Podcast
Questions and Answers
What may be the central psychological component of placebo efficacy?
What may be the central psychological component of placebo efficacy?
- Expectation of improvement (correct)
- A history of heart congestion
- Experimenter bias
- Physiological conditioning
According to the studies, which psychosocial factor was linked to higher mortality rates?
According to the studies, which psychosocial factor was linked to higher mortality rates?
- Active lifestyle
- Low stress levels
- Social isolation (correct)
- Marital status
Which factor is correlated with adherence in patients after an acute heart attack?
Which factor is correlated with adherence in patients after an acute heart attack?
- Social support
- Psychosocial factors like stress (correct)
- Age of the patient
- Type of medication received
How did the adherence of patients influence their mortality rate?
How did the adherence of patients influence their mortality rate?
What is one effect of patient expectations on anxiety according to the study findings?
What is one effect of patient expectations on anxiety according to the study findings?
What is meant by a double-blind study?
What is meant by a double-blind study?
Which of the following best describes the placebo effect?
Which of the following best describes the placebo effect?
What percentage of patients are estimated to respond to placebo treatments?
What percentage of patients are estimated to respond to placebo treatments?
Which of the following is NOT a proposed theory for how placebos work?
Which of the following is NOT a proposed theory for how placebos work?
What is one implication associated with placebos as referenced in the content?
What is one implication associated with placebos as referenced in the content?
What can the variability in placebo response rates indicate?
What can the variability in placebo response rates indicate?
Which of the following is considered a non-interactive theory regarding how placebos function?
Which of the following is considered a non-interactive theory regarding how placebos function?
Which aspect is associated with the psychological implications of the placebo effect?
Which aspect is associated with the psychological implications of the placebo effect?
Which factor is NOT associated with the placebo effect according to the discussed characteristics of treatment?
Which factor is NOT associated with the placebo effect according to the discussed characteristics of treatment?
What type of medication characteristics were found to enhance the placebo effect?
What type of medication characteristics were found to enhance the placebo effect?
Which aspect of the healthcare provider enhances the placebo effect?
Which aspect of the healthcare provider enhances the placebo effect?
What does experimenter bias refer to in the context of placebo studies?
What does experimenter bias refer to in the context of placebo studies?
Which of the following best describes 'confabulations' related to placebo effects?
Which of the following best describes 'confabulations' related to placebo effects?
Which of the following statements is true regarding the characteristics related to the treatment?
Which of the following statements is true regarding the characteristics related to the treatment?
How does the status of the healthcare provider impact the placebo effect?
How does the status of the healthcare provider impact the placebo effect?
What issue arises from focusing solely on patient, treatment, or professional characteristics in placebo studies?
What issue arises from focusing solely on patient, treatment, or professional characteristics in placebo studies?
What best defines a placebo?
What best defines a placebo?
In a randomised double-blind placebo controlled trial, what is the primary purpose of blinding?
In a randomised double-blind placebo controlled trial, what is the primary purpose of blinding?
Which of the following statements about a randomised controlled trial (RCT) is true?
Which of the following statements about a randomised controlled trial (RCT) is true?
What is a nocebo?
What is a nocebo?
How have definitions of placebo changed over time?
How have definitions of placebo changed over time?
What is a characteristic of a placebo used in clinical trials?
What is a characteristic of a placebo used in clinical trials?
What is a clinical implication of using placebos?
What is a clinical implication of using placebos?
In what situation would a placebo be considered ethically problematic?
In what situation would a placebo be considered ethically problematic?
What key concept underlies the learning theory in interactive theories?
What key concept underlies the learning theory in interactive theories?
What role does a placebo play in reducing anxiety according to the interactive theories?
What role does a placebo play in reducing anxiety according to the interactive theories?
How does the physiological theory explain the placebo effect?
How does the physiological theory explain the placebo effect?
In the endorphin study by Levine, Gordon, and Fields, what was the outcome for placebo responders?
In the endorphin study by Levine, Gordon, and Fields, what was the outcome for placebo responders?
What may happen as a result of the use of placebos?
What may happen as a result of the use of placebos?
What is a key aspect of the expectation theory related to patient motivation?
What is a key aspect of the expectation theory related to patient motivation?
In the context of the interactive theories, what does the association between the treatment and the recovery symbolize?
