Podcast
Questions and Answers
Which aspect of religion does philosophy primarily engage with, distinguishing it from theology?
Which aspect of religion does philosophy primarily engage with, distinguishing it from theology?
- Religion as a human phenomenon open to rational inquiry. (correct)
- The historical and cultural evolution of religious institutions.
- Personal experiences of faith and spiritual practices.
- Doctrinal accuracy and scriptural interpretation.
Which of the following best characterizes the 'naturalistic definition' of religion?
Which of the following best characterizes the 'naturalistic definition' of religion?
- It emphasizes adherence to traditional religious doctrines.
- It describes a divinely ordained path to spiritual fulfillment.
- It focuses on rituals and practices prescribed by religious institutions.
- It describes religion as a purely human activity or state of mind. (correct)
How does Kant's deontological ethics relate morality to reason?
How does Kant's deontological ethics relate morality to reason?
- Morality is achieved through cultivating virtues and habits.
- Morality leads to reason by structuring actions according to duty and the categorical imperative. (correct)
- Morality is ultimately based on divine command and religious authority.
- Morality is derived from empirical observation and personal feelings.
According to Friedrich Schleiermacher, what constitutes the essence of religion?
According to Friedrich Schleiermacher, what constitutes the essence of religion?
What does Clifford Geertz suggest about the function of religion in society?
What does Clifford Geertz suggest about the function of religion in society?
How did the pre-Socratic philosophers challenge conventional religious beliefs?
How did the pre-Socratic philosophers challenge conventional religious beliefs?
In Plato's metaphysics, what is considered the ultimate reality?
In Plato's metaphysics, what is considered the ultimate reality?
According to Aristotle's theory of abstraction, how does one arrive at the 'ideation' of an object, such as 'appleness'?
According to Aristotle's theory of abstraction, how does one arrive at the 'ideation' of an object, such as 'appleness'?
How does the concept of creatio ex nihilo challenge the Greek philosophical premise of nihil ex nihilo?
How does the concept of creatio ex nihilo challenge the Greek philosophical premise of nihil ex nihilo?
What was the primary focus of philosophical inquiry during the medieval period?
What was the primary focus of philosophical inquiry during the medieval period?
How did Augustine's conception of God differ from that of pagan religions?
How did Augustine's conception of God differ from that of pagan religions?
According to Anselm, what is the relationship between faith and understanding?
According to Anselm, what is the relationship between faith and understanding?
What did Roger Bacon advocate as essential for understanding God?
What did Roger Bacon advocate as essential for understanding God?
Which of the following best describes Thomas Aquinas' approach to philosophy and religion?
Which of the following best describes Thomas Aquinas' approach to philosophy and religion?
How did Christian reform movements and new scientific discoveries complicate the relationship between faith and reason in the modern world?
How did Christian reform movements and new scientific discoveries complicate the relationship between faith and reason in the modern world?
According to Kant's deontological ethics, morality inevitably leads to the realm of aesthetics, not necessarily reason.
According to Kant's deontological ethics, morality inevitably leads to the realm of aesthetics, not necessarily reason.
Friedrich Schleiermacher posited that religion's essence lies in societal structures, dictating morality and ethics.
Friedrich Schleiermacher posited that religion's essence lies in societal structures, dictating morality and ethics.
According to Emile Durkheim, religion's primary role is to fracture societal norms by rigidly separating the sacred from the mundane.
According to Emile Durkheim, religion's primary role is to fracture societal norms by rigidly separating the sacred from the mundane.
According to Plato, the realm of the senses is the realm of truth, while the realm of reason is subject to illusion.
According to Plato, the realm of the senses is the realm of truth, while the realm of reason is subject to illusion.
According to Aristotle, God is the intersection of the organic unity of God, Humans, and Nature.
According to Aristotle, God is the intersection of the organic unity of God, Humans, and Nature.
The concept of 'Nihil ex nihilo', which states nothing comes from nothing, reinforces the concept of the world's creation from nothing.
