Podcast
Questions and Answers
What constitutes the meaning structure of a social network?
What constitutes the meaning structure of a social network?
- The statistical distribution of connections within the network.
- The economic exchanges that occur within the network.
- The forms of meaning, like identities and expectations, attached to actors and their ties. (correct)
- The physical locations where network members interact.
What is the primary distinction the author makes regarding the analysis of meaning in social networks?
What is the primary distinction the author makes regarding the analysis of meaning in social networks?
- Whether meaning is located subjectively on the individual level or interpersonally in communication. (correct)
- Whether meaning is related to cooperation or competition.
- Whether meaning is analyzed through conversation or document analysis.
- Whether meaning is imposed by researchers or derived from the network itself.
How does the text define 'culture' in the context of social networks?
How does the text define 'culture' in the context of social networks?
- The high arts and intellectual achievements of network members.
- The personal beliefs held by individuals within a network.
- The repertoire of meaning forms that are widely available and used within a specific context. (correct)
- The degree of homogeneity in network interactions.
What is the role of 'relational expectations' in social relationships?
What is the role of 'relational expectations' in social relationships?
Which concept does the text introduce to describe how multiple ties in a network become relevant to one another?
Which concept does the text introduce to describe how multiple ties in a network become relevant to one another?
What role does 'identity' play in coupling multiple network ties?
What role does 'identity' play in coupling multiple network ties?
What are 'relationship frames,' as discussed in the text, and what role do they play?
What are 'relationship frames,' as discussed in the text, and what role do they play?
What is the significance of network culture in the context of social networks?
What is the significance of network culture in the context of social networks?
How does the text describe the relationship between structure and meaning in social networks?
How does the text describe the relationship between structure and meaning in social networks?
How does the concept of 'structural equivalence' relate to cultural similarity?
How does the concept of 'structural equivalence' relate to cultural similarity?
What is the significance of understanding the 'interpretive stance' in social network analysis?
What is the significance of understanding the 'interpretive stance' in social network analysis?
In the context of social categories and relationship models, what do opportunity structures influence?
In the context of social categories and relationship models, what do opportunity structures influence?
What is a key feature of network research focused on meaning?
What is a key feature of network research focused on meaning?
How do social scientists typically investigate 'meaning' according to the phenomenological tradition?
How do social scientists typically investigate 'meaning' according to the phenomenological tradition?
What distinguishes 'culture' from 'meaning' in the context of social networks, according to definition 2.3?
What distinguishes 'culture' from 'meaning' in the context of social networks, according to definition 2.3?
In what way does social reality lie, according to Weber, Schutz, Thomas, and Merton?
In what way does social reality lie, according to Weber, Schutz, Thomas, and Merton?
What is one way the definition presented in the text does not side in cultural and deterministic notions?
What is one way the definition presented in the text does not side in cultural and deterministic notions?
In the context of social structure consist consisting of what are expectations, according to Parsons et al. and Niklas Luhmann?
In the context of social structure consist consisting of what are expectations, according to Parsons et al. and Niklas Luhmann?
What perspective does this chapter lean towards, for the theoretical and methodological primacy of meaning?
What perspective does this chapter lean towards, for the theoretical and methodological primacy of meaning?
What are some examples of crystallized structures of meaning?
What are some examples of crystallized structures of meaning?
What did network researchers primarily focus on in network research according to Section 2.3?
What did network researchers primarily focus on in network research according to Section 2.3?
According to this chapter, what would be the result from carefully negotiated identity in one social relationship on structure in others?
According to this chapter, what would be the result from carefully negotiated identity in one social relationship on structure in others?
What can occur through performance of relationships?
What can occur through performance of relationships?
Who offers a notion of switchings when regarding processes such as the simultaneous activation and referencing of one tie?
Who offers a notion of switchings when regarding processes such as the simultaneous activation and referencing of one tie?
How does Section 2 address processes of communication?
How does Section 2 address processes of communication?
What does meaning consist of encompassing wide arrays of aspects of the social world?
What does meaning consist of encompassing wide arrays of aspects of the social world?
What is a component in the two-component interaction with others, according to the ideas of McCall & Simmons in 1978 when regards to communication?
What is a component in the two-component interaction with others, according to the ideas of McCall & Simmons in 1978 when regards to communication?
