5 Questions
Explain the Oppenheimer case and the legal question it raised regarding dual nationality and tax obligations.
The Oppenheimer case involved a dual national who was unsure if he had to pay tax as an English national by neutralization. The question was whether he became a national before or after losing his German citizenship.
Describe the scenario in the Speluncean Explorers case and the different perspectives of the justices involved.
In the Speluncean Explorers case, five men were trapped in a cave. One of them suggested killing and eating one in order to survive. Justice Truepenny, a legal positivist, upheld the conviction based on the existing law. Justice Foster, a natural law theorist, acquitted the men as they were not operating under normal societal conditions. Justice Tattin recused himself, and Justice Keen, another legal positivist, supported the conviction.
What was Justice Truepenny's legal philosophy in the Speluncean Explorers case?
Justice Truepenny followed a legal positivist approach by upholding the conviction based on the existing law.
What was Justice Foster's legal philosophy in the Speluncean Explorers case?
Justice Foster adhered to natural law theory and acquitted the men, arguing that they could not be judged under normal laws as they were not operating in a normal society.
Explain the significance of the Oppenheimer case in relation to nationality and the loss of citizenship.
The Oppenheimer case raised important questions about the timing of nationality acquisition and the loss of citizenship. It explored whether an individual becomes a national before or after losing their previous citizenship, particularly concerning tax obligations.
Test your knowledge of landmark jurisprudence cases with this quiz! Explore the Oppenheimer Case, where a dual national questioned his tax obligations after losing his German citizenship. Dive into the Speluncean Explorers case, authored by Lon Fuller, which involves a group of men trapped in a cave. Sharpen your legal reasoning skills and discover the fascinating aspects of these influential cases.
Make Your Own Quizzes and Flashcards
Convert your notes into interactive study material.
Get started for free
