Podcast
Questions and Answers
What is the main goal of forensic science in relation to evidence?
What is the main goal of forensic science in relation to evidence?
- To follow strict rules and policies
- To ensure no evidence is left untested
- To maximize the value of evidence (correct)
- To collect evidence in a haphazard manner
Which ethical framework emphasizes duty and rules in decision-making?
Which ethical framework emphasizes duty and rules in decision-making?
- Contemporary Ethics
- Virtue Ethics
- Utilitarianism
- Deontology (correct)
What is a significant limitation mentioned in forensic science regarding evidence collection?
What is a significant limitation mentioned in forensic science regarding evidence collection?
- Evidence can always be retested later
- Eating evidence can invalidate its value
- There is only one opportunity to collect evidence at a crime scene (correct)
- All evidence is guaranteed to be probative
How should decisions in forensic science ideally be made?
How should decisions in forensic science ideally be made?
Which of the following best describes utilitarianism in the context of forensic evidence testing?
Which of the following best describes utilitarianism in the context of forensic evidence testing?
What factors may lead police to evaluate evidence and determine the required forensic analyses?
What factors may lead police to evaluate evidence and determine the required forensic analyses?
Which case type is usually prioritized over others in evidence testing?
Which case type is usually prioritized over others in evidence testing?
What is a reason that evidence may not be submitted for forensic analysis?
What is a reason that evidence may not be submitted for forensic analysis?
Which aspect of a case may affect the prioritization of evidence testing?
Which aspect of a case may affect the prioritization of evidence testing?
In the context of case sampling, which type of case is typically expedited?
In the context of case sampling, which type of case is typically expedited?
What is a common consideration in deciding which samples to collect at a crime scene?
What is a common consideration in deciding which samples to collect at a crime scene?
What type of evidence may be prioritized due to the risk of witness memory loss?
What type of evidence may be prioritized due to the risk of witness memory loss?
What might complicate the decision on how many samples to send to a laboratory?
What might complicate the decision on how many samples to send to a laboratory?
Which of the following situations would not typically warrant prioritizing a forensic case?
Which of the following situations would not typically warrant prioritizing a forensic case?
What is a crucial factor in ensuring the integrity of forensic analysis?
What is a crucial factor in ensuring the integrity of forensic analysis?
What role do forensic scientists have in educating potential evidence submitters?
What role do forensic scientists have in educating potential evidence submitters?
How do ethics in forensics relate to ethics in medicine?
How do ethics in forensics relate to ethics in medicine?
What is the significance of having scientifically based testing in forensic cases?
What is the significance of having scientifically based testing in forensic cases?
What is the primary goal of forensic analysts when prioritizing cases?
What is the primary goal of forensic analysts when prioritizing cases?
What is a reason why an item may not be initially accepted for DNA testing?
What is a reason why an item may not be initially accepted for DNA testing?
How can evidence degradation affect forensic examinations?
How can evidence degradation affect forensic examinations?
What reflects a common issue that forensic analysts may face with case processing?
What reflects a common issue that forensic analysts may face with case processing?
What implication does the prioritization of tests have in forensic investigations?
What implication does the prioritization of tests have in forensic investigations?
What significant event occurred on February 1, 1993, concerning Bernardo's test results?
What significant event occurred on February 1, 1993, concerning Bernardo's test results?
How long was the delay in providing serology results to the police?
How long was the delay in providing serology results to the police?
What was one of the consequences of delaying DNA testing for Bernardo's case?
What was one of the consequences of delaying DNA testing for Bernardo's case?
What was noted as a contributing factor to the delay in the investigation of Bernardo's case?
What was noted as a contributing factor to the delay in the investigation of Bernardo's case?
Which of the following was a notable issue mentioned regarding the handling of the case?
Which of the following was a notable issue mentioned regarding the handling of the case?
What impact can delays in DNA testing have, as highlighted in the content?
What impact can delays in DNA testing have, as highlighted in the content?
What was suggested as a necessary balance regarding public funds in the content?
What was suggested as a necessary balance regarding public funds in the content?
What was one of the potential legal implications mentioned?
What was one of the potential legal implications mentioned?
How many other suspect samples were suitable for DNA analysis during the delay period?
How many other suspect samples were suitable for DNA analysis during the delay period?
What does the information highlight as a public interest aspect related to the case?
What does the information highlight as a public interest aspect related to the case?
