Podcast
Questions and Answers
What treatment methods were used on individuals believed to be possessed by evil spirits?
What treatment methods were used on individuals believed to be possessed by evil spirits?
- Herbal remedies
- Community support
- Gentle counseling
- Horrifying tortures (correct)
What was one way that elites diverted attention from their own failings?
What was one way that elites diverted attention from their own failings?
- By blaming individuals on possession by the Devil (correct)
- By promoting education
- By encouraging public debate
- By implementing social reforms
Who were primarily accused of witchcraft during the pre-18th century?
Who were primarily accused of witchcraft during the pre-18th century?
- Children of farmers
- Economically independent women (correct)
- Clergy members
- Elderly men
What shift in thinking occurred due to the scientific revolution during the Enlightenment?
What shift in thinking occurred due to the scientific revolution during the Enlightenment?
What idea did Enlightenment philosophers promote about society?
What idea did Enlightenment philosophers promote about society?
What role did public executions play in society pre-18th century?
What role did public executions play in society pre-18th century?
What was a significant outcome of blaming the Devil for social problems?
What was a significant outcome of blaming the Devil for social problems?
Which of the following best describes the view of society by Enlightenment thinkers?
Which of the following best describes the view of society by Enlightenment thinkers?
What is a significant reform suggested by the Classical School?
What is a significant reform suggested by the Classical School?
Which of the following is a limitation of the Classical School?
Which of the following is a limitation of the Classical School?
How does the Classical School of thought view the timing of punishment?
How does the Classical School of thought view the timing of punishment?
What principle does the Classical School advocate regarding laws?
What principle does the Classical School advocate regarding laws?
What is one of the key contributions of the Classical School to criminal law?
What is one of the key contributions of the Classical School to criminal law?
What was a primary goal of Neoclassical criminologists?
What was a primary goal of Neoclassical criminologists?
The Statistical School was primarily associated with which of the following methodologies?
The Statistical School was primarily associated with which of the following methodologies?
According to the Statistical School, criminality is largely a result of what?
According to the Statistical School, criminality is largely a result of what?
Which characteristic is NOT considered by Neoclassical criminologists when individualizing sentences?
Which characteristic is NOT considered by Neoclassical criminologists when individualizing sentences?
Which school of thought emphasized the influence of external social forces on behavior?
Which school of thought emphasized the influence of external social forces on behavior?
Which statement best describes the Positive School's view on crime causation?
Which statement best describes the Positive School's view on crime causation?
What limitation did the Statistical School face during its time?
What limitation did the Statistical School face during its time?
Which of the following best describes the approach of Lombroso and the Positive School?
Which of the following best describes the approach of Lombroso and the Positive School?
What was a major criticism made by Beccaria regarding the justice system of the time?
What was a major criticism made by Beccaria regarding the justice system of the time?
What assumption is the Classical theory of crime based on?
What assumption is the Classical theory of crime based on?
According to the Classical theory, what is considered the most effective form of punishment?
According to the Classical theory, what is considered the most effective form of punishment?
What did Beccaria’s essay emphasize about the nature of laws and punishments?
What did Beccaria’s essay emphasize about the nature of laws and punishments?
What was one of the consequences of the Classical School's influence on criminal justice?
What was one of the consequences of the Classical School's influence on criminal justice?
In the context of the Classical School, what is meant by the term 'social contract'?
In the context of the Classical School, what is meant by the term 'social contract'?
What key reform did the Classical School advocate for regarding the penalties for crimes?
What key reform did the Classical School advocate for regarding the penalties for crimes?
What was the primary goal of reforms proposed by Classical theorists?
What was the primary goal of reforms proposed by Classical theorists?
What was a key reason Lombroso's theories were accepted during his time?
What was a key reason Lombroso's theories were accepted during his time?
How did Lombroso distinguish criminals in his theories?
How did Lombroso distinguish criminals in his theories?
Which category did Lombroso not include in his classification of offenders?
Which category did Lombroso not include in his classification of offenders?
What was a common belief about the cause of unusual phenomena prior to the 18th century?
What was a common belief about the cause of unusual phenomena prior to the 18th century?
What assumption did Lombroso make about individuals in prison?
What assumption did Lombroso make about individuals in prison?
What was one of the criticisms of Lombroso's methodology?
What was one of the criticisms of Lombroso's methodology?
According to Judeo-Christian teachings, what is one explanation for sinful behavior?
According to Judeo-Christian teachings, what is one explanation for sinful behavior?
Which characteristic did Lombroso associate with robbers?
Which characteristic did Lombroso associate with robbers?
