Podcast
Questions and Answers
Which scenario most accurately reflects Rawls' concept of 'justice as fairness' in a society marked by reasonable pluralism?
Which scenario most accurately reflects Rawls' concept of 'justice as fairness' in a society marked by reasonable pluralism?
- A society where the government promotes a single philosophical doctrine to unite the population and eliminate conflicting views.
- A society where economic inequalities are allowed to grow without intervention, as long as everyone has the freedom to pursue their own interests.
- A society where the dominant religious group enforces its moral values on all citizens to ensure social cohesion.
- A society where all individuals are entitled to their own conception of the good, but basic rights are protected and resources are distributed to benefit the least advantaged. (correct)
In Rawls' framework, what is the primary role of the 'original position' and the 'veil of ignorance'?
In Rawls' framework, what is the primary role of the 'original position' and the 'veil of ignorance'?
- To create a fair and impartial setting for choosing principles of justice by preventing individuals from knowing their own advantages or disadvantages in society. (correct)
- To allow individuals to negotiate principles of justice while fully aware of their own social status, race, and gender, so they can advocate for their specific group.
- To ensure that those with more wealth and power can shape the principles of justice to protect their interests.
- To establish a system where decisions are made based on historical precedents and existing social hierarchies.
How does Rawls differentiate between 'ideal theory' and 'nonideal theory,' and why is this distinction important?
How does Rawls differentiate between 'ideal theory' and 'nonideal theory,' and why is this distinction important?
- Ideal theory and nonideal theory are interchangeable; Rawls uses them to describe the same concepts of justice from different perspectives.
- Ideal theory provides a framework for perfect justice under optimal conditions, while nonideal theory addresses how to approach real-world injustices and partial compliance. (correct)
- Ideal theory focuses on how justice applies when people don't fully comply, while nonideal theory assumes strict compliance.
- Ideal theory is concerned with historical injustices like slavery, while nonideal theory focuses on establishing a utopian society from scratch.
According to Rawls, what is the significance of 'overlapping consensus' in a well-ordered society?
According to Rawls, what is the significance of 'overlapping consensus' in a well-ordered society?
Which of the following best describes the role of 'public justification' in Rawls' theory of justice?
Which of the following best describes the role of 'public justification' in Rawls' theory of justice?
In Rawls' theory, what is the relationship between 'background justice' and the 'basic structure' of society?
In Rawls' theory, what is the relationship between 'background justice' and the 'basic structure' of society?
How does Rawls' concept of 'burdens of judgment' contribute to his argument for toleration and political liberalism?
How does Rawls' concept of 'burdens of judgment' contribute to his argument for toleration and political liberalism?
According to Rawls, how should a society address 'historical injustices' such as slavery and gender inequality?
According to Rawls, how should a society address 'historical injustices' such as slavery and gender inequality?
What role does 'reciprocity' play in Rawls' theory of justice?
What role does 'reciprocity' play in Rawls' theory of justice?
How does the 'liberal principle of legitimacy' constrain the exercise of political power in Rawls' framework?
How does the 'liberal principle of legitimacy' constrain the exercise of political power in Rawls' framework?
Flashcards
Fact of Reasonable Pluralism
Fact of Reasonable Pluralism
Society has many reasonable, conflicting views.
Society as Fair Cooperation
Society as Fair Cooperation
Ongoing cooperation across generations ensuring fairness for all citizens, not just a few.
Basic Structure
Basic Structure
The main institutions (laws, economy, government) that shape life, determining background justice and fairness over time.
