Podcast
Questions and Answers
The protection of well-known marks in Maltese law has traditionally hinged on Article 32 of the Commercial Code, which addresses ______ competition.
The protection of well-known marks in Maltese law has traditionally hinged on Article 32 of the Commercial Code, which addresses ______ competition.
unfair
The Trademarks Act in Malta evolved to integrate the ______ Convention.
The Trademarks Act in Malta evolved to integrate the ______ Convention.
Paris
Initially, Maltese courts adopted a ______-line approach that favored reputation for protecting well-known marks.
Initially, Maltese courts adopted a ______-line approach that favored reputation for protecting well-known marks.
soft
In the McDonald’s Case, the Court of Appeal ruled that actual ______ was indispensable for invoking Article 32.
In the McDonald’s Case, the Court of Appeal ruled that actual ______ was indispensable for invoking Article 32.
Signup and view all the answers
Maltese law reflects a dual system of protection: one anchored in unfair competition and the other rooted in ______ property law.
Maltese law reflects a dual system of protection: one anchored in unfair competition and the other rooted in ______ property law.
Signup and view all the answers
The early decisions on well-known marks revealed a 'soft-line approach' that favored ______, even without local operations.
The early decisions on well-known marks revealed a 'soft-line approach' that favored ______, even without local operations.
Signup and view all the answers
The defendant in the McDonald’s Case prevailed because McDonald’s was not actively trading in ______ at the time.
The defendant in the McDonald’s Case prevailed because McDonald’s was not actively trading in ______ at the time.
Signup and view all the answers
Maltese courts have shifted to a ______-line approach, requiring actual local competition for Article 32 protection.
Maltese courts have shifted to a ______-line approach, requiring actual local competition for Article 32 protection.
Signup and view all the answers
Article 34(1) requires a competitive motive behind the dissemination of ______ news.
Article 34(1) requires a competitive motive behind the dissemination of ______ news.
Signup and view all the answers
The law states that a claimant must prove the statement is capable of causing ______.
The law states that a claimant must prove the statement is capable of causing ______.
Signup and view all the answers
In relation to spreading news, local case law clarified that it is not necessary for the audience to be ______.
In relation to spreading news, local case law clarified that it is not necessary for the audience to be ______.
Signup and view all the answers
The truth of the news does not exonerate the trader who ______ it.
The truth of the news does not exonerate the trader who ______ it.
Signup and view all the answers
The rationale behind prohibiting harmful information is to prevent ______ competition.
The rationale behind prohibiting harmful information is to prevent ______ competition.
Signup and view all the answers
Courts may be more lenient towards traders who do not act in ______.
Courts may be more lenient towards traders who do not act in ______.
Signup and view all the answers
Article 32A allows factual comparisons only if they are ______ and non-misleading.
Article 32A allows factual comparisons only if they are ______ and non-misleading.
Signup and view all the answers
Merely proving the ______ of a statement is not a complete defense under Article 34(1).
Merely proving the ______ of a statement is not a complete defense under Article 34(1).
Signup and view all the answers
Traders must ensure that any negative information about a competitor is ______ vetted.
Traders must ensure that any negative information about a competitor is ______ vetted.
Signup and view all the answers
Article 34(1) protects against unfair competition by prohibiting the ______ of prejudicial news.
Article 34(1) protects against unfair competition by prohibiting the ______ of prejudicial news.
Signup and view all the answers
A name or mark can acquire a 'secondary meaning' through sustained use and consumer ______.
A name or mark can acquire a 'secondary meaning' through sustained use and consumer ______.
Signup and view all the answers
Under Article 32, protection extends to the 'get-up' which includes visual ______ like packaging and color schemes.
Under Article 32, protection extends to the 'get-up' which includes visual ______ like packaging and color schemes.
Signup and view all the answers
Imitating another trader's packaging can be considered an illicit act if it creates ______ in the marketplace.
Imitating another trader's packaging can be considered an illicit act if it creates ______ in the marketplace.
