Questions and Answers
What is the primary assumption of the doctrine of mens rea?
What is the problem with moral luck in punishment?
What is the main goal of punishment according to normative theories?
What is the significance of the requirement of mens rea in punishment?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the descriptive theory of punishment that is most accurate in Australia?
Signup and view all the answers
What is an exception to the requirement of mens rea?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the purpose of punishment according to the NSW Crimes Act?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the main issue with punishing people based on the outcome of their actions?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the main principle of the Retributive Theory of punishment?
Signup and view all the answers
According to Aristotle, what is the natural function of human beings?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the primary goal of punishment in the Retributive Theory?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the name of the principle that states that no one can benefit from their own criminal wrongdoing?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the name of the case that reflects the principle of 'an eye for an eye'?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the name of the act that codifies the principle of not benefiting from one's own criminal wrongdoing?
Signup and view all the answers
Why was Rene Rivkin punished for insider trading?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the name of the philosopher who is credited with the foundational theory of retributivism?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the name of the justice that deals with the distribution of goods?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the main goal of punishment in the Kieran Loveridge case?
Signup and view all the answers
What is a potential issue with retributive theory in terms of its objectivity?
Signup and view all the answers
According to strong retribution theorists, what should be the approach to punishment?
Signup and view all the answers
What is a critique of retributive theory in terms of its focus?
Signup and view all the answers
What is a limitation of retributive theory in terms of its assumption about the offender?
Signup and view all the answers
What type of retributive theory does Braithwaite argue for?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the main focus of Braithwaite's alternative theory of punishment?
Signup and view all the answers
What is a criticism of Braithwaite's alternative theory?
Signup and view all the answers
What is a key difference between retributive theory and Braithwaite's alternative theory?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the primary purpose of Confiscation of the Proceeds of Crime?
Signup and view all the answers
According to Immanuel Kant, why should the criminal suffer?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the main idea behind the Social Contract theory of punishment?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the principle of proportionality in punishment?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the primary goal of punishment according to the Retributive Theory?
Signup and view all the answers
According to Herbert Morris, what is the consequence of not obeying the social contract?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the concept of 'Just Desert' in the Retributive Theory?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the advantage of the Retributive Theory in punishing only the guilty?
Signup and view all the answers
What is a criticism of the Retributive Theory?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the benefit of the Retributive Theory to society?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the underlying assumption about human behavior that the doctrine of mens rea relies on?
Signup and view all the answers
Which of the following is a consequence of punishing individuals based on the outcome of their actions?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the primary goal of punishment according to normative theories?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the significance of the requirement of mens rea in reducing moral luck in punishment?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the primary purpose of Confiscation of the Proceeds of Crime?
Signup and view all the answers
Which philosopher's theory is based on the idea that punishment should be proportionate to the degree of wrongdoing?
Signup and view all the answers
Which of the following is a descriptive theory of punishment that is most accurate in Australia?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the main critique of the Retributive Theory in terms of its focus?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the primary issue with punishing individuals based on the outcome of their actions, rather than their intentions?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the main idea behind the concept of 'Just Desert' in the Retributive Theory?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the primary focus of the mixed theory of punishment in Australia?
Signup and view all the answers
According to the Social Contract theory, what is the consequence of not obeying the law?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the consequence of punishing individuals based on the outcome of their actions, rather than their intentions, according to Nagel and Williams?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the main advantage of the Retributive Theory in terms of punishing only the guilty?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the primary goal of punishment according to the NSW Crimes Act?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the primary assumption underlying the concept of moral luck?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the main limitation of the Retributive Theory in terms of its assumption about the offender?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the primary goal of punishment according to David Hicks' book?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the main critique of the Retributive Theory in terms of its objectivity?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the principle of proportionality in punishment?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the primary goal of retributive theory in correcting inequalities?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the principle behind the 'forfeiture rule'?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the primary focus of distributive justice?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the significance of the Kieran Loveridge case in retributive theory?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the key distinction between Aristotle's view of human beings and that of Immanuel Kant and John Stuart Mill?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the primary goal of corrective justice in retributive theory?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the significance of Rene Rivkin's case in retributive theory?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the primary focus of the lex talionis principle?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the primary goal of punishment in the retributive theory?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the significance of the forfeiture rule in retributive theory?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the fundamental flaw in the retributive theory of punishment?
