11 Questions
What concept in tort law focuses on describing an action as if it was performed by a reasonable person with normal mental faculties and insight?
Objective fault
In cases of temporary mental disturbance in tort law, who is responsible for decisions made under unreliable judgment due to drug or alcohol influence?
The actor
What allows some legal systems to absolve an actor of liability due to the absence of subjective fault?
Temporary mental disturbance
Which scenario would lead to a focus on subjective fault in tort law?
A large divergence between the real actor and the fictive reasonable person
In tort law, who is presumed responsible for their actions based on subjective fault?
A person who consciously decides to act in a certain way
When does subjective fault come into question in tort law?
In cases of temporary mental disturbance and unconsciousness
What standard of behavior does English law expect from children?
To act as an ordinarily prudent and responsible child of their age
At what age category are children not liable at all according to Article 8 to 8 BJB?
0 to 6 years old
What happens to children in the second category according to Article 8 to 8 BJB in accidents involving motorized vehicles?
They are not liable at all
How does the law tend to treat children and persons of unsound mind regarding accountability?
Use a lower standard of accountability for them
In which age category are children who did not have the required insight for recognition of responsibility excluded from liability?
10 to 18 years old
Study Notes
- In tort law, the focus is usually on objective fault, where actions are judged based on how a reasonable person with normal mental faculties would act.
- Subjective fault comes into play when there is a significant difference between the actual actor and the reasonable person, leading to a different approach in assessing responsibility.
- Subjective fault questions whether the person consciously decided to act in a certain way and if it's fair to hold them responsible for unforeseen consequences.
- Cases of subjective fault often involve temporary mental disturbances, unconsciousness due to medical reasons, or impaired judgment from drugs or alcohol.
- Legal systems may offer different standards of accountability for individuals with diminished mental capabilities, such as children and persons of unsound mind under guardianship.
Explore the concepts of subjective fault and objective fault in tort law. Learn how actions are assessed based on the standards of a reasonable person with normal mental faculties. Understand the implications of wrongful behavior in a legal context.
Make Your Own Quizzes and Flashcards
Convert your notes into interactive study material.
Get started for free
