Podcast
Questions and Answers
According to Martin Shaw, war is defined as:
According to Martin Shaw, war is defined as:
- A contention by force
- A continuation of politics by other means
- An act of force by an organized social power to compel an enemy to submit (correct)
- A state of affairs that may exist even without ongoing operations
What did Thomas Hobbes suggest about war without fighting?
What did Thomas Hobbes suggest about war without fighting?
- It is a state of affairs that may exist even without ongoing operations
- It lacks consideration of the motives, consequences, and political nature of war
- It suggests a psychological or political state of preparedness for war (correct)
- It is a continuation of politics by other means
According to Carl von Clausewitz, war is the continuation of politics by other means, but what is a limitation of this definition?
According to Carl von Clausewitz, war is the continuation of politics by other means, but what is a limitation of this definition?
- It includes aspects like political objectives, ethical considerations, and long-term impacts
- It overlooks non-state conflicts and prioritizes combat (correct)
- It suggests a psychological or political state of preparedness for war
- It emphasizes winning through strategy, intelligence, and minimal violence
What is the focus of Sun Tzu's definition of war?
What is the focus of Sun Tzu's definition of war?
According to Cicero, what is war?
According to Cicero, what is war?
What does the fuller definition of war according to the text suggest?
What does the fuller definition of war according to the text suggest?
What does the sociological approaches to war emphasize the need to account for?
What does the sociological approaches to war emphasize the need to account for?
According to sociological perspectives on war, what are the categories of conflict under international law?
According to sociological perspectives on war, what are the categories of conflict under international law?
Who are the sociologists who present perspectives on war in the text?
Who are the sociologists who present perspectives on war in the text?
What factors contribute to the degeneration of war and the targeting of civilians?
What factors contribute to the degeneration of war and the targeting of civilians?
What are some millennial challenges in the military mentioned in the text?
What are some millennial challenges in the military mentioned in the text?
How does international law define a civilian?
How does international law define a civilian?
What factors influence a soldier's decision to kill?
What factors influence a soldier's decision to kill?
What strategies can civilians employ for survival in war zones?
What strategies can civilians employ for survival in war zones?
In the context of combat, what does the text discuss regarding the impact of physical distance on the decision to kill?
In the context of combat, what does the text discuss regarding the impact of physical distance on the decision to kill?
What issues arise from the Geneva Conventions' definition of civilians in war zones?
What issues arise from the Geneva Conventions' definition of civilians in war zones?
What is discussed in the text regarding the human being as a killer?
What is discussed in the text regarding the human being as a killer?
What are the different ideologies that justify the targeting of civilians in war?
What are the different ideologies that justify the targeting of civilians in war?
What are some group dynamics influencing soldier behavior?
What are some group dynamics influencing soldier behavior?
How is the concept of civilian immunity gendered in the context of war?
How is the concept of civilian immunity gendered in the context of war?
How have technological developments impacted the nature of warfare concerning civilian populations?
How have technological developments impacted the nature of warfare concerning civilian populations?
What role does targeting women play in the broader strategy of warfare?
What role does targeting women play in the broader strategy of warfare?
What ambiguities are involved in defining a civilian in the context of war?
What ambiguities are involved in defining a civilian in the context of war?
In what ways does redefining the enemy impact both combatants and civilians?
In what ways does redefining the enemy impact both combatants and civilians?
What does the text differentiate between in terms of military hierarchy?
What does the text differentiate between in terms of military hierarchy?
What is emphasized by functional discipline in the military?
What is emphasized by functional discipline in the military?
What are the factors that determine how one fits into military culture and lifestyle, as per the text?
What are the factors that determine how one fits into military culture and lifestyle, as per the text?
What does the text discuss in relation to the association of masculinity with the military?
What does the text discuss in relation to the association of masculinity with the military?
How has the notion of the battlefield expanded post-WWI, according to the text?
How has the notion of the battlefield expanded post-WWI, according to the text?
What has expanded the battlefield to include civilian 'home fronts' and eventually the entire planet, as per the text?
What has expanded the battlefield to include civilian 'home fronts' and eventually the entire planet, as per the text?
What characterizes most modern conflicts, as discussed in the text?
What characterizes most modern conflicts, as discussed in the text?
Flashcards are hidden until you start studying
Study Notes
Military Organization and Modern Warfare
- The document discusses the nature of hierarchy in the military, distinguishing between machine hierarchy and professional bureaucracy.
- It differentiates between formal discipline, focusing on outward trappings like salutes and uniforms, and functional discipline, which emphasizes self-steering through informal group norms.
- The text explores factors that determine how one fits into military culture and lifestyle, including natural identification, socialization, selective identification, and calculative identification.
- It delves into the reasons for associating masculinity with the military, discussing biological explanations and gendered social dynamics, and explores key values of the warrior ethos and the sociological explanation for the link between masculinity and military life.
- Explores how military culture views civilian life during peacetime and wartime, discussing the identification of the civilian world as feminine and the implications of excluding women from the military.
- Historically, battlefields were clear physical spaces where armies met to achieve political goals, but post-WWI, there has been an increased focus on civilian populations alongside enemy armies, expanding the notion of the battlefield.
- The advent of bomber aircraft and nuclear weapons expanded the battlefield to include civilian "home fronts" and eventually the entire planet, and guerilla warfare and terrorism further blurred the lines between military and civilian spaces.
- War has become more personal, with tactics like torture, medical experimentation, and psychological warfare targeting individual bodies and minds. With increasing levels of warfare, violence infiltrates every aspect of social space.
- Most modern conflicts are internal, occurring among rival groups within a country, leading to more limited and less extensive battlespaces. Former rival states may become partners, and warfare often targets ethnic or religious groups to homogenize populations through violence.
- In the West, media plays a significant role in constructing the reality of war and shaping attitudes toward it. The media utilizes pre-existing prejudices, stereotypes, and binary worldviews to portray the enemy.
- Wars must be perceived as addressing threats to Western interests and must present limited risks to Western societies. Involvement in wars is carefully controlled, emphasizing quick resolution, minimal Western casualties, reliance on airpower, and efficient enemy targeting.
- American media is saturated with violence, which may desensitize the public to violent images and contribute to the perception that complex problems can be solved simply.
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.