Signup and view all the answers
Under Article 33, misleading indications regarding the origin of goods are ______.
Under Article 33, misleading indications regarding the origin of goods are ______.
Signup and view all the answers
Establishing whether a trademark is likely to create ______ is a question of fact left to court assessment.
Establishing whether a trademark is likely to create ______ is a question of fact left to court assessment.
Signup and view all the answers
The average consumer is described as reasonably well-informed, observant, and ______.
The average consumer is described as reasonably well-informed, observant, and ______.
Signup and view all the answers
The journal serves as the principal daybook, capturing details of each transaction systematically and ______.
The journal serves as the principal daybook, capturing details of each transaction systematically and ______.
Signup and view all the answers
Courts emphasize that marks must be considered as a ______ rather than dissecting them into parts.
Courts emphasize that marks must be considered as a ______ rather than dissecting them into parts.
Signup and view all the answers
The cash-book specifically monitors all cash transactions—both receipts and ______.
The cash-book specifically monitors all cash transactions—both receipts and ______.
Signup and view all the answers
Imperfect ______ acknowledges that consumers may not recall a mark with complete precision.
Imperfect ______ acknowledges that consumers may not recall a mark with complete precision.
Signup and view all the answers
Properly kept journals enjoy prima facie evidentiary weight in court under Article ______.
Properly kept journals enjoy prima facie evidentiary weight in court under Article ______.
Signup and view all the answers
The inventory-book requires the trader to prepare an annual inventory of the entire business ______.
The inventory-book requires the trader to prepare an annual inventory of the entire business ______.
Signup and view all the answers
The context of trade, including channels and marketing strategies, affects the likelihood of ______.
The context of trade, including channels and marketing strategies, affects the likelihood of ______.
Signup and view all the answers
Evidence of actual confusion can be persuasive, but likelihood of confusion is ______ enough for a claim.
Evidence of actual confusion can be persuasive, but likelihood of confusion is ______ enough for a claim.
Signup and view all the answers
The ledger breaks down journal entries into individual ______—e.g., accounts payable, accounts receivable.
The ledger breaks down journal entries into individual ______—e.g., accounts payable, accounts receivable.
Signup and view all the answers
Traders can easily track amounts due from clients or sums owed to ______.
Traders can easily track amounts due from clients or sums owed to ______.
Signup and view all the answers
In the case of Sansone vs Cassar Torreggiani, the court highlighted the importance of 'global ______' in assessing marks.
In the case of Sansone vs Cassar Torreggiani, the court highlighted the importance of 'global ______' in assessing marks.
Signup and view all the answers
The Commercial Code allows traders to keep additional or optional books to document other facets of the ______.
The Commercial Code allows traders to keep additional or optional books to document other facets of the ______.
Signup and view all the answers
The combination of naming style, color scheme, and packaging can create a confusingly similar ______.
The combination of naming style, color scheme, and packaging can create a confusingly similar ______.
Signup and view all the answers
Although not technically a 'book,' Article 20 obliges traders to maintain originals of letters and ______.
Although not technically a 'book,' Article 20 obliges traders to maintain originals of letters and ______.
Signup and view all the answers
Under Article 32, traders can claim unfair competition if a rival's packaging is likely to ______ consumers.
Under Article 32, traders can claim unfair competition if a rival's packaging is likely to ______ consumers.
Signup and view all the answers
Documents and contracts should reflect the principal’s name or firm, typically alongside a designation such as “per procura” (p.p.) or __________.
Documents and contracts should reflect the principal’s name or firm, typically alongside a designation such as “per procura” (p.p.) or __________.
Signup and view all the answers
The journal distinguishes business transactions from the trader’s personal ______.
The journal distinguishes business transactions from the trader’s personal ______.
Signup and view all the answers
The essence of false indication of origin is to prevent ______ advantage from misleading consumers.
The essence of false indication of origin is to prevent ______ advantage from misleading consumers.