The patterns of communication of relationships is viewed how with relationship to that of interpersonal expectations?
The patterns of communication of relationships is viewed how with relationship to that of interpersonal expectations?
What did British Anthropologists J.A. Barnes and Elizabeth Bott invent?
What did British Anthropologists J.A. Barnes and Elizabeth Bott invent?
What aspects of understanding are intertwined, according to King-To Yeung and John Levi Martin?
What aspects of understanding are intertwined, according to King-To Yeung and John Levi Martin?
When considering the difference between social relationships as structure, and that as process, what are they respectively?
When considering the difference between social relationships as structure, and that as process, what are they respectively?
When examining how culture and meaning were incorporated in research and social networks, what is the period this occurred?
When examining how culture and meaning were incorporated in research and social networks, what is the period this occurred?
What were early sociometric and network scholars mainly concerned with?
What were early sociometric and network scholars mainly concerned with?
What is one thing that blockmodeling derives categories of actors from?
What is one thing that blockmodeling derives categories of actors from?
Who did Emirbayer and Goodwin criticize White in regards to?
Who did Emirbayer and Goodwin criticize White in regards to?
How are friendship links and love links alike?
How are friendship links and love links alike?
Structurally, which pattern do the multiple clients connect to?
Structurally, which pattern do the multiple clients connect to?
For a marriage and the affair, assuming an extended affair is happening, what do they act as?
For a marriage and the affair, assuming an extended affair is happening, what do they act as?
Flashcards
Meaning in network research
Meaning in network research
The expectations, symbols, schemata, and cultural practices inscribed in interpersonal structures.
Social Structures
Social Structures
Consists of expectations of a pay cheque in exchange for work, of traffic rules, of legal sanctions to criminal activity, etc.
Meaning Structure
Meaning Structure
The level of interpersonal expectations that evolve in and guide communication
Meaning Structure of a Social Network
Meaning Structure of a Social Network
Signup and view all the flashcards
Meaning
Meaning
Signup and view all the flashcards
Meaning
Meaning
Signup and view all the flashcards
Culture
Culture
Signup and view all the flashcards
Communication Patterns
Communication Patterns
Signup and view all the flashcards
Relationship Culture
Relationship Culture
Signup and view all the flashcards
Social Relationship
Social Relationship
Signup and view all the flashcards
Social Relationships
Social Relationships
Signup and view all the flashcards
Relationship Frame
Relationship Frame
Signup and view all the flashcards
Identity of an Actor
Identity of an Actor
Signup and view all the flashcards
Network Domain
Network Domain
Signup and view all the flashcards
Study Notes
- Most network research neglects the meaning linked to networks and relationships.
- Chapter 2 sketches the interplay of structure and meaning in networks, along with methodological implications that lays the foundation for deeper dives in later chapters, including groups, ethnic categories, role patterns, love and gender.
- This approach draws heavily on the relational sociology of Harrison White and incorporates insights from systems theory, social psychology, symbolic interactionism, and social anthropology.
Social Structure and Meaning
- Social structure is substantially composed of symbolic constructs, like expectations, identities, and categories.
- Network research focuses on structure and meaning, exploring culture and meaning.
- A historical overview shows how culture integrates network research.
- Social relationships, as network units, consist of relational expectations that are symbolic and interwoven with cultural forms.
Dyadic Relationships and Network Formation
- Dyadic relationships couple to form a network.
- Multiple ties relate in communicative events.
- Identities are constructed as involved in multiple relationships.
- Social relationships are negotiated and defined by culturally available "relationship frames."
- Network constellations correspond to cultural formations as symbolic forms shared in densely connected clusters, and also by structurally equivalent positions in a network.
Levels of Network Research
- Social network research involves five interrelated levels:
- Analytical picture of the network (derived from empirical observation).
- Patterns of communication.
- Interpersonal expectations that evolve and guide communication.
- Opportunity structures for contact.
- Social categories and relationship models.
Analytical Picture of Networks
- Analytical pictures are derived from research.
- Researchers often deal with relationships between actors as 1s and 0s
- Relationships are either observed to exist or not, depending on operational definitions.
Patterns of Communication
- Patterns of communication are analyzed in trade networks, email exchanges, or recorded conversations.
- Communication processes have a supra-personal quality, shaped more by structural and situational exigencies than intentions.