What key principle characterizes the Classical School of criminology?
What key principle characterizes the Classical School of criminology?
Which of the following criticisms was directed at the Classical School?
Which of the following criticisms was directed at the Classical School?
What reasoning did Lombroso provide for women being less criminal?
What reasoning did Lombroso provide for women being less criminal?
Who did Lombroso classify as having criminal behavior due to mental illness?
Who did Lombroso classify as having criminal behavior due to mental illness?
What aspect of crime did the Positive School seek to address?
What aspect of crime did the Positive School seek to address?
What was a significant influence of the Positive School on the field of criminology?
What was a significant influence of the Positive School on the field of criminology?
What is the view of possession in pre-18th century theories of crime?
What is the view of possession in pre-18th century theories of crime?
Which area of research did the Positive School influence in the early 20th century?
Which area of research did the Positive School influence in the early 20th century?
Flashcards
Pre-18th Century Crime Theories
Pre-18th Century Crime Theories
Belief that evil spirits or supernatural forces caused criminal behavior.
Evil Spirits and Magic
Evil Spirits and Magic
People believed that unusual events, like natural disasters or illnesses, were caused by evil spirits.
Possession by Evil Spirits
Possession by Evil Spirits
The belief that people possessed by evil spirits were responsible for criminal behavior.
Temptation
Temptation
Signup and view all the flashcards
Sinful and Morally Inferior
Sinful and Morally Inferior
Signup and view all the flashcards
Pre-Enlightenment Crime Theories
Pre-Enlightenment Crime Theories
Signup and view all the flashcards
Evil Spirits and Pathological Behavior
Evil Spirits and Pathological Behavior
Signup and view all the flashcards
Judeo-Christian Influence on Crime Theories
Judeo-Christian Influence on Crime Theories
Signup and view all the flashcards
Witchcraft Torture
Witchcraft Torture
Signup and view all the flashcards
Trials by Fire or Combat
Trials by Fire or Combat
Signup and view all the flashcards
Demonic Possession Theory
Demonic Possession Theory
Signup and view all the flashcards
Diverting Attention Theory
Diverting Attention Theory
Signup and view all the flashcards
Witchcraft Accusations Against Women
Witchcraft Accusations Against Women
Signup and view all the flashcards
Scientific Revolution and Crime
Scientific Revolution and Crime
Signup and view all the flashcards
Enlightenment and Social Contract
Enlightenment and Social Contract
Signup and view all the flashcards
Enlightenment View of Crime
Enlightenment View of Crime
Signup and view all the flashcards
Classical Theory of Crime
Classical Theory of Crime
Signup and view all the flashcards
Deterrence Theory
Deterrence Theory
Signup and view all the flashcards
Deterrence Principles
Deterrence Principles
Signup and view all the flashcards
Equality Before the Law
Equality Before the Law
Signup and view all the flashcards
Fixed Penalties for Crimes
Fixed Penalties for Crimes
Signup and view all the flashcards
The Positive School
The Positive School
Signup and view all the flashcards
The Statistical School
The Statistical School
Signup and view all the flashcards
What were the core ideas of the Statistical School?
What were the core ideas of the Statistical School?
Signup and view all the flashcards
How did the Statistical School view the causes of crime?
How did the Statistical School view the causes of crime?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What did Lombroso believe about criminals?
What did Lombroso believe about criminals?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What were the key features of the Positive School?
What were the key features of the Positive School?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What was the main difference between the Classical School and the Positive School?
What was the main difference between the Classical School and the Positive School?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What was the goal of the Neoclassical School?
What was the goal of the Neoclassical School?
Signup and view all the flashcards
Classical School of Criminology
Classical School of Criminology
Signup and view all the flashcards
Cesare Beccaria
Cesare Beccaria
Signup and view all the flashcards
Rational Choice Theory
Rational Choice Theory
Signup and view all the flashcards
Proportionality of Punishment
Proportionality of Punishment
Signup and view all the flashcards
Free Will
Free Will
Signup and view all the flashcards
Social Contract
Social Contract
Signup and view all the flashcards
Criminal Deterrence
Criminal Deterrence
Signup and view all the flashcards
Lombroso's Atavism Theory
Lombroso's Atavism Theory
Signup and view all the flashcards
What are 'stigmata' in Lombroso's theory?
What are 'stigmata' in Lombroso's theory?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What physical traits did Lombroso associate with robbers?
What physical traits did Lombroso associate with robbers?
Signup and view all the flashcards
How did Lombroso explain women's lower crime rates?
