Faith, Tradition, and Fear of God

Choose a study mode

Play Quiz
Study Flashcards
Spaced Repetition
Chat to Lesson

Podcast

Play an AI-generated podcast conversation about this lesson
Download our mobile app to listen on the go
Get App

Questions and Answers

What are the two objectives for studying Emunah, according to Rav Saadia Gaon (Rasag)?

  1. To prove the truth of Mesorah (tradition). 2. To know how to answer those who deny God and Torah.

According to Rabbi Yehuda Albo, what quality must Emunah (faith) possess? According to Rashaz of Ladi, what is Emunah (Faith)?

Albo: Emunah (faith) must be so clear to a person as if he sees it with his own eyes. Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi: Emunah (faith) means trust and habit; a person must accustom himself to believe in God in every situation, whether it is revealed or hidden.

According to Ramchal, what is the difference between the study of Yirat Hashem (fear of God) and all other studies?

Ramchal explains that the wise used to study Yira, Gemara, Halacha, but not Mussar (ethics), because it was too simple for them; common people studied Mussar but not Yira, because it was not for them. Ultimately, the wise did not study Mussar and the common people did not study Torah.

According to Ramchal, why do "most quick witted people" not study the study of Yirah (fear) and cling to God?

<p>According to Ramchal, the reason &quot;most quick witted and insightful people&quot; do not engage in the study of <em>Yirah</em> (fear) and clinging to God is because they felt this was too simple for them.</p>
Signup and view all the answers

Why does Rav Kook emphasize the need to delve deeply into the study of Emunah (faith)?

<p>Rav Kook emphasizes deep study because today's generation seeks understanding and explanations; learning Emunah (faith) out of fear is insufficient, as the generation seeks profound answers to every question.</p>
Signup and view all the answers

What is the error in understanding the concept of "Bitachon" (trust) and what is the difference between Emunah (faith) and Bitachon (trust)?

<p>Bitachon (trust)=A person thinks that good will happen because of his bitachon in G-d. Emunah (faith)=A general view, Halacha faith. A man doesn't know what future will bring.</p>
Signup and view all the answers

According to Rav Kook, why are there Torah learners who leave for bad culture?

<p>According to Rav Kook, every Jew has a particular area of Torah suited to him. If a person learns something that is not a suitable fit, he will have an internal resistance to learning, which can lead him to distance himself from religion.</p>
Signup and view all the answers

What is the "pillar around which Emunah revolves," and why is it important?

<ol> <li>Believe in the days of the Messiah 2) God is the leader 3) there is no likeness or body to God 4) God is the ancient one in the world 5) God is one God 6) Believe in the resurrection of the dead.</li> </ol>
Signup and view all the answers

If all matters of Emunah are achieved through investigations... what is the wise point that you gave in prophecy and in signs and wonders?

<p>Attaining truth through reason takes time, with many potentially erring or adopting false beliefs; prophecy, signs, and wonders therefore offer a direct, divine alternative.</p>
Signup and view all the answers

What is "The great measure of kindness" and the two meanings of this measure that were missed by Iyov?

<p>The greatest measure of kindness is participating in the burden and sorrow of the community: 1) Identification with the suffering of others 2) Identification with the suffering of an individual.</p>
Signup and view all the answers

What are the two advantages of praying in a tzibur (congregation), according to Yehuda Halevi?

<p>According to Yehuda Halevi, the two advantages of praying in a <em>tzibur</em> (congregation) are: 1. When a community prays, their prayer is for the benefit of the entire community, and therefore does not harm individuals. 2. Sometimes a person's prayer is faulty or not focused, so their prayer is incomplete - the <em>tzibur</em> (congregation) completes the prayer as one complete prayer.</p>
Signup and view all the answers

How is the "inner self" of the first man created and how is it created with the people of Israel?

<p>The first man listened to the advice of the snake and sinned because he did not listen to his inner self. When a person becomes more elevated in holiness or when the people of Israel behave with more holiness so the inner self of that person or with is revealed.</p>
Signup and view all the answers

What are the two foundations that build the holiness of Israel and what is the relationship between them, according to Rav Kook?

<ol> <li>Intrinsic Soul: In every Jew is a soul with an inner holy power. 2. Choice: a Jewish person can choose whether to engage in Torah and Mitzvot. The soul of a person can reveal itself only when one chooses true choice.</li> </ol>
Signup and view all the answers

How does Rav Kook encourage educators, that the activity they are doing is not for nothing?

<p>Education is an internal and slow process of discovering the soul, a divine mission and a means of repairing the world. This understanding can strengthen the spirit of educators and fill their work with deep meaning.</p>
Signup and view all the answers

According to Rabbeinu Bahya, what is a person obligated to study? What does Rabbi Nachman say regarding keeping Mitzvot (commandments)?