- Analyzing communication patterns is a reliable method for detecting network structures if the type of transactions are specified.
Interpersonal Expectations
- Communication is what happens in networks, and the third level is why particular communication occurs between actors.
- Social structures consist of expectations, with social networks and relationships featuring specific relational expectations about actor behavior toward others.
- The same holds in any network ties as relatively stable patterns of communication emerge through established expectations.
- Relational expectations are outside formal organizations/larger social fields but only in ties between two actors.
- The tie between A and B becomes a relationship due to repeated communication and relational expectations.
- Relational expectations influence the construction of identities, negotiated relationships and identities and the definition, of “what is going on” in a relationship.
Meaning Structure of Social Networks
- Meaning structure consists of the forms of meaning (identities, stories, expectations) attached to actors in a network and to the ties between them.
- Meaning location is subjective (Weber/Schütz) or in communication (Luhmann).
- Social relationships and identities carry a meaning in their context as relational expectations.
- Meaning draws on symbolic forms available in the wider cultural context.
- Subjective conceptions and expectations are network research bases. Network generators draw on individual accounts of network connections equating the network with subjected perceptions.
Communication Patterns and Meaning Structure
- Patterns of communication and the meaning structure mirror that of network ties as relational "states" and on the basis of "events."
- Relational states develop from events and structure them, meaning measurement and conceptualizations prevent conflation and confusion.
- Meaning structure and communication patterns are influenced by opportunity structures, social categories, and relationship models. These order networks by constraining and enabling communication patterns and meaning structures.
Opportunity Structures for Contact
- Opportunity structures include the place of residence and other foci of activity.
- Foci of activity affect communication, leading to new ties or deepening relationships.
- Place of residence and foci of activity are characterized by the composition of people meeting in terms of demographics.
- Opportunity structures are often not devoid of meaning, as people move to locations based on expectations.
Relationship Models and Social Categories
- Factors comprise relationship models (love, kinship, friendship) and social categories (gender, age, ethnic descent).
- These belong to the realm of culture that is shared in a context and relational institutions that model how to relate.
- Relationship models/social categories structure ties and networks according to cultural expectations.
- These make relationship life easier by supplying prepackaged expectations to reduce communication uncertainty; adoptions become part of the meaning structure, indirectly affecting communication patterns.
- Opportunity structures and relational institutions form part of the wider sociocultural configuration of society.
- Actual networks are patterned by these factors and enable/prevent contact. Categories/relationship models prescribe interaction, ordering contacts into patterns of structural equivalence.
Integrated Model of Network Analysis
- The causal starting points are the socio-demographic and cultural structures with opportunity structures make for a structuring of the patterns of communication.
- Social categories and relationship models are adopted as part of the meaning structure to influence the definition of identities and relationships.
- Communication patterns and meaning structure constitute the network as a social structure, intricately tied to each other.
- Social networks, meaning structure, and communication patterns are tightly interconnected although we may not be able to relate these levels of networks empirically.
Culture and Meaning
- There is feedback from networks to sociodemographics and cultural patterns.
- Social categories and relationship models are reproduced and modified in the interplay of communication and meaning structure.
Meaning
- Meaning is the wider term that humans attach to objects/symbols by acting on these meanings.
- Weber argued that all action is driven by the subjective meaning of their environment. And Shütz insisted that an actor orient themselves to the layers of meaning.
- There are twin versions of reality: the objective and the idea.
- Laws, family, and other entities are crystallized meaning structures.
- Human actors act upon expectations they hold of the behavior of others.
- All social structures consist of cognitive/normative expectations and expectations of others.
Symbols and Interaction
- Individuals subjectively process symbols and negotiate their meaning in interaction.
- A “definition of the situation” arises for subsequent interaction start from.
- Meaning is not confined to individuals but becomes consequential in communication.
- It is processed dually, in psychic systems/communication.
- Sociology should focus on meaning in communication as communicated meaning and becomes consequential through organizational decision opinions, mass, news, scientific claims, political claims, etc.
- The focus on communication radically breaks with action-theoretical traditions and connects with Mead/Blumer, most symbolic interactionism focuses on subjective meaning more than meaning-interaction.
- Linguistics consider meaning in signs rather than only in people’s minds (de Saussure [1916] 2013; Morris 1971).