Signup and view all the answers
According to Braithwaite, what is the primary purpose of punishment?
Signup and view all the answers
What is a limitation of the retributive theory in terms of its focus?
Signup and view all the answers
What is a critique of the retributive theory in terms of its objectivity?
Signup and view all the answers
What is a key difference between the retributive theory and Braithwaite's alternative theory?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the main criticism of Braithwaite's alternative theory?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the primary goal of punishment according to strong retribution theorists?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the assumption underlying the retributive theory of punishment?
Signup and view all the answers
What is a limitation of the retributive theory in terms of its assumption about the offender?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the primary focus of Braithwaite's alternative theory of punishment?
Signup and view all the answers
Match the following philosophers with their theories of punishment:
Signup and view all the answers
Match the following theories of punishment with their primary goals:
Signup and view all the answers
Match the following concepts with their descriptions:
Signup and view all the answers
Match the following legislation with their purposes:
Signup and view all the answers
Match the following theories with their primary critiques:
Signup and view all the answers
Match the following concepts with their relationships to moral luck:
Signup and view all the answers
Match the following philosophers with their critiques of punishment:
Signup and view all the answers
Match the following theories with their primary focuses:
Signup and view all the answers
Match the following concepts with their relationships to punishment:
Signup and view all the answers
Match the following theories with their primary purposes:
Signup and view all the answers
Match the following philosophers with their contributions to the concept of retributivism:
Signup and view all the answers
Match the following types of justice with their descriptions:
Signup and view all the answers
Match the following cases with their relevance to the concept of retributivism:
Signup and view all the answers
Match the following principles with their descriptions:
Signup and view all the answers
Match the following acts with their relevance to the concept of retributivism:
Signup and view all the answers
Match the following concepts with their descriptions:
Signup and view all the answers
Match the following philosophers with their views on human nature:
Signup and view all the answers
Match the following cases with their relevance to the concept of reciprocity:
Signup and view all the answers
Match the following principles with their relevance to the concept of retributivism:
Signup and view all the answers
Match the following concepts with their descriptions:
Signup and view all the answers
Match the following philosophers with their corresponding theories of punishment:
Signup and view all the answers
Match the following concepts with their corresponding explanations:
Signup and view all the answers
Match the following theories with their corresponding advantages:
Signup and view all the answers
Match the following theories with their corresponding criticisms:
Signup and view all the answers
Match the following concepts with their corresponding explanations:
Signup and view all the answers
Match the following theories with their corresponding underlying assumptions:
Signup and view all the answers
Match the following philosophers with their corresponding explanations of punishment:
Signup and view all the answers
Match the following theories with their corresponding primary goals of punishment:
Signup and view all the answers
Match the following concepts with their corresponding benefits to society:
Signup and view all the answers
Match the following theories with their corresponding primary focuses:
Signup and view all the answers
Match the following criticisms of the Retributive Theory with their descriptions:
Signup and view all the answers
Match the following theories of punishment with their primary focuses:
Signup and view all the answers
Match the following philosophers or theorists with their contributions:
Signup and view all the answers
Match the following concepts in punishment with their descriptions:
Signup and view all the answers
Match the following limitations of the Retributive Theory with their explanations:
Signup and view all the answers
Match the following criticisms of Braithwaite's alternative theory with their explanations:
Signup and view all the answers
Match the following theories or concepts with their underlying assumptions:
Signup and view all the answers
Match the following criticisms of retribution with their explanations:
Signup and view all the answers
Match the following philosophers or theorists with their views on punishment:
Signup and view all the answers
Match the following concepts in punishment with their implications:
Signup and view all the answers
Study Notes
The Problem of Moral Luck and Free Will
- In Anglo-American Jurisprudence, both mens rea and actus reus are required for punishment, except for strict liability offenses.