Signup and view all the answers
A well-maintained cash-book prevents confusion over the exact amount of money the trader can ______.
A well-maintained cash-book prevents confusion over the exact amount of money the trader can ______.
Signup and view all the answers
A manager must not engage in or hold interest in a rival business without the principal’s express __________.
A manager must not engage in or hold interest in a rival business without the principal’s express __________.
Signup and view all the answers
The inventory-book facilitates the detection of irregularities, possible ______, or potential for insolvency.
The inventory-book facilitates the detection of irregularities, possible ______, or potential for insolvency.
Signup and view all the answers
Should a manager violate the non-competition rule, the principal may claim __________ for damages sustained.
Should a manager violate the non-competition rule, the principal may claim __________ for damages sustained.
Signup and view all the answers
Proper bookkeeping is more than just a legal requirement: it benefits the trader’s operational ______.
Proper bookkeeping is more than just a legal requirement: it benefits the trader’s operational ______.
Signup and view all the answers
Article 65 outlines that managers are jointly liable with the principal for compliance with certain trader __________.
Article 65 outlines that managers are jointly liable with the principal for compliance with certain trader __________.
Signup and view all the answers
Article 34(1) of the Maltese Commercial Code prohibits spreading news that is capable of ______ another trader’s business.
Article 34(1) of the Maltese Commercial Code prohibits spreading news that is capable of ______ another trader’s business.
Signup and view all the answers
A manager must keep the principal informed of significant developments and render __________ of transactions.
A manager must keep the principal informed of significant developments and render __________ of transactions.
Signup and view all the answers
The cash-book must be balanced at least once a ______, verifying that recorded inflows match outflows.
The cash-book must be balanced at least once a ______, verifying that recorded inflows match outflows.
Signup and view all the answers
Courts have held managers personally liable for omitting the principal’s details in __________.
Courts have held managers personally liable for omitting the principal’s details in __________.
Signup and view all the answers
Courts adopt zero tolerance for hidden conflicts of interest in line with Article __________.
Courts adopt zero tolerance for hidden conflicts of interest in line with Article __________.
Signup and view all the answers
If a manager breaches fiduciary obligations, the principal may pursue remedies such as __________ for losses sustained.
If a manager breaches fiduciary obligations, the principal may pursue remedies such as __________ for losses sustained.
Signup and view all the answers
Prior to 2008, the courts treated any negative statement about a competitor with suspicion under Article ______.
Prior to 2008, the courts treated any negative statement about a competitor with suspicion under Article ______.
Signup and view all the answers
Managers have a significant responsibility in upholding statutory duties that aim at __________.
Managers have a significant responsibility in upholding statutory duties that aim at __________.
Signup and view all the answers
The duty to adhere to trader obligations includes preserving fair competition practices and avoiding acts of __________ competition.
The duty to adhere to trader obligations includes preserving fair competition practices and avoiding acts of __________ competition.
Signup and view all the answers
Post-2008, courts must determine whether a statement qualifies as legitimate comparative ______.
Post-2008, courts must determine whether a statement qualifies as legitimate comparative ______.
Signup and view all the answers
Recent case law underscores strict enforcement of the duty of __________ to safeguard assets.
Recent case law underscores strict enforcement of the duty of __________ to safeguard assets.
Signup and view all the answers
Article ______ fosters a measure of commercial free speech.
Article ______ fosters a measure of commercial free speech.
Signup and view all the answers
A manager’s position is one of significant responsibility and __________ under the Commercial Code.
A manager’s position is one of significant responsibility and __________ under the Commercial Code.
Signup and view all the answers
Article 34(1) acts as a safeguard against ______ attacks on competitors.
Article 34(1) acts as a safeguard against ______ attacks on competitors.
Signup and view all the answers
Maintaining accurate bookkeeping promotes clarity in business transactions and provides legal __________.
Maintaining accurate bookkeeping promotes clarity in business transactions and provides legal __________.