How did Lombroso explain women's lower crime rates?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What were Lombroso's categories of criminals?
What were Lombroso's categories of criminals?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What were the criticisms of Lombroso's theories?
What were the criticisms of Lombroso's theories?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What was the core of Lombroso's theory?
What was the core of Lombroso's theory?
Signup and view all the flashcards
Are Lombroso's theories still accepted today?
Are Lombroso's theories still accepted today?
Signup and view all the flashcards
Study Notes
Early Theories of Criminology
- Prior to the 18th century, theories of crime were rooted in religious beliefs and superstition. Widespread belief existed in evil spirits and magic. People attributed unusual natural occurrences to evil spirits, leading to the belief that human behaviour was also influenced by them.
- Judeo-Christian teachings offered two perspectives: Temptation, where humans have free will, or Possession, where wrongdoers were believed to be possessed by evil spirits. Severe and often fatal methods were used to remove these spirits.
- Religious and political elites used blaming social problems on evil spirits to silence rebellion and divert attention from their failings.
- Drawing and quartering was a common, horrific punishment during the Middle Ages.
- Witches were scapegoats for anger, and often women, especially those economically independent, were accused. Their presence in communities challenged existing male-dominated power structures, and public executions reasserted male authority. Thousands were executed for witchcraft between the 15th and 17th centuries.
- The Scientific Revolution during the Enlightenment caused a paradigm shift in thinking toward systematic doubt and empirical validation. This shift moved away from religious superstition to naturalistic explanations and the scientific method (observation). This prompted scientific approaches to understanding crime and criminal behaviour.
- Enlightenment philosophers posited a social contract, where individuals voluntarily surrendered some freedoms for a safer society, and the state was responsible for security and adhering to citizens' rights.
- The Classical School of criminology, emerging in the 18th and early 19th centuries, was the first formal school of thought in the field. It reformed the administration of justice and the prison system.
- Cesare Beccaria's Essay on Crime and Punishments (1764), critiqued the cruelty, inhumanity, and arbitrariness of existing justice systems, advocating for punishments proportionate to the harm caused. In 18th century England, 350 offenses were punishable by death.
- The Classical Theory posited that individuals are rational beings who calculate the consequences of their actions, and therefore penalties deter crime. Justice and punishment should fit the crime and be swift and certain, proportional to the harm, to maintain a functioning social contract. The principle of equal punishment for equal crimes did not account for individual circumstances.
- Specific Reforms introduced by the Classical school included eliminating executions for minor offenses, clear and accessible laws, separate lawmaking and judging powers, and public proceedings.
- Neoclassical Theory introduced flexibility to the laws and justice system, considering individual circumstances (e.g., age, socio-economic status). Judges were given more discretion.
- The Statistical School emerged in the first half of the 19th century, using statistics to explore social issues and structural explanations of crime, associating with Positivism. They rejected the notion of humans as rational beings; instead seeing behaviour (including criminality) as a result of social conditions.
- Scholars gathered data in this school to look at crime patterns over time and space, concluding they stemmed from social forces. This work anticipated later sociological theories.
- The Positive School (associated with Lombroso) used scientific methods to study crime, proposing that crime is caused by biological factors. They viewed criminals as a distinct physical type or atavists (less evolved).
- Lombroso believed physical characteristics (“stigmata”) like facial features, could predict criminality. Women were deemed less criminal due to maternal instincts, piety, and lack of passion. Offenders were categorized (e.g., criminals of passion, epileptics, criminaloids). His scientific methods were flawed and unsystematic.
- Subsequent researchers like Goring and Hooton attempted to validate or build upon Lombroso's theories, studying physical and intellectual differences and associating them with crime. Hooton advocated for the segregation of "unfit individuals", leading to the eugenics movement.
- Somatotype theory, developed by Sheldon in the 1950s, categorized body types (endomorphs, ectomorphs, mesomorphs) with purported personality correlations to crime.
- Goddard suggested feeblemindedness and criminality were inherited traits, measuring IQs among prisoners. His research lacked consideration of social factors.
- The eugenics movement, influenced by poor research, led to the involuntary sterilization of individuals with intellectual disabilities, highlighting the potential harm of applying biological theories to legal policy.
- Modern research continues to investigate the role of biological and social factors in determining criminal behaviour.
Summary
- Early criminology theories, initially grounded in religious beliefs and superstition, shifted to scientific approaches.
- Classical school theories focused on rational actors and proportionate punishment. While influential, they were rigid.
- Positivist theories explored biological factors, influenced early legal systems regarding criminals. However, these were often problematic in methodology and conclusions.
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.