Podcast
Questions and Answers
Under which circumstances does 'all law' not apply to disputes between private individuals?
Under which circumstances does 'all law' not apply to disputes between private individuals?
- When a case is not of public interest.
- If statutory provisions are absent.
- When parties are governed by international law only.
- Considering the common law or customary law applicable to the parties. (correct)
In the context of rights, which section specifically states that everyone is entitled to equal protection of the law?
In the context of rights, which section specifically states that everyone is entitled to equal protection of the law?
- Section 9(4) (correct)
- Section 12(1)
- Section 28(1)(b)
- Section 32(1)(b)
Which case challenged the constitutionality of legislation related to the sexual exploitation of children?
Which case challenged the constitutionality of legislation related to the sexual exploitation of children?
- Minister of Health v Treatment Action Campaign
- Khumalo v Holomisa
- Teddy Bear Clinic case (correct)
- Dawood case
Which of the following factors is NOT mentioned as relevant in determining the applicability of rights in a dispute?
Which of the following factors is NOT mentioned as relevant in determining the applicability of rights in a dispute?
What kind of interpretation is required for understanding the application of rights and duties in legal disputes?
What kind of interpretation is required for understanding the application of rights and duties in legal disputes?
What must be embraced if a meaning conformable with the Bill of Rights can be ascribed to legislation?
What must be embraced if a meaning conformable with the Bill of Rights can be ascribed to legislation?
Under what circumstances does the development of common law become necessary?
Under what circumstances does the development of common law become necessary?
What is one possible outcome of developing common law?
What is one possible outcome of developing common law?
What is the nature of the Bill of Rights in relation to transformative constitutionalism?
What is the nature of the Bill of Rights in relation to transformative constitutionalism?
In the case K v Minister of Safety and Security, why was the minister initially deemed not vicariously liable?
In the case K v Minister of Safety and Security, why was the minister initially deemed not vicariously liable?
Which section of the Bill of Rights pertains to the limitation clause?
Which section of the Bill of Rights pertains to the limitation clause?
How are common law concepts typically interpreted in relation to constitutional values?
How are common law concepts typically interpreted in relation to constitutional values?
Which element is generally NOT considered when determining if a contract term is unenforceable due to public policy?
Which element is generally NOT considered when determining if a contract term is unenforceable due to public policy?
What differentiates operative rights from substantive rights?
What differentiates operative rights from substantive rights?
What does the concept of transformative constitutionalism aim to achieve?
What does the concept of transformative constitutionalism aim to achieve?
What does the Constitution create that influences the development of common law?
What does the Constitution create that influences the development of common law?
Which of the following sections specifically addresses socio-economic rights?
Which of the following sections specifically addresses socio-economic rights?
What does the gold-plate doctrine emphasize regarding the interpretation of legislation?
What does the gold-plate doctrine emphasize regarding the interpretation of legislation?
How is the application of rights described in terms of vertical and horizontal application?
How is the application of rights described in terms of vertical and horizontal application?
What does Section 7(2) of the Bill of Rights outline?
What does Section 7(2) of the Bill of Rights outline?
Which was stated as a principal aim of the Constitution’s preamble?
Which was stated as a principal aim of the Constitution’s preamble?
What is the primary purpose of using factors in the context of public interest in legal cases?
What is the primary purpose of using factors in the context of public interest in legal cases?
Which of the following best describes amici curiae?
Which of the following best describes amici curiae?
What is the status of foreign law in South African legal contexts?
What is the status of foreign law in South African legal contexts?
Which section of the Constitution ensures that no one may be subjected to slavery, servitude, or forced labor?
Which section of the Constitution ensures that no one may be subjected to slavery, servitude, or forced labor?
What is required for an individual or organization to be admitted as amici curiae in court?
What is required for an individual or organization to be admitted as amici curiae in court?
Which of the following statements about the application of the Bill of Rights is true?
Which of the following statements about the application of the Bill of Rights is true?
In which type of legal standing can natural persons claim general rights under the Constitution?
In which type of legal standing can natural persons claim general rights under the Constitution?
What does vertical application of rights refer to?
What does vertical application of rights refer to?
What is a significant limitation concerning claims made under Section 36?
What is a significant limitation concerning claims made under Section 36?
Which of the following groups is specifically mentioned as having restricted rights under South African law?
Which of the following groups is specifically mentioned as having restricted rights under South African law?
What is a key characteristic of submissions made by amici curiae?
What is a key characteristic of submissions made by amici curiae?
Which of the following does section 8(1) of the Constitution imply regarding rights?
