Podcast
Questions and Answers
What historical reasons are mentioned for the social and human sciences being critical of biological sciences?
What historical reasons are mentioned for the social and human sciences being critical of biological sciences?
Dread of determinism, reductionism, and the ethical and socio-political consequences of relating humans to animals.
What is one common request that life sciences make of social sciences?
What is one common request that life sciences make of social sciences?
To supply them with the 'factors' and 'variables' that make up the 'socio-ome'.
What two-fold approach to biology is proposed in the text?
What two-fold approach to biology is proposed in the text?
Critically evaluate the claims of biology, and develop an affirmative relationship with new understandings of the dynamic between life and its environment.
What does the text suggest is a potential alternative approach to the relationship between human sciences and biology, rather than just supplying 'factors' and 'variables'?
What does the text suggest is a potential alternative approach to the relationship between human sciences and biology, rather than just supplying 'factors' and 'variables'?
What should an affirmative relationship with biology not entail?
What should an affirmative relationship with biology not entail?
What is one biological attribute of humans that arose from selection pressures of emerging human forms of life?
What is one biological attribute of humans that arose from selection pressures of emerging human forms of life?
What is meant by a 'non-reductionist biology' within this context?
What is meant by a 'non-reductionist biology' within this context?
According to Paul Hirst and Penny Woolley, what is one way in which human attributes are shaped?
According to Paul Hirst and Penny Woolley, what is one way in which human attributes are shaped?
What does the text suggest social and human sciences are also studies of?
What does the text suggest social and human sciences are also studies of?
What kind of relationship is proposed between the social and life sciences?
What kind of relationship is proposed between the social and life sciences?
What is one example of a human attribute that varies greatly across cultures and historical time, according to the text?
What is one example of a human attribute that varies greatly across cultures and historical time, according to the text?
What is a potential benefit of creating a new relationship between the social and life sciences?
What is a potential benefit of creating a new relationship between the social and life sciences?
The text quotes Dobzhansky stating that human society and culture are a product of what?
The text quotes Dobzhansky stating that human society and culture are a product of what?
According to Dobzhansky, what is one thing that profoundly affects the biological evolution of humans?
According to Dobzhansky, what is one thing that profoundly affects the biological evolution of humans?
What does the text imply about the need to move past 'downstream implications' of biology?
What does the text imply about the need to move past 'downstream implications' of biology?
What is the central theme regarding human attributes explored in Hirst and Woolley’s argument?
What is the central theme regarding human attributes explored in Hirst and Woolley’s argument?
According to Bachelard, when should scientists describe their thinking?
According to Bachelard, when should scientists describe their thinking?
What did Georges Canguilhem say the thought of the living must take from the living?
What did Georges Canguilhem say the thought of the living must take from the living?
According to Canguilhem, what should our relationship to knowledge from the life sciences be?
According to Canguilhem, what should our relationship to knowledge from the life sciences be?
What do the conditions of possibility of our 'regimes of truth about life' define?
What do the conditions of possibility of our 'regimes of truth about life' define?
What is the core belief in a 'flat' ontology of life, as described?
What is the core belief in a 'flat' ontology of life, as described?
What is increasingly becoming a domain of intervention and production?
What is increasingly becoming a domain of intervention and production?
Why is the idea of biological control a 'fantasy'?
Why is the idea of biological control a 'fantasy'?
What can analyzing the life sciences' reshaping of our experience help us identify?
What can analyzing the life sciences' reshaping of our experience help us identify?
Why is it important to be critical of the life sciences?
Why is it important to be critical of the life sciences?
How does the text contrast the complexity of a Boeing 747 with that of a simple cell?
How does the text contrast the complexity of a Boeing 747 with that of a simple cell?
Approximately how many kinds of genetic parts does a yeast cell have according to the text?
Approximately how many kinds of genetic parts does a yeast cell have according to the text?
What is one crucial difference in science that Bachelard and Canguilhem encourage?
What is one crucial difference in science that Bachelard and Canguilhem encourage?
What 'other parts' besides genetic material does the text mention as contributing to the complexity of a cell?
What 'other parts' besides genetic material does the text mention as contributing to the complexity of a cell?
About how many neurons does a human brain contain, as stated in the text?
About how many neurons does a human brain contain, as stated in the text?
What does the text suggest social scientists should do to understand scientific activities?
What does the text suggest social scientists should do to understand scientific activities?
What does the text advocate for as the best way to understand the philosophical issues at stake in biology?
