Podcast
Questions and Answers
What are two benefits of living in communities?
What are two benefits of living in communities?
More security against external dangers and opportunities for fulfilling personal relationships.
According to the ethical point of view, what should individuals consider?
According to the ethical point of view, what should individuals consider?
Individuals should consider both their own core values and respect the core values of others.
Define morality in the context of society.
Define morality in the context of society.
Morality is a society’s rules of conduct regarding what people ought or ought not to do.
Why is ethical thinking important in analyzing issues?
Why is ethical thinking important in analyzing issues?
Signup and view all the answers
What dilemma does Alexis face in her scenario?
What dilemma does Alexis face in her scenario?
Signup and view all the answers
Did Alexis's use of library resources unfairly disadvantage any peers?
Did Alexis's use of library resources unfairly disadvantage any peers?
Signup and view all the answers
What were the consequences for innocent computer users in the East Asian country due to the antispam organization's actions?
What were the consequences for innocent computer users in the East Asian country due to the antispam organization's actions?
Signup and view all the answers
Did the East Dakota State Police violate anyone’s rights by using video cameras for speed detection?
Did the East Dakota State Police violate anyone’s rights by using video cameras for speed detection?
Signup and view all the answers
What would be some ethical obligations related to releasing a buggy software product?
What would be some ethical obligations related to releasing a buggy software product?
Signup and view all the answers
What ethical issue might arise from rushing a mobile app to market despite existing bugs?
What ethical issue might arise from rushing a mobile app to market despite existing bugs?
Signup and view all the answers
What does subjective relativism imply about moral decisions?
What does subjective relativism imply about moral decisions?
Signup and view all the answers
How does cultural relativism define right and wrong?
How does cultural relativism define right and wrong?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the main ethical stance of Divine Command Theory?
What is the main ethical stance of Divine Command Theory?
Signup and view all the answers
What is ethical egoism and its core principle?
What is ethical egoism and its core principle?
Signup and view all the answers
According to Kantianism, what is the 'categorical imperative'?
According to Kantianism, what is the 'categorical imperative'?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the second formulation of the Categorical Imperative according to Kant?
What is the second formulation of the Categorical Imperative according to Kant?
Signup and view all the answers
How does Kant's ethical theory evaluate Carla's decision to submit a purchased report?
How does Kant's ethical theory evaluate Carla's decision to submit a purchased report?
Signup and view all the answers
What differentiates a perfect duty from an imperfect duty in Kantian ethics?
What differentiates a perfect duty from an imperfect duty in Kantian ethics?
Signup and view all the answers
According to utilitarianism, under what condition is an action considered good?
According to utilitarianism, under what condition is an action considered good?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the main evaluation criterion for Rule Utilitarianism?
What is the main evaluation criterion for Rule Utilitarianism?
Signup and view all the answers
How did Alexis's use of library resources contribute to her academic success?
How did Alexis's use of library resources contribute to her academic success?
Signup and view all the answers
What were the unintended consequences of the antispam organization's actions?
What were the unintended consequences of the antispam organization's actions?
Signup and view all the answers
What ethical considerations might the East Dakota State Police have faced when complying with the FBI's request?
What ethical considerations might the East Dakota State Police have faced when complying with the FBI's request?
Signup and view all the answers
In what ways could the start-up engineer address the risks associated with releasing a buggy app before it is fully tested?
In what ways could the start-up engineer address the risks associated with releasing a buggy app before it is fully tested?
Signup and view all the answers
How does subjective relativism challenge the notion of universal ethical standards?
How does subjective relativism challenge the notion of universal ethical standards?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the primary difference between subjective relativism and tolerance?
What is the primary difference between subjective relativism and tolerance?
Signup and view all the answers
What are two major criticisms of cultural relativism?
What are two major criticisms of cultural relativism?
Signup and view all the answers
Why is Divine Command Theory considered impractical in multicultural societies?
Why is Divine Command Theory considered impractical in multicultural societies?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the primary assertion of ethical egoism regarding moral actions?
What is the primary assertion of ethical egoism regarding moral actions?
Signup and view all the answers
How does Kant's Categorical Imperative relate to making promises?
How does Kant's Categorical Imperative relate to making promises?
Signup and view all the answers
What are the core values that most people share according to the ethical point of view?