The concept of 'Nihil ex nihilo', which states nothing comes from nothing, reinforces the concept of the world's creation from nothing.
According to Plato, the word theology emerges in history to represent the study of ethics.
According to Plato, the word theology emerges in history to represent the study of ethics.
In Plato's philosophical view, Forms are objects of religious devotion, urging worship as numerous gods.
In Plato's philosophical view, Forms are objects of religious devotion, urging worship as numerous gods.
According to the lectures, in modern times, the prevailing attitude is to believe before attempting to understand.
According to the lectures, in modern times, the prevailing attitude is to believe before attempting to understand.
The prevailing view in ancient thought held that the divine could be conceived of as existing independently of the world.
The prevailing view in ancient thought held that the divine could be conceived of as existing independently of the world.
According to Kant, morality always boils down to the question: “what should I ______?”
According to Kant, morality always boils down to the question: “what should I ______?”
According to ______, 'The essence of religion consists in the feeling of an absolute dependence'.
According to ______, 'The essence of religion consists in the feeling of an absolute dependence'.
According to Geertz, religion acts as a cultural system which establishes powerful, pervasive, and long-standing ______ and motivations in men.
According to Geertz, religion acts as a cultural system which establishes powerful, pervasive, and long-standing ______ and motivations in men.
According to ______, the necessary inclusion of a transcendent being effectively excludes religious traditions with no intentional transcendent object.
According to ______, the necessary inclusion of a transcendent being effectively excludes religious traditions with no intentional transcendent object.
Rational examination of the truths and principles of being, knowledge, and conduct is the Working Definition of ______.
Rational examination of the truths and principles of being, knowledge, and conduct is the Working Definition of ______.
The three logical principles are identity, non-contradiction and Excluded ______.
The three logical principles are identity, non-contradiction and Excluded ______.
[Blank] is perfect and unchanging, the world of Forms is reality; Senses is changing and therefore imperfect, the sensible world is just a shadow of the world of Forms.
[Blank] is perfect and unchanging, the world of Forms is reality; Senses is changing and therefore imperfect, the sensible world is just a shadow of the world of Forms.
The goal of our lives is to contemplate ______; it is through this contemplation that we surpass our imperfections.
The goal of our lives is to contemplate ______; it is through this contemplation that we surpass our imperfections.
According to Aristotle, the force that exerts a force on reality is ______.
According to Aristotle, the force that exerts a force on reality is ______.
In Greek tragedies, no matter how hard you try to avoid the ______, you can not escape fate.
In Greek tragedies, no matter how hard you try to avoid the ______, you can not escape fate.
The Medieval period was initiated by the ______, which became the first cause Aristotle was only talking about the first mover.
The Medieval period was initiated by the ______, which became the first cause Aristotle was only talking about the first mover.
Nihil ex nihilo means that nothing comes from ______.
Nihil ex nihilo means that nothing comes from ______.
St. Augustine and Anselm had the following beliefs, respectively: Credo ut ______ and Fides quaerens intellectum.
St. Augustine and Anselm had the following beliefs, respectively: Credo ut ______ and Fides quaerens intellectum.
For Augustine, biblical God is intimately inolved with the world, especially with the importance of the mister of the ______.
For Augustine, biblical God is intimately inolved with the world, especially with the importance of the mister of the ______.
Roger Bacon believed that nothing can be known about God without prior study of languages, mathematics, optics, experiential science, and moral ______.
Roger Bacon believed that nothing can be known about God without prior study of languages, mathematics, optics, experiential science, and moral ______.
Explain how Kant's deontological ethics lead to reason, referencing his concept of the Categorical Imperative.
Explain how Kant's deontological ethics lead to reason, referencing his concept of the Categorical Imperative.
Contrast Plato's theory of Forms with Aristotle's perspective on how form relates to matter, especially as it concerns understanding reality.
Contrast Plato's theory of Forms with Aristotle's perspective on how form relates to matter, especially as it concerns understanding reality.
