CHAPTER 8 Pay for Performance

108 Questions

What is the main concept behind pay-for-performance programs?

Differentiating rewards based on performance

What level of an organization can be rewarded in pay-for-performance programs?

Individual, divisional, and corporate levels

What percentage of organizations claim to be pay-for-performance based?

Around 90-95%

Why do many organizations adopt pay-for-performance programs?

To differentiate rewards based on performance

What does Kerry Hsu suggest about organizations' ability to effectively implement pay-for-performance?

Fewer than 90% of organizations feel they do it well

What are the three crucial aspects in motivating behavior based on the expectancy theory?

Believing in achieving the goal, having the right tools, and valuing the reward

How does the equity theory suggest individuals evaluate their contributions to the organization?

By comparing their contributions to the contributions of other employees

What is a fundamental difference between the expectancy theory and the equity theory?

The expectancy theory revolves around individual beliefs and rewards, while equity theory emphasizes comparisons between contributions and rewards.

Why is it essential for individuals in the expectancy theory to believe that they can accomplish the desired goal?

Because without this belief, motivation may be lacking

How does the expectancy theory differentiate between simply expecting a reward and valuing the reward received?

By emphasizing that simply expecting a reward is insufficient

In what way does the equity theory impact individuals' perceptions within an organization?

It leads employees to compare their contributions with those of others

What is one of the consequences mentioned if an employee feels their side of the equation is low?

Decrease contribution by calling in sick

What options do individuals have if they feel their side of the equation is not equal?

Demand a pay increase or decrease contribution

What role does 'clear line of sight' play in pay-for-performance programs?

It helps employees see the value of their contributions

How might an employer improve a pay-for-performance program?

Ensure employees can clearly see the link between performance and rewards

How does lack of attention and feedback affect employee motivation?

Lack of feedback leads to demotivation.

What type of reward may not be appealing to a younger employee?

Increase in 401k match by 1%.

What can lead to demotivation in a pay-for-performance program?

Getting a merit increase lower than other coworkers.

What is emphasized as equally important as relative compensation levels?

Absolute compensation levels.

The majority of organizations claim to be pay-for-performance organizations, but fewer than 90% feel that they implement it effectively.

True

Research has shown that performance differentiation in pay-for-performance programs is not prevalent in organizations today.

False

What action would an employee most likely take if they feel their side of the equation is low but cannot demand a pay raise?

Decrease their contribution by becoming disengaged

Clear differentiation based on performance is a key aspect of pay-for-performance programs.

True

In pay-for-performance programs, employees must always demand a pay increase if they feel their side of the equation is low.

False

Employees have to believe that if they perform well, they're going to get a ______

reward

The equity theory highlights that individuals compare their contributions to the organization against the rewards they receive, but do not compare it to other employees.

False

In the context of pay-for-performance, what does 'differentiation' refer to?

Rewarding high performers more than low performers

Individuals under the equity theory evaluate their contributions relative to other employees in the organization.

True

What is a key aspect considered by employees regarding their pay?

Comparison with other's pay

Absolute compensation levels are considered less important than relative compensation levels in the context of motivating employees.

False

What theory is the concept of employees comparing their situation with others.

Equity Theory

In Equity Theory, what happens if an employee perceives underreward inequity?

They will compare their ratio of outcomes to inputs

From the employee's perspective, why is pay important beyond just monetary value?

As a sign of status and success

In the context of pay-for-performance programs, what does 'valence' represent?

The value of the reward

What aspect of pay is highlighted as important to employees beyond just monetary value?

Fairness compared with others' pay

Why is a clear line of sight essential in pay-for-performance programs?

To clarify performance expectations for employees

What is the main purpose of pay from an employee's perspective?

Affecting overall income and standard of living

What theory represents the link between behavior and outcome?

Expectancy

What plays a crucial role in determining motivation according to Expectancy Theory?

Value of the reward

What is an essential aspect of Pay for Performance programs?

Having a clear line of sight for employees

According to Equity Theory, what do individuals change based on how they feel to make it fair?