What are the core values that most people share according to the ethical point of view?
Signup and view all the answers
How do communities minimize costs for their members?
How do communities minimize costs for their members?
Signup and view all the answers
What role does morality play in society?
What role does morality play in society?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the significance of ethical thinking in understanding complex situations?
What is the significance of ethical thinking in understanding complex situations?
Signup and view all the answers
In ethical terms, why might Alexis’s actions in the library be considered problematical?
In ethical terms, why might Alexis’s actions in the library be considered problematical?
Signup and view all the answers
Explain how Carla's decision to submit a purchased report violated the second formulation of the Categorical Imperative.
Explain how Carla's decision to submit a purchased report violated the second formulation of the Categorical Imperative.
Signup and view all the answers
What is the difference between perfect duties and imperfect duties within Kantian ethics?
What is the difference between perfect duties and imperfect duties within Kantian ethics?
Signup and view all the answers
How does Act Utilitarianism determine whether an action is right or wrong?
How does Act Utilitarianism determine whether an action is right or wrong?
Signup and view all the answers
What moral guideline can be derived from the evaluation of the Highway Routing Scenario?
What moral guideline can be derived from the evaluation of the Highway Routing Scenario?
Signup and view all the answers
Why is the proposal to release an anti-worm considered wrong according to Rule Utilitarianism?
Why is the proposal to release an anti-worm considered wrong according to Rule Utilitarianism?
Signup and view all the answers
What underlying principle supports the establishment of communities despite their inherent costs?
What underlying principle supports the establishment of communities despite their inherent costs?
Signup and view all the answers
In the ethical context, how can an individual balance selfish interests against the well-being of others?
In the ethical context, how can an individual balance selfish interests against the well-being of others?
Signup and view all the answers
What role does morality play in the context of a society's rules of conduct?
What role does morality play in the context of a society's rules of conduct?
Signup and view all the answers
How does ethical thinking contribute to an individual’s personal development during complex decision-making?
How does ethical thinking contribute to an individual’s personal development during complex decision-making?
Signup and view all the answers
Why is the examination of morality considered a rational aspect of ethics?
Why is the examination of morality considered a rational aspect of ethics?
Signup and view all the answers
How does subjective relativism differ from tolerance in ethical decision-making?
How does subjective relativism differ from tolerance in ethical decision-making?
Signup and view all the answers
What is a primary argument against cultural relativism?
What is a primary argument against cultural relativism?
Signup and view all the answers
Explain the impracticality of Divine Command Theory in modern diverse societies.
Explain the impracticality of Divine Command Theory in modern diverse societies.
Signup and view all the answers
What does Kant mean by the 'Categorical Imperative' and how does it function in ethical reasoning?
What does Kant mean by the 'Categorical Imperative' and how does it function in ethical reasoning?
Signup and view all the answers
How does ethical egoism potentially lead to morally unacceptable behavior?
How does ethical egoism potentially lead to morally unacceptable behavior?
Signup and view all the answers
In what ways did Alexis's actions benefit her, and what potential negative impact could they have had on her peers?
In what ways did Alexis's actions benefit her, and what potential negative impact could they have had on her peers?
Signup and view all the answers
Assess the ethical dilemma faced by the antispam organization when creating a blacklist that affected innocent users.
Assess the ethical dilemma faced by the antispam organization when creating a blacklist that affected innocent users.
Signup and view all the answers
What obligations, if any, do the East Dakota State Police have toward drivers who might be unfairly penalized by the new speed detection system?
What obligations, if any, do the East Dakota State Police have toward drivers who might be unfairly penalized by the new speed detection system?
Signup and view all the answers
Evaluate the moral implications of a start-up engineer choosing to release a buggy app to maintain a competitive edge.
Evaluate the moral implications of a start-up engineer choosing to release a buggy app to maintain a competitive edge.
Signup and view all the answers
How might subjective relativism influence the decisions made by individuals in ethically complex scenarios like those presented?
How might subjective relativism influence the decisions made by individuals in ethically complex scenarios like those presented?
Signup and view all the answers
What does Kantian ethics imply about the treatment of individuals in moral decision-making?
What does Kantian ethics imply about the treatment of individuals in moral decision-making?
Signup and view all the answers
How would the principle of utility assess the ethics of Carla submitting a purchased report?
