Podcast
Questions and Answers
Explain the concept of intabulation in the context of the acquisition of stolen, missing, or lost property.
Explain the concept of intabulation in the context of the acquisition of stolen, missing, or lost property.
Intabulation is a process of entering certain types of property into the state register, it considers immovable property. It is used in Austria and through in tabulation, the acquisition of ownership over immovable property can be established. Transfer of immovable ownership takes place by means of intabulation.
What does Roman law consider stolen goods as, and how does it affect their usucaption?
What does Roman law consider stolen goods as, and how does it affect their usucaption?
Roman law considers stolen goods as RES INHABILES, precluding their usucaption.
What are the specific circumstances under which modern private law systems allow the bona fide acquisition of stolen, missing, or lost property?
What are the specific circumstances under which modern private law systems allow the bona fide acquisition of stolen, missing, or lost property?
Modern private law systems allow bona fide acquisition of stolen, missing, or lost property under specific circumstances.
In what ways does Austrian law permit bona fide acquisition of stolen, missing, or lost property?
In what ways does Austrian law permit bona fide acquisition of stolen, missing, or lost property?
Signup and view all the answers
Under what conditions does German law state that the acquirer becomes the owner of a thing even if it does not belong to the alienor?
Under what conditions does German law state that the acquirer becomes the owner of a thing even if it does not belong to the alienor?
Signup and view all the answers
What provisions does Swiss law allow for a possessor to reclaim stolen or lost property?
What provisions does Swiss law allow for a possessor to reclaim stolen or lost property?
Signup and view all the answers
How long does French law allow the owner to reclaim a lost or stolen thing from the possessor?
How long does French law allow the owner to reclaim a lost or stolen thing from the possessor?
Signup and view all the answers
Explain the conditions under which the original owner may have a lost or stolen thing returned to them under Art 2277 of the Italian Civil Code.
Explain the conditions under which the original owner may have a lost or stolen thing returned to them under Art 2277 of the Italian Civil Code.
Signup and view all the answers
Under what conditions does a person acquire ownership of movable goods from someone who is not their owner, according to Art 1153 of the Italian Civil Code?
Under what conditions does a person acquire ownership of movable goods from someone who is not their owner, according to Art 1153 of the Italian Civil Code?
Signup and view all the answers
What does Art 1156 of the Italian Civil Code state about aggregates of movable items or movable items entered into public registers?
What does Art 1156 of the Italian Civil Code state about aggregates of movable items or movable items entered into public registers?
Signup and view all the answers
Under Austrian law, when is bona fide acquisition pursuant to § 367 ABGB impossible?
Under Austrian law, when is bona fide acquisition pursuant to § 367 ABGB impossible?
Signup and view all the answers
What are the conditions for proper (short) usucaption of movables under §146 ABGB of Austrian law?
What are the conditions for proper (short) usucaption of movables under §146 ABGB of Austrian law?
Signup and view all the answers
Describe the conditions for improper (long) usucaption under Austrian law.
Describe the conditions for improper (long) usucaption under Austrian law.
Signup and view all the answers
What is the departure from the principle of entry into the land register pursuant to § 4 Grundbuchsgesetz in the context of usucaption of real estate?
What is the departure from the principle of entry into the land register pursuant to § 4 Grundbuchsgesetz in the context of usucaption of real estate?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the requirement for acquisition based on the land register under Austrian law?
What is the requirement for acquisition based on the land register under Austrian law?
Signup and view all the answers
Explain the voluntarian approach to transfer of ownership in the French Code civil of 1804.
Explain the voluntarian approach to transfer of ownership in the French Code civil of 1804.
Signup and view all the answers
What is the principle of abstraction in German law and how does it differentiate between the creation of obligations and the conveyance of rights in rem?
What is the principle of abstraction in German law and how does it differentiate between the creation of obligations and the conveyance of rights in rem?
Signup and view all the answers
Under German law, what determines the passing of ownership, and is agreement on the legal cause required for the transfer?
Under German law, what determines the passing of ownership, and is agreement on the legal cause required for the transfer?
Signup and view all the answers
Explain the principle of causal conveyance in the Swiss ZGB, the Dutch Burgerlijk Wetboek, and the Austrian ABGB.
Explain the principle of causal conveyance in the Swiss ZGB, the Dutch Burgerlijk Wetboek, and the Austrian ABGB.
Signup and view all the answers
Describe the doctrine of TITULUS and MODUS in the Austrian ABGB and its significance in the acquisition of rights in rem.
Describe the doctrine of TITULUS and MODUS in the Austrian ABGB and its significance in the acquisition of rights in rem.
Signup and view all the answers
What are the methods of conveyance for movables under the Austrian ABGB, and how is the transfer of immovable property different?
What are the methods of conveyance for movables under the Austrian ABGB, and how is the transfer of immovable property different?
Signup and view all the answers
How is the passing of ownership of immovable property under the Austrian ABGB effected, and what is its effect?
How is the passing of ownership of immovable property under the Austrian ABGB effected, and what is its effect?
Signup and view all the answers
Explain the different models concerning the transfer of ownership of movables that have merged in modern civil law codifications.
