Utilitarianism: Principles and Criticisms

WellMadeByzantineArt avatar
WellMadeByzantineArt
·
·
Download

Start Quiz

Study Flashcards

19 Questions

Match the following terms with their corresponding definitions:

Principle of utility = Promotion of happiness as the test for judging human conduct Greatest happiness principle = Systematic framework for assessing the moral value of actions based on utility and happiness Breaking a promise = Criticisms of utilitarianism related to implications contrary to moral intuitions Human motivation = Criticisms of utilitarianism suggesting actions are not solely driven by pleasure and pain

Match the following statements with their related concepts:

Utilitarianism's challenges = Critics arguing theory sanctions immoral practices like lying and stealing Opponents' moral intuitions = Criticisms of utilitarianism due to implications contrary to personal ethical beliefs Modification attempts = Utilitarians seeking to adjust theory to address objections on motivation and actions Defending utilitarianism = Showing theory does not lead to the negative implications opponents claim it has

Match the following terms with their definitions:

Utilitarianism = Ethical theory that focuses on outcomes to determine right and wrong Maximizing Utility = Choosing the option that produces the largest amount of good Overall Consequences = Determining the rightness or wrongness of an action based on its total effects Principle of Utility = Foundation of utilitarianism that emphasizes outcomes in decision-making

Match the following key principles with their descriptions:

Principle of Utility = States that right and wrong are best determined by focusing on the outcomes of actions and choices Greatest Happiness Principle = A specific application of the principle of utility that focuses on maximizing overall happiness Criticisms of Utilitarianism = Concerns raised about the complexity and potential drawbacks of the utilitarian approach Consequentialism = Ethical theory asserting that consequences of actions determine moral correctness

Match the following debates with their corresponding topics:

Principle of utility debate = Discussions on promoting happiness as the primary criterion for judging human behavior Critics' objections = Debates surrounding utilitarianism's implications on moral actions like promise-breaking Human actions discussion = Debates on whether human motivations align solely with pleasure and pain as per utilitarian view Theory application challenges = Debates on the complexities and controversies in applying utilitarianism in ethical evaluations

Match the following concepts with their explanations:

Principle of Utility = Suggests that the moral correctness should be based on outcomes rather than intentions Greatest Happiness Principle = Focuses on maximizing happiness for all affected by an action Consequentialism = Belief that the consequences of actions determine their ethical value Critics of Utilitarianism = Express concerns about oversimplification and neglect of individual rights in utilitarian calculations

Match the following ideas with their related theories:

Principle of Utility = Forms the foundation for determining right and wrong in utilitarianism Criticisms of Utilitarianism = Highlight potential flaws in a system that prioritizes overall consequences Greatest Happiness Principle = Specific application focusing on maximizing happiness in decision-making Consequentialism = Broader ethical theory placing importance on the outcomes of actions

John Stuart Mill advocated for free speech, freedom of thought, and individuality in his book "On Liberty" published in _____.

1859

Utilitarian moral theory is based on the idea that actions should create the greatest amount of good for the greatest number of _____.

people

Utilitarianism is often contrasted with other moral theories such as deontology and virtue _____.

ethics

John Stuart Mill emphasized individual freedom over mere happiness or _____ in his development of utilitarianism.

pleasure

Mill argued that individuals should have liberty as long as their actions do not harm _____.

others

Utilitarianism evaluates actions based on their ability to promote overall happiness and reduce _____.

suffering

Utilitarianism is a philosophy that focuses on the idea of maximizing happiness and minimizing ______.

suffering

A ______ would argue that it would be best to allocate funds in a way that benefits as many students as possible.

utilitarian

Jeremy Bentham and John Stuart Mill proposed the philosophy of ______ in the 18th and 19th centuries respectively.

utilitarianism

Utilitarianism emphasizes the importance of considering ______ when making decisions.

consequences

Jeremy Bentham was known for his ______ philosophy which focuses on maximizing happiness.

utilitarian

Bentham's ideas were influential in the development of modern ______, particularly with regards to individual rights and freedoms.

democracy

Study Notes

Utilitarianism: The Principle of Utility, Criticisms, and the Greatest Happiness Principle

Utilitarianism is an ethical theory that asserts that right and wrong are best determined by focusing on the outcomes of actions and choices. This is a form of consequentialism, which holds that the consequences of an action determine its moral correctness. Utilitarianism provides a systematic approach to evaluating the moral value of actions, policies, laws, character traits, and other matters that involve choices. The theory is complex, as it requires understanding several key principles: the principle of utility, the greatest happiness principle, and criticisms of utilitarianism.

The Principle of Utility

The principle of utility is the foundation of utilitarianism. It states that right and wrong are best determined by focusing on the outcomes of actions and choices. Utilitarianism holds that whatever is being evaluated, we ought to choose the option that "maximizes utility," or the action or policy that produces the largest amount of good. In other words, the principle of utility suggests that the rightness or wrongness of an action is determined by its overall consequences.

The Greatest Happiness Principle

The greatest happiness principle is a specific application of the principle of utility. It holds that the right action is the one that leads to the greatest overall happiness for all affected by the action. This principle is often attributed to philosopher John Stuart Mill, who argued that the promotion of happiness is the test by which to judge all human conduct.

Criticisms of Utilitarianism

Despite its attractive theoretical virtues, utilitarianism has faced several criticisms. Some opponents argue that the theory has implications contrary to their moral intuitions, such as sanctioning the breaking of a promise or widespread practices like lying and stealing. Others have criticized the utilitarian view on motivation, suggesting that human actions are not always driven by pleasure and pain. Some utilitarians have sought to modify the theory to accommodate these objections, while others have defended the theory by showing that it does not have the implications its opponents claim it has.

In conclusion, utilitarianism is a complex ethical theory that offers a principled approach to evaluating right and wrong. Its principle of utility and greatest happiness principle provide a systematic framework for assessing the moral value of actions, while its criticisms highlight the challenges and debates surrounding its application.

Explore the foundational principles of utilitarianism including the principle of utility and the greatest happiness principle, along with common criticisms of this ethical theory. Understand how utilitarianism focuses on the outcomes of actions and choices to determine moral correctness.

Make Your Own Quizzes and Flashcards

Convert your notes into interactive study material.

Get started for free

More Quizzes Like This

Use Quizgecko on...
Browser
Browser