How would the principle of utility assess the ethics of Carla submitting a purchased report?
Signup and view all the answers
What distinction does Kant make between perfect duties and imperfect duties?
What distinction does Kant make between perfect duties and imperfect duties?
Signup and view all the answers
In the Anti-Worm scenario, what principle does Rule Utilitarianism use to evaluate the proposed action of creating a helpful worm?
In the Anti-Worm scenario, what principle does Rule Utilitarianism use to evaluate the proposed action of creating a helpful worm?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the main flaw of Act Utilitarianism highlighted in the content, particularly regarding its application?
What is the main flaw of Act Utilitarianism highlighted in the content, particularly regarding its application?
Signup and view all the answers
Study Notes
Living in Communities: Benefits and Costs
- Communities provide security against external dangers and enable the exchange of goods and services.
- Economic specialization in communities can lead to a higher standard of living and personal relationships.
- Costs of living in communities include prohibitions and obligations for certain actions, with nonconformance potentially leading to punishment.
- The existence of communities is justified by the benefits outweighing the associated costs.
Ethical Perspectives
- Core values shared by individuals typically revolve around life, happiness, and accomplishment.
- Two worldviews exist:
- Selfish: Focuses solely on personal interests.
- Ethical: Respects others and acknowledges their values.
Definitions
- Society: A group of individuals organized under rules that promote member welfare over time.
- Morality: The rules of conduct that dictate right and wrong actions in societal contexts.
- Ethics: The rational analysis of morality that evaluates behavior against established moral principles.
Importance of Studying Ethics
- Ethical studies encourage individuals to consider diverse perspectives on issues, leading to personal growth and better decision-making.
- Recognizes the complexity of ethical dilemmas which often require deep analysis for resolution.
Ethical Scenarios
- Scenarios presented include dilemmas involving deceit, harm, benefits, and ethical evaluation of actions.
- Common questions arise regarding fairness, rights violations, and alternative actions to achieve goals.
Ethical Theories Overview
- Subjective Relativism: Moral judgments are seen as personal and culturally dependent, leading to both subjective conclusions and challenges in establishing universal moral standards.
- Cultural Relativism: Right and wrong are defined by societal morals which vary across cultures and time periods, but faces criticism for potentially allowing harmful practices to persist.
Divine Command Theory
- Aligns right actions with God's will as disclosed in holy texts, but is criticized for inconsistency across different scriptures and impracticality in diverse societies.
Ethical Egoism
- Suggests individuals should act in their own self-interest, promoting maximum personal benefit. However, this approach can lead to immoral actions and neglect others' needs.
Kantianism
- Centers on the concept of good will, asserting that moral actions must respect others as ends in themselves rather than means to an end.
- Two formulations of the Categorical Imperative guide ethical decision-making:
- Act only according to principles that can be universalized.
- Treat individuals as moral equals deserving of dignity.
Utilitarianism
- Act Utilitarianism: Evaluates actions based on their outcomes, advocating for actions that maximize overall happiness.
- Rule Utilitarianism: Normative approach that supports moral rules leading to general happiness when universally followed.
Practical Evaluations
- Ethical scenarios evaluate the anticipated benefits and harms of actions, with various stakeholders considered.
- Case studies illustrate the complexities of ethical decision-making and the potential for societal impact.### Case for Rule Utilitarianism
- Moral decisions can be guided by established rules rather than individual utilitarian calculations.
- Moral rules can withstand exceptional situations without losing their validity.
- Reduces issues related to moral luck, where outcomes influence moral judgment.
- Minimizes bias in moral decision-making by relying on consistent rules.
- Appeals broadly to diverse social groups, providing a common ethical framework.
Case Against Utilitarianism in General
- Requires all consequences to be measured on a single scale, necessitating uniform units for calculation.
- Forces quantification of human life value in certain scenarios, raising ethical concerns.
- Fails to address unjust distribution of positive outcomes, lacking a justice principle.
- Conflicts may arise between the Principle of Utility and principles of justice, complicating moral evaluations.
Social Contract Theory
- Thomas Hobbes posits that life in the "state of nature" would be dire and prompts acceptance of a social contract.
- Implicit social contract establishes governance and moral rules among citizens.
- Jean-Jacques Rousseau emphasizes societal order where no individual is above the law.