Their balance between effort and reward

Employees in merit pay programs receive compensation adjustments based on __________.

The outcome of their performance evaluation

What distinguishes a lump sum bonus from a traditional merit pay increase?

Inclusion in the employee's salary

How does variable pay contribute to alignment within an organization?

By establishing a link between organizational success and individual performance

In a merit pay program, employees with a rating of '1' may receive what percentage increase in their compensation?

Why is variable pay not guaranteed?

Because companies may not meet certain objectives

What is the primary rationale behind merit pay programs rewarding employees for achieving certain levels of performance?

To reward employees who perform at higher levels

What is a key aspect that pay-for-performance plans must ensure to align employee performance with organizational objectives?

Aligning employee performance with organizational goals

Why is motivation listed as one of the purposes of variable pay?

'To establish a link between actions and organizational performance'

What is a key factor that distinguishes profit sharing from merit raises or lump sum bonuses?

Link to company profits

What is the key difference between base pay and variable pay in compensation?

Base pay is fixed, while variable pay varies with performance.

Why is variable pay considered important in helping employees understand the link between their actions and organizational goals?

It allows employees to see the connection between their actions and organizational objectives.

Why is it important for employees to have a clear line of sight in understanding pay-for-performance programs?

To align employee efforts with organizational goals effectively

What is an essential characteristic of variable pay standards?

Linking to strategic objectives

What is an important consideration for effective incentive plans based on the text?

Linking to all aspects of the job

How does variable pay assist in reinforcing desired behavior?

By acknowledging and rewarding the desired behavior and results

What makes deferred profit sharing plans tax-advantageous?

Lower taxation on retirement income withdrawals

How do bonuses differ from merit pay plans in terms of cost to companies?

Bonuses generally cost companies less in the long run.

In a straight piecework plan, how is employee compensation calculated?

By rewarding employees for the number of units produced.

What distinguishes a differential piecework plan from a straight piecework plan?

Differential plans change pay levels based on certain output thresholds.

What is the primary purpose of spot awards in organizations?

To encourage future performance with immediate rewards.

Why do companies use piecework incentive plans?

To tie employee compensation directly to unit production.

What is the main difference between merit pay increases and lump sum bonuses?

Merit pay increases are tied to past performance while lump sum bonuses are not.

Deferred profit sharing plans do not offer tax advantages to employees.

False

What challenge to performance management do some studies highlight regarding creative tasks?

Performance decreases with rewards

How do some studies suggest rewards impact employee performance on creative tasks?

Creative tasks are devalued by rewards

According to studies, what impact does assigning rewards to tasks have on intrinsic motivation?

Decreases intrinsic value

What do some organizations and academics believe about performance management in relation to pay for performance?

It may be ineffective or a farce

Why do some larger organizations decide to drop pay for performance despite believing in its value?

The process may not provide sufficient value to the organization

How should organizations handle the challenge of setting individual compensation plans for each employee?

By trying to satisfy most people while considering efficiency

What does the text imply about the importance of aligning compensation plans with performance?

It reinforces desired behaviors and values in organizations

In the context of pay-for-performance programs, what is the primary concern related to setting individual compensation plans for all employees?

Economic efficiency and equity issues

What is highlighted as a key principle that should guide pay decisions in organizations?

Rewarding high achievers and those who contribute significantly

How does the text suggest organizations navigate the challenge of not being able to satisfy every employee with individual compensation plans?

By aiming to satisfy most employees and prioritizing high achievers

What barrier can be overcome by acknowledging that managers are uncomfortable with assessing employees?

Lack of clear line of sight

What is highlighted as an important role for HR in assisting organizations regarding pay-for-performance programs?

Providing tools, training and calibration assistance

Why do managers often look to HR for help and assistance with compensation decisions?

Due to discomfort in making decisions

What can help organizations implement pay-for-performance programs effectively?

Offering tools, training, and assistance

What makes it challenging to allocate rewards in organizations with high performance ratings?

Too many employees performing above expectations

How does calibrated ratings make it easier to allocate rewards?

By identifying high performers more accurately

What is a significant challenge faced by organizations with high percentages of employees above expectations in terms of performance ratings?