In the context of the interactive theories, what does the association between the treatment and the recovery symbolize?
Which of the following statements is true regarding naloxone?
Which of the following statements is true regarding naloxone?
What is a significant factor in enhancing the efficacy of effective analgesics according to the study results?
What is a significant factor in enhancing the efficacy of effective analgesics according to the study results?
What was the primary conclusion from the Open-Hidden Study of Morphine regarding patient expectations?
What was the primary conclusion from the Open-Hidden Study of Morphine regarding patient expectations?
Which of the following best defines a nocebo?
Which of the following best defines a nocebo?
What does learning theory explain in relation to the placebo effect?
What does learning theory explain in relation to the placebo effect?
A major finding of the Open-Hidden Study of Morphine was that patients receiving visible analgesics reported what compared to those receiving hidden analgesics?
A major finding of the Open-Hidden Study of Morphine was that patients receiving visible analgesics reported what compared to those receiving hidden analgesics?
Which of the following factors does NOT contribute to the placebo effect according to the provided content?
Which of the following factors does NOT contribute to the placebo effect according to the provided content?
What does the term 'white coat effect' refer to in the context of placebo theory?
What does the term 'white coat effect' refer to in the context of placebo theory?
What is a critical ethical implication of placebo use in clinical settings?
What is a critical ethical implication of placebo use in clinical settings?
What factor was NOT identified as contributing to poor adherence in the beta-blocker versus placebo study?
What factor was NOT identified as contributing to poor adherence in the beta-blocker versus placebo study?
Which psychological component is least likely to be directly influenced by patient expectations regarding treatment?
Which psychological component is least likely to be directly influenced by patient expectations regarding treatment?
In the study comparing beta-blockers and placebos, which group had a higher mortality risk due to lower adherence levels?
In the study comparing beta-blockers and placebos, which group had a higher mortality risk due to lower adherence levels?
Which of the following effects is primarily triggered by the expectation of treatment, according to the content provided?
Which of the following effects is primarily triggered by the expectation of treatment, according to the content provided?
What combination of factors was associated with the highest mortality in patients post-heart attack?
What combination of factors was associated with the highest mortality in patients post-heart attack?
What percentage of UK doctors reported using impure placebos at least once in their career?
What percentage of UK doctors reported using impure placebos at least once in their career?
What is the implication of prescribing a placebo solely to satisfy a difficult patient, according to the American Medical Association?
What is the implication of prescribing a placebo solely to satisfy a difficult patient, according to the American Medical Association?
What technique does the American Medical Association suggest could produce a placebo-like effect without using a placebo?
What technique does the American Medical Association suggest could produce a placebo-like effect without using a placebo?
What percentage of surveyed doctors in Israel did not inform their patients that they were prescribed a placebo?
What percentage of surveyed doctors in Israel did not inform their patients that they were prescribed a placebo?
What reasoning do most UK doctors provide for considering placebos ethical?
What reasoning do most UK doctors provide for considering placebos ethical?
What is a typical response rate of patients to placebo treatments?
What is a typical response rate of patients to placebo treatments?
Which theory suggests that the characteristics of the healthcare provider can influence the placebo effect?
Which theory suggests that the characteristics of the healthcare provider can influence the placebo effect?
What stigma is associated with the use of placebos in medical practice?
What stigma is associated with the use of placebos in medical practice?
Which of the following represents a physiological explanation for the placebo effect?
Which of the following represents a physiological explanation for the placebo effect?
What common misconception might patients have about placebo treatments based on the discussed stigma?
What common misconception might patients have about placebo treatments based on the discussed stigma?
What phenomenon describes the tendency of patients to request higher doses over time when using placebos?
What phenomenon describes the tendency of patients to request higher doses over time when using placebos?
Which of the following is an example of a non-interactive theory related to the placebo effect?
Which of the following is an example of a non-interactive theory related to the placebo effect?
Which of the following best characterizes the impact of treatment characteristics on placebo effectiveness?
Which of the following best characterizes the impact of treatment characteristics on placebo effectiveness?
What is the relationship between perception of treatment seriousness and the placebo effect?
What is the relationship between perception of treatment seriousness and the placebo effect?
Which factor does NOT significantly influence the placebo effect according to the content?
Which factor does NOT significantly influence the placebo effect according to the content?