What is one reason for the backlog of untested rape kits?
What is one reason for the backlog of untested rape kits?
What is a financial concern related to rape kits?
What is a financial concern related to rape kits?
What potential effect can re-opening old cases have on victims?
What potential effect can re-opening old cases have on victims?
What factor is NOT a reason for the destruction of rape kits?
What factor is NOT a reason for the destruction of rape kits?
How have testing rape kits contributed to wrongful convictions?
How have testing rape kits contributed to wrongful convictions?
What ethical dilemma arises from the backlog of rape kits?
What ethical dilemma arises from the backlog of rape kits?
What message is conveyed when sexual assault kits are not analyzed?
What message is conveyed when sexual assault kits are not analyzed?
Which of the following is NOT a consequence of destroying rape kits?
Which of the following is NOT a consequence of destroying rape kits?
What is a primary consideration for prioritizing the testing of rape kits?
What is a primary consideration for prioritizing the testing of rape kits?
What is a commonly perceived issue with the label of 'uncooperative complainant'?
What is a commonly perceived issue with the label of 'uncooperative complainant'?
What is one of the primary differences between a hospital autopsy and a coroner's autopsy?
What is one of the primary differences between a hospital autopsy and a coroner's autopsy?
Which role is primarily responsible for seizing important items during death investigations?
Which role is primarily responsible for seizing important items during death investigations?
What is an ethical concern associated with autopsies?
What is an ethical concern associated with autopsies?
Which of the following is NOT a responsibility of coroners?
Which of the following is NOT a responsibility of coroners?
What training is necessary for pathologists to become coroners in Canada?
What training is necessary for pathologists to become coroners in Canada?
How does family concern influence autopsies conducted by coroners?
How does family concern influence autopsies conducted by coroners?
Which of the following statements about the oversight council is true?
Which of the following statements about the oversight council is true?
Which of the following describes medicolegal autopsies?
Which of the following describes medicolegal autopsies?
What is a potential benefit of conducting an autopsy?
What is a potential benefit of conducting an autopsy?
How does grief affect families during death investigations?
How does grief affect families during death investigations?
What role can grief counsellors play in death investigations?
What role can grief counsellors play in death investigations?
Why might families have objections to autopsies?
Why might families have objections to autopsies?
What is a primary ethical consideration for death investigators when working with grieving families?
What is a primary ethical consideration for death investigators when working with grieving families?
In the context of Indigenous Canadians, what is a significant concern regarding burial practices?
In the context of Indigenous Canadians, what is a significant concern regarding burial practices?
What is one potential consequence of not conducting an autopsy?
What is one potential consequence of not conducting an autopsy?
What responsibilities does the Independent Special Interlocutor have regarding unmarked graves?
What responsibilities does the Independent Special Interlocutor have regarding unmarked graves?
What was the significance of the anomalies found during the Pine Creek excavation?
What was the significance of the anomalies found during the Pine Creek excavation?
What is the main lesson learned from the Pine Creek excavation regarding evidence collection?
What is the main lesson learned from the Pine Creek excavation regarding evidence collection?
What challenges did investigators face during the Pikangikum fire investigation?
What challenges did investigators face during the Pikangikum fire investigation?
Why is it considered important for Indigenous communities to heal in relation to the findings from excavations?
Why is it considered important for Indigenous communities to heal in relation to the findings from excavations?
How did the response to the Pikangikum fire incorporate various professionals?
How did the response to the Pikangikum fire incorporate various professionals?
What was the age range of the victims in the Pikangikum house fire?
What was the age range of the victims in the Pikangikum house fire?
What was a primary goal of the investigators following the Pikangikum fire incident?
What was a primary goal of the investigators following the Pikangikum fire incident?
Which of the following best summarizes the role of the Special Interlocutor mentioned?
Which of the following best summarizes the role of the Special Interlocutor mentioned?
What is required to rule out criminal activity in Jesse's case?
What is required to rule out criminal activity in Jesse's case?
What ethical argument did Dr. Caplan present regarding organ retention?
What ethical argument did Dr. Caplan present regarding organ retention?
Which legal right protects a family's control over the final disposition of a deceased person?
Which legal right protects a family's control over the final disposition of a deceased person?
What was the outcome of the Shipley family's lawsuit regarding organ retention?
What was the outcome of the Shipley family's lawsuit regarding organ retention?
What concern does allowing medical examiners to take the brain raise for families?
