law (Dworkin)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Dworkin: Principles vs. Rules
Dworkin: Principles vs. Rules
Signup and view all the flashcards
Originalist View of Constitutional Interpretation
Originalist View of Constitutional Interpretation
Signup and view all the flashcards
Living Constitutionalism (Dworkin)
Living Constitutionalism (Dworkin)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Public Law vs. Private Law
Public Law vs. Private Law
Signup and view all the flashcards
Popular Sovereignty
Popular Sovereignty
Signup and view all the flashcards
Democratic Government
Democratic Government
Signup and view all the flashcards
Hans Kelsen: Hierarchy of Norms
Hans Kelsen: Hierarchy of Norms
Signup and view all the flashcards
Carl Schmitt: The Sovereign & the Constitution
Carl Schmitt: The Sovereign & the Constitution
Signup and view all the flashcards
Schmitt's Friend-Enemy Distinction
Schmitt's Friend-Enemy Distinction
Signup and view all the flashcards
Schmitt's Lord of Exception
Schmitt's Lord of Exception
Signup and view all the flashcards
Rawls's Original Position
Rawls's Original Position
Signup and view all the flashcards
Rawls's Veil of Ignorance
Rawls's Veil of Ignorance
Signup and view all the flashcards
Rawls's Reflective Equilibrium
Rawls's Reflective Equilibrium
Signup and view all the flashcards
Rawls's Difference Principle
Rawls's Difference Principle
Signup and view all the flashcards
Rawls's Circumstances of Justice
Rawls's Circumstances of Justice
Signup and view all the flashcards
Rawls's Fact of Pluralism
Rawls's Fact of Pluralism
Signup and view all the flashcards
Rawls's Reasonable Pluralism
Rawls's Reasonable Pluralism
Signup and view all the flashcards
Rawls's Overlapping Consensus
Rawls's Overlapping Consensus
Signup and view all the flashcards
Rawls's Public Reason
Rawls's Public Reason
Signup and view all the flashcards
Rawls's Political Conception of Justice
Rawls's Political Conception of Justice
Signup and view all the flashcards
Rawls's Well-Ordered Society
Rawls's Well-Ordered Society
Signup and view all the flashcards
Rawls's Political Conception of the Person
Rawls's Political Conception of the Person
Signup and view all the flashcards
Study Notes
What is Law? What is Politics?
- Law is viewed descriptively as it is (facts) or normatively as it should be (prescriptions)
- Descriptive law describes physical occurrences, like Newton's Law of Gravity.
- Normative law describes how reality should be, like how a law should be followed.
- Hans Kelsen's theory of law efficacy is that a law is only valid if it is effective.
- A law that isn't followed is a defective law.
- Politics arises from the need to prioritize goals in societies that can't do everything at once.
- Carl Schmitt believes the goals of the most powerful are prioritized.
- Law allows social life and politics to take place.
- Law is a system of rules that enable communal will and regulates the interactions between groups by establishing rights and obligations.
- Rules regulate conduct; constitutive rules create the behavior.
- Regulative rules regulate actions that exist independently of the rules themselves.
- Constitutive rules create the behavior/conduct that they regulate.
Regulatory vs Constitutive Rules
- Regulative rules regulate actions that exist independently of the rules themselves.
- Traffic laws are examples of regulative rules.
- Constitutive rules create behaviors/conducts that they then regulate.
- Sports rules and board game rules are examples of constitutive rules.
- Constitutional rules are both regulative and constitutive rules.
Positivism VS Justice-tracking Law
- Laws must be made by a sovereign.
- Laws depend on the authority and the sovereign, not the content.
5 Assumptions of Legal Positivism
- Laws are man-made
- Separation of law and morality
- Pure analysis of legal concepts, distinct from other subjects
- A closed logical system
- Moral judgments cannot be established by logical roots.
3 Versions of Positive Law
- Thomas Hobbes's contract theory of law.
- Law is a command with sanctions from a sovereign.
- The sovereign is ultimate, unrestricted, and powerful.
Rights of the Sovereign
- The legal order is irreversible.
- The sovereign is above the law and cannot be tried/condemned for actions.
- Property is a positive creation, not a natural right.
- The sovereign has all powers and no separation of powers.
The Rights of the Sovereign
- The legal order is irreversible
- The sovereign is above the law.
- The sovereign cannot be tried or condemned.
- Property is a positive creation, not a natural right.
- There is no separation of powers.
Legal Positivism VS Justice-tracking Law
- Legal positivism focuses on the origin of law by authoritative bodies.
- Justice-tracking law focuses on the moral merit of a law.
- Thomas Hobbes describes laws as those that the emperor (sovereign) desires.
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.