Explain Ludwig Wittgenstein's concept of 'family resemblance' and how it challenges essentialist approaches to defining religion?
Explain Ludwig Wittgenstein's concept of 'family resemblance' and how it challenges essentialist approaches to defining religion?
How did the concept of 'primum movens' or 'first mover' evolve from Aristotelian philosophy to become integrated into medieval theocentric worldviews?
How did the concept of 'primum movens' or 'first mover' evolve from Aristotelian philosophy to become integrated into medieval theocentric worldviews?
Discuss the implications of shifting from a classical cosmocentric worldview to a modern anthropocentric one for understanding the relationship between humanity, nature, and divinity?
Discuss the implications of shifting from a classical cosmocentric worldview to a modern anthropocentric one for understanding the relationship between humanity, nature, and divinity?
Explain the philosophical problem that natural evils pose for philosophical theology, particularly in relation to God's attributes of omnipotence, omniscience, and omnibenevolence.
Explain the philosophical problem that natural evils pose for philosophical theology, particularly in relation to God's attributes of omnipotence, omniscience, and omnibenevolence.
Distinguish between 'reasonability' and 'rationality' in the context of religious epistemology, and provide an example to illustrate the difference.
Distinguish between 'reasonability' and 'rationality' in the context of religious epistemology, and provide an example to illustrate the difference.
How did the encounter between Greek philosophical thought and Jewish/Christian theology alter the course of both domains of knowledge during the medieval period?
How did the encounter between Greek philosophical thought and Jewish/Christian theology alter the course of both domains of knowledge during the medieval period?
What does Anselm mean by 'fides quaerens intellectum,' and how does it differ from the modern approach that understanding must precede belief?
What does Anselm mean by 'fides quaerens intellectum,' and how does it differ from the modern approach that understanding must precede belief?
Explain how Aquinas integrates Aristotelian philosophy into his theology, noting both his use and transformation of Aristotelian doctrines.
Explain how Aquinas integrates Aristotelian philosophy into his theology, noting both his use and transformation of Aristotelian doctrines.
Flashcards
Philosophy of Religion
Philosophy of Religion
Thinking about religion using philosophical concepts.
Religio
Religio
Reverence for gods
Religare
Religare
To bind together
Re-legere
Re-legere
Signup and view all the flashcards
Five Elements of Philosophy
Five Elements of Philosophy
Signup and view all the flashcards
Deontological Ethics
Deontological Ethics
Signup and view all the flashcards
Postulates of Reason
Postulates of Reason
Signup and view all the flashcards
Plato's Forms
Plato's Forms
Signup and view all the flashcards
Heraclitus’s Philosophy
Heraclitus’s Philosophy
Signup and view all the flashcards
Agape
Agape
Signup and view all the flashcards
Religion (Geertz)
Religion (Geertz)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Religion (Durkheim)
Religion (Durkheim)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Religion (Schleiermacher)
Religion (Schleiermacher)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Religion (Huxley)
Religion (Huxley)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Working Definition of Philosophy
Working Definition of Philosophy
Signup and view all the flashcards
Contextualizing Religion
Contextualizing Religion
Signup and view all the flashcards
Naturalistic Definition
Naturalistic Definition
Signup and view all the flashcards
Morality
Morality
Signup and view all the flashcards
Speculative Discipline
Speculative Discipline
Signup and view all the flashcards
Imagination (Philosophy)
Imagination (Philosophy)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Understanding of Philosophy
Understanding of Philosophy
Signup and view all the flashcards
Theodicy
Theodicy
Signup and view all the flashcards
Classical Cosmocentrism
Classical Cosmocentrism
Signup and view all the flashcards
Fideism
Fideism
Signup and view all the flashcards
Reasonability
Reasonability
Signup and view all the flashcards
Religious Definition
Religious Definition
Signup and view all the flashcards
Critique of Pure Reason
Critique of Pure Reason
Signup and view all the flashcards
Reason (Philosophy)
Reason (Philosophy)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Intuition (Philosophy)