- The doctrine of mens rea assumes free will, where the offender has made a choice and could have chosen otherwise.
- The requirement of mens rea reduces moral luck in punishment, as it only punishes individuals for crimes they have freely chosen to commit.
Moral Luck in Punishment
- Despite the requirement of mens rea, moral luck still arises in punishment, as the outcome of the offender's actions affects their punishment.
- Different punishments are given for the same act, depending on the consequences, even if the different consequences were the result of luck.
- Example: The NSW Crimes Act penalizes causing death or serious injury while driving under the influence with up to 10 years in prison, while traffic legislation offers a lesser penalty for dangerous driving without causing harm.
Theories of Punishment's Purpose (Justifications)
- Normative theories focus on what ought to be the purpose of punishment.
- Descriptive theories, such as the mixed theory, are most accurate in describing the purpose of punishment in Australia, which includes multiple purposes.
Retributive Theory
- Gained popularity in criminological philosophy over the past 30 years, with Herbert Morris' article: Persons and Punishment.
- Principle: Criminals should lose what they gained, and everyone should see this happen.
- Aristotle's foundational theory of retributivism emphasizes the purpose of reasoning and the capacity for humans to reason.
- Aristotle divided justice into:
- Distributive Justice: deals with the distribution of goods.
- Corrective Justice: rectifies or remedies inequalities that arise in dealings between individuals, including criminal punishment.
- In retribution theory, punishment is a form of corrective justice, where a wrong is corrected in a civilized way to restore the distributive balance of advantages between the criminal and the law-abiding.
Types of Retribution
- Strict: Lex talionis - "an eye for an eye, a tooth for a tooth", focusing on the material consequences of an act.
- Example: A life for a life in the context of capital punishment.
- Proportional: Deprives the criminal of freedom of choice proportional to the degree to which the criminal exercised their freedom in the unlawful act.
- Example: Imprisonment is proportional to the degree to which the criminal exercised their freedom in the unlawful act.
Retributive Theory Cases
- Rene Rivkin's trading example: Punished not because of the quantum gained, but because the offense is about gaining an unmerited advantage over law-abiding individuals.
- Kieran Loveridge case: Highlights that justice must not only take away the criminal's gains but also should be seen to do so, to ensure public confidence in the legal system.
Criticisms of Retributive Theory
- While the principle of proportionality puts the scales into balance, the practical application can be challenging.
- The absence of an objective for putting scales back into balance may lead to historical or cultural biases and not an objective moral desert.
- Strong retribution theorists do not allow for leniency or discount in the amount of punishment deserved by the offender.
- Does not align with rehabilitative aims as punishment may make them a hardened criminal instead of a better person.
- Assumes that the offender always gains benefit from their conduct, without considering people for whom the society was not balanced before the crime happened.
- Breach of social contract approach: The merit of punishment is the offender's breach of social contract and not material gain.
The Problem of Moral Luck and Free Will
- In Anglo-American Jurisprudence, both mens rea and actus reus are required for punishment, with exceptions for strict liability offenses.
- The doctrine of mens rea assumes free will, where engaging in intentional conduct is a choice, and the process of choice involves a mental act.
- The requirement of mens rea reduces moral luck in punishment by only punishing people for crimes they have freely chosen to commit.
The Problem of Moral Luck in Punishment
- Moral luck arises in punishment because the outcome of an offender's actions affects their punishment.
- According to Nagel and Williams, an element of luck cannot be entirely eliminated in dishing out punishment.
- Example: Different punishments for the same act depending on consequences, even if the different consequences were the result of luck.
