Podcast
Questions and Answers
According to Cleanth Brooks, what is the significance of embracing metaphor in modern poetic technique?
According to Cleanth Brooks, what is the significance of embracing metaphor in modern poetic technique?
- It encourages poets to prioritize abstract themes over concrete imagery.
- It allows poets to directly express universal truths without the need for specific details.
- It provides poets with a means to create purely decorative and ornamental verse.
- It enables poets to access the universal through the particular, grounding meaning in concrete details. (correct)
In Cleanth Brooks' view, how do the elements of a poem relate to one another?
In Cleanth Brooks' view, how do the elements of a poem relate to one another?
- As independent statements that contribute to a philosophical argument.
- As abstract concepts that are embellished with concrete details for aesthetic effect.
- As isolated, beautiful images that can be arranged to create artificial meaning.
- As parts of an organic whole, similar to the way blossoms are related to the other parts of a growing plant. (correct)
What does Brooks suggest about the relationship between context and poetic verses?
What does Brooks suggest about the relationship between context and poetic verses?
- Context only serves to obscure the true meaning of poetic verses.
- Context is irrelevant to the interpretation of poetic verses.
- Memorable verses possess intrinsic poetic quality regardless of their surrounding context.
- Memorable verses derive their poetic quality from their relationship to a particular context. (correct)
According to Brooks, what is the function of irony in poetry?
According to Brooks, what is the function of irony in poetry?
Brooks references Shakespeare's song 'Who is Silvia?' to demonstrate what concept?
Brooks references Shakespeare's song 'Who is Silvia?' to demonstrate what concept?
What does Brooks argue is the danger of thinking of Wordsworth's poems as 'simple and spontaneous'?
What does Brooks argue is the danger of thinking of Wordsworth's poems as 'simple and spontaneous'?
According to Brooks, what is the task of a modern poet in relation to language?
According to Brooks, what is the task of a modern poet in relation to language?
What is the function of the Pontius Pilate metaphor in Randall Jarrell's 'Eighth Air Force,' according to Brooks?
What is the function of the Pontius Pilate metaphor in Randall Jarrell's 'Eighth Air Force,' according to Brooks?
What does Brooks suggest about the role of personal beliefs in interpreting poetry?
What does Brooks suggest about the role of personal beliefs in interpreting poetry?
According to Cleanth Brooks, what separates a genuine poem from a mere abstraction?
According to Cleanth Brooks, what separates a genuine poem from a mere abstraction?
Flashcards
Modern Poetic Technique
Modern Poetic Technique
Modern poetic technique emphasizes metaphor and the commitment to it. Poets access the universal through the particular.
Meaning in Poetry
Meaning in Poetry
Poetry's meaning emerges from specific details, reversing conventional language habits where the tail wags the dog, powering the poem.
Commitment to Metaphor
Commitment to Metaphor
Metaphor usage indirectly implies commitment, requiring organic relationships between particular images and statements.
Importance of Context
Importance of Context
Signup and view all the flashcards
Irony
Irony
Signup and view all the flashcards
Invulnerability to Irony
Invulnerability to Irony
Signup and view all the flashcards
Modern Poetic Irony
Modern Poetic Irony
Signup and view all the flashcards
Theme in Poetry
Theme in Poetry
Signup and view all the flashcards
Study Notes
- Modern poetic technique embodies the rediscovery of metaphor and a full commitment to it.
- Poets access the universal by navigating particulars.
- Rather than embellishing abstract themes with details, poets realize and abide by the details to reach general meanings.
- In poetry, meaning emerges from particulars, reversing conventional language habits.
Metaphor and Indirection
- Commitment to metaphor implies indirection regarding the general theme.
- It also implies organic relationships between images and statements.
- Poems are not collections of beautiful images but have organically related elements.
- Poem elements resemble parts of a growing plant, not juxtaposed blossoms.
- Poetic beauty needs the stalk, leaf, and roots.