What does the text advocate for as the best way to understand the philosophical issues at stake in biology?
According to Foucault, what is the focus of an archaeological study of the human sciences?
According to Foucault, what is the focus of an archaeological study of the human sciences?
How does Franklin's work on 'Postmodern Procreation' analyze assisted reproductive technologies?
How does Franklin's work on 'Postmodern Procreation' analyze assisted reproductive technologies?
What is the primary focus of Freud's 'Introductory Lectures on Psychoanalysis'?
What is the primary focus of Freud's 'Introductory Lectures on Psychoanalysis'?
In the context of Gibson et al.'s work, what is significant about the 'creation of a bacterial cell controlled by a chemically synthesized genome'?
In the context of Gibson et al.'s work, what is significant about the 'creation of a bacterial cell controlled by a chemically synthesized genome'?
According to Gigerenzer, what role do heuristics play in cognitive psychology?
According to Gigerenzer, what role do heuristics play in cognitive psychology?
What is the main idea behind Goldstein's The Organism: A Holistic Approach to Biology?
What is the main idea behind Goldstein's The Organism: A Holistic Approach to Biology?
According to Grosz, what is the relationship between the body and subjectivity?
According to Grosz, what is the relationship between the body and subjectivity?
What is Haraway's concept of 'situated knowledges' in feminist science studies?
What is Haraway's concept of 'situated knowledges' in feminist science studies?
What is a key role of social science in relation to the life sciences?
What is a key role of social science in relation to the life sciences?
What does the text suggest is an important consideration when analyzing the relationship between biology and human social life?
What does the text suggest is an important consideration when analyzing the relationship between biology and human social life?
What specific concept, according to the document, challenges a purely biological view of human behavior by emphasizing the influence of the environment on gene expression?
What specific concept, according to the document, challenges a purely biological view of human behavior by emphasizing the influence of the environment on gene expression?
What term does the text use to describe the way in which biology and culture are interlinked and mutually constitutive?
What term does the text use to describe the way in which biology and culture are interlinked and mutually constitutive?
What is presented as a potential area of concern regarding the use of biomarkers in psychiatry?
What is presented as a potential area of concern regarding the use of biomarkers in psychiatry?
Beyond providing 'factors' and 'variables', what does the text suggest social sciences can offer to the understanding of human life?
Beyond providing 'factors' and 'variables', what does the text suggest social sciences can offer to the understanding of human life?
What is one way that the text suggests biological knowledge can be applied without promoting a deterministic view of human behavior?
What is one way that the text suggests biological knowledge can be applied without promoting a deterministic view of human behavior?
What methodological issue in the relationship between social and life sciences does the text highlight when life sciences ask social science for ‘factors’ and 'variables’?
What methodological issue in the relationship between social and life sciences does the text highlight when life sciences ask social science for ‘factors’ and 'variables’?
Flashcards
Thought of the Living
Thought of the Living
The idea that our understanding of life should be informed by contemporary scientific knowledge about life.
Conditions of Possibility
Conditions of Possibility
The specific conditions and assumptions that make scientific knowledge about life, and its impact on our reality, possible.
Analyzing the Limits of Life Science
Analyzing the Limits of Life Science
The process of examining the constraints and possibilities created by scientific knowledge about life.
