Podcast
Questions and Answers
What do externalities signify in the context of economic production?
What do externalities signify in the context of economic production?
According to Herman Daly, which issue should be addressed foremost in economic sustainability?
According to Herman Daly, which issue should be addressed foremost in economic sustainability?
How does Elinor Ostrom's work challenge the concept of 'The Tragedy of the Commons'?
How does Elinor Ostrom's work challenge the concept of 'The Tragedy of the Commons'?
What does the relationship between institutions and resources signify in Ostrom's analysis?
What does the relationship between institutions and resources signify in Ostrom's analysis?
Signup and view all the answers
What aspect does Nicholas Georgescu-Roegen highlight regarding the economy?
What aspect does Nicholas Georgescu-Roegen highlight regarding the economy?
Signup and view all the answers
Which of the following is NOT a focus of Elinor Ostrom's study on common pool resources?
Which of the following is NOT a focus of Elinor Ostrom's study on common pool resources?
Signup and view all the answers
In the context of ecological economics, what is NOT a consequence of externalities?
In the context of ecological economics, what is NOT a consequence of externalities?
Signup and view all the answers
What is considered the optimal condition for managing common resources according to Ostrom?
What is considered the optimal condition for managing common resources according to Ostrom?
Signup and view all the answers
What is a primary focus of ecological economics in terms of measuring economic flows?
What is a primary focus of ecological economics in terms of measuring economic flows?
Signup and view all the answers
Which analysis method does ecological economics prefer for evaluating environmental projects?
Which analysis method does ecological economics prefer for evaluating environmental projects?
Signup and view all the answers
According to ecological economics, what role does nature play in economic analysis?
According to ecological economics, what role does nature play in economic analysis?
Signup and view all the answers
What is a key question addressed by research in ecological economics regarding ecosystems?
What is a key question addressed by research in ecological economics regarding ecosystems?
Signup and view all the answers
In the context of provisioning systems defined by Fanning et al., what elements interact to satisfy human needs?
In the context of provisioning systems defined by Fanning et al., what elements interact to satisfy human needs?
Signup and view all the answers
What aspect does ecological economics recognize when evaluating projects?
What aspect does ecological economics recognize when evaluating projects?
Signup and view all the answers
Which modeling approach is suggested for better understanding the economy's relationship with ecosystems?
Which modeling approach is suggested for better understanding the economy's relationship with ecosystems?
Signup and view all the answers
What characteristic of ecological systems is recognized in ecological economics?
What characteristic of ecological systems is recognized in ecological economics?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the primary focus of ecological economics?
What is the primary focus of ecological economics?
Signup and view all the answers
How does environmental economics view nature in relation to economic processes?
How does environmental economics view nature in relation to economic processes?
Signup and view all the answers
What does the term 'market failure' refer to in environmental economics?
What does the term 'market failure' refer to in environmental economics?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the main criticism of the neoclassical approach in environmental economics?
What is the main criticism of the neoclassical approach in environmental economics?
Signup and view all the answers
What is a common feature of command-and-control regulations in environmental economics?
What is a common feature of command-and-control regulations in environmental economics?
Signup and view all the answers
In the context of environmental economics, which statement best describes the role of the market?
In the context of environmental economics, which statement best describes the role of the market?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the focus of natural resources economics?
What is the focus of natural resources economics?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the primary goal of focusing on market failures in environmental economics?
What is the primary goal of focusing on market failures in environmental economics?
Signup and view all the answers
Study Notes
Introduction to Economics and Environment
- The course is titled "Topics in Economics and Environment (Jour)"
- The course is offered by IHEC Brussels Management School
- The course dates are 2024-2025
Economics and the Environment
- This section introduces the intersection of economics and environment
Where is the Environment? (Part 1)
- A circular flow diagram illustrates the economy (Mankiw, 2017, p. 23)
- Households and firms interact in markets for goods/services and factors of production.
- The outer set of arrows reflects dollar flow, while the inner shows input/output flow.
Where is the Environment? (Part 2)
- A diagram shows the relationship between various economic concepts including: Monopolistic Competition, Oligopoly, Game Theory, Public Goods, etc and Foundational Consumer Theory
The Conventional View of the Economy
- A diagram illustrates a simple view of the US economy in 1990
- Capital: $3015
- Labor: 2000 hours
- GDP: $23,195 (average per person)
- Source: Hall et al. (2008)
From Classical to Neoclassical Thought
- The first economists, like William Petty (1623–1687), considered labour and land as fundamental factors/mothers of wealth.
- The Physiocrats, led by Francois Quesnay (1694–1774), stressed the role of nature (land) and the net product in wealth creation.
- David Ricardo (1772–1823) focused on labour, differentiating between rent, and profits based on marginal returns versus subsistence wages.
- Classical theory presented land as the framework for wealth distribution & profit, but this notion was simplified from reality, overlooking land degradation.
Classical Economists and Labour
- Land, in classical theory, is the structure within which the economic process operates.
- Nature encompasses the economy.
- The notion of nature is simplified, ignoring concrete reality.
- Physiocrats regarded land as having its own life, while Ricardo treated it as a technical characteristic.
Political Economy in the 19th Century
- Figures include Karl Marx (1818–1883) and William S. Jevons (1835–1882)
Karl Marx
- He expanded Ricardo's labor theory of value to highlight exploitation.
- He analyzed surplus value (difference between produced value & value needed to produce)
- He noted the impact of rural-urban shifts on land use & agricultural practices (Soil erosion, Liebig).
- He recognized the connection between exploitation and ecological degradation
William Stanley Jevons
- Jevons analyzed the relation between economic activity and the depletion of resources, particularly coal.
- He examined costs of production, prices, and quantities.
- Coal extraction is both expansionist and progress driver (steam engine).
- He predicted limits to production related to resource limits & growing exploitation and stagnation costs.
Conservation vs Preservation: Pinchot vs Muir
- G. Pinchot (1865–1946), the first head of the United States Forest Service, advocated for the responsible use of resources (e.g. forestry as tree farming).
- John Muir (1838–1914) emphasized wilderness preservation, influencing the creation of national parks.
The Neoclassical Turning Point
- Classical economics focuses on production costs, material determinants of production, and relationships between social classes.
- Neoclassical economics highlights utility received from production and consumption and psychological aspects of value.
- There's a shift away from empiricism to theoretical speculation.
- Nature is excluded from economic analysis.
Hotelling (1885-1973)
- Hotelling analyzed the exploitation of natural resources from a capital management perspective, but without considering environmental impact.
Realities of Nature Disappear
- Neoclassical economics neglects nature's specifics due to its emphasis on equilibrium conditions, and psychological value theory.
- The economic process is considered autonomous, independent from material conditions.
The Keynesian Turning Point
- Keynesian thought dematerializes economic theory, emphasizing aggregated monetary flows and disregarding material production.
- The economy is seen as a network of monetary flows; the material aspect is unimportant.
Mid-20th Century: Is Nature Back?
- Economists like