Poems as Little Dramas
- Poems resemble little dramas where the total effect results from all elements, avoiding superfluous parts and waste motion.
- The importance of context is highlighted to see parts relating to each other organically and to the total theme indirectly.
Importance of Context
- Memorable verses derive poetic quality from their relation to the context.
- Context modifies even the meaning of specific items.
- Meaning exists in a specific situation delivered by dramatic characters.
- Context loads specific word, image, or statement with significance, turning these into symbols or dramatic utterances.
- "Ironical" statements are obvious warps of a statement by context.
Irony and Rhetoric
- In "this is a fine state of affairs" in defined contexts can mean the opposite as a basic case of irony.
- Complete meaning reversals are influenced by context and potentially tone.
- Tone of irony can be achieved by contextual arrangement with Gray's Elegy as an example.
- Posed questions are rhetorical
- The answer lies within the nature of breath (fleeting) and death (dull and cold).
- There are different ironical forms.
- These include sardonic, tragic, self-irony, playful, arch, mocking, and gentle.
Qualification of Context
- Poems bear contextual pressure which causes meaning to be revised.
- Statements, even ones appearing to be philosophical, are treated as dialogue within a drama.
- Relevance, rhetoric, and meaning cannot exist without the context which they were written in.
- Poems lack abstract statements.
Irony in Modern Criticism
- "Irony" is used because it is one of few terms which represents a broad range of poetic qualities.
- When trying to prove the statement "which seems to lie before us like a land of dreams hath really neither joy nor love nor light," metaphysics are often raised which distract and prevent justification.
- Lines within a poem should be defended within the context of the piece.
- Poem truth can assessed given T.S. Eliot's test, asking the reader if the statement is mature and coherent.
- Assessing as a drama brings up questions like, "Does the speaker oversimplify?" or, "Are they objective?"
- The question is, "Is the statement ironical, or just callow, glib and sentimental?"
Poetry of Synthesis
- A poem that passes Eliot's test is I.A. Richards' "poetry of synthesis."
- This poetry does not leave out parts hostile to its style; it is invulnerable to irony and discordant because it can fuse both elements.
- Irony is more than acknowledgement of a context's restrictions.
- Invulnerability to irony is contextual stability, where internal restrictions balance with each other.
- Stable contexts are like arches, where the forces dragging stones strengthen support via counterthrust.
Irony in Simple Lyrics
- Contextual restrictions are evident in poems, such as one of Shakespeare's songs.
- The song seems to elevate its subject, Sylvia, on a celestial and moral level.
Shakespeare's "Who is Silvia"
- The bestowed grace that is mentioned in the song is theologically odd because it is so that she might be admired.
- Christian charity isn't implied as the motive for love, instead, the pagan god Cupid is brought in.
- Given that Cupid lives in her eyes, "For beauty lives with kindness" takes on another dimension, because the god lives with what he has already claimed for his own.
- The use of pagan myth and Christian concepts isn't a mishap, rather, its wittily composed.
- While the author isn't interested in the issue of self-awareness, with an implication of playful irony, the tune is appealing, with aspects fitting to a lyric from a mortal.
- The overall impression is light and complex.
Wordsworth’s Lucy Poems
- The violet and star define a situation where, to the world, Lucy is modest and shy, but in their eye, she is the brightest star, not as arrogant as the sun.
- The two provide balance in the situation.
Wordsworth contrasts vs Donne
- Contrasts often exploited by John Donne's poems is highlighted here in that lovers turn into each other's worlds, despite not being valued by a grander world.
- Rather than having one standard, Wordsworth's approach offers straight alignment vs his ironic style.
Wordsworth: "A Slumber Did My Spirit Seal"
- The speaker's carelessness for mortality is considered spiritual lethargy.
- The absence of "human fears" relates to fears commonly felt by people.
- The stanza warps in this direction.
Irony in the Second Stanza
- The potential for irony becomes apparent during the second stanza.
- If the resting has secured the spirit, then it has secured her soul: "No movement has she now, no power; / She neither hears nor sees."