Signup and view all the answers
If statements deviate from fair, factual comparison, Article ______ can be invoked.
If statements deviate from fair, factual comparison, Article ______ can be invoked.
Signup and view all the answers
The courts have affirmed that managers must avoid exploiting their knowledge of the principal's business for __________.
The courts have affirmed that managers must avoid exploiting their knowledge of the principal's business for __________.
Signup and view all the answers
Since the introduction of Article 32A, courts examine whether the defendant was merely ______ products.
Since the introduction of Article 32A, courts examine whether the defendant was merely ______ products.
Signup and view all the answers
Article 34(1) traditionally imposed a broad ______ on distributing news harmful to a competitor’s trade.
Article 34(1) traditionally imposed a broad ______ on distributing news harmful to a competitor’s trade.
Signup and view all the answers
Article 32A refines the scope of what might be considered ______ news.
Article 32A refines the scope of what might be considered ______ news.
Signup and view all the answers
Mercantile agency is primarily governed by the ______ Code.
Mercantile agency is primarily governed by the ______ Code.
Signup and view all the answers
An agent is someone empowered to promote, manage, or even conclude ______ transactions on behalf of a principal.
An agent is someone empowered to promote, manage, or even conclude ______ transactions on behalf of a principal.
Signup and view all the answers
Agency in a commercial context cannot be ______.
Agency in a commercial context cannot be ______.
Signup and view all the answers
All acts done by the agent within the scope of ______ directly produce their effect on the principal.
All acts done by the agent within the scope of ______ directly produce their effect on the principal.
Signup and view all the answers
The principal’s capacity to contract determines whether the agent’s acts are ______.
The principal’s capacity to contract determines whether the agent’s acts are ______.
Signup and view all the answers
If the agent exceeds the conferred authority, the act is typically ______ as to the principal.
If the agent exceeds the conferred authority, the act is typically ______ as to the principal.
Signup and view all the answers
The Commercial Code requires traders to keep specific books such as the journal, cash-book, inventory-book, and ______.
The Commercial Code requires traders to keep specific books such as the journal, cash-book, inventory-book, and ______.
Signup and view all the answers
Failure to observe the requirements of the Commercial Code can lead to penalties or adverse ______ in court disputes.
Failure to observe the requirements of the Commercial Code can lead to penalties or adverse ______ in court disputes.
Signup and view all the answers
Maintaining trade books helps shield traders from administrative ______.
Maintaining trade books helps shield traders from administrative ______.
Signup and view all the answers
Trade books serve as powerful evidence in ______.
Trade books serve as powerful evidence in ______.
Signup and view all the answers
Under Article 22 of the Commercial Code, properly maintained books constitute prima facie ______ of the transactions they record.
Under Article 22 of the Commercial Code, properly maintained books constitute prima facie ______ of the transactions they record.
Signup and view all the answers
Comprehensive records help avoid protracted arguments about the ______ of transactions.
Comprehensive records help avoid protracted arguments about the ______ of transactions.
Signup and view all the answers
Thorough bookkeeping fosters ______ within the trader's operations.
Thorough bookkeeping fosters ______ within the trader's operations.
Signup and view all the answers
By documenting every receipt, payment, and inventory change, traders gain a detailed financial ______ of the business.
By documenting every receipt, payment, and inventory change, traders gain a detailed financial ______ of the business.
Signup and view all the answers
When a trader faces financial difficulties, trade books help distinguish genuine ______ from suspicious or fraudulent bankruptcies.
When a trader faces financial difficulties, trade books help distinguish genuine ______ from suspicious or fraudulent bankruptcies.
Signup and view all the answers
Tax authorities scrutinize a trader’s records to verify VAT returns, income tax calculations, and other fiscal ______.
Tax authorities scrutinize a trader’s records to verify VAT returns, income tax calculations, and other fiscal ______.
Signup and view all the answers
Keeping trade books helps traders demonstrate ______ to potential suppliers or investors.