- James Rachels defines morality as a set of mutually agreed rules for relational harmony.
Kinds of Rights
- Negative rights require others to refrain from interfering (e.g., privacy).
- Positive rights compel others to act on your behalf (e.g., education).
- Absolute rights are unconditional; limited rights are subject to circumstances.
John Rawls’s Principles of Justice
- Individuals have claims to basic rights as long as they do not infringe on the same rights for others.
- Social and economic inequalities must ensure equal opportunity and benefit the least advantaged, known as the difference principle.
Convenience Stores Scenario
- Bill collects customer purchase data to create profiles for marketing.
- Customers have differing reactions to the sale of their information.
- Evaluation hinges on rights concerning privacy and consent for information sharing.
Case for Social Contract Theory
- Framed through rights language, explaining self-interested behavior without common agreements.
- Analyzes governmental authority and civil obedience as justified actions.
Case Against Social Contract Theory
- The absence of an actual signed social contract raises questions about legitimacy.
- Conflicts where actions can have multiple ethical interpretations complicate the theory.
- Potentially unjust towards individuals who cannot uphold the contract due to various reasons.
Virtue Ethics
- Critiques Enlightenment theories for neglecting moral education, social relationships, and emotions.
- Virtue ethics centers on the idea of achieving excellence (arete) through moral virtues.
- Intellectual virtues involve reasoning; moral virtues concern character traits like honesty.
Aristotle on Happiness
- Happiness results from living virtuously, acquired through consistent moral behavior.
- Virtue Ethics emphasizes the right action consistent with virtuous character in any circumstance.
Vices
- Vices prevent flourishing, existing as opposites of virtues.
- Virtues are often positioned between two extremes, e.g., courage is between cowardliness and rashness.
Case for Virtue Ethics
- Emphasizes virtues over obligations or consequences, aligning ethical focus with moral character.
- Recognizes that moral skills develop through practice over time and acknowledges the role of emotions.
Case Against Virtue Ethics
- Disagreements exist on which traits constitute virtues for flourishing.
- Limited applicability to government policy-making and accountability for actions.
Comparing Workable Ethical Theories
- Ethical objectivism asserts morality exists independently, contrasting with relativism which considers morality as a human construct.
- Workable ethical theories share characteristics like logical reasoning and factual bases.
- Examples include Kantianism, utilitarianism, social contract theory, and virtue ethics.
Morality of Breaking the Law
- From a social contract theory perspective, societal burdens are accepted for rights protection, emphasizing law obedience unless higher moral obligations compel disobedience.
- Kantianism argues against subverting laws under the guise of justice due to potential consequences for society.
- Rule utilitarianism weighs the happiness produced against societal respect for law.
- Act utilitarianism examines specific scenarios where benefits of breaking the law could outweigh harms.
Summary of Theories
- Kantianism: Advocates respect for equal personhood and rationality in interactions.
- Utilitarianism: Prioritizes outcome considerations in moral decisions.
- Social Contract Theory: Encourages collective promotion of human rights.
- Virtue Ethics: Trusts in virtuous individuals to make right choices based on character.
Personal Ethical Decision-Making
- Encourages individual reflection on moral duties, rights, consequences, and virtues.
- Prompts consideration of personal aspirations for character and societal context.
Living in Communities: Benefits and Costs
- Communities provide security against external dangers and enable the exchange of goods and services.
- Economic specialization in communities can lead to a higher standard of living and personal relationships.
- Costs of living in communities include prohibitions and obligations for certain actions, with nonconformance potentially leading to punishment.
- The existence of communities is justified by the benefits outweighing the associated costs.
Ethical Perspectives
- Core values shared by individuals typically revolve around life, happiness, and accomplishment.
- Two worldviews exist:
- Selfish: Focuses solely on personal interests.
- Ethical: Respects others and acknowledges their values.
Definitions
- Society: A group of individuals organized under rules that promote member welfare over time.
- Morality: The rules of conduct that dictate right and wrong actions in societal contexts.
- Ethics: The rational analysis of morality that evaluates behavior against established moral principles.
Importance of Studying Ethics
- Ethical studies encourage individuals to consider diverse perspectives on issues, leading to personal growth and better decision-making.
- Recognizes the complexity of ethical dilemmas which often require deep analysis for resolution.