Which of the following does section 8(1) of the Constitution imply regarding rights?
What was the outcome regarding the church firing a music teacher due to homosexuality in the case of Strydom v Nederduitse Gereformeerde Gemeente Moreleta Park?
What was the outcome regarding the church firing a music teacher due to homosexuality in the case of Strydom v Nederduitse Gereformeerde Gemeente Moreleta Park?
What is a necessary condition for horizontal application of rights?
What is a necessary condition for horizontal application of rights?
Under what provision can juristic persons exercise rights tailored to their context?
Under what provision can juristic persons exercise rights tailored to their context?
What factor should be considered when evaluating foreign laws in relation to South African laws?
What factor should be considered when evaluating foreign laws in relation to South African laws?
What is the main purpose of the Promotion of Equality and Prevention of Unfair Discrimination Act (PEPUDA)?
What is the main purpose of the Promotion of Equality and Prevention of Unfair Discrimination Act (PEPUDA)?
According to section 6 of PEPUDA, who is prohibited from unfairly discriminating against individuals?
According to section 6 of PEPUDA, who is prohibited from unfairly discriminating against individuals?
What must courts do if legislation does not adequately give effect to the rights outlined?
What must courts do if legislation does not adequately give effect to the rights outlined?
In which case was the common law of defamation developed to include 'reasonable publication'?
In which case was the common law of defamation developed to include 'reasonable publication'?
What does section 8(3)(b) of PEPUDA allow courts to do?
What does section 8(3)(b) of PEPUDA allow courts to do?
How does the Constitution influence South African law?
How does the Constitution influence South African law?
What was affirmed in the Pharmaceutical Manufacturers ZACC 1 case?
What was affirmed in the Pharmaceutical Manufacturers ZACC 1 case?
What interest does the development of the common law remedy of rei vindicatio serve according to the Juma Musjid case?
What interest does the development of the common law remedy of rei vindicatio serve according to the Juma Musjid case?
Flashcards
Foreign law
Foreign law
Foreign legal systems' approaches to human rights, often providing insights but not directly legally binding on South African law.
Discretionary consideration of foreign law
Discretionary consideration of foreign law
Using foreign law as a guide for South African human rights matters, but recognizing the uniqueness of South Africa's legal and social context .
Amicus curiae
Amicus curiae
A person/ group offering legal expertise or information to the court that is not a party to the case.
Claimant's legal standing
Claimant's legal standing
Signup and view all the flashcards
Section 36 Limitations Act
Section 36 Limitations Act
Signup and view all the flashcards
Natural Person Rights
Natural Person Rights
Signup and view all the flashcards
Juristic Person
Juristic Person
Signup and view all the flashcards
Bill of Rights (Sections 7-39)
Bill of Rights (Sections 7-39)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Transformative Constitutionalism
Transformative Constitutionalism
Signup and view all the flashcards
Operative Rights
Operative Rights
Signup and view all the flashcards
Substantive Rights
Substantive Rights
Signup and view all the flashcards
Justiciable Rights
Justiciable Rights
Signup and view all the flashcards
Limitation Clause (s. 36)
Limitation Clause (s. 36)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Vertical Application of Rights
Vertical Application of Rights
Signup and view all the flashcards
Horizontal Application of Rights
Horizontal Application of Rights
Signup and view all the flashcards
Socio-economic redress
Socio-economic redress
Signup and view all the flashcards
Preamble (Constitution)
Preamble (Constitution)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Public Interest
Public Interest
Signup and view all the flashcards
Equality and Human Dignity
Equality and Human Dignity
Signup and view all the flashcards
Legal Standing
Legal Standing
Signup and view all the flashcards
Amici Curiae
Amici Curiae
Signup and view all the flashcards
Horizontal Application
Horizontal Application
Signup and view all the flashcards
Vertical Application
Vertical Application
Signup and view all the flashcards
Duty Bearers
Duty Bearers
Signup and view all the flashcards
Direct Horizontal Application
Direct Horizontal Application
Signup and view all the flashcards
Direct Vertical Application
Direct Vertical Application
Signup and view all the flashcards
S 39(2) common law development
S 39(2) common law development
Signup and view all the flashcards
Common Law Inconsistency
Common Law Inconsistency
Signup and view all the flashcards
Common Law Development Outcomes
Common Law Development Outcomes
Signup and view all the flashcards
Vicarious Liability
Vicarious Liability
Signup and view all the flashcards
Indirect Application of Constitutional Values
Indirect Application of Constitutional Values
Signup and view all the flashcards
Public Policy in Contracts
Public Policy in Contracts
