Political Doctrine Quiz

Podcast

Play an AI-generated podcast conversation about this lesson

Questions and Answers

Which political doctrine advocates for a government structured in three branches?

Utilitarianism

Marxism

Federalism

Montesquieu's Division of Powers (correct)

The Judiciary branch is completely independent in its judicial review and appointments.

False

What is the primary function of the Legislative branch in relation to the Executive?

To draft and depend on proposals from the Executive.

The concept of __________ focuses on specific functions or criteria to define Administration.

Objective Doctrine Signup and view all the answers

What is an example of a constitutional body performing administrative functions?

Administrative Courts Signup and view all the answers

Match the following concepts with their descriptions:

Executive = Includes the government and Board of Ministers Legislative = Dependent on drafts from the Executive Judiciary = Independent in judicial review but politically influenced Public Administration = Part of the Executive branch and linked to legality principle Signup and view all the answers

Public bodies and private entities can both perform administrative activities.

True Signup and view all the answers

What historical event led to the modern complex administration replacing ancient structures?

The French Revolution Signup and view all the answers

What was established by the Division of Powers Doctrine?

Executive independence from old political powers Signup and view all the answers

The Supreme Court in Spain was created in 1834 with administrative supervision.

False Signup and view all the answers

What year was the Spanish Constitution enacted that ensured full judicial review of administrative conflicts?

1978 Signup and view all the answers

The _____ principle requires that the public administration must act according to the law.

legality Signup and view all the answers

Match the following key features of public administration with their descriptions:

Legality Principle = Must act according to the law Privilege Position = Reports presumed true, enjoys autotutela Autonomy = Organizational, financial, and functional independence Single Legal Personality = Reflects on the entire organization Signup and view all the answers

Which act introduced 'delegated jurisdiction'?

Santamaria de Paredes Act Signup and view all the answers

Public administration can focus on private interests according to its principles.

False Signup and view all the answers

In what year did the LJCA expand judicial control over administrative issues?

1956 Signup and view all the answers

Study Notes

I. Concept

Division of Powers: Montesquieu's doctrine divides government into three branches: Executive, Legislative, and Judiciary.
Executive Branch: Comprises the government and the Board of Ministers, responsible for policy implementation.
Legislative Branch: Dependent on Executive drafts for new laws and policies, creating a reciprocal relationship.
Judiciary Branch: Independent in judicial review but politically influenced regarding judicial appointments.
Relationship Between Branches: Frequent interactions, especially Legislative actions reliant on Executive proposals.
Public Administration: Part of the Executive branch, subject to court monitoring and aligned with the principle of legality, ensuring subordination to Legislative authority.
Administrative Law: Lack of a definitive understanding of administrative phenomena, with various doctrines proposed for analysis.
Objective Doctrine: Aims to establish criteria to clearly define the functions of Public Administration.
Public Service Definition: Lacks consistency historically and contextually; not all administrative actions relate directly to public services.
Administrative Privileges (Autotutela): Not universally applicable; administrative bodies may operate similarly to private citizens.
Public Interest Concept: Faces similar challenges as the public service definition, with unclear interpretations.
Subjective Doctrine: Identifies legal entities categorized as Administration by law.
Entities with Public Legal Personality: Follows Administrative law and is supervised by Administrative Courts.
Inadequacies in Administration:
- Constitutional bodies undertake administrative functions, remaining under Administrative law despite a lack of administrative identity.
- Private entities, like concession holders, engaging in administrative tasks are subjected to administrative oversight.
- Public institutions may employ private or civil law frameworks (e.g., labor laws) for certain operations.
Government’s Dual Role: Functions politically while also managing administrative responsibilities.

II. Origin and Historical Evolution

Historical Roots: The French Revolution catalyzed modern administration, leading to more complex systems but replacing antiquated structures.
Division of Powers Impact: Ensured the Executive's independence from traditional political influences while initially excluding any form of judicial review.
Conseil d’Etat: Established as an independent body to oversee Public Administration, facilitating a "withheld jurisdiction" approach.
Spain’s Adaptation to Administration:
- 1834: Establishment of the Supreme Court without administrative oversight.
- 1845: Consejo de Estado assumed administrative supervision.
- 1888: Santamaria de Paredes Act introduced the concept of "delegated jurisdiction".
- 1904: Maura Act conferred full jurisdiction relating to administrative matters to the Supreme Court.
- 1956: The Law on Contentious Administrative Jurisdiction (LJCA) expanded judicial control, though limited under Franco’s regime.
- 1978: Spanish Constitution established comprehensive judicial review of administrative disputes.

III. Personification of Public Administration in the Current Legal System

Legality Principle: Public Administration must operate strictly within the confines of the law.
Political Influences: Operations are swayed by political agendas, not merely legal mandates.
Privileged Position: Public Administration reports are assumed accurate, enjoying the principle of autotutela.
Public Interest Focus: Administrative actions should be aimed exclusively at serving the public interest.
Organizational Structure: Defined hierarchies and responsibilities are established within administrative proceedings.
Legal Personality: Administrative structures are recognized as legal entities, distinct from individual officers.
Public vs. Private Personality: Unique legal frameworks (administrative or private) apply, influencing judicial categorizations.
Assigned Powers: Powers designated to administrative entities cannot be relinquished; they are integral to the body’s function.
Single Legal Personality: All administrative actions reflect a unified organizational identity; a unified public record system is mandated.
Autonomy of Administrative Bodies: Organizational, financial, and operational autonomy is present, except in specific administrative agencies.
Administrative Agencies:
- Instrumental Administrations: Created to perform specific tasks and provide public services.
- Limited Powers: Operate within specified realms of authority, subject to legal constraints.

Studying That Suits You

Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.

Description

Test your knowledge on the political doctrine that advocates for a government divided into three branches. Explore the functions and interrelations of the Legislative and Executive branches, as well as the role of independent Judiciary. Additionally, match key concepts with their definitions to deepen your understanding.