What concern does allowing medical examiners to take the brain raise for families?
Which ruling was the basis for the court overturning the Shipley family's settlement?
Which ruling was the basis for the court overturning the Shipley family's settlement?
What aspect of the right of sepulcher does not include organ retention?
What aspect of the right of sepulcher does not include organ retention?
What is a potential downside of retaining organs for investigation?
What is a potential downside of retaining organs for investigation?
What is one key practice of organ retention in Ontario?
What is one key practice of organ retention in Ontario?
Under what condition can a coroner's office retain an organ?
Under what condition can a coroner's office retain an organ?
Who must authorize the decision to retain an organ after an autopsy?
Who must authorize the decision to retain an organ after an autopsy?
What increases the likelihood of misidentification of deceased individuals?
What increases the likelihood of misidentification of deceased individuals?
Which factor is essential when informing a family about retained organs?
Which factor is essential when informing a family about retained organs?
What is the main purpose of delaying a funeral in the context of organ retention?
What is the main purpose of delaying a funeral in the context of organ retention?
What might complicate the identification of deceased individuals for grieving families?
What might complicate the identification of deceased individuals for grieving families?
What must families be informed about regarding organ retention?
What must families be informed about regarding organ retention?
What was one method used for identifying bodies in the Marchioness SS Disaster?
What was one method used for identifying bodies in the Marchioness SS Disaster?
Which situation did not correctly identify the individuals involved in the Indiana tragedy?
Which situation did not correctly identify the individuals involved in the Indiana tragedy?
What is a major challenge faced by investigators in the Marchioness SS Disaster regarding body retrieval?
What is a major challenge faced by investigators in the Marchioness SS Disaster regarding body retrieval?
Which of the following statements about Xavier LaBelle and Parker Tobin is accurate?
Which of the following statements about Xavier LaBelle and Parker Tobin is accurate?
Which option reflects an unethical practice in death investigations?
Which option reflects an unethical practice in death investigations?
What was a significant issue for the families of those involved in the Indiana tragedy?
What was a significant issue for the families of those involved in the Indiana tragedy?
What procedure was suggested for bodies which were likely to float due to putrefaction and bloating?
What procedure was suggested for bodies which were likely to float due to putrefaction and bloating?
What conclusion can be drawn about the role of coroner's offices in tragic incidents?
What conclusion can be drawn about the role of coroner's offices in tragic incidents?
Flashcards
Imminent Threat to Public Safety
Imminent Threat to Public Safety
Cases that have the potential to cause immediate harm to the public.
Degradable Forensic Evidence
Degradable Forensic Evidence
Evidence that can deteriorate or be lost over time, requiring immediate analysis.
Director Approval
Director Approval
Cases that require approval from a supervisor or high-ranking official before proceeding.
High Profile Cases
High Profile Cases
Signup and view all the flashcards
Ethics in Forensics
Ethics in Forensics
Signup and view all the flashcards
QA in Forensic Science
QA in Forensic Science
Signup and view all the flashcards
Proactive Ethics
Proactive Ethics
Signup and view all the flashcards
Normative Ethics
Normative Ethics
Signup and view all the flashcards
Deontological Ethics
Deontological Ethics
Signup and view all the flashcards
Utilitarian Ethics
Utilitarian Ethics
Signup and view all the flashcards
Evidence Prioritization
Evidence Prioritization
Signup and view all the flashcards
Case Priority in Forensics
Case Priority in Forensics
Signup and view all the flashcards
Prioritizing Evidence for Efficiency
Prioritizing Evidence for Efficiency
Signup and view all the flashcards
Forensic Case Backlog
Forensic Case Backlog
Signup and view all the flashcards
Virtue Ethics in Forensics
Virtue Ethics in Forensics
Signup and view all the flashcards
Case Sampling
Case Sampling
Signup and view all the flashcards
Excessive Backlog
Excessive Backlog
Signup and view all the flashcards
Case Importance
Case Importance
Signup and view all the flashcards
Known vs. Unknown Assailant
Known vs. Unknown Assailant
Signup and view all the flashcards
Witnesses and Memory Loss
Witnesses and Memory Loss
Signup and view all the flashcards
Violent vs Non-Violent Cases
Violent vs Non-Violent Cases
Signup and view all the flashcards
Police Evaluation of Evidence
Police Evaluation of Evidence
Signup and view all the flashcards
Expedited Cases
Expedited Cases
Signup and view all the flashcards
DNA Test Turnaround Time
DNA Test Turnaround Time
Signup and view all the flashcards
Public Safety Risk
Public Safety Risk
Signup and view all the flashcards
DNA Inclusion
DNA Inclusion
Signup and view all the flashcards
DNA Testing
DNA Testing
Signup and view all the flashcards
Financial Cost of Delay
Financial Cost of Delay