<p>Rabbeinu Bahya: One is obligated to study the obligations of the limbs and the obligations of the hearts because it constitutes a basis for the fulfillment of the commandments. Rabbi Nachman: To follow mitzvot without any questions.</p>
Signup and view all the answers

What is Rav Kook's criticism of the education given in our generation?

<p>Rav Kook explains that in his generation the power of thought influenced less and they were given to serving God out of fear-mitzvot out of routine or fear. In our generation however the teachers need to see the inner qualities of the students and not just external because this is a generation that demands deep answers and explanations.</p>
Signup and view all the answers

Are Rav Kook's words about education in his generation relevant to our generation?

<p>According to me his words aren't relevant because today students are not afraid of punishment (if they do something wrong), so teaching them to believe through fear won't help. Therefore you need to teach them to love Emunah and learn with their own will, a personal desire to explore and discover.</p>
Signup and view all the answers

What is the Ba'al HaTanya's explanation for the term "Faith"?

<p>The Ba'al Hatanya says that the term &quot;faith&quot; is from the word &quot;training,&quot; a person needs to train himself to believe in Hashem in every situation regardless of whether that situation is good or bad, known or hidden.</p>
Signup and view all the answers

The Chazon Ish says that one needs to believe that Hashem will save us from suffering, is this compatible with the officer's approach?

<p>The Chazon Ish said that we need to trust that God will save us from suffering, to some degree we need to agree with our leader but we shouldn't have blind trust.</p>
Signup and view all the answers

Why does the Midrash (homiletic story) return and emphasize that Abraham was "grieving" in his searches after God?

<p>Abraham concluded that there is a god that manages the world without seeing him, he revealed this through external observations and the exercise of reason.</p>
Signup and view all the answers

What dream did the king of the Khazars dream, and what did he decide to do as a result of the dream?

<p>He saw in a dream that an angel told him that his intentions were commendable, but not his actions. As a result, he decided to embark on a quest to find some worthy action that the angel would commend.</p>
Signup and view all the answers

What is the requirement of the quality of kindness from a person doing kindness with another?

<p>The measure of kindness requires a person to give kindness with another person more then his own personal interest.</p>
Signup and view all the answers

What is the appropriate way to study Mesilat Yesharim?

<p>The book is intended not to discover new insights but it is for memorizing the simple things, to remember them and fulfill them-although they are very simple it is important to repeat and memorize them.</p>
Signup and view all the answers

What was the sin of the first man?

<p>According to me his words are not relevant because today students are not afraid of punishment therefore you need to teach them to love Emunah and learn with their own will, a personal desire to explore and discover.</p>
Signup and view all the answers

What is Rav Kook's criticism of educators?

<p>Educators are unable to look into the pupils 'personality but they teach things that are on the outside.</p>
Signup and view all the answers

What is the field of study in Mesilat Yesharim and why are so few engaged there?

<p>Ethical lessons - because the sages were engaged in Torah study, they neglected the ethical lessons and saw them as unimportant.</p>
Signup and view all the answers

What is the great importance of Mussar according to Ramchal?

<p>Ramchal explains that to develop the quality of ones self is not less important then learning Torah.</p>
Signup and view all the answers

What is the downside of the education towards Emunah and Musar by the way of education?

<p>If they don't learn Emunah by the source of education they will not have the ability to deal with our generations questions.</p>
Signup and view all the answers

According to Rabbenu Bachya, what foundation is essential for observing mitzvot? How does Rabbi Nachman approach the performance of Mitzvot?

<p>Rabbenu Bachya says that it is essential to learn about the obligations of the body and the obligations of the heart since this is a foundation for doing Mitzvot (commandments). Rabbi Nachman explains that to follow mitzvot without any questions.</p>
Signup and view all the answers

Flashcards

What are the two purposes for studying faith?

To prove the tradition's accuracy and know how to respond to heretics.

What is faith according to Rabbi Albo and Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi?

Albo: Clear as seeing with your own eyes. Maladi: Faith is trust and habit, believing in all situations.

What is the difference between learning yirat Hashem and other subjects, according to Ramchal?

In the past, scholars didn't learn mussar, as it was too simple; common people didn't learn yirat Hashem, so both lacked learning.

According to the Ramchal, why do most quick-witted/smart people not study yirah and devekut?

Quick-witted people think it's too basic and neglect to study yirat Hashem and devekut.

Signup and view all the flashcards

Why does Rabbi Kook emphasize deepening the study of faith?

This generation seeks understanding, so learning faith through fear isn't enough; deep answers are needed.