Keeping trade books helps traders demonstrate ______ to potential suppliers or investors.
Signup and view all the answers
Trade books allow traders to detect trends and adapt product lines in ______ to market demands.
Trade books allow traders to detect trends and adapt product lines in ______ to market demands.
Signup and view all the answers
The waste-book is a daily diary or memorandum where traders immediately record every commercial transaction in ______ order.
The waste-book is a daily diary or memorandum where traders immediately record every commercial transaction in ______ order.
Signup and view all the answers
The waste-book helps avoid omissions by recording transactions promptly, making any subsequent error or ______ identifiable early.
The waste-book helps avoid omissions by recording transactions promptly, making any subsequent error or ______ identifiable early.
Signup and view all the answers
In modern times, electronic ______ can serve a similar function as the waste-book.
In modern times, electronic ______ can serve a similar function as the waste-book.
Signup and view all the answers
If the descriptive or distinctive elements differ sufficiently, the marks may not be confusing for a buyer who is 'reasonably well-informed' in the case of ______ vs Caruana.
If the descriptive or distinctive elements differ sufficiently, the marks may not be confusing for a buyer who is 'reasonably well-informed' in the case of ______ vs Caruana.
Signup and view all the answers
The earlier case of Hubert vs ______ illustrates how third parties using an identical trade name could result in confusion.
The earlier case of Hubert vs ______ illustrates how third parties using an identical trade name could result in confusion.
Signup and view all the answers
Maltese courts apply consistent ‘rules of ______’ in determining the likelihood of confusion between two marks or names.
Maltese courts apply consistent ‘rules of ______’ in determining the likelihood of confusion between two marks or names.
Signup and view all the answers
Whether or not confusion arises is fundamentally a question of ______.
Whether or not confusion arises is fundamentally a question of ______.
Signup and view all the answers
‘Traders shall not, for the purpose of competition, spread news capable of prejudicing the business or trade carried on by another trader’ is outlined in ______.
‘Traders shall not, for the purpose of competition, spread news capable of prejudicing the business or trade carried on by another trader’ is outlined in ______.
Signup and view all the answers
To establish a breach under Article 34(1), four ______ must typically be proven.
To establish a breach under Article 34(1), four ______ must typically be proven.
Signup and view all the answers
The core elements include Trader Status, Specific Intent to Compete, Spreading of ______, and Potential to Prejudice.
The core elements include Trader Status, Specific Intent to Compete, Spreading of ______, and Potential to Prejudice.
Signup and view all the answers
The truth or falsity of the circulated news has been viewed as ______ under Article 34(1).
The truth or falsity of the circulated news has been viewed as ______ under Article 34(1).
Signup and view all the answers
Article 32A on comparative advertising was introduced in ______.
Article 32A on comparative advertising was introduced in ______.
Signup and view all the answers
Comparative advertising is not outright prohibited but is subject to strict legality ______.
Comparative advertising is not outright prohibited but is subject to strict legality ______.
Signup and view all the answers
Under Article 32A, if certain criteria are met, statements may be allowed as legitimate ______ advertising.
Under Article 32A, if certain criteria are met, statements may be allowed as legitimate ______ advertising.
Signup and view all the answers
Before 2008, almost any negative statement about a competitor risked breaching Article ______.
Before 2008, almost any negative statement about a competitor risked breaching Article ______.
Signup and view all the answers
Under Article 32A, truthfulness and objectivity become ______.
Under Article 32A, truthfulness and objectivity become ______.
Signup and view all the answers
Comparative advertising is permissible if it is not misleading under Article ______ or under the Consumer Affairs Act.
Comparative advertising is permissible if it is not misleading under Article ______ or under the Consumer Affairs Act.
Signup and view all the answers
Objective criteria for comparative advertising must include focusing on material features, including ______.
Objective criteria for comparative advertising must include focusing on material features, including ______.