Ethical Scenarios
- Scenarios presented include dilemmas involving deceit, harm, benefits, and ethical evaluation of actions.
- Common questions arise regarding fairness, rights violations, and alternative actions to achieve goals.
Ethical Theories Overview
- Subjective Relativism: Moral judgments are seen as personal and culturally dependent, leading to both subjective conclusions and challenges in establishing universal moral standards.
- Cultural Relativism: Right and wrong are defined by societal morals which vary across cultures and time periods, but faces criticism for potentially allowing harmful practices to persist.
Divine Command Theory
- Aligns right actions with God's will as disclosed in holy texts, but is criticized for inconsistency across different scriptures and impracticality in diverse societies.
Ethical Egoism
- Suggests individuals should act in their own self-interest, promoting maximum personal benefit. However, this approach can lead to immoral actions and neglect others' needs.
Kantianism
- Centers on the concept of good will, asserting that moral actions must respect others as ends in themselves rather than means to an end.
- Two formulations of the Categorical Imperative guide ethical decision-making:
- Act only according to principles that can be universalized.
- Treat individuals as moral equals deserving of dignity.
Utilitarianism
- Act Utilitarianism: Evaluates actions based on their outcomes, advocating for actions that maximize overall happiness.
- Rule Utilitarianism: Normative approach that supports moral rules leading to general happiness when universally followed.
Practical Evaluations
- Ethical scenarios evaluate the anticipated benefits and harms of actions, with various stakeholders considered.
- Case studies illustrate the complexities of ethical decision-making and the potential for societal impact.### Case for Rule Utilitarianism
- Moral decisions can be guided by established rules rather than individual utilitarian calculations.
- Moral rules can withstand exceptional situations without losing their validity.
- Reduces issues related to moral luck, where outcomes influence moral judgment.
- Minimizes bias in moral decision-making by relying on consistent rules.
- Appeals broadly to diverse social groups, providing a common ethical framework.
Case Against Utilitarianism in General
- Requires all consequences to be measured on a single scale, necessitating uniform units for calculation.
- Forces quantification of human life value in certain scenarios, raising ethical concerns.
- Fails to address unjust distribution of positive outcomes, lacking a justice principle.
- Conflicts may arise between the Principle of Utility and principles of justice, complicating moral evaluations.
Social Contract Theory
- Thomas Hobbes posits that life in the "state of nature" would be dire and prompts acceptance of a social contract.
- Implicit social contract establishes governance and moral rules among citizens.
- Jean-Jacques Rousseau emphasizes societal order where no individual is above the law.
- James Rachels defines morality as a set of mutually agreed rules for relational harmony.
Kinds of Rights
- Negative rights require others to refrain from interfering (e.g., privacy).
- Positive rights compel others to act on your behalf (e.g., education).
- Absolute rights are unconditional; limited rights are subject to circumstances.
John Rawls’s Principles of Justice
- Individuals have claims to basic rights as long as they do not infringe on the same rights for others.
- Social and economic inequalities must ensure equal opportunity and benefit the least advantaged, known as the difference principle.
Convenience Stores Scenario
- Bill collects customer purchase data to create profiles for marketing.
- Customers have differing reactions to the sale of their information.
- Evaluation hinges on rights concerning privacy and consent for information sharing.
Case for Social Contract Theory
- Framed through rights language, explaining self-interested behavior without common agreements.
- Analyzes governmental authority and civil obedience as justified actions.
Case Against Social Contract Theory
- The absence of an actual signed social contract raises questions about legitimacy.
- Conflicts where actions can have multiple ethical interpretations complicate the theory.
- Potentially unjust towards individuals who cannot uphold the contract due to various reasons.
Virtue Ethics
- Critiques Enlightenment theories for neglecting moral education, social relationships, and emotions.
- Virtue ethics centers on the idea of achieving excellence (arete) through moral virtues.
- Intellectual virtues involve reasoning; moral virtues concern character traits like honesty.
Aristotle on Happiness
- Happiness results from living virtuously, acquired through consistent moral behavior.
- Virtue Ethics emphasizes the right action consistent with virtuous character in any circumstance.
Vices
- Vices prevent flourishing, existing as opposites of virtues.
- Virtues are often positioned between two extremes, e.g., courage is between cowardliness and rashness.
Case for Virtue Ethics
- Emphasizes virtues over obligations or consequences, aligning ethical focus with moral character.
- Recognizes that moral skills develop through practice over time and acknowledges the role of emotions.
Case Against Virtue Ethics
- Disagreements exist on which traits constitute virtues for flourishing.
- Limited applicability to government policy-making and accountability for actions.
Comparing Workable Ethical Theories
- Ethical objectivism asserts morality exists independently, contrasting with relativism which considers morality as a human construct.
- Workable ethical theories share characteristics like logical reasoning and factual bases.
- Examples include Kantianism, utilitarianism, social contract theory, and virtue ethics.
Morality of Breaking the Law
- From a social contract theory perspective, societal burdens are accepted for rights protection, emphasizing law obedience unless higher moral obligations compel disobedience.
- Kantianism argues against subverting laws under the guise of justice due to potential consequences for society.
- Rule utilitarianism weighs the happiness produced against societal respect for law.
- Act utilitarianism examines specific scenarios where benefits of breaking the law could outweigh harms.
Summary of Theories
- Kantianism: Advocates respect for equal personhood and rationality in interactions.
- Utilitarianism: Prioritizes outcome considerations in moral decisions.
- Social Contract Theory: Encourages collective promotion of human rights.
- Virtue Ethics: Trusts in virtuous individuals to make right choices based on character.
Personal Ethical Decision-Making
- Encourages individual reflection on moral duties, rights, consequences, and virtues.
- Prompts consideration of personal aspirations for character and societal context.
Living in Communities: Benefits and Costs
- Communities provide security against external dangers and enable the exchange of goods and services.
- Economic specialization in communities can lead to a higher standard of living and personal relationships.
- Costs of living in communities include prohibitions and obligations for certain actions, with nonconformance potentially leading to punishment.
- The existence of communities is justified by the benefits outweighing the associated costs.
Ethical Perspectives
- Core values shared by individuals typically revolve around life, happiness, and accomplishment.
- Two worldviews exist:
- Selfish: Focuses solely on personal interests.
- Ethical: Respects others and acknowledges their values.
Definitions
- Society: A group of individuals organized under rules that promote member welfare over time.
- Morality: The rules of conduct that dictate right and wrong actions in societal contexts.
- Ethics: The rational analysis of morality that evaluates behavior against established moral principles.
Importance of Studying Ethics
- Ethical studies encourage individuals to consider diverse perspectives on issues, leading to personal growth and better decision-making.
- Recognizes the complexity of ethical dilemmas which often require deep analysis for resolution.
Ethical Scenarios
- Scenarios presented include dilemmas involving deceit, harm, benefits, and ethical evaluation of actions.
- Common questions arise regarding fairness, rights violations, and alternative actions to achieve goals.
Ethical Theories Overview
- Subjective Relativism: Moral judgments are seen as personal and culturally dependent, leading to both subjective conclusions and challenges in establishing universal moral standards.
- Cultural Relativism: Right and wrong are defined by societal morals which vary across cultures and time periods, but faces criticism for potentially allowing harmful practices to persist.
Divine Command Theory
- Aligns right actions with God's will as disclosed in holy texts, but is criticized for inconsistency across different scriptures and impracticality in diverse societies.
Ethical Egoism
- Suggests individuals should act in their own self-interest, promoting maximum personal benefit. However, this approach can lead to immoral actions and neglect others' needs.
Kantianism
- Centers on the concept of good will, asserting that moral actions must respect others as ends in themselves rather than means to an end.
- Two formulations of the Categorical Imperative guide ethical decision-making:
- Act only according to principles that can be universalized.
- Treat individuals as moral equals deserving of dignity.
Utilitarianism
- Act Utilitarianism: Evaluates actions based on their outcomes, advocating for actions that maximize overall happiness.
- Rule Utilitarianism: Normative approach that supports moral rules leading to general happiness when universally followed.
Practical Evaluations
- Ethical scenarios evaluate the anticipated benefits and harms of actions, with various stakeholders considered.
- Case studies illustrate the complexities of ethical decision-making and the potential for societal impact.### Case for Rule Utilitarianism
- Moral decisions can be guided by established rules rather than individual utilitarian calculations.
- Moral rules can withstand exceptional situations without losing their validity.
- Reduces issues related to moral luck, where outcomes influence moral judgment.
- Minimizes bias in moral decision-making by relying on consistent rules.
- Appeals broadly to diverse social groups, providing a common ethical framework.
Case Against Utilitarianism in General
- Requires all consequences to be measured on a single scale, necessitating uniform units for calculation.
- Forces quantification of human life value in certain scenarios, raising ethical concerns.
- Fails to address unjust distribution of positive outcomes, lacking a justice principle.
- Conflicts may arise between the Principle of Utility and principles of justice, complicating moral evaluations.
Social Contract Theory
- Thomas Hobbes posits that life in the "state of nature" would be dire and prompts acceptance of a social contract.
- Implicit social contract establishes governance and moral rules among citizens.
- Jean-Jacques Rousseau emphasizes societal order where no individual is above the law.
- James Rachels defines morality as a set of mutually agreed rules for relational harmony.
Kinds of Rights
- Negative rights require others to refrain from interfering (e.g., privacy).
- Positive rights compel others to act on your behalf (e.g., education).
- Absolute rights are unconditional; limited rights are subject to circumstances.
John Rawls’s Principles of Justice
- Individuals have claims to basic rights as long as they do not infringe on the same rights for others.
- Social and economic inequalities must ensure equal opportunity and benefit the least advantaged, known as the difference principle.
Convenience Stores Scenario
- Bill collects customer purchase data to create profiles for marketing.
- Customers have differing reactions to the sale of their information.
- Evaluation hinges on rights concerning privacy and consent for information sharing.
Case for Social Contract Theory
- Framed through rights language, explaining self-interested behavior without common agreements.
- Analyzes governmental authority and civil obedience as justified actions.
Case Against Social Contract Theory
- The absence of an actual signed social contract raises questions about legitimacy.
- Conflicts where actions can have multiple ethical interpretations complicate the theory.
- Potentially unjust towards individuals who cannot uphold the contract due to various reasons.
Virtue Ethics
- Critiques Enlightenment theories for neglecting moral education, social relationships, and emotions.
- Virtue ethics centers on the idea of achieving excellence (arete) through moral virtues.
- Intellectual virtues involve reasoning; moral virtues concern character traits like honesty.
Aristotle on Happiness
- Happiness results from living virtuously, acquired through consistent moral behavior.
- Virtue Ethics emphasizes the right action consistent with virtuous character in any circumstance.
Vices
- Vices prevent flourishing, existing as opposites of virtues.
- Virtues are often positioned between two extremes, e.g., courage is between cowardliness and rashness.
Case for Virtue Ethics
- Emphasizes virtues over obligations or consequences, aligning ethical focus with moral character.
- Recognizes that moral skills develop through practice over time and acknowledges the role of emotions.
Case Against Virtue Ethics
- Disagreements exist on which traits constitute virtues for flourishing.
- Limited applicability to government policy-making and accountability for actions.
Comparing Workable Ethical Theories
- Ethical objectivism asserts morality exists independently, contrasting with relativism which considers morality as a human construct.
- Workable ethical theories share characteristics like logical reasoning and factual bases.
- Examples include Kantianism, utilitarianism, social contract theory, and virtue ethics.
Morality of Breaking the Law
- From a social contract theory perspective, societal burdens are accepted for rights protection, emphasizing law obedience unless higher moral obligations compel disobedience.
- Kantianism argues against subverting laws under the guise of justice due to potential consequences for society.
- Rule utilitarianism weighs the happiness produced against societal respect for law.
- Act utilitarianism examines specific scenarios where benefits of breaking the law could outweigh harms.
Summary of Theories
- Kantianism: Advocates respect for equal personhood and rationality in interactions.
- Utilitarianism: Prioritizes outcome considerations in moral decisions.
- Social Contract Theory: Encourages collective promotion of human rights.
- Virtue Ethics: Trusts in virtuous individuals to make right choices based on character.
Personal Ethical Decision-Making
- Encourages individual reflection on moral duties, rights, consequences, and virtues.
- Prompts consideration of personal aspirations for character and societal context.
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.
Description
Explore the dynamics of living in communities, examining both the benefits such as increased security and economic specialization, and the costs including obligations and potential punishments. This quiz delves into ethical perspectives and core values shared by members of communities.