Signup and view all the flashcards
Government Liability
Government Liability
Signup and view all the flashcards
Legal Liability
Legal Liability
Signup and view all the flashcards
Serial Sexual Predator
Serial Sexual Predator
Signup and view all the flashcards
Resource Allocation Balance
Resource Allocation Balance
Signup and view all the flashcards
Case Prioritization
Case Prioritization
Signup and view all the flashcards
Rape Kit Backlog
Rape Kit Backlog
Signup and view all the flashcards
Sending the wrong message
Sending the wrong message
Signup and view all the flashcards
Utilitarian Framework
Utilitarian Framework
Signup and view all the flashcards
Re-opening old cases
Re-opening old cases
Signup and view all the flashcards
Re-traumatization
Re-traumatization
Signup and view all the flashcards
Destruction of rape kits
Destruction of rape kits
Signup and view all the flashcards
National Registry of Exoneration
National Registry of Exoneration
Signup and view all the flashcards
No one simple answer
No one simple answer
Signup and view all the flashcards
Larger picture
Larger picture
Signup and view all the flashcards
Ethical Considerations in Forensic Science
Ethical Considerations in Forensic Science
Signup and view all the flashcards
Autopsy
Autopsy
Signup and view all the flashcards
Hospital Autopsy
Hospital Autopsy
Signup and view all the flashcards
Coroner's Autopsy
Coroner's Autopsy
Signup and view all the flashcards
Inquest
Inquest
Signup and view all the flashcards
Cremation Certificate
Cremation Certificate
Signup and view all the flashcards
Religious Beliefs and Autopsies
Religious Beliefs and Autopsies
Signup and view all the flashcards
Oversight Council
Oversight Council
Signup and view all the flashcards
Registry of Pathologists
Registry of Pathologists
Signup and view all the flashcards
Grief's Impact on Decision Making
Grief's Impact on Decision Making
Signup and view all the flashcards
Cultural Sensitivity in Death Investigations
Cultural Sensitivity in Death Investigations
Signup and view all the flashcards
Special Interlocutor's Role
Special Interlocutor's Role
Signup and view all the flashcards
Obstacles from Religious Beliefs
Obstacles from Religious Beliefs
Signup and view all the flashcards
Benefits of Autopsies
Benefits of Autopsies
Signup and view all the flashcards
Grief Counselors as Liaisons
Grief Counselors as Liaisons
Signup and view all the flashcards
Ethical Considerations in Death Investigations
Ethical Considerations in Death Investigations
Signup and view all the flashcards
Ground Penetrating Radar (GDR): Evidence Limitation
Ground Penetrating Radar (GDR): Evidence Limitation
Signup and view all the flashcards
Importance of Excavation for Healing
Importance of Excavation for Healing
Signup and view all the flashcards
Remote Investigation Challenges
Remote Investigation Challenges
Signup and view all the flashcards
Ethics in Death Investigations
Ethics in Death Investigations
Signup and view all the flashcards
Community Support in Tragedy
Community Support in Tragedy
Signup and view all the flashcards
Collaboration in Justice
Collaboration in Justice
Signup and view all the flashcards
Special Interlocutor: Beyond Information Gathering
Special Interlocutor: Beyond Information Gathering
Signup and view all the flashcards
Accurate Investigations: Seeking Truth
Accurate Investigations: Seeking Truth
Signup and view all the flashcards
Organ retention in autopsies
Organ retention in autopsies
Signup and view all the flashcards
Coroner's investigation
Coroner's investigation
Signup and view all the flashcards
Transparency in organ retention
Transparency in organ retention
Signup and view all the flashcards
Legitimate reasons for organ retention
Legitimate reasons for organ retention
Signup and view all the flashcards
Family's right to organ disposition
Family's right to organ disposition
Signup and view all the flashcards
Misidentification in mass disasters
Misidentification in mass disasters
Signup and view all the flashcards
Informing families about retained organs
Informing families about retained organs
Signup and view all the flashcards
Misidentification in Death Investigations
Misidentification in Death Investigations
Signup and view all the flashcards
Dental Records in Identification
Dental Records in Identification
Signup and view all the flashcards
Coroner's Inquest
Coroner's Inquest
Signup and view all the flashcards
Removal of Hands for Fingerprints
Removal of Hands for Fingerprints
Signup and view all the flashcards
Right of Sepulcher
Right of Sepulcher
Signup and view all the flashcards
Jesse's Death Investigation
Jesse's Death Investigation
Signup and view all the flashcards
Tissue Fixation in Formalin
Tissue Fixation in Formalin
Signup and view all the flashcards
Dr. Caplan's Argument
Dr. Caplan's Argument
Signup and view all the flashcards
Family's Perspective on Organ Retention
Family's Perspective on Organ Retention
Signup and view all the flashcards
Jesse's Death Case Court Ruling
Jesse's Death Case Court Ruling
Signup and view all the flashcards
Shipley Family Lawsuit
Shipley Family Lawsuit
Signup and view all the flashcards
Displaying Retained Organs
Displaying Retained Organs
Signup and view all the flashcards
Study Notes
Lecture 7 - Evidence Testing: Ethical Considerations
- Crime scene labs face ethical considerations regarding sample collection, prioritization, and testing.
