Podcast
Questions and Answers
What is the primary principle that John Fletcher proposes for making ethical decisions in situation ethics?
What is the primary principle that John Fletcher proposes for making ethical decisions in situation ethics?
Agape, or selfless love, is the primary principle for making ethical decisions.
How does situation ethics relate to consequentialism?
How does situation ethics relate to consequentialism?
Situation ethics is a consequentialist theory as it evaluates actions based on the outcomes they produce.
Explain the principle of relativism in situation ethics.
Explain the principle of relativism in situation ethics.
Relativism in situation ethics rejects absolute rules, emphasizing that moral decisions depend on individual situations.
What does the principle of pragmatism imply in the context of situation ethics?
What does the principle of pragmatism imply in the context of situation ethics?
Signup and view all the answers
According to Fletcher, what is the relationship between love and justice?
According to Fletcher, what is the relationship between love and justice?
Signup and view all the answers
Describe how situation ethics distinguishes between good and bad actions.
Describe how situation ethics distinguishes between good and bad actions.
Signup and view all the answers
What role do personal relationships play in situation ethics?
What role do personal relationships play in situation ethics?
Signup and view all the answers
What does Fletcher mean by 'the ends justify the means' in situation ethics?
What does Fletcher mean by 'the ends justify the means' in situation ethics?
Signup and view all the answers
Study Notes
Situation Ethics
- John Fletcher rejected traditional ethical systems, preferring a consequentialist approach based on agape (Christian love).
- Situation ethics prioritizes love (agape) as the sole intrinsic good, regardless of the situation.
- Decisions are based on the outcome (consequences) of an action, aiming for maximum love/selflessness.
- It's relativistic, meaning that a moral judgement depends on the specific circumstances of a situation, rather than fixed rules.
Working Principles
- Pragmatism: Actions must be practical and effective in producing the desired outcome.
- Relativism: Moral rules like "always" or "never" are rejected, as absolutes are inappropriate.
- Positivism: Love is the highest good and needs to take priority.
- Personalism: Individual people are prioritized; morality focuses on personal responses, rather than objective laws.
6 Working Principles
- Love: The central tenet – intrinsically good, regardless of situation. It involves self-giving to others.
- Love is the norm: Christian love is self-giving and responsible love. It prioritizes others' best interests but respects people's free will.
- Love & Justice: Love inevitably leads to justice (fairness, where everyone gets what they deserve).
- Love & Neighbours: Love extends to all, including those we don't naturally favour, such as enemies.
- Means & Ends: The goal is love, and actions are judged based on that goal, not the means used to get there.
- Situational Variation: Actions that produce love in one situation might be wrong in another, unlike traditional ethics which have fixed rules.
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.
Related Documents
Description
Explore the principles of situation ethics as proposed by John Fletcher. This quiz focuses on the concepts of pragmatism, relativism, positivism, and personalism, highlighting love as the intrinsic good in moral decision-making. Test your understanding of how these principles guide moral actions based on circumstances.