Signup and view all the flashcards
Horizontal Application of Rights
Horizontal Application of Rights
Signup and view all the flashcards
Khumalo v Holomisa
Khumalo v Holomisa
Signup and view all the flashcards
Section 8(2) & 8(3)
Section 8(2) & 8(3)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Teddy Bear Clinic Case
Teddy Bear Clinic Case
Signup and view all the flashcards
Dawood Case
Dawood Case
Signup and view all the flashcards
Minister of Health v Treatment Action Campaign
Minister of Health v Treatment Action Campaign
Signup and view all the flashcards
"All organs of state"
"All organs of state"
Signup and view all the flashcards
PEPUDA
PEPUDA
Signup and view all the flashcards
S 6, PEPUDA
S 6, PEPUDA
Signup and view all the flashcards
S 8(3)(a)
S 8(3)(a)
Signup and view all the flashcards
S 8(3)(b)
S 8(3)(b)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Reasonable Publication (Defamation)
Reasonable Publication (Defamation)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Rei Vindicatio
Rei Vindicatio
Signup and view all the flashcards
Indirect Application Bill of Rights
Indirect Application Bill of Rights
Signup and view all the flashcards
One System of Law (Pharmaceutical Manufacturers)
One System of Law (Pharmaceutical Manufacturers)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Study Notes
Bill of Rights: Procedural Aspects
- South Africa's Bill of Rights (BoR) is holistic, with all rights enforceable by courts. Litigation structure differs from other constitutional breaches.
- Operative rights regulate how the BoR operates and is enforced by courts (e.g., s 36 limitation clause). Substantive rights are rights to something (e.g., housing).
- Transformative constitutionalism uses the Constitution to facilitate social and economic change, while protecting human dignity. Judges need to support decisions with constitutional values, not just technical legal arguments.
- Langa emphasizes that constitutional decisions should be justified by reference to the rights and values enshrined in the Constitution, not just legal precedent.
- Bill of Rights litigation has a specific structure (procedural, substantive, remedy phases).
- Procedural stage: Court jurisdiction, claimant qualifications, standing.
- Substantive stage: Rights' scope and content, evaluating whether rights were infringed.
- Remedy stage: Appropriately addressing any limitations to rights.
- Courts need to consider whether a claimant's claim to a particular right is justiciable.
- The Constitution's interpreting principles require courts to prioritize human dignity, equality, and freedom
Interpreting Rights
- Bill of rights litigation differs from other types of litigation due to its overarching structure.
- Important considerations include: jurisdiction of the court, beneficiaries of particular rights, and the claimant's ability to bring the claim (standing).
- There are 3 key stages to Bill of Rights litigation: procedural, substantive, and remedy.
- Understanding the scope and content of the right is crucial alongside examining potential limitations under s 36 of the Constitution.
- Interpretation must account for societal values underpinning an open and democratic society (human dignity, equality, freedom).
- Consider international and foreign law, but be mindful social and historical context.
Claimants, Legal Standing, and Amici Curiae
- Claimants can be natural persons (individuals) or juristic persons (corporations, organizations).
- Standing: Individuals must have a sufficient personal interest in the case. Specific categories of persons have additional or unique standing.
- Amici curiae (friends of the court): Outside experts providing additional input, with the court's approval.
- Applicants may have additional standing if they fall into specific categories under section 38 of the Constitution.
- Considerations when evaluating standing include what rights are involved, whether any limitation applies, and the relationship between the claimant and the affected party.
Duty Bearers and Bill of Rights Application.
- "Duty bearers" are the parties obligated to respect the BoR. Vertical application involves state organs. Horizontal application involves non-state actors.
- Rights can directly or indirectly apply to non-state entities, depending on the nature of the right and context.
- Direct Application: Courts assess legislation, actions, or common law against the BoR and provide remedies if the Bill of rights are not followed.
- Indirect Application: Considers whether the Bill of Rights' values are promoted - no direct remedies are possible.
- Cases and statutes (like Section 39(2)) provide further guidance on how to apply the BoR.
Principle of Subsidiarity in Bill of Rights Application
- Litigation often requires relying on legislation that aims to uphold constitutional rights instead of directly relying on the Bill of Rights.
- Subsidiarity generally dictates that legislatures create enabling legislation for BoR values and rights, rather than courts, except in certain gray areas.
- Courts have to take into consideration whether or not any legislation can reasonably be interpreted/applied in terms of the Bill of Rights given various circumstances.
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.