- Decisions must balance important items with a comprehensive approach.
- Sending all samples for testing may not always be the most efficient or ethical course of action.
- Prioritizing certain cases and evidence is crucial due to limited resources.
Case Sampling
- Case prioritization & resource allocation is key.
- Police assess the case, using expert knowledge to determine the necessary forensic tests to support the evidence.
- Factors like knowledge gaps or insufficient resources might lead to evidence not being submitted.
- Excessive case backlogs create delays or unavailable resources.
- Medical tests might need coordinating with forensic protocols.
- Decisions account for the potential imbalance in importance.
Case Type and History
- Case importance is weighed in decision-making.
- Higher priority is often given to homicide or sexual assault cases.
- Known offender cases generally hold priority.
- Existing witness statements are a crucial variable for assessment.
- The known/unknown offender status and level of violence influence prioritization.
Expedited Cases
- Criminal cases with public safety implications are prioritized during investigation.
- Cases where forensic evidence is subject to degradation also have a higher priority.
- Cases receiving director approval are expedited.
- High profile cases often receive expedited treatment.
- Cases representing imminent threat to public safety are given priority.
Ethics in Forensics vs. Medicine
- Forensic ethics are closely tied to medical ethical principles.
- Factors such as case circumstances and available tests influence actions.
- Both fields share similarities in ethical considerations regarding individual cases.
Training & Knowledge in Forensics
- Training and expertise are vital in forensic labs for appropriate analysis.
- Labs should provide training.
- Scientists and labs need to educate those submitting evidence regarding collection and preservation techniques.
Ethical Guidance for Evidence Collection & Preservation
- Forensic science protocols, although heavily focused on technical considerations, also require ethical guidelines.
- Proactive ethical guidance in decision-making is emphasized.
- Ethics must be prioritized in balancing practicality and maintaining high quality of service.
- There's a need to balance the value of all evidence with efficient processing.
Normative Ethics in Forensics
- Normative ethics offer frameworks for ethical decision-making in forensics.
- Three common ethical frameworks exist: deontology (duties), utilitarianism (greatest good for the greatest number), and virtue ethics.
- Resources in forensic sciences are limited, which has implications for analysis.
- Forensic evidence collection must be optimized to meet the needs of the case.
- These frameworks help guide decisions regarding resource allocation.
Case Priority & Analysis
- In investigations, critical analysis and prioritization of forensic evidence are required.
- Analysis decisions depend on the case type and evidence itself.
- The analysis might change depending on evidence quality.
Example Criteria for DNA Testing
- Some evidence may not be considered viable due to factors such as reduced success rates, degradation, and relevance to the case.
- Priority criteria includes expected recovery rate for results and relevance to the allegations.
Case Examples (Scarborough Rapist)
- Specific examples demonstrate the need for prioritization and rapid evidence processing to improve outcomes.
- A case study highlighting delays in analysis and ethical considerations.
- The example of the Scarborough Rapist highlights the consequences of case backlog and prioritization failures.
- This example underscores the urgency and importance of addressing backlog problems.
- Delays in this case, and the larger implications for public safety, are illustrated.
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.