Intuition (Philosophy)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Principles (Philosophy)
Principles (Philosophy)
Signup and view all the flashcards
"Family-Resemblance" Concept
"Family-Resemblance" Concept
Signup and view all the flashcards
Truths in Definitions
Truths in Definitions
Signup and view all the flashcards
Principle of Identity
Principle of Identity
Signup and view all the flashcards
Principle of Non-Contradiction
Principle of Non-Contradiction
Signup and view all the flashcards
Emile Durkheim
Emile Durkheim
Signup and view all the flashcards
Medieval Theocentrism
Medieval Theocentrism
Signup and view all the flashcards
Primum Movens
Primum Movens
Signup and view all the flashcards
Religious Language
Religious Language
Signup and view all the flashcards
Philosophical Theology
Philosophical Theology
Signup and view all the flashcards
Religious Epistemology
Religious Epistemology
Signup and view all the flashcards
Rational Theology
Rational Theology
Signup and view all the flashcards
Xenophanes of Colophon
Xenophanes of Colophon
Signup and view all the flashcards
Effects of Christianity
Effects of Christianity
Signup and view all the flashcards
Importance of Belief
Importance of Belief
Signup and view all the flashcards
Theology
Theology
Signup and view all the flashcards
Attributes of First Cause
Attributes of First Cause
Signup and view all the flashcards
Thought Thinking
Thought Thinking
Signup and view all the flashcards
Studying Something
Studying Something
Signup and view all the flashcards
Study Notes
Lecture 1: Philosophy of Religion
- Theology differs from the philosophy of religion: philosophy of religion studies religion as a human phenomenon
- Two conditions that determine if a denomination is Christian:
- The belief that Jesus Christ is truly human
- The belief that Jesus Christ is truly divine, thus part of the Trinity
- Three Etymological Derivations:
- Religio signifies reverence for gods or piety
- Religare signifies "to bind together"
- Re-legere means "to read or consider again" or "to consider carefully."
- Spirituality is religion personalized, while religion is spirituality institutionalized.
Lecture 2
- Five Elements Necessary to do Philosophy:
- Imagination
- Senses
- Reason
- Intuition
- Principles
Religious Definition
- Religious Definition: emerges from within a particular religious tradition, problem - definition will be biased
Naturalistic Definition
- Centers upon an awareness of, and response to, a reality that transcends ourselves
- Describes it as a purely human activity/state of mind
- Problem - tends to be reductionist
- Heightened morality, personal piety, and socio-cultural reality is oversimplified by reductionism
- Morality reduces to the question: "what should I do?"
Religion and Morality
- Religion reduced to morality involves Kant's Deontological Ethics
- Kant discusses duty as a categorical imperative and wrote three works:
- Critique of Pure Reason: addresses whether one can truly know God, but concludes one can believe in God
- Critique of Practical Reason: introduces Postulates of Reason, affirmed by practical reason but cant be proved by pure reason
- Critique of Judgment: covers Aesthetics
- Knowledge is justified through belief
- One cannot simply state "I believe it's raining outside," one must check to justify that belief with "I know it's raining outside."
- Postulates of Reason: elements in thinking that can never be certain by pure reason, but can be affirmed with practical reason.
- Morality (in Kant's deontological ethics), leads to reason
- Iris Murdoch states that morality has always been connected to religion and religion with mysticism
Mysticism and Plato
- Mysticism is a non-dogmatic faith in the reality of the Good, occasionally connected with experience
- Plato's Dualistic Metaphysics: Forms = Reality
- Parmenides states that what is real is permanent and unchanging is an illusion, reason is liable for forms reality
- Reason is reliable: 1+1=2
- Senses = Shadow/Illusion
- Heraclitus said that what is real is change and what is permanent is illusion
- Senses tell us what we are real
- Cannot step in the same river twice
- For the Greeks, Philia, or mutual love is the greatest form of love
- For Christians, it is Agape, selfless, fully giving and non-mutual
Lecture 3
- Religion reduced to Socio-cultural Reality - Clifford Geertz
- Religion, as a cultural system, establishes moods and motivations in men
- Religion solidifies social identity
- Examples of solidifying social identity: driver's license or bridal showers
- Emile Durkheim: Religion is the cement of society is a unified system of beliefs and practices relative to sacred things.