Original Position
Original Position
Signup and view all the flashcards
Veil of Ignorance
Veil of Ignorance
Signup and view all the flashcards
Public Justification
Public Justification
Signup and view all the flashcards
Political Conception of Justice
Political Conception of Justice
Signup and view all the flashcards
Two Principles of Justice
Two Principles of Justice
Signup and view all the flashcards
Strains of Commitment
Strains of Commitment
Signup and view all the flashcards
Nonideal Theory
Nonideal Theory
Signup and view all the flashcards
Study Notes
Fact of Reasonable Pluralism
- Society is composed of numerous reasonable yet conflicting viewpoints
- Rawls suggests uniting society without suppressing individual views
Society as Fair Cooperation
- Society entails ongoing cooperation between generations
- Justice principles ensure fairness for all citizens, not just a select few
Basic Structure
- This refers to the primary institutions shaping life, including laws, the economy, and government
- It determines background justice and fairness over time
Original Position
- This is a hypothetical fair negotiation behind a veil of ignorance
- It removes bias, ensuring justice is chosen fairly
Veil of Ignorance
- People in the original position are unaware of their class, race, etc.
- This prevents individuals from rigging justice in their favor
Two Moral Powers
- These consist of a sense of justice (reasonableness) and a conception of the good (rationality)
- They justify why citizens are free and equal
Public Justification
- It uses public reason to justify laws to others
- This maintains justice that is democratic, not merely personal
Overlapping Consensus
- Diverse beliefs converge on a political conception of justice
- Social unity is maintained without imposing a single religion/philosophy
Ideal Theory
- It assumes strict compliance and a well-ordered society
- This provides a starting point for understanding justice under optimal conditions
Burdens of Judgment
- Reasonable individuals disagree due to complexity and bias, which is permanent
- It explains why pluralism persists
Political Conception of Justice
- Justice is not tied to any specific religion or philosophy
- It ensures a neutral foundation for justice
Two Principles of Justice
- These include equal basic liberties and fair equality of opportunity, plus the Difference Principle
- They guarantee liberty first, then fairness in inequalities
Background Justice
- Fairness is maintained by a just basic structure
- It ensures a fair framework for all social activities and transactions
Considered Convictions
- These are deep moral judgments that serve as fixed points
- It ensures justice principles align with fundamental moral beliefs
Fair Equality of Opportunity
- Talent and effort should dictate success, not birth privilege
- It ensures real social mobility
Difference Principle
- Inequalities are acceptable only if they benefit the least advantaged
- This justifies inequalities by helping the worst off
Reciprocity
- A middle ground is struck between impartiality and mutual advantage
- It encourages those who are better-off to contribute to society
Four-Stage Sequence
- This involves the original position, constitution, laws, and judicial enforcement
- Principles of justice are applied step-by-step
Primary Goods
- These are essential resources needed to live freely
- It ensures everyone has a fair starting point
Liberal Principle of Legitimacy
- Political power is legitimate only if justifiable to all reasonable citizens under certain conditions like rights, wealth, and respect
- This prevents oppression and unfair rule
Fact of Oppression
- This exists when a state enforces one doctrine over others, requiring coercion
- It justifies political liberalism and fair rules
Ideal Historical Process
- A society remains just if rights, duties, and fair rules are consistently followed
- It ensures justice holds up over time
Pure Background Procedural Justice
- If rules are fair, any outcome is deemed fair
- Justice arises from the process, not the outcome
Reasonable Pluralism
- Society accommodates numerous reasonable but conflicting beliefs
- It demonstrates why no single doctrine can define justice
Nonideal Theory
- It addresses real-world injustices given current conditions
- Utilized because of the need for practical reform in unjust societies
Feasibility & Stability
- Justice must be realistic and stable over time
- It ensures justice operates in practice, not just in theory
Partial Compliance
- This relates to how justice is applied when people don't fully comply (e.g., civil disobedience)
- It helps address unjust laws and institutions
Historical Injustices
- These acknowledge past injustices such as slavery and gender inequality
- This showcases that ideal theory alone is insufficient
Addressing Injustices
- Guidance is provided on which wrongs are most urgent to fix
- This helps prioritize justice reforms
Strains of Commitment
- Justice must be realistically followable by citizens
- It ensures people can commit to justice long-term
Duty of Public Civility
- It is a duty to debate using fair, shared reasons
- This prevents political breakdown and polarization
Political Capital
- Society thrives on reasonableness, fairness, and civility
- This strengthens cooperation and stability
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.