Difficulty allocating awards

How do calibrated ratings make it easier to allocate rewards?

By aligning ratings with actual performance

What is a common outcome when employees do not perceive fairness in reward allocation?

Demotivation and decreased performance

Why do organizations run calibration meetings?

To bring performance evaluations back to reality

What is highlighted as one of the most crucial steps in making pay-for-performance successful?

Getting commitment from the executive team

Why is it crucial for pay-for-performance to be seen as an organization program?

To align with the organization's strategic goals

What is emphasized as a significant obstacle to successful pay-for-performance programs?

Unrealistic goals that employees doubt they can achieve

What aspect must executives embody for pay-for-performance programs to succeed as per the text?

'Talking the talk' and 'walking the walk'

Why are organizations generally dissatisfied with pay-for-performance programs?

Lack of clear line of sight among employees

What percentage of organizations rated their pay-for-performance plans as grade C or worse in a study by World at Work and Simpson Consulting?

58-59%

What is the primary reason for the dissatisfaction with pay-for-performance programs?

Misalignment with individual compensation plans

What percentage of respondents in a Mercer survey viewed their pay-for-performance system as highly effective?

Why do most organizations feel less than completely satisfied with pay-for-performance programs, according to the text?

Lack of transparency in rewards allocation

In the context of pay-for-performance programs, what is the importance of executive team alignment?

It ensures goals are challenging and consistent

What kind of goals are described as ideal in pay-for-performance programs?

Challenging but realistic

What consequence arises when employees perceive the leadership as indecisive about pay-for-performance?

Decreased trust

Why is it important for pay-for-performance programs to have clear alignment with corporate goals?

To maintain consistency and make sense in goal setting

What impact does wishy-washy executive support have on employee behavior in pay-for-performance programs?

Employees start cutting corners

What is one of the most common issues regarding pay-for-performance programs?

HR not willing to have difficult discussions with employees

Why does the manager's excuse of HR giving a distribution impact pay-for-performance negatively?

It shifts focus from organization-wide initiative to administrative task

How does the discomfort in assessing other adults impact pay-for-performance programs?

Managers are less likely to give constructive criticism

How does poor goal setting impact pay-for-performance programs?

It removes strategic objectivity from the program

Why might managers find it challenging to rate employees in pay-for-performance programs?

HR restricts the number of above-average ratings

What type of employees are most dissatisfied with a poor pay-for-performance program according to the text?

High academic achievers

Which group of employees are more likely to leave an organization over pay specifically according to the text?

High-performing employees

What is the impact of having a poor pay-for-performance program on high academic achievers according to the text?

They leave the organization

Why do high performers find ineffective pay-for-performance programs unsatisfactory according to the text?

Low pay differentiation

What is listed as the top reason why high-performing employees leave their organizations?

Better pay elsewhere

Study Notes

Understanding Pay-for-Performance Programs

Pay-for-performance programs differentiate employees based on their performance, rewarding those who perform well with more significant rewards than those who perform poorly.

Theories Influencing Pay-for-Performance

Expectancy Theory:
- Three components:
  - Belief that a goal can be accomplished
  - Belief that accomplishing the goal will result in a reward
  - Valuing the reward
Equity Theory:
- Individuals compare their contributions and rewards to those of others
- Desire for equality in the ratio of contributions to rewards

Designing Effective Pay-for-Performance Programs

Clear line of sight between performance and rewards
Understanding of expectancy and equity theories helps design better programs

Types of Pay-for-Performance Programs

Merit Pay Programs:
- Reward employees based on past performance levels
- Typical increases range from 0-5% based on performance ratings
Lump Sum Merit Bonuses:
- One-time payment based on performance
- Not rolled into salary
Variable Pay:
- Compensation contingent on performance or results achieved
- Goals or objectives must be met for payout
- Eligibility dependent on organizational strategy and employee characteristics
Profit Sharing Plans:
- Company profits shared with employees
- Can be distributed as cash or deferred
Piecework Incentive Plans:
- Employees receive a fixed rate per unit produced
- Straight piecework and differential piecework plans
Spot Awards:
- Instant rewards for exhibiting certain behaviors or achieving outcomes
- Managerial flexibility in awarding