- Religion reduced to Personal Piety -Friedrich Schleiermacher: Religion consists in the feeling of an absolute dependence
- Think about relationships, when in love and they aren't there, things become meaningless
- Julian Huxley: essence of religion stems from man's capacity for awe and reverence, and the feeling of sacredness
- Aristotle's Commentary on Elements of Definition:
- Genus (General) + Species (Specific)
- Aristotle defined man as a rational animal.
- Essentialist Tendency of Religion: the inclusion of a transcendent being excludes religious traditions with no intentional transcendent object.
- Religion becomes too broad= beliefs and areas of study that are generally not considered religion (marxism, nationalism, socialism).
- "Family-Resemblance" Concept - Ludwig Wittgenstein
- Seeks to shy away from the essentialist approach to religion
- Certain concepts are clusters accommodating differences, yet is still identifiable
- The example of the game: games have different forms (individual, group, etc.) with no common essence.
- Instead of a set of defining characteristics, there is a network of similarities.
Lecture 4
- Working Definition of Philosophy: Rational investigation of the truths and principles of being, knowledge, and conduct.
- Three Logical Principles:
- Identity (A is A)
- Non-Contradiction (A is not not A)
- Excluded Middle (Either A or not A)
- Truths in the definition are unchanging
- Principles in the definition are changing because they describe ways of thinking.
- Being = Metaphysics
- Knowledge = Epistemology
- Conduct = Ethics
- Understanding of Philosophy - Way of Life: A consistent way of responding to the world
- Grounded on morality
- Reflective of Life
- Way of living = Way of being
- Speculative Discipline
- Way of seeing things
- Seeing reality in a different perspective
Lecture 5 and Religion
- Five Elements Necessary to do Philosophy:
- Imagination: faculty of taking in new ideas, images, or concepts of external objects not present to the senses
- Senses:
- Mental World (World of Ideas)
- External Objective World (Reality)
- Reason: Intellectual faculty by which we think, understand, and form judgment
- Intuition: Ability to understand something immediately, without conscious reasoning
- Principles: Propositions serving as the foundation for a system, belief, behavior, or reasoning
- In the context of the five elements of philosophy, Principles are the software, while imagination, senses, reason, and intuition, are the hardware
- Both philosophy and religion are motivated by awe, wonder, and amazement
- Both respond to the fundamental question of life: Who am I? What is the meaning of life?
- Both are directed by a sense of ultimacy that sometimes is = God.
Lectures 6, 7 & 8
Lecture 6
- Defining Philosophy of Religion: Book of scripture = supernatural theology, Book of nature = natural philosophy
Lecture 7
- Plato
- Theology first appeared as logos about God
- Divinities are anything beyond human experience
- Philosophy is Religious in nature
- Divine representation: form of the good
- Philosophy is a lifelong quest for salvation, like the Myth of the Cave
- Goal is to contemplate perfection to surpass imperfections
- Plato never urged readers to worship the Forms as many gods, who are unparalleled excellence but not gods
- Reason: Perfect and unchanging, reality
- Senses: Changing, imperfect, and just a shadow
Lecture 8
- Aristotle
- Aristotle disagrees with this teachers' dualist interpretation of forms
- Form informs matter
- Theory of Abstraction
- What you see is the percepta
- Remove what is non-essential so the ‘ideation’ can be reached
- Applies (example) dont need ‘red, sweet, crunchy’
- Remove anything mathematical
- Arrive at the 'ideation'
Quote
- When one is learning, one is actually just remembering
Medieval Perspectives
Shifting Worldviews
- Theos (God) = Transcendent
- Kosmos (World) = Context
- Anthropos (Humanity) = Inquiry
- This rose as a result of natural evils: Think earthquakes, tsunamis, etc. killing so many people even when supposedly God is omnipotent, omniscient, and omnibenevolent.