Biovalue
Biovalue
Signup and view all the flashcards
Reshaping Experience
Reshaping Experience
Signup and view all the flashcards
Critical Examination of Life Science
Critical Examination of Life Science
Signup and view all the flashcards
Biomedicine
Biomedicine
Signup and view all the flashcards
Biotechnology
Biotechnology
Signup and view all the flashcards
Flat ontology of life
Flat ontology of life
Signup and view all the flashcards
Misleading fantasy of biological control
Misleading fantasy of biological control
Signup and view all the flashcards
Complexity of biological systems
Complexity of biological systems
Signup and view all the flashcards
Field work in philosophy
Field work in philosophy
Signup and view all the flashcards
Hesitant and modest operative philosophy of biologists
Hesitant and modest operative philosophy of biologists
Signup and view all the flashcards
Life as more than pure mechanism
Life as more than pure mechanism
Signup and view all the flashcards
Empirical investigation of scientific practices
Empirical investigation of scientific practices
Signup and view all the flashcards
Engaging with actual scientists
Engaging with actual scientists
Signup and view all the flashcards
Social Sciences and Biology
Social Sciences and Biology
Signup and view all the flashcards
Dobzhansky's View on Human Evolution
Dobzhansky's View on Human Evolution
Signup and view all the flashcards
Human Attributes: Biosocial Influence
Human Attributes: Biosocial Influence
Signup and view all the flashcards
Physical Attributes and Evolution
Physical Attributes and Evolution
Signup and view all the flashcards
Culture and Human Attributes
Culture and Human Attributes
Signup and view all the flashcards
Empirical Evidence of Cultural Influence
Empirical Evidence of Cultural Influence
Signup and view all the flashcards
Social Sciences in Human Biology
Social Sciences in Human Biology
Signup and view all the flashcards
Understanding Human Biology
Understanding Human Biology
Signup and view all the flashcards
Double Relationship with Biology
Double Relationship with Biology
Signup and view all the flashcards
Dread of Determinism
Dread of Determinism
Signup and view all the flashcards
Reductionism
Reductionism
Signup and view all the flashcards
Critical Evaluation of Life Sciences
Critical Evaluation of Life Sciences
Signup and view all the flashcards
Affirmative Relationship with Biology
Affirmative Relationship with Biology
Signup and view all the flashcards
Social and Human Sciences as Sciences of the Living
Social and Human Sciences as Sciences of the Living
Signup and view all the flashcards
Non-Reductionist Biology
Non-Reductionist Biology
Signup and view all the flashcards
Critical Friendship
Critical Friendship
Signup and view all the flashcards
The Order of Things - Foucault
The Order of Things - Foucault
Signup and view all the flashcards
Durkheim's Sociology
Durkheim's Sociology
Signup and view all the flashcards
Corporeal Feminism - Grosz
Corporeal Feminism - Grosz
Signup and view all the flashcards
Archaeology of the Human Sciences - Foucault
Archaeology of the Human Sciences - Foucault
Signup and view all the flashcards
Situated Knowledges - Haraway
Situated Knowledges - Haraway
Signup and view all the flashcards
Heuristics - Gigerenzer
Heuristics - Gigerenzer
Signup and view all the flashcards
When Species Meet - Haraway
When Species Meet - Haraway
Signup and view all the flashcards
Microbiome
Microbiome
Signup and view all the flashcards
Study Notes
The Human Sciences in a Biological Age
- Contemporary humans understand themselves in radically new ways due to insights from genomics and neuroscience.
- This understanding of the human is shaping the social and political issues of the 21st century.
- A new relationship is required between social/human sciences and life sciences, moving beyond commentary and critique.
Keywords
- Biology, body, brain, ethics, human, social
Creaturely Understanding
- Humans are contemporary creatures.
- Humans understand themselves through multiple different perspectives, not a singular "we".
- Social and moral sciences have views about human nature.
- These sciences constantly negotiate their relationship with biology.
- Biology is both the field of knowledge about living beings and the reality of those beings.
Reframing the Human
- Biopolitics, the focus on human vitality, which involves rights to life, equality of humans, the value of life, and interventions to enhance life, is central to the study of the human sciences.
- There is a tension between experimental reductionism and emergence/complexity in the contemporary life sciences.
- Contemporary biology reveals multiple affinities between humans and other creatures.
Technologiazation of Vitality
- The digital manipulation of living biological processes reflects the information age.
- Biological knowledge is increasingly capitalized and central to practices of self-management.
- Living organisms are understood as dynamic and complex systems.
- There are relations between different visions of living systems to the human sciences, exploring human complexity.
- The significance of the biological for social and ethical issues.
Biology and Sociology
- Biology and sociology arose closely together in the 19th century.
- Sociology has always grappled with biology since its inception.
- Historically, attempts have been made to draw a distinction between biological and social realms.
- The social sciences serve a biopolitical role.
- The social sciences claim to provide 'know-how' for governing individual and collective lives.
Genomics beyond the Gene
- Genetic explanations have entered human history with both positive and negative consequences.
- The gene-for paradigm, focusing on specific genes for characteristics, has been challenged by later research.
- Modern genomics has increasingly used probabilism and complexity instead of straightforward deterministic approaches.
- Epigenetics, studying how biological traits can be altered by external factors without altering the DNA sequence, are becoming central.
Conclusion
- Critical/philosophical issues arise studying life sciences/humanity.
- A collaborative approach, understanding "field work in philosophy", and understanding empirical investigations of operative philosophies are essential.
- Humans have a "vital milieu" that includes their bodies, minds, and social contexts.
- Biologically informed understanding of human nature and its social context are necessary.
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.