Effective Variable Pay Plans

Must link to firm's strategic objectives
Clear standards of performance
Incentivize employees to excel in all aspects of their job
Standards must be attainable and easily understood
Provide meaningful incentives### Pay for Performance
Pay for performance is a motivational tool that aligns employees' interests with the organization's broader goals.
It has a significant impact on employee attitudes and behaviors.
Despite its importance, some organizations have dropped pay for performance systems, citing issues with the rating system and its impact on intrinsic motivation.
Research has shown that external rewards can decrease intrinsic motivation in certain situations.

Challenges to Performance Management

Some academics argue that performance management is a farce, and ratings systems are not effective.
Employees may feel that ratings are unfair or do not accurately reflect their performance.
Managers may not be comfortable with giving difficult feedback, and employees may not trust the rating system.

Importance of Good Goal Setting

Good goal setting is essential for pay for performance programs to be successful.
Goals should be challenging but achievable, and aligned with organizational objectives.
Poor goal setting can lead to demotivation and dissatisfaction among employees.

Equity Theory and Fairness

Equity theory proposes that employees evaluate the fairness of their situation by comparing their outcomes (pay, benefits, etc.) to their inputs (effort, experience, etc.) and comparing it to a comparison other.
If an employee feels under-rewarded or over-rewarded, they may experience inequity and dissatisfaction.

High Performers and Pay for Performance

High performers are more likely to be dissatisfied with pay for performance programs that are not well-designed.
Research shows that high performers are more likely to leave an organization for better pay elsewhere.
Organizations should focus on satisfying high performers, as they are critical to the organization's success.

Robust Performance Management Program

A robust performance management program is essential for the success of a pay for performance program.
The program should provide tools, training, and calibration to ensure that managers are comfortable with assessing employees and making difficult decisions.
Calibration meetings can help to ensure that ratings are fair and consistent across the organization.

Improvement Strategies

Get commitment from the executive team, especially the CEO, to support pay for performance.
Implement calibration meetings to ensure fairness and consistency in ratings.
Focus on good goal setting and provide training and tools to managers to help them assess employees effectively.### Pay for Performance
Pay-for-performance is a prevalent practice in organizations, with 90-95% of organizations claiming to have a pay-for-performance philosophy.
The concept of pay-for-performance is based on the idea of differentiation, where those who perform well receive significantly more rewards than those who don't.

Motivation and Expectancy Theory

Expectancy theory states that motivation is a function of:
- Expectancy: the link between behavior and outcome
- Instrumentality: the link between behavior and pay
- Valence: the value of the reward
Employees need to believe that their goals can be accomplished, and that they will receive a reward for achieving those goals.

Equity Theory

Equity theory is based on the idea that individuals constantly compare their contribution to the organization versus the rewards they receive.
Employees want to have equality in their contribution-reward ratio, and if they feel it's not equal, they may:
- Demand a pay increase
- Decrease their contribution

Designing a Better Pay-for-Performance Program

Key takeaways from expectancy and equity theories:
- Ensure a clear line of sight for employees to achieve their goals
- Employees must believe they will receive a reward for good performance
- Absolute and relative compensation levels are important
High-performing employees are more likely to be dissatisfied with poor pay-for-performance programs
High-performing employees are more likely to leave an organization due to poor pay

Common Issues with Pay-for-Performance Programs

Managers are not able or willing to have difficult discussions with employees about pay
HR is often seen as running the pay-for-performance process, rather than it being an organization-wide initiative
Poor goal setting, including unrealistic or unachievable goals
Lack of commitment from executive teams
Inadequate communication and feedback

Test your knowledge of pay-for-performance programs with this quiz focusing on the theory and practice discussed in the transcribed lecture by TurboScribe.ai. Learn about the concept of differentiation in compensation and its prevalence in organizations today.

Make Your Own Quizzes and Flashcards

Convert your notes into interactive study material.