Theories of Punishment's Purpose (Justifications)
- Normative theories (what ought to be the purpose of punishment) are concerned with finding the best way to stop offenses in the future and acknowledging something wrong has occurred.
- There are different types of punishment, and many legal philosophers have considered this issue.
Retributive Theory
- Retributive theory has gained renewed popularity in criminological philosophy over the past 30 years.
- Principle: Criminals should lose what they gained, and everyone should see this happen.
- Aristotle (384-322 BC) credited with the foundational theory of retributivism, emphasizing teleology or purpose.
- Aristotle argued that reasoning well (virtue) enhances survival prospects because virtuous behavior avoids triggering revenge or violent repercussions.
- Aristotle divided justice into distributive justice (dealing with the distribution of goods) and corrective justice (rectifying or remedying inequalities).
Retributive Theory (continued)
- In retribution theory, punishment is a form of corrective justice where a wrong is corrected in a civilized way to restore the distributive balance of advantages between the criminal and the law-abiding.
- Example: Rene Rivkin's trading example, where punishment is not because of the quantum gained but because the offense is about gaining an unmerited advantage over law-abiding individuals.
- Related case: Kieran Loveridge, highlighting that justice must not only take away the criminal's gains but also should be seen to do so, to ensure public confidence in the legal system.
- In retributive theory, punishment is seen as a form of reciprocity, which can be strict (lex talionis) or proportional (depriving the criminal of freedom of choice proportional to the degree to which the criminal exercised their freedom in the unlawful act).
Retributive Theory (continued)
- The forfeiture rule aligns with the principle that no one can benefit from their own criminal wrongdoing, preventing criminals from gaining financially from their crimes.
- Example: Cleaver v Mutual Reserve Fund Life Association (QB) and David Hicks' case, highlighting the principle of restoring the balance of benefits and burdens in a society.
- Immanuel Kant (1724-1804) argued that the criminal must suffer as the victim suffered to ensure that the scales of equality and justice between the two are re-established.
- According to some philosophers, the merit of punishment is the offender's breach of social contract, not material gain.
Retributive Theory (continued)
- Finnis argued that punishment restores the balance by depriving the offender of the liberty they took in action to which they were not entitled.
- Sadowski (Just Desert) argued that the merit of punishment is not the benefit gained by the criminal in breaking the law but their refusal to obey the law which everyone else is obligated to obey.
- Just Desert theory is based on moral desert, where the concept of desert is ancient and emphasizes that if you do something wrong, then as a matter of justice, you deserve the consequences of that.
- Herbert Morris (1928) argued that the criminal act is an attempt to evade the burden of obedience required by the social contract, and punishment restores the balance by depriving the offender of the unmerited advantage.
Advantages of Retributive Theory
- Restoration of balance between the law-abiding and the offender.
- Explains why only the guilty are punished and not the innocent.
- Endorses principle of proportionality.
- Society expresses solidarity with the victim by punishing the offender.
Criticisms of Retributive Theory
- The principle of proportionality can be challenging to apply in practice.
- Value judgments can lead to historical or cultural biases.
- Strong retribution theorists do not allow for leniency or discount in the amount of punishment deserved.
- The assumption that the offender always gains benefit from their conduct does not consider people for whom the society was not balanced before the crime happened.
- The theory assumes that the past cannot be changed, so punishment does not give any future benefit.
- The theory does not align with rehabilitative aims, as punishment may make the offender a hardened criminal instead of a better person.
The Problem of Moral Luck and Free Will
- In Anglo-American Jurisprudence, both mens rea and actus reus are required for punishment, with exceptions for strict liability offenses.
- The doctrine of mens rea assumes free will, where engaging in intentional conduct is a choice, and the process of choice involves a mental act.
- The requirement of mens rea reduces moral luck in punishment by only punishing people for crimes they have freely chosen to commit.