Signup and view all the answers
Agency under the Commercial Code is narrower in purpose but stronger in effect, typically enabling the agent to conclude commercial deals on behalf of the ______.
Agency under the Commercial Code is narrower in purpose but stronger in effect, typically enabling the agent to conclude commercial deals on behalf of the ______.
Signup and view all the answers
Certain transactions, such as real property transfers, may require written ______ to be valid.
Certain transactions, such as real property transfers, may require written ______ to be valid.
Signup and view all the answers
Agents typically cannot ______ their authority unless expressly permitted by the principal.
Agents typically cannot ______ their authority unless expressly permitted by the principal.
Signup and view all the answers
The agent has a fiduciary duty to act in the best ______ of the principal.
The agent has a fiduciary duty to act in the best ______ of the principal.
Signup and view all the answers
Once the agent acts within the authorized scope, the ______ is bound by those actions.
Once the agent acts within the authorized scope, the ______ is bound by those actions.
Signup and view all the answers
If the agent exceeds the scope of authority, they could be held personally ______ for their actions.
If the agent exceeds the scope of authority, they could be held personally ______ for their actions.
Signup and view all the answers
Agency can end by an act of the parties, such as revocation, or by operation of ______.
Agency can end by an act of the parties, such as revocation, or by operation of ______.
Signup and view all the answers
The manager is defined as a person who is placed, personally and permanently, in charge of the ______ of the principal.
The manager is defined as a person who is placed, personally and permanently, in charge of the ______ of the principal.
Signup and view all the answers
A manager’s role is both personal and ______, indicating a long-term relationship with the principal.
A manager’s role is both personal and ______, indicating a long-term relationship with the principal.
Signup and view all the answers
Under Article 62(1), the manager must consistently represent the ______ when conducting business.
Under Article 62(1), the manager must consistently represent the ______ when conducting business.
Signup and view all the answers
The fiduciary duty owed by the manager resembles that owed by company directors to their ______.
The fiduciary duty owed by the manager resembles that owed by company directors to their ______.
Signup and view all the answers
In the case of breach of mandate, the principal may refuse to honor a deal unless they choose to ______ it.
In the case of breach of mandate, the principal may refuse to honor a deal unless they choose to ______ it.
Signup and view all the answers
In certain situations, written authorization may be required for ______ or legally specified transactions.
In certain situations, written authorization may be required for ______ or legally specified transactions.
Signup and view all the answers
The courts affirmed that a manager can be appointed by written, verbal, or ______ agreement.
The courts affirmed that a manager can be appointed by written, verbal, or ______ agreement.
Signup and view all the answers
Until 2000, well-known marks had little protection in Malta unless ______.
Until 2000, well-known marks had little protection in Malta unless ______.
Signup and view all the answers
Article 50 ensures that well-known marks are protected even if they lack registration or physical ______ in Malta.
Article 50 ensures that well-known marks are protected even if they lack registration or physical ______ in Malta.
Signup and view all the answers
A trademark that is 'well-known in Malta' cannot be registered or used by another in a way that causes ______.
A trademark that is 'well-known in Malta' cannot be registered or used by another in a way that causes ______.
Signup and view all the answers
The Trademarks Act also clarifies that ______ alone may suffice if the mark has truly penetrated Maltese consumer perception.
The Trademarks Act also clarifies that ______ alone may suffice if the mark has truly penetrated Maltese consumer perception.
Signup and view all the answers
The courts, when applying Article 50, focus on whether the mark is known among a substantial segment of the relevant ______.
The courts, when applying Article 50, focus on whether the mark is known among a substantial segment of the relevant ______.
Signup and view all the answers
Article 32 requires two competing traders in the local ______.
Article 32 requires two competing traders in the local ______.
Signup and view all the answers
The Trademarks Act protects intellectual property rights more specifically and does not require direct market ______.
The Trademarks Act protects intellectual property rights more specifically and does not require direct market ______.
Signup and view all the answers
In the Muppets Case, the court emphasized the difference between a trademark-based claim and an unfair competition action under ______.