Signup and view all the flashcards

What is the mistake in understanding 'bitachon'? What's the difference between 'emuna' and 'bitachon'?

Mistakenly, people think good results come from belief. True faith: outlook; Bitachon: Human action related

Signup and view all the flashcards

According to Rabbi Kook, why do some Torah learners embrace negative culture?

Each person has a path in Torah that suits them. If not, they may feel internal resistance and distance themselves from religion.

Signup and view all the flashcards

What are the pillars around which faith revolves?

Believe in Mashiach, Divine Leader, unique Divine Being, immaterality, God exists, afterlife.

Signup and view all the flashcards

If faith issues are resolved by investigations, what's the point of prophecy?

Prophecy bypasses the need for long, potentially flawed investigations.

Signup and view all the flashcards

What is 'the greatest act of kindness'? What two parts make it up.

Participation in public and personal suffering.

Signup and view all the flashcards

What are the advantages of public prayer?

The group's prayer is for the benefit of all so it doesn't harm singular people; If some have poor kavana the tzibbur completes it.

Signup and view all the flashcards

How is the 'inner self' created in individuals and in Israel?

The first person failed to connect to inner self; increased spirituality reveals the inner self.

Signup and view all the flashcards

What creates sanctity according to Rav Kook?

Natural soul's holiness and the free will to study Torah/Mitzvot that reveals soul.

Signup and view all the flashcards

How does Rav Kook encourage educators?

Education needs to be the slow,internal reveal of soul instead of just lecturing kids.

Signup and view all the flashcards

What is Avodat Hashem with innocence, according to Rabbeinu Bachya and Rav Nachman?

Rabbeinu Bachya explains the obligation learn the body, and mind's obligations in mitzvot through thmimus, Rav Nachman mitzvot performed without question.

Signup and view all the flashcards

What Rav Kook's criticism regarding current education?

Critical, because their teaching is external, not addressing student's internal needs.

Signup and view all the flashcards

Is the past advice about education relevent?

No, people should connect out of love, not fear.

Signup and view all the flashcards

What is The Tanya definition of faith?

Faith is about practicing belief even when things are good or bad, clear or hidden.

Signup and view all the flashcards

According to Chazon Ish is believing enough?

The Chazon Ish says to believe the Almighty will help you from any type of suffering as long as one meets the leaders demands.

Signup and view all the flashcards

Why did the Midrash emphasize Avraham's 'agony' in seeking God?

Avraham inferred Divine direction without being shown through external observation

Signup and view all the flashcards

What dream did the King of Kouzar have and was did he learn from it.

dream from a angel that told the King of Kuzari only his intent was good and the rest wasn't.

Signup and view all the flashcards

How kindess relates to someone else.

kindness requires action only and good intent is not enough.

Signup and view all the flashcards

What the proper mindset to have to learn massilas yesharim.

the point of the book is reviwing the basics and putting the concepts into practice, not just reading

Signup and view all the flashcards

What wsa eht first human sin?

listening to hte naccah and not the inner self

Signup and view all the flashcards

what is the rabbi kook critque on educator?

does not teach the students inner self, instead they tach just the outward things

Signup and view all the flashcards

What is important in life?

in the world and in the yesharim we need to learn it all .

Signup and view all the flashcards

why important develop yoruself

it is important to develop yourself. its that importatn

Signup and view all the flashcards

why improtatn tahe faith

it is improtant to have faith

Signup and view all the flashcards

Study Notes

  • In the name of God
  • A plea to save from thoughts of Israel

Goals of Studying Faith According to Saadia Gaon

  • To prove the correctness of tradition
  • To know what to answer to heretics

Definition of Faith According to Different Scholars

  • Albo: Faith must be as clear as if a person saw it with their own eyes.
  • Maladi: Faith is trust and habit; a person must accustom themself to believe in God in every situation, whether it is revealed or hidden.

Difference Between Learning Fear of God and Other Studies, According to Ramchal

  • The wise used to study fear, Talmud, and law but not morality because it was too simple for them.
  • People who studied morality did not study fear because it was not for the common people.
  • The wise ultimately did not study morality, and the common people did not study Torah.

Why Most Intellectuals Do Not Delve into Fear and Devotion

  • Every wise person agreed that it was important but neglected the subject daily, claiming it was too simple for them.

Rav Kook's Emphasis on Deepening the Study of Faith Today

  • Today's generation seeks to understand and receive explanations.
  • Studying faith out of fear is not enough, and the generation seeks profound answers to every question.

The Flaw in Understanding "Security" and the Difference Between Faith and Security

  • People think there is a good reality and a bad reality, and one must believe the good option will occur through God's security.
  • A person does not know what the future consequences will be.
  • Faith is a general view and law, while security is a person's view of themself and their actions.