- There is implication that uncharacteristic slumber stirred him.
- There are endless considerations such as to what Donne would've formed of such concept.
- The creator suggests the sensation via the lover's serious jolt at the lack of motion.
Suggesting her inertness
- Instead of mentioning sleep, the response is suggested through fierce motion a similar motion which stones engage because they're twirled daily.
- The girl falls back into disarray, amongst items chained like a tree in one point, or completely unfeeling, for example, jewels and rocks.
- The point in the beginning stanza emphasizes the concept that the girl appeared immune to standard limits completely.
- Suggesting empty expression or motion which will be constant conveys significance.
- The point of the world (her world) to be never-ending seems to the writer to describe this poem.
- It can show almost every angle of significance presented over again in older lines.
Two Contrasts
- Poet doesn't explicitly illustrate with the resting of the man versus resting of the wife.
- With the second, a contrast of one senses has come full circle where the girl gets separated against "touch of common age."
- She "couldn't feel touch of common age" since she comes across as divine/immortal.
- In the next verse, in the grave, she doesn't "feel touch of common age since they feel nothing.
Wordsworth versus others
- Ironic is too bold/author insists.
- Furthermore, the verses appear amazing and in order, there could not have been an superior alternative with Donne's instead of William's approach.
- They are basically of comparable dynamic since the association comes from William rather, Donne.
- Regarding relation, the part to area is healthy (meaning each section can and adjusts to).
Simplicity and Spontaneity
- Possible to mutilate.
- When all- is this essential and unplanned- is being described?
- Throughout 1800 since they approach a word from 1900- easy/natural mutually special? Exactly what could after affect (reader, easy and/or spontaneous.
Poem writing theories
- Verses of higher complexity have come along such.
- Easy, organic poems are being considered by what, it offers on author an easy/unforced word with intricate, honest verse.
- Writers shouldn't be too literal since there are concepts to be addressed.
Modern poetry, irony, and context
- Pressure reveals/exists naturally/easily- especially in simple, meaningful lines.
- Much in verses these days apply sharp point and possibly own tactic of style.
Reasons for that include
- Breakdown between signs the broad disinterest, particularly lack for the incredibly drained, weak terms even for promos.
- Current generation in the role is attempting to improve weak/tired terms so it will hold connotations yet again powerful and direct.
- This has happened often for many years; but it is happening now for author who is now.
- There are a number of analysts that give- point to this bloodless mind even those flaws of expected viewers.
- For writers aren't reaching naive original mind yet the mind of society with profitable art.
- All things similar, writer is doing everything easy way to get to direct, energetic verse.
Randall Jarrett "Eighth air force" is a triumph in this area
- There is the flower in water in what a puppy is drinking there appears to be a sergant outside.
- The intoxicated sergant, whistling the melody similar to the men, this reveals a regard to what.
The tone now comes over, just like the verse!
- There's a puppy from what they will play.
- Nevertheless their's to allow for it, from each way and this to affirm for what timber to allow it is to the wolf cave.
Explicit meaning
- From what they three, at least on will and numbers off people whom have been killed.
- What could have been said (murder) happens the end!
The situation in the world
- If leader, which is revealed to being from the beginning is smiling from what we discover later there's hurting ending as the end approaches.
- Honest heart of one is on edge. Man = rough animal, is the last to save.
- Pilate is a device utilized for emphasis.
- Since man for who is now (who said O) is what under what is now.
Reinforcement within the script
- Torture in present is of top hopes and failure of reject as void verse.
- With is an higher amount!
- To get to what is correct and one needs to accept; this comes easily by giving/showing how to and honesty.
Misconceptions
- Honest with themes and these verses hasn't been accepted since how they lean. Within most here it's too direct/simple.
- At all there are circumstances can do and total and get a grip on with verse comes near more direct and now, and can come naturally if one does right.
- This will hold this place that comes from to one general; The proper word will define more clear what the area describes which takes an area of what makes a feeling become- part where what will grow,
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.