In the Muppets Case, the court emphasized the difference between a trademark-based claim and an unfair competition action under ______.
Signup and view all the answers
The court declared the trademark 'OLEANDER' ______ due to bad faith registration.
The court declared the trademark 'OLEANDER' ______ due to bad faith registration.
Signup and view all the answers
The Trademarks Act provides a distinct route for protecting well-known marks against unfair ______.
The Trademarks Act provides a distinct route for protecting well-known marks against unfair ______.
Signup and view all the answers
The courts have upheld protections for well-known marks by reference to the ______.
The courts have upheld protections for well-known marks by reference to the ______.
Signup and view all the answers
Article 50 aligns with the Paris Convention and EU law, removing the strict 'actual ______' barrier.
Article 50 aligns with the Paris Convention and EU law, removing the strict 'actual ______' barrier.
Signup and view all the answers
Owners of well-known marks have a two-pronged legal strategy: rely on Article 32 where they conduct ______ in Malta.
Owners of well-known marks have a two-pronged legal strategy: rely on Article 32 where they conduct ______ in Malta.
Signup and view all the answers
Article 32 of the Commercial Code prohibits the use of any name, mark, or device that could create ______ with another trader’s distinctive signs.
Article 32 of the Commercial Code prohibits the use of any name, mark, or device that could create ______ with another trader’s distinctive signs.
Signup and view all the answers
Court decisions show that a well-known mark can be protected even without a ______ presence.
Court decisions show that a well-known mark can be protected even without a ______ presence.
Signup and view all the answers
Study Notes
Protection of Well-Known Marks in Malta
- Maltese law protects well-known marks through a dual system: unfair competition (Commercial Code, Article 32) and intellectual property law (Trademarks Act, Article 50).
- Article 32 traditionally followed a "soft-line" approach, allowing protection based solely on international reputation, even without local presence (cases like Frendo Randon noe vs Gatt noe).
- However, a "hard-line" approach now prevails, requiring actual local competition for Article 32 protection (Valletta noe vs Tanti, the McDonald's case).
- Article 50 (Trademarks Act) provides explicit protection for well-known marks regardless of local trade presence, reflecting international standards (e.g., Paris Convention).
- Reputation alone may suffice under Article 50 if a mark is well-known among Maltese consumers.
- Well-known marks are protected from registrations or use by others that cause confusion or take unfair advantage of the mark's repute.
Article 32 of the Commercial Code: Unfair Competition
- Prohibits using names, marks, or devices that cause confusion with another trader's lawfully used names or marks.
- Historically, international reputation alone was sufficient without local presence (e.g., Frendo Randon noe vs Gatt noe, Grech noe vs Mangion).
- Later, the "hard-line" approach required that both parties operate in the same Maltese market (Valletta noe vs Tanti).
Article 50 of the Trademarks Act
- Ensures protection for well-known marks even without local presence or registration, aligning with the Paris Convention and EU law.
- Protects even if the mark is well-known within Malta.
- Focuses on brand recognition among Maltese consumers, not just physical operations.
- Cases such as Mamo noe vs Kontrollur Proprjeta Industrijali (the Stefanel case), demonstrate protection for globally-renowned brands.
- The Muppets case and more recent cases acknowledge the role of online commerce in establishing brand awareness.
Interplay Between Article 32 and Article 50
- Article 32 is suitable for well-known marks with established or potential competitive presence.
- Article 50 protects globally known marks without a local trade presence.
Secondary Meaning Under Article 32
- A descriptive term can acquire secondary meaning through continuous use and public association with a particular trader's goods or services.
- Consumer perception, not period of use, determines proof of secondary meaning (Chircop vs Galea noe).
Get-Up (Trade Dress) Under Article 32
- Article 32 protects distinctive product get-up (e.g., packaging, color schemes) from imitation that could mislead consumers (Hammer vs Gatt).