Classical Cosmocentrism
- Threefold unity of God, Man and Nature.
- Each component has a direct and interrelated relationship with fate as the logic in this world.
Medieval Theocentrism
- God influences man and nature
- This includes Christianity, Judaism, and Islam
- According to Aristotle, there has to be something outside the circle: the primum movens (the first mover)
- To understand nature, know God.
- Logos of man and nature is in the mind of God.
Early Philosophers
- Creator: God, Creation: Man and Nature
- First Cause/Prime Mover/Primum Movens
- Must be a cause NOT caused by something
- Immutable and divine
- Lies outside the organic unity of God, Humans and Nature Attributes:
- Eternal, Incorporeal, Indivisible, Immutable, Perfect Life and Knowledge
- Modern Antropocentrism = separate and ‘projecting’
- Fragmentation where people envision reality
- Individuals have different ideas on GOD and Nature
Pre-Socratic Philosophers addressed religion:
- Some criticized conventional religion as implausible
- Provided mechanistic explanations for the intention of Gods = design
- Understood the divine terms of religion
- Xenophanes of Colophon - morality, questions whether Gods are moral when they are not models and projects that to humans
- Democritus - universe
- Divinities: Theologians believe thinking must grapple w/ indeterminateness
Divine Perspectives
- Thought thinks because else it lowers perfection
- Learn more and know less, therefore not absolute
- Cannot address prayers because it is rational theology
- On Christianity: attributes of the Primum Movens, but also that God equals Perfection.
- Nihil ex nihilo (nothing comes from nothing)
- Eternity of the world
Medieval & Renaissance Periods
- In Christianity, creatio ex nihilo (creation out of nothing)- everything exists because of God’ free will.
- Question of Resurrection- Greek clashes with Jewing and Christian idea
- There was a clash between Greek and Christian faith (two different worldviews)
- The side of philosophy saw a renewed interest in the representation of the divine
- Thinkers from religious traditions articulated their faiths by using philosophical categories
- Founded by Alexander the Great
- Use philosophical ideas to interpret the Torah
- School of Alexandria = Interpretations of the Bible
- Divine Revelation = source of truth for theologians
Theology vs Philosophy
- Philosophy needs to convert
- Philosophy provides for theology, purpose
- Biblical Gods operate outside world, pagan Gods exist within
Biblical Theology
- Paganism sees God as part of our unity
- Christianity sees God entering it and ultimately becoming human
Medieval Philosophy
- Fides quaerens intellectum means: what do I know I believe in what beliefs
- The expression fides quaerens intellectum prompts the questions “What do I even believe in?” and “What do theological formulas mean?”
- Augustine poses:"What do I believe when I believe in God?"
- God tells no lies as He is good
- Seek of understanding and truth
- Ontological arguement by Anselm is about better understanding God
- Theodicy addresses questions/proofs for God's existence
- Roger Bacon = study languages and science before God
- Essential to know God
- Study creation
Lecture 9
- Theology improves, while philosophy employs
- Great deference from ancient philosophers
- Religion embraces human
- Intellectual, justice, goodness, honorific, substance
- Understand through what you see
- Refuses Accomodations from Aristotles
- Immaculate conception- what is possible has happened -Aquinas believes you need to exist to be freed
Modern Day:
- Aquinas said that you would need an immaculate birth and it requires conception, but Duns said God is all powerful when Gods word does not fit, and God does not need to fit in your words : theocentrism
- Legacy intellectum is complicated in these ways:
- Christian Reform movements are critical
- Nova scientia over 'new science'
- General points :
- Legalize points = doctrine
- Obedience
- Thinkers affirmed God is real.
- For Aquinas, religion is lost bond/ external/ holy
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.