What role does the pharmaceutical brand name play in the placebo effect?
What role does the pharmaceutical brand name play in the placebo effect?
What factor influences the report of improved symptoms despite unchanged conditions?
What factor influences the report of improved symptoms despite unchanged conditions?
How does the practitioner’s enthusiasm affect the placebo response?
How does the practitioner’s enthusiasm affect the placebo response?
What assumption is critiqued regarding the examination of factors influencing the placebo effect?
What assumption is critiqued regarding the examination of factors influencing the placebo effect?
What describes the impact of high professional status of a healthcare provider on the placebo effect?
What describes the impact of high professional status of a healthcare provider on the placebo effect?
What is indicated by experimenter bias in the context of placebo studies?
What is indicated by experimenter bias in the context of placebo studies?
Which definition best captures the evolving understanding of placebos?
Which definition best captures the evolving understanding of placebos?
What is the primary purpose of a randomised double-blind placebo controlled trial?
What is the primary purpose of a randomised double-blind placebo controlled trial?
Which theory suggests that the context of treatment delivery influences the effects of a placebo?
Which theory suggests that the context of treatment delivery influences the effects of a placebo?
What distinguishes a nocebo from a placebo?
What distinguishes a nocebo from a placebo?
What are the ethical implications of using placebos in clinical settings?
What are the ethical implications of using placebos in clinical settings?
Which element is essential to achieve adequate blinding in a randomised placebo controlled trial?
Which element is essential to achieve adequate blinding in a randomised placebo controlled trial?
In what aspect have definitions of placebos changed over time?
In what aspect have definitions of placebos changed over time?
What is a key characteristic of a randomised controlled trial (RCT)?
What is a key characteristic of a randomised controlled trial (RCT)?
What role does naloxone play in the context of the placebo effect?
What role does naloxone play in the context of the placebo effect?
How does the learning theory relate to patient recovery in the context of treatment?
How does the learning theory relate to patient recovery in the context of treatment?
What can be inferred about the relationship between a patient’s expectation and pain perception?
What can be inferred about the relationship between a patient’s expectation and pain perception?
What evidence supports the claim that endorphin release occurs with placebos?
What evidence supports the claim that endorphin release occurs with placebos?
Which of the following accurately reflects the physiological theory of placebo effects?
Which of the following accurately reflects the physiological theory of placebo effects?
In the study conducted by Levine, Gordon, and Fields, which group was most likely to experience pain relief through the placebo effect?
In the study conducted by Levine, Gordon, and Fields, which group was most likely to experience pain relief through the placebo effect?
What psychological aspect enhances the effectiveness of a placebo treatment according to expectation theory?
What psychological aspect enhances the effectiveness of a placebo treatment according to expectation theory?
What primary factor differentiates the unconditioned response from the conditioned response in learning theory related to recovery?
What primary factor differentiates the unconditioned response from the conditioned response in learning theory related to recovery?
Flashcards
Placebo
Placebo
An inactive substance or procedure given to a participant in a clinical trial, designed to be indistinguishable from the real treatment, ensuring blinding.
Randomized Controlled Trial (RCT)
Randomized Controlled Trial (RCT)
An experiment where participants are randomly assigned to different groups, one receiving the actual treatment and the other receiving a placebo.
Double-Blind Placebo Controlled Trial
Double-Blind Placebo Controlled Trial
A type of RCT where neither the participant nor the researcher knows who is getting the real treatment and who is getting the placebo.
Blinding
Blinding
Signup and view all the flashcards
Placebo Effect
Placebo Effect
Signup and view all the flashcards
Theories of Placebo Effect
Theories of Placebo Effect
Signup and view all the flashcards
Nocebo Effect
Nocebo Effect
Signup and view all the flashcards
Clinical and Ethical Implications of Placebo Use
Clinical and Ethical Implications of Placebo Use
Signup and view all the flashcards
Double-blind study
Double-blind study
Signup and view all the flashcards
Non-interactive theories of the placebo effect
Non-interactive theories of the placebo effect
Signup and view all the flashcards
Interactive theories of the placebo effect
Interactive theories of the placebo effect
Signup and view all the flashcards
Patient characteristics in the placebo effect
Patient characteristics in the placebo effect
Signup and view all the flashcards
Physiological theories of the placebo effect
Physiological theories of the placebo effect
Signup and view all the flashcards
Patient expectations in the placebo effect
Patient expectations in the placebo effect
Signup and view all the flashcards
What is the placebo effect?