- Meaning is analyzed in communication (verbal/texts with without inferring the subjective dispositions and interpretations of actors in line with Luhmann's notice.
Components of Meaning
- The meaning of something-always relates to the meaning of other things
- Word meaning consists in the relations to other words.
- Meaning is organized in relations connecting symbols, practices, social contexts, roles, and expectations.
- Overall, the notion of “meaning” signifies an interpretive stance, but must specify a designated area of social phenomena with social scientists must investigate what people think of the world.
- Meaning covers what we see when interpreting signs, texts, or behavior.
- Interpretive stance observes meaning.
- Social structures are symbolically constructed to vary in the meaning we attach to them and their social reality lies in structures of meaning we devise. Relies on definitions of the situation; consists of expectations.
Culture
- Culture is slightly easier to define than meaning, though it suffers breadth and encompasses norms, values, knowledge, language/symbols, and practices.
- Culture is shared within a context, and it is the “culture of this context”.
- That disregarding meaning leads to faulty interpretations and should be incorporated into theory and empirical research.
Network Culture
- Available and Widely Used
- The forms of meaning in a "culture" have to become independent of their application in communication to acquire an abstract meaning. Thus. the forms must be known and relatively invariant in their particular context.
- Social habitats of culture range from Dyadic relationships the jargon distinct ways of communicating to the culture organization.
- A network domain comprises all sorts of symbols, narratives, and linguistic forms that emerge in a densely knit network context, characterizing it in contrast to other network contexts,
Culture in Networks
- It is impossible to draw on cultural material not available in a given context; isolated network contexts show more homogeneity.
- The extent to which culture determines action depends on the configuration of sociocultural context.
- Culture includes the social categories and relationship models that to the level of meaning assigned to actors and to the ties between them level 3.
Incorporating Culture
- Original researchers considered it more methodical refinements until Harrison White created the blockmodel technique.
- Blockmodeling starts from the idea that network patterns follow underlying patterns of actors and relationships and makes for systematic relations.
- It derives categories of actors from network and tries to map the categorical order of social networks without categories/self-descriptions.
- Cultural/social psychological meanings of actual ties are largely bypassed ( 1976, 734)
Identity and Control
- Relational sociologist generally followed White’s lead in the New York school. The approach focuses the theoretical reflection of social networks/application to sociocultural phenomena. .
- Some pursue the line to analyze networks of categories/relation frames instead of actors: the aim of this research is to identify patterns of culture (1998). It is concerned networks between linguistics.
- American Network research has gone down a structuralist path to follow the “antcategorical imperative or in arguing that social networks need to not structured by diffuse boundaries (1997).
- Social networks may be seen as constituted processes communication intersection.
Relationships As Expectations
- Networks of ties between/individual collective actors; dyadic relationships are described as basic firms of society that are filled with meanings but with resulting social dynamics.
- More precise social relationship definition found in Weber’s work states the term “social relationship” will be used to content meaningful action term relationship exists entirely exclusively in probability meaningful course.
- Pattern the “action profiles” consist activities expected within relationship.
- Social groups consist processes dynamics between closeness relationships processes integrated regularities communication of structure.
Contingency
- Social relationships have to a process from coming from relationships expectations action, making predicting communication Parsons concept to reduce fundamental uncertainty and chapter is build-up.
- Social all the instruments exist expectations, position individual/all.
Social Relationships
- Social relationships but behavior and their behavior/deviant Denzin 1970 expectation towards recognized differences from with others
- Relational situation and definition alter social network identity identity a definition reduce these a social
- Relation to these
-
- Relational expectation from
-
- Relationship with social the
The Processes Linking Multiple Ties
- Inherent they be reproduction such of be and to multiple are to look
- Multiple (A, D distinct is communication their for the that Sounds
- The processes are of play - Communication with is
- A is colleague C it. The two
Identities
- identities is the important the to different
- To
- of the world can
- that of
- in on The is
- can then to for at of
Relationship Frames
- Relational and is together from models the The will
- A will family, or all at or at
- (c)Network
- to love The with is - Still will or at
- patronage of - Their
Network Structures
- and to this with
- a and The with
- There that/by each - Then is a for
- as this
Network Mechanisms
- Then is with
- The their is - For If and is to too
- The There The
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.