Why Torah Learners Emerge into Bad Culture, According to Rav Kook

  • Every person in Israel has a specific area in the Torah that suits them.
  • If a person learns something unsuitable, they will feel internal resistance, potentially leading them away from religion.

Pillar of Faith

  • Remembering the event at Mount Sinai, where God commanded to remember it for generations and teach it to our children.
  • Believing in the days of the Messiah
  • God is a leader.
  • God has no image or body.
  • God is the first in the world.
  • God is one.
  • Believing in the resurrection of the dead

The Wisdom of Prophecy, Signs and Wonders

  • Attaining truth through intellect is possible but takes a long time. In the process, many may reach wrong conclusions or false beliefs.
  • God sent prophecy, signs, and wonders.

The Greatest Kindness

  • Participating in the burden and sorrow of the community.
  • Identifying with the suffering of others
  • Identifying with the suffering of an individual

Advantages of Prayer in Public According to Yehuda Halevi

  • Public prayer benefits the entire community and does not harm individuals.
  • If an individual's prayer is flawed or not focused, the community completes the prayer into one whole prayer.

Forming the "Inner Self"

  • Adam listened to the snake’s counsel over his inner self.
  • The "inner self" is created through increased holiness in an individual through righteous behavior.

Two Elements Building the Holiness of Israel, According to Rav Kook

  • Virtue: Every Jew has a soul with an inner sacred power.
  • Choice: Every Jew can choose whether to engage in Torah and commandments.
  • The virtue of a person can be revealed only when they make the right choice.

How Rabbi Kook Encourages Educators

  • Education is a slow internal process of revealing the soul, a divine mission, and a means to repair the world.
  • This understanding can strengthen the spirit of educators and fill their work with deep meaning.

Service of God With Innocence

  • Rabbeinu Bahya: It is obligatory to learn the obligation of the limbs and the obligation of the hearts because this constitutes the basis for the fulfillment of the commandments.
  • Rabbi Nachman: To fulfill commandments without any inquiry

Rabbi Kook's Critique on Education

  • In his generation, the power of thought had less influence, and people were led by fear or habit-based commandments.
  • Today, teachers must see the inner selves , otherwise it will not resonate
  • They must see the the learners internal beliefs and motives rather than external behaviors because the current generation demands answers and deep explanations.

Relevance of Rabbi Kook's Words Today

  • Rabbi Kook's words are not relevant today, as students are not afraid of punishment and threatening them or teaching them to believe through fear will not help.
  • Teaching students to love faith and study it through personal desire to explore and discover is more effective.

Explanation of Faith

  • Faith is the language of trust and habit, and a person needs to accustom themself to believe in God, whether it is good or bad, revealed or hidden.

Faith and Trust

  • According to Hazon Ish, one must believe that God will save us from trouble
  • The standard of conduct must match faith through the commander's words.

Why the Midrash Repeated That Abraham Was "Sorry" During His Searches

  • Abraham concluded there is a God who runs the world without us seeing him
  • He divined this through outward observation and the operation of the intellect.

The Story and the Decision

  • The King of Khazar had a dream where an angel told him his intentions were good, but his actions were not.
  • Following the dream, he decided to go out and search for an act that the angel would approve of.

The Requirement of the Trait of Kindness

  • The trait of kindness requires a person to do kindness to others and not to relate to things only for their own benefit.

The Suitable Way to Study

  • The book is not meant for one to read new novelties, but to review and learn the simple things, to remember them and fulfill them
  • It is important to repeat and review them, even though they are very simple.

The Sin of the First Man

  • The sin that the first man committed was not listening to his inner self and instead listening to the snake
  • He was punished for it.

Rabbi Kook’s Critique of Educators

  • Educators are unable to look at the inwardness of the student and only come to teach external things unrelated to the person's inner self.

The Topic of Study and Why People Do Not Study It Much

  • Because the wise were occupied with studying Torah, they neglected the study of morality and saw it as unimportant.

Importance of Morality According to Ramchal

  • To invest effort in developing the field of one's traits because it is no less important than studying Torah

Drawbacks

  • There is still much to fix regarding morality in our generation, and regarding faith, if one does not learn deeply according to the requirements of the generation, one will not be able to cope with the questions of our generation.

Studying That Suits You

Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.

Quiz Team

Related Documents

More Like This

Tanya Chapter 1 Flashcards
17 questions

Tanya Chapter 1 Flashcards

EffortlessGyrolite7402 avatar
EffortlessGyrolite7402
Joodse Filosofie en Eichmann Analyse
15 questions
Maimonides: Jewish Philosophy and Law
8 questions
Use Quizgecko on...
Browser
Browser