Podcast
Questions and Answers
What is a confession?
What is a confession?
Which types of confessions are admissible in court?
Which types of confessions are admissible in court?
What must a confession be in order to be admissible?
What must a confession be in order to be admissible?
Which of the following statements may not be considered a confession?
Which of the following statements may not be considered a confession?
Signup and view all the answers
Under what circumstances can equivocal statements be admissible in court?
Under what circumstances can equivocal statements be admissible in court?
Signup and view all the answers
What must the jury consider when evaluating a statement made by a defendant?
What must the jury consider when evaluating a statement made by a defendant?
Signup and view all the answers
When can a statement made by a defendant be used against them in court?
When can a statement made by a defendant be used against them in court?
Signup and view all the answers
What is a confession considered to be?
What is a confession considered to be?
Signup and view all the answers
Under what circumstances are inculpatory statements admissible in court?
Under what circumstances are inculpatory statements admissible in court?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the right to silence under common law and in Hong Kong?
What is the right to silence under common law and in Hong Kong?
Signup and view all the answers
Study Notes
- A confession is a statement wholly or partly adverse to the person who made it.
- Confessions can be oral, written, or both.
- Confessions must be relevant and unequivocal to be admissible.
- Saying "sorry" or making equivocal statements may not be considered a confession.
- Equivocal statements may be admissible if they can reasonably be considered evidence for a relevant fact.
- The jury must consider the entirety of a situation when considering a statement and put it into context.
- The jury can only use a statement against the defendant if it was intended to be evidence for a relevant fact and is truthful.
- A confession is a declaration against self-interest.
- Inculpatory statements are admissible if voluntary and residual discretion to exclude is not exercised.
- Mixed statements must be considered as a whole, and the jury must weigh all evidence in making their decision.
- Exculpatory parts of a mixed statement have less weight than inculpatory parts.
- Uncommon confessions include confession via apology and confession by legal counsel.
- The Apology Ordinance applies to apologies made in connection with a matter.
- A confession must be voluntary to be admissible.
- The prosecution must prove that a confession was not obtained through fear, prejudice, or gain by oppression.
- Failure to rule on voluntariness can result in a quashed conviction.
- A confession obtained through a person in authority requires proof that the defendant was not influenced by their conduct.
- Inducements, threats, or violence can lead to a confession being inadmissible.
- Oppression can sap the free will needed for a voluntary confession.
- The right to silence is not absolute under common law, but it is in Hong Kong.
- The right to remain silent is absolute.
- The exercise of the right to silence should not be used against the accused.
- A defendant cannot be cross-examined on why they remained silent.
- A person's silence at the scene cannot be held against them in trial.
- No inference of guilt can be drawn from a defendant's failure to make exculpatory statements.
- If a defendant selectively answers questions, the entire interview can be shown to the jury.
- Cautioned statements are not required by law but are internal guidelines.
- Rule II applies when there are reasonable grounds to suspect a person has committed an offense.
- Rule III applies when a person is charged or informed they may be prosecuted.
- The standard cautioning is not required by law but must be followed internally.
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.
Description
Are you familiar with the rules and regulations surrounding confessions and the right to silence in criminal trials? Test your knowledge with our quiz! From the admissibility of confessions to the guidelines for cautioning suspects, this quiz covers a range of important topics. Perfect for law students, legal professionals, and anyone interested in criminal law, this quiz will challenge your understanding of the legal system and its requirements for a fair trial. So, put your legal knowledge to the test and see how much you really