What is the placebo effect?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What is the central role of expectation in the placebo effect?
What is the central role of expectation in the placebo effect?
Signup and view all the flashcards
How did the beta-blocker study demonstrate the power of expectations?
How did the beta-blocker study demonstrate the power of expectations?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What is experimenter bias?
What is experimenter bias?
Signup and view all the flashcards
How did adherence to treatment impact survival rate in the beta-blocker study?
How did adherence to treatment impact survival rate in the beta-blocker study?
Signup and view all the flashcards
Treatment Severity and Placebo Effect
Treatment Severity and Placebo Effect
Signup and view all the flashcards
Brand Perception and Placebo Effect
Brand Perception and Placebo Effect
Signup and view all the flashcards
Professional Status and Placebo Effect
Professional Status and Placebo Effect
Signup and view all the flashcards
Practitioner's Empathy and Placebo Effect
Practitioner's Empathy and Placebo Effect
Signup and view all the flashcards
Experimenter Bias
Experimenter Bias
Signup and view all the flashcards
Confabulations
Confabulations
Signup and view all the flashcards
Reporting Error
Reporting Error
Signup and view all the flashcards
Interactive Theories of Placebo Effect
Interactive Theories of Placebo Effect
Signup and view all the flashcards
Classical Conditioning in Placebo Effect
Classical Conditioning in Placebo Effect
Signup and view all the flashcards
Anxiety Reduction in Placebo Effect
Anxiety Reduction in Placebo Effect
Signup and view all the flashcards
Opioid System and Placebo Effect
Opioid System and Placebo Effect
Signup and view all the flashcards
Endorphin Release Study
Endorphin Release Study
Signup and view all the flashcards
Expectation Theory
Expectation Theory
Signup and view all the flashcards
Ethical Considerations of Placebos
Ethical Considerations of Placebos
Signup and view all the flashcards
Blind Study
Blind Study
Signup and view all the flashcards
White Coat Effect
White Coat Effect
Signup and view all the flashcards
Patient Expectations
Patient Expectations
Signup and view all the flashcards
Physiological Mechanisms of Placebo
Physiological Mechanisms of Placebo
Signup and view all the flashcards
Ethical Issues with Placebo Use
Ethical Issues with Placebo Use
Signup and view all the flashcards
Placebo Controlled Trial
Placebo Controlled Trial
Signup and view all the flashcards
What is a placebo?
What is a placebo?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What is a randomised double-blind placebo controlled trial?
What is a randomised double-blind placebo controlled trial?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What are the different theories of how the placebo effect works?
What are the different theories of how the placebo effect works?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What is a nocebo?
What is a nocebo?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What are the ethical implications of placebo use?
What are the ethical implications of placebo use?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What is a placebo in a clinical trial?
What is a placebo in a clinical trial?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What is a double-blind study?
What is a double-blind study?
Signup and view all the flashcards
Non-interactive theories
Non-interactive theories
Signup and view all the flashcards
Interactive theories
Interactive theories
Signup and view all the flashcards
Physiological theories
Physiological theories
Signup and view all the flashcards
Treatment Severity and the Placebo Effect
Treatment Severity and the Placebo Effect
Signup and view all the flashcards
Professional Status and the Placebo Effect
Professional Status and the Placebo Effect
Signup and view all the flashcards
Doctor's Expectations Influence Placebo Effect
Doctor's Expectations Influence Placebo Effect
Signup and view all the flashcards
Confabulation in the Placebo Effect
Confabulation in the Placebo Effect
Signup and view all the flashcards
Reporting Error in the Placebo Effect
Reporting Error in the Placebo Effect
Signup and view all the flashcards
Problems with Non-Interactive Theories
Problems with Non-Interactive Theories
Signup and view all the flashcards
Adherence and Survival
Adherence and Survival
Signup and view all the flashcards
Meaning Response
Meaning Response
Signup and view all the flashcards
Benevolent Deception
Benevolent Deception
Signup and view all the flashcards
Placebo Use in Medicine
Placebo Use in Medicine
Signup and view all the flashcards
The Placebo Effect in Context
The Placebo Effect in Context
Signup and view all the flashcards
Study Notes
Placebos and the Patient-Professional Encounter
- This lecture explores placebos, their evolving definitions, and their influence in medical practice.
