38 Questions
What was the purpose of Robert-Houdin's mission in Algeria?
To outperform the marabouts and demonstrate French magic's superiority
What was the role of the marabouts in Algerian society?
They were holy men and religious teachers
Why were the French military struggling to subdue the Algerians?
Due to the stiff and protracted local resistance
What was the purpose of stage magic in European society prior to Robert-Houdin's mission?
To champion Reason and Science and demystify superstition
What was Robert-Houdin's task in relation to the marabouts?
To outperform them
Who was the French ruler who supposedly asked Robert-Houdin to intervene in Algeria?
Napoleon III
What was the primary purpose of Robert-Houdin's performances?
To create a sense of wonder and curiosity about how the tricks were done
How did Robert-Houdin reinforce the rational credentials of his stage magic?
By building his own devices using the latest scientific theories
What was the purpose of Robert-Houdin's light and heavy box trick?
To showcase the power of electromagnetism
What was the ultimate effect of Robert-Houdin's performances on the audience?
To reinforce the belief that magic is impossible
What was the original target of Robert-Houdin's scientific stage magic?
Fortune-tellers, mediums, and mystical charlatans
What was the result of Robert-Houdin's use of magical enchantment?
A reinforcement of the discourse of disenchantment
How did Robert-Houdin's stage magic find new targets with the expansion of European imperialism?
By targeting new audiences in colonized territories
What was Robert-Houdin's attitude towards the concept of magic?
He saw it as a tool for entertainment and education
What is the underlying assumption about the shaman's behavior?
The shaman does not believe in the magical system.
What is the conclusion drawn about the shaman's rituals?
They are meant to deceive the viewer.
Why were anthropologists obsessed with catching magic-users in the act?
To disprove the notion that magic-users believe in magic.
What can be inferred about the shaman's belief in the magical system?
The shaman knows the magical system is false.
What is the anthropologists' view of 'primitive' magic?
A delusional system believed by the unlearned.
What does the shaman's behavior reveal about their role?
The shaman is a con-artist who deceives others.
What is the underlying motivation behind the shaman's rituals?
To deceive the viewer.
How would you describe the anthropologists' approach to studying societies?
Interventionist and involved.
What is the fundamental assumption of the scientific worldview of the Enlightenment period?
Matter obeys universal physical laws
What is the primary reason why magic was viewed as irrational by the Enlightenment thinkers?
It was not universal and did not obey physical laws
How did the Enlightenment thinkers view the operation of matter in the universe?
Matter operates in a mechanical and deterministic way
What is the implication of a society having an active magical tradition, according to the Enlightenment thinkers?
It is a sign of a society that is at the opposite end of the social evolutionary spectrum from civilization
What is the analogy used to describe the operation of fundamental particles in the scientific worldview?
Fundamental particles are like billiard balls
Why would the idea of magic be seen as incompatible with the concept of electricity?
Because electricity operates according to physical laws, while magic does not
What is the criterion for a rational explanation of natural phenomena, according to the Enlightenment thinkers?
That it is based on empirical evidence and universal physical laws
What is the characteristic of a 'primitive' magical tradition, according to the Enlightenment thinkers?
It is based on supernatural forces and operates in a unique way for each individual
What is a commonality between anthropology and the Enlightenment project?
Proclaiming the objective supremacy of Reason, science, and civilisation
What do stage magicians and anthropologists like Tylor have in common?
They both narratively perform linguistic recreations of magic rituals
What is the result of the anthropologists' and stage magicians' performances?
The audience's faith in the progress of Reason and modern Europe's cultural superiority is reinforced
Why might anthropology have turned its attention to stage magic?
Because both are in need of analysis and share similar knowledge-systems
What is the author suggesting might be a subject of investigation by anthropologists?
Anthropology itself
What is the similarity between 'primitive' magic and stage magic?
Both are in need of analysis and share similar knowledge-systems
What prevented people from noticing the similarities between 'primitive' magic, stage magic, and anthropology?
The dichotomy between savagery and civilisation, or between reason and magic
What is the outcome of the anthropologists' and stage magicians' performances on the audience?
The audience is disenchanted with the magic and it is explained away by appeal to science and reason
Study Notes
French Colonization of Algeria
- In the mid-19th century, French forces encountered resistance from Algerians, taking 45 years to subdue the opposition.
Robert-Houdin's Mission
- French ruler Napoleon III asked Robert-Houdin to assist in pacifying Algeria by outperforming marabout magicians.
- Marabouts were holy men and religious teachers who used magic to convince people of their supernatural powers, leading rebellions against the French occupation.
- Robert-Houdin's mission was to demonstrate French magic as superior, creating the appearance of magical effects while reinforcing the notion that nothing supernatural was taking place.
Robert-Houdin's Stage Magic
- Robert-Houdin's performances used the latest scientific developments, such as electromagnetism, to associate stage magic with technique, science, and technological ingenuity.
- He delighted his audience with magic feats while reinforcing the belief that magic was impossible and that everything was just technique and illusion.
Imperialism and Disenchantment
- Robert-Houdin's stage magic served to reinforce the discourse of disenchantment, teaching the audience to look for natural causes for every supposedly supernatural event.
- The scientific worldview of the period saw the universe as made up of particles obeying universal physical laws, with matter behaving in a mechanical fashion.
'Primitive' Magic vs. Stage Magic
- 'Primitive' magic was viewed as irrational, offending the sensibilities of educated Europeans who believed in a rational, scientific understanding of natural phenomena.
- Stage magic, on the other hand, was seen as rational, associating magic with technique, science, and technological ingenuity.
Anthropology and Stage Magic
- Anthropology, as a product of the Enlightenment project, sought to demonstrate its scientific credibility by debunking superstition and irrationality.
- Anthropologists resembled stage magicians, performing linguistic recreations of exotic magic rituals, enchanting the audience, and then disenchanting the magic by explaining it away through science and rational evolution.
Learn about the French colonization of Algeria in the mid-19th century, including Napoleon III's strategy to pacify the opposition using a magician.
Make Your Own Quizzes and Flashcards
Convert your notes into interactive study material.
Get started for free