Explain the different models concerning the transfer of ownership of movables that have merged in modern civil law codifications.
Signup and view all the answers
What is the principle of consensus in the context of acquiring ownership of physical objects?
What is the principle of consensus in the context of acquiring ownership of physical objects?
Signup and view all the answers
According to natural law, how do we acquire things, and what is the reasoning behind it?
According to natural law, how do we acquire things, and what is the reasoning behind it?
Signup and view all the answers
What are the sources from Justinian's time and what acts of conveyance have they substituted?
What are the sources from Justinian's time and what acts of conveyance have they substituted?
Signup and view all the answers
What has disappeared in contrast to older sources, and what does Institutions 2. 1.40 emphasize?
What has disappeared in contrast to older sources, and what does Institutions 2. 1.40 emphasize?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the informa TRADITIO and its significance in modern civil law codifications?
What is the informa TRADITIO and its significance in modern civil law codifications?
Signup and view all the answers
What has happened to the distinction between civil-law and bonitarian ownership, and what is emphasized in contrast to older sources?
What has happened to the distinction between civil-law and bonitarian ownership, and what is emphasized in contrast to older sources?
Signup and view all the answers
Explain the principle of consensus in the transfer of ownership of movables according to modern civil law codifications.
Explain the principle of consensus in the transfer of ownership of movables according to modern civil law codifications.
Signup and view all the answers
What are the different models concerning the transfer of ownership of movables that have merged in modern civil law codifications?
What are the different models concerning the transfer of ownership of movables that have merged in modern civil law codifications?
Signup and view all the answers
What are the acts of conveyance dating from the early days of Roman civil law that are no longer mentioned in sources from Justinian's time?
What are the acts of conveyance dating from the early days of Roman civil law that are no longer mentioned in sources from Justinian's time?
Signup and view all the answers
What act of conveyance has substituted the informa TRADITIO in modern civil law codifications?
What act of conveyance has substituted the informa TRADITIO in modern civil law codifications?
Signup and view all the answers
What does Institutions 2.1.40 emphasise regarding the transfer of ownership of physical objects in modern civil law codifications?
What does Institutions 2.1.40 emphasise regarding the transfer of ownership of physical objects in modern civil law codifications?
Signup and view all the answers
What does natural law dictate regarding the acquisition of things in modern civil law codifications?
What does natural law dictate regarding the acquisition of things in modern civil law codifications?
Signup and view all the answers
When is ownership of bodily things transferred according to modern civil law codifications?
When is ownership of bodily things transferred according to modern civil law codifications?
Signup and view all the answers
Study Notes
Transfer of Ownership in European Legal Systems
- Early modern scholars, including Hugo Grotius, believed that under IUS NATURALE, the owner's intent to transfer ownership (VOLUNTAS DOMINI REM SUAM TRANSFERENDI) was sufficient for a valid transfer of ownership, influencing subsequent legal systems.
- The French Code civil of 1804 reflects a voluntarian approach, where ownership is transferred upon the owner entering an obligation towards the acquirer, such as a valid contract of sale, with ownership being acquired and transmitted by means of obligations.
- French law stipulates that ownership is transferred when the parties reach consensus about the contract for ownership transfer, and a donation is perfected when the parties have consented, without the necessity of any other conveyance.
- French law synchronizes the creation of obligations and the passing of ownership, with the transfer of ownership also being important in the bona fide acquisition of ownership.
- German law strictly differentiates between the creation of obligations and the conveyance of rights in rem, with the validity of a conveyance being independent of the validity of the underlying agreement, known as the principle of abstraction.
- Under German law, the passing of ownership depends on the owner giving the object to the acquirer and both agreeing that ownership passes, with no necessity for agreement on the legal cause for the transfer.
- In cases of dispute or invalidity of the contract, the passing of ownership is not reversed under German law, with remedies available under the law of obligations, such as claims for unjust enrichment.
- Some European legal systems, such as the Swiss ZGB and the Dutch Burgerlijk Wetboek, as well as the Austrian ABGB, adhere to the principle of causal conveyance, requiring both a valid title (IUSTA CAUSA) and a conveyance (TRADITIO) for the passing of ownership of movables.
- The Austrian ABGB follows the doctrine of TITULUS and MODUS, where the acquisition of rights in rem depends on the existence of a legally recognized title and a legal act of conveyance, stipulating that ownership and other rights in rem may only be acquired by transfer and receipt, except in cases explicitly stated by law.
- Conveyance of movables under the Austrian ABGB is usually effected by physical handover, declaration, or assignment of possession, with conveyance by signs allowed in specific cases, while immovable property transfer requires entry in the land register.
- The passing of ownership of immovable property under the Austrian ABGB is effected by entry in the land register, constitutive in its effect, with a record of the legal agreement entered into the official register intended for this purpose.
- European legal systems vary in their approaches to transfer of ownership, with some emphasizing the owner's intent, while others require a valid title and conveyance for the passing of ownership, reflecting historical and legal influences.
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.
Description
Test your knowledge of transfer of ownership in European legal systems with this quiz. Explore concepts such as voluntarian approach, passing of ownership, principle of abstraction, causal conveyance, and the influence of historical and legal factors on different legal systems.