10 Questions
What is the primary reason why some scholars argue that women should not hold positions of leadership?
Because men are considered the protectors and maintainers of women according to Qur'an 4:34.
What is the interpretation of the hadith by Imam Abu Hanifa?
Women can serve as judges in financial and other matters.
What is the example given in the text to support the argument that women can hold positions of leadership?
The Queen of Sheba (Bilqis) who led a community.
What is the main point of the verse Qur'an 9:71?
Men and women are to cooperate to further the progress of their community.
What is the minority view regarding the hadith's exclusion of women from leadership positions?
The exclusion is limited to women as rulers in an Islamic state.
What is the characteristic of Queen of Sheba's leadership mentioned in the Quran?
High display of leadership decorum
What is the interpretation of Quran 4:34 according to the passage?
It refers to the domestic and matrimonial leadership of the husband
What was the role of Umm ‘Umara Nusayba and Umm Mani during the Prophet's time?
They gave their pledge to the Head of the Muslim Community and State along with men
What was the responsibility entrusted to Shaffa bin Abdullah bin Abdu Shams by Umar Ibn Al-Khattab?
Supervising administrative market affairs
What was the special dispensation granted to Umm Warage by the Prophet?
She was allowed to pray at home and lead her staff in prayer
Study Notes
Women in Leadership Positions
- There is no text in the Qur'an that excludes women from positions of leadership.
- Qur'an 9:71 states that both men and women are protectors of one another, enjoining what is just and forbidding what is evil.
The Hadith on Women in Leadership
- A hadith reported by the Prophet states that "people will not prosper if they choose as their head of State a woman."
- Scholars differ in their interpretation of this hadith.
Interpretations of the Hadith
- One group believes that women cannot hold positions of leadership, citing Qur'an 4:34, which states that men are the protectors and maintainers of women.
- A minority view interprets the hadith to mean that the exclusion is limited to women as rulers in an Islamic State, but not in other positions.
- Imam Abu Hanifa believes that women can serve as witnesses in financial transactions and can also judge on financial and other matters.
- A third group sees no objection to appointing women as leaders, citing the example of the Queen of Sheba (Bilqis) in the Qur'an.
Women's Participation in Political Affairs
- During the time of the Prophet, women participated actively in political affairs, such as the pledge of allegiance (Bay'a at Aqabah) by a delegation of people from Madinah.
- Two women, Umm 'Umara Nusayba and Umm Mani, gave their pledge to the Head of the Muslim Community and Head of its State.
Notable Positions Held by Women
- Umar Ibn Al-Khattab entrusted the supervision of administrative market affairs to Shaffa bin Abdullah bin Abdu Shams.
- Shaffa bin Abdullah bin Abdu Shams held a position equivalent to a Ministerial position today.
- Umm Warage was a lady who the Prophet used to visit, and she was allowed to pray at home and lead her staff, male and female, in prayer.
Explore the role of Muslim women in leadership positions, including Head of State and Judges, and their rights according to the Quran. Discover the verses that support their participation in governance.
Make Your Own Quizzes and Flashcards
Convert your notes into interactive study material.
Get started for free
