Taking a Stance: Expressing Justified Opinions

Podcast

Play an AI-generated podcast conversation about this lesson

Questions and Answers

What is the primary difference between stating an opinion and 'taking a position' (Stellung nehmen) as described in the text?

Stating an opinion is more formal than taking a position.
Taking a position involves justifying your opinion with evidence. (correct)
Taking a position requires no justification, while stating an opinion does.
Taking a position must always be negative, while stating an opinion can be positive.

In the context of 'taking a position,' what does 'neutral position' (neutrale Stellung) refer to?

A preliminary stage before forming a definite opinion.
A position that lacks any emotional investment.
A position given by an official or an authority on the topic.
A position where you neither agree nor disagree with the statement. (correct)

What is the purpose of step 4 (Schritt 4) in 'taking a position'?

To provide personal anecdotes related to the topic.
To introduce new, unrelated evidence.
To support your position and reasoning with textual evidence. (correct)
To summarize the main points of opposing arguments.

Which of the following sentence beginnings would be most suitable for expressing your own view, as suggested in Formulierunghilfen?

<code>Many arguments speak for/against...</code> (D) Signup and view all the answers

Lina questions if procrastination is an illness. What step is this in 'taking a position'?

Repeat and Explain Given Statement (A) Signup and view all the answers

What is the correct order for 'taking a position'?

Repeat and Explain Given Statement, Formulate Positions on the Statement, Explain Your Standpoint, Present Textual Evidence (B) Signup and view all the answers

In the example for step 2, what is being expressed?

Agreement to the Statement (C) Signup and view all the answers

Which of the following best describes the function of the 'Formulierungshilfen' (Formulation Aids)?

They offer suggestions for how to formulate and express different aspects of your position. (C) Signup and view all the answers

Someone says 'According to me, it is irrefutable...', which step is this most similar to?

Explaining your Standpoint (A) Signup and view all the answers

How does the text advise you to use provided materials?

Use the material as the foundation for your opinion. (D) Signup and view all the answers

Flashcards

What does 'Stellung nehmen' mean?

To express your opinion on a specific topic, and justify it with materials in a factual text comparison.

Step 1: Restate the given statement

Restate the given statement in your own words to show understanding.

Step 2: Formulate your stance

Formulate your stance on the statement: agreement, rejection, or neutral position.

Step 3: Reason your viewpoint.

Provide a rationale for your chosen point of view.

Signup and view all the flashcards

Step 4: Support!

Support your opinion by using the text.

Signup and view all the flashcards

Formulation aids

Helps to support your stance.

Signup and view all the flashcards

Study Notes

Taking a position involves expressing one's opinion on a specific topic and justifying it with the help of materials, especially in factual text comparisons.

Steps to Take a Stand

Step 1: Reproduce and explain the given statement.
- Example: Lina wonders why procrastination should be a disease, as she finds postponing unpleasant duties quite normal.
Step 2: Formulate statements about the given statement, including agreement, rejection, or a neutral position.
- Example: I agree with Lina's statement because, in my opinion, ...
Step 3: Provide a justification for your own point of view.
- Example: To a certain extent, everyone puts off tasks. Only in extreme cases is it possibly a disease.
Step 4: Cite textual evidence that supports the statement and justification.
- Example: Many arguments support my reasoning because in line XXX, the author states that it cannot be a disease because (...).

Formulation Aids

"In my opinion..."
"I agree (don't agree) with the opinion because..."
"I can (not) understand how someone..."
"Many arguments speak for/against..."
"For these reasons, I come to the conclusion that..."
"Finally, it can be stated that..."

Studying That Suits You

Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.

Description

Learn how to effectively take a position on a topic by expressing your opinion and supporting it with evidence. This guide outlines steps for formulating statements, providing justifications, and citing textual evidence to bolster your viewpoint. Includes helpful phrases for expressing agreement, disagreement, or neutrality.