Evolving Definitions of Placebos
- A pharmacologically inert substance given to benefit or please a patient.
- Any component of a treatment lacking specific biological activity for the targeted condition.
- The observable treatment effects not attributable to the treatment's mechanisms but to the surrounding contexts.
Randomised Double-Blind Placebo-Controlled Trials
- An experimental design comparing two or more interventions.
- Participants are randomly assigned to intervention groups.
- An inactive substance or procedure is given to participants.
- Placebos are designed for indistinguishability from active interventions to prevent bias. Neither participants nor clinicians know the treatment allocation.
- Double-blinding minimizes bias by concealing assigned group information.
Placebo - Contemporary Views
- Modern scientific practice is based on the randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial, expecting drugs to perform better than a placebo.
- Gaps in research regarding placebo effects are acknowledged.
Placebo Effect: Typical Example (graph)
- Presents a graph illustrating pain relief over time for saline and morphine treatments.
- Placebos often produce comparable responses to medications for similar complaints.
Placebo Effect
- Evidence from both practice and experimental studies show the presence of the placebo effect across physiological status, behavioral responses, and subjective experiences.
- Placebos mimic the effects of most medications, potentially causing habituation, withdrawal symptoms, and dependence.
- Placebo response rates typically range from 30-50%, sometimes approximating half the effectiveness of the active treatment.
- Significant individual variation in placebo responsiveness exists, estimated at 35% by the WHO.
History and Significance of Placebos
- Placebos carry a negative connotation, often perceived as deception or a conspiracy.
- There's a presumption that non-physiological effects are not genuine or are solely driven by suggestion.
Theories of How Placebos Work
- Non-interactive theories: Focus on factors outside the patient-provider interaction.
- Treatment characteristics (perceived treatment severity, surgical vs. injection procedures)
- Patient characteristics (emotional dependence, extraversion, neuroticism, suggestibility)
- Characteristics of health professionals (professional status, warmth, and empathy)
- Interactive theories: Focus on patient-provider interactions and perceived outcomes.
- Experimenter Bias: influence of the researcher's expectations.
- Reporting Error: inaccuracies or misinterpretations of symptoms.
- Learning Theory: symptom response conditioned through associations.
- Anxiety reduction theory: treatment reduces anxiety, leading to improvement.
- Physiological theories: Address the physiological mechanisms underlying placebo effects.
- Patient expectations: patients' beliefs about treatment impacting their responses.
Patient Expectations and Placebo Effetcs
- Patients' beliefs in a treatment directly influence their physical responses – positive or negative.
- Reduced anxiety and increased trust contribute to effective treatment when clinical context (surroundings, treatment details, and practitioner conduct) is also conducive.
- Core to placebo efficacy is patient expectation of improvement. Expectations may lead to reduced anxiety, higher trust, and enhanced treatment effectiveness.
Nocebo Effects
- Nocebo: negative effects, i.e., "I will harm."
- Informed anticipation of side effects increases the likelihood of experiencing them.
- Nocebo effects, typically generalized and diffuse (e.g., drowsiness, nausea, fatigue), are more common in women and influenced by previous negative experiences/expectations.
- Balancing patient information and minimizing nocebo effects is a clinical challenge.
Methodology of Placebo Study (examples)
- Study of Endorphin Release: Patients were divided into four groups (morphine, naloxone, placebo + placebo, placebo + naloxone), examining pain relief in relation to these treatments.
- Study of Beta-Blockers vs. Placebo: Two groups (beta-blocker vs. placebo) of heart attack survivors were studied for mortality over 12 months, focusing on patient characteristics and adherence.
- Open-Hidden Study of Morphine: Two groups received morphine, either visibly or concealed, and observed pain relief differences. Pain relief was greater for those receiving the visibly administered treatment.
Other Details
- Summary of placebo effect theories
- Summary of results from various studies
Required Reading
- Alder B., et al. Psychology and Sociology applied to Medicine for detailed discussion of placebos.
- Koshi & Short (2007). A comprehensive review of placebo theory in pain practice offering insights and implications for research.
- Ogden (Specific chapter references missing from PDF).
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.