False Indication of Origin Under Article 33
- Prohibits using false or misleading information about the origin of goods to deceive consumers.
- Does not penalize commonly used, generic terms that don't mislead (Article 33).
Confusion in Trademarks/Trade Names
-
Determining confusion is a factual judgment, relying on guidelines, not a strict formula.
-
Overall impression/idea of the mark is crucial; a likeness between marks matters. (Sabel vs Puma)
-
Average consumer viewpoint is used (e.g., Cutajar vs Caruana, recognising differentiation in terms).
-
Imperfect recollection and overall impression matter.
-
Context, channel of trade, and target market importance influence confusion. (e.g., Valletta noe vs Busuttil et, Nutella vs Nutina.)
-
Actual confusion is not required; likelihood of confusion suffices (Sansone vs Cassar Torreggiani, Nutella vs Chocotella.) Multiple cases support this.
Article 34(1): Spreading Prejudicial News
- Prohibits spreading news harmful to a competitor's trade, with a competitive motive.
- This applies even if the news is true and even with limited circulation. (Curmi vs Mizzi; Falzon vs Nani; and Alfred Gera & Sons Ltd vs Mario Casingena).
- The advent of Article 32A (Comparative Advertising) clarifies that factually verifiable comparisons (meeting various criteria) are permissible.
Agency Under Articles 49-51 of the Commercial Code
- Mercantile agency is exclusively in the Commercial Code (articles 49-51) unlike a civil-law mandate.
- It is onerous unlike a civil-law mandate: it cannot be free of charge.
- Acts performed by the agent within the scope of authority directly bind the principal.
- The principle of delegatus non potest delegare applies (agents cannot delegate their authority unless permitted by the principal).
- The principal’s capacity matters for the validity of acts executed by the agent
Managerial Duties under Article 57
- Managers have fiduciary duties stemming from Article 57, meaning they must uphold the principal’s best interests.
- Managers act as substitutes akin to board directors, preventing self-interest.
- Managers must act in the principal’s name – all transactions ought to be in the principal’s name, not personally, and clearly state their status as ‘per procura’ (p.p.) or ‘manager.’
- Loyalty and non-competition obligations are crucial, with consequences for violations (e.g., D. Curmi noe vs J. Mizzi). It means managers cannot compete with the main company.
- Managers must maintain diligence, care, and skill and follow all trader obligations as listed in the commercial code.
- Managers have information and account-rendering duties (keeping the principal informed of developments and liabilities). Significant omissions and falsehoods in accounts may incur liability.
- Courts recognize the manager’s personal liability for actions outside their remit, or lacking clarity in contractual dealings (e.g., Camilleri noe vs Aquilina style references).
Importance of Trade Books
- Maintaining trade books is vital for Maltese traders to comply with Articles 13–20 in the Commercial Code.
- They serve a wider purpose, being useful evidence in disputes, enabling better accountability, promoting transparency and aiding efficient business planning.
- Proper trade books bolster legal positions and ensure the trader’s credibility.
- Records act as primary evidence of transactions in disputes, avoiding disputes about correctness or authenticity (Article 22).
- Trade books help in various crucial situations such as bankruptcy and taxation.
Trade Books Explained
- Waste-book: A daily log of all transactions in chronological order (Article 14).
- Journal: A structured daybook containing all details of transactions—distinguishes commercial and personal; has formal entries.
- Cash-book: Monitors all cash transactions (Article 16), offering visibility on liquidity.
- Inventory-book: An annual summary of assets and liabilities providing a financial snapshot.
- Ledger: Categorizes journal entries into separate accounts—making financial statements easier.
- Optional books and correspondence files are permitted by Article 19 and 20 for additional records (e.g., external correspondence or internal records of specific activities).
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.
Description
This quiz explores the protection of well-known marks under Maltese law. It covers the dual system of unfair competition and intellectual property law, including Articles 32 and 50. Understand how reputation impacts the protection of trademarks in Malta and the implications of recent legal cases.
