5 Questions
What basic information should be included in the critique of any type of journal article?
Title of article, author(s) name(s), journal title, volume number, date, month, page numbers
What should be considered when critiquing the abstract of a journal article?
Specificity, representativeness, and correct form
What is a specific consideration for critiquing empirical/research articles?
Appropriateness of study design and methods
Which aspect should be evaluated regarding the presentation of procedures in a research article?
Sufficiency for enabling replication
1.7
Are the statistical methods appropriate.
Study Notes
Critiquing a Journal Article
- When critiquing a journal article, basic information to be included are:
- Key findings and implications
- Methodology and design
- Strengths and limitations
- Results and their significance
- Conclusion and recommendations
Critiquing an Abstract
- When critiquing the abstract of a journal article, consider:
- Clarity and conciseness
- Accuracy in representing the full article
- Inclusion of key findings and implications
- Ability to stand alone as a summary
Critiquing Empirical/Research Articles
- A specific consideration for critiquing empirical/research articles is:
- The validity and reliability of the data collection and analysis methods
Evaluating Procedures in a Research Article
- When evaluating the presentation of procedures in a research article, consider:
- Clarity and detail in describing the methodology
- Adherence to ethical standards
- Applicability and generalizability of the procedures
- Potential biases and limitations
Learn how to critique different types of journal articles by addressing basic information, such as the title, author(s), journal details, problem statement, and the author's purpose, approach, hypothesis, and conclusions. This will help you understand the key components of a well-structured critique.
Make Your Own Quizzes and Flashcards
Convert your notes into interactive study material.
Get started for free