The Problem of Moral Luck in Punishment
- Moral luck arises in punishment because the outcome of an offender's actions affects their punishment.
- According to Nagel and Williams, an element of luck cannot be entirely eliminated in dishing out punishment.
- Example: Different punishments for the same act depending on consequences, even if the different consequences were the result of luck.
Theories of Punishment's Purpose (Justifications)
- Normative theories (what ought to be the purpose of punishment) are concerned with finding the best way to stop offenses in the future and acknowledging something wrong has occurred.
- There are different types of punishment, and many legal philosophers have considered this issue.
Retributive Theory
- Retributive theory has gained renewed popularity in criminological philosophy over the past 30 years.
- Principle: Criminals should lose what they gained, and everyone should see this happen.
- Aristotle (384-322 BC) credited with the foundational theory of retributivism, emphasizing teleology or purpose.
- Aristotle argued that reasoning well (virtue) enhances survival prospects because virtuous behavior avoids triggering revenge or violent repercussions.
- Aristotle divided justice into distributive justice (dealing with the distribution of goods) and corrective justice (rectifying or remedying inequalities).
Retributive Theory (continued)
- In retribution theory, punishment is a form of corrective justice where a wrong is corrected in a civilized way to restore the distributive balance of advantages between the criminal and the law-abiding.
- Example: Rene Rivkin's trading example, where punishment is not because of the quantum gained but because the offense is about gaining an unmerited advantage over law-abiding individuals.
- Related case: Kieran Loveridge, highlighting that justice must not only take away the criminal's gains but also should be seen to do so, to ensure public confidence in the legal system.
- In retributive theory, punishment is seen as a form of reciprocity, which can be strict (lex talionis) or proportional (depriving the criminal of freedom of choice proportional to the degree to which the criminal exercised their freedom in the unlawful act).
Retributive Theory (continued)
- The forfeiture rule aligns with the principle that no one can benefit from their own criminal wrongdoing, preventing criminals from gaining financially from their crimes.
- Example: Cleaver v Mutual Reserve Fund Life Association (QB) and David Hicks' case, highlighting the principle of restoring the balance of benefits and burdens in a society.
- Immanuel Kant (1724-1804) argued that the criminal must suffer as the victim suffered to ensure that the scales of equality and justice between the two are re-established.
- According to some philosophers, the merit of punishment is the offender's breach of social contract, not material gain.
Retributive Theory (continued)
- Finnis argued that punishment restores the balance by depriving the offender of the liberty they took in action to which they were not entitled.
- Sadowski (Just Desert) argued that the merit of punishment is not the benefit gained by the criminal in breaking the law but their refusal to obey the law which everyone else is obligated to obey.
- Just Desert theory is based on moral desert, where the concept of desert is ancient and emphasizes that if you do something wrong, then as a matter of justice, you deserve the consequences of that.
- Herbert Morris (1928) argued that the criminal act is an attempt to evade the burden of obedience required by the social contract, and punishment restores the balance by depriving the offender of the unmerited advantage.
Advantages of Retributive Theory
- Restoration of balance between the law-abiding and the offender.
- Explains why only the guilty are punished and not the innocent.
- Endorses principle of proportionality.
- Society expresses solidarity with the victim by punishing the offender.
Criticisms of Retributive Theory
- The principle of proportionality can be challenging to apply in practice.
- Value judgments can lead to historical or cultural biases.
- Strong retribution theorists do not allow for leniency or discount in the amount of punishment deserved.
- The assumption that the offender always gains benefit from their conduct does not consider people for whom the society was not balanced before the crime happened.
- The theory assumes that the past cannot be changed, so punishment does not give any future benefit.
- The theory does not align with rehabilitative aims, as punishment may make the offender a hardened criminal instead of a better person.
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.
Description
This quiz explores the concept of moral luck and its relationship with free will in the context of criminal law, particularly in Anglo-American Jurisprudence. It delves into the requirement of mens rea and its exceptions.