Podcast
Questions and Answers
According to the content, how do judges typically make decisions using sources of law?
According to the content, how do judges typically make decisions using sources of law?
- They exclusively rely on past rulings without any interpretation.
- They manipulate language to fit their desired outcomes. (correct)
- They strictly adhere to the rules without exceptions.
- They prioritize public opinion over legal sources.
What does Frank argue about the nature of judges in the legal system?
What does Frank argue about the nature of judges in the legal system?
- Judges are strictly impartial entities.
- Judges function as automated decision-makers.
- Judges operate only based on established precedents.
- Judges are influenced by human traits and biases. (correct)
In the context of law and economics, what is wealth defined as?
In the context of law and economics, what is wealth defined as?
- A mixture of personal connections and monetary resources.
- The total value of the economy within a country.
- All physical assets owned by an individual.
- Satisfactions that can be measured in monetary terms. (correct)
What is the perspective of Hart regarding judicial decision-making?
What is the perspective of Hart regarding judicial decision-making?
What might be a potential benefit of recognizing judicial discretion according to Frank?
What might be a potential benefit of recognizing judicial discretion according to Frank?
How do social science studies suggest judges' decisions can be influenced?
How do social science studies suggest judges' decisions can be influenced?
What does Holmes imply about the perception of taxes and fines from the perspective of the bad man?
What does Holmes imply about the perception of taxes and fines from the perspective of the bad man?
What is one of the two pitfalls mentioned in relation to Holmes’ predictive theory of law?
What is one of the two pitfalls mentioned in relation to Holmes’ predictive theory of law?
Which of the following accurately depicts the role of precedent as discussed?
Which of the following accurately depicts the role of precedent as discussed?
What does Frank suggest about how judges make decisions?
What does Frank suggest about how judges make decisions?
How does Jerome Frank view judicial discretion?
How does Jerome Frank view judicial discretion?
What distinction does Frank make regarding 'actual law' and 'probable law'?
What distinction does Frank make regarding 'actual law' and 'probable law'?
What does Holmes argue about the role of public opinion in judicial decisions?
What does Holmes argue about the role of public opinion in judicial decisions?
Which philosophical perspective does Frank align with in his legal realism?
Which philosophical perspective does Frank align with in his legal realism?
What kind of changes to legal education does Holmes suggest?
What kind of changes to legal education does Holmes suggest?
What does Frank criticize about the 'conventional view' of law?
What does Frank criticize about the 'conventional view' of law?
What major influence does Frank draw upon to express his concerns regarding judicial discretion?
What major influence does Frank draw upon to express his concerns regarding judicial discretion?
Flashcards are hidden until you start studying
Study Notes
Holmes' View of Law
- Holmes believed in the "predictive theory of law," suggesting that law should be viewed from the perspective of a "bad man" who only cares about the consequences of breaking it.
- Holmes argued that there’s no substantial difference between taxes and fines for a "bad man."
- He stressed that law involves more than just logic and that judges' decisions are often influenced by public opinion.
- He advocated for legal education to emphasize the importance of considering social advantage in interpreting laws.
Jerome Frank's Legal Realism
- Frank, a legal realist, agreed with Holmes' views. He believed that “conventional view” of law, which emphasizes the application of logic and reason, is unrealistic.
- Frank argued that the desire for absolute certainty in law is a “childish” desire for a “fixed father controlled universe.”
- He believed that judges are more influenced by their “hunches” than any established legal principle.
- He challenged the notion that judges never change existing law or make new law.
- Frank believed that judges are like witnesses in trials, influenced by their biases, prejudices, and even inadmissible evidence.
Law and Economics
- Economics analyzes exchanges people are willing to make and what they're willing to give up.
- Wealth is defined in economic terms as “all satisfactions that can be measured” or “preferences backed by willingness to pay.”
- Economists believe in maximizing wealth through free market exchanges, as people are assumed to act rationally and try to obtain things they desire most.
- The free market is seen as a mechanism for distributing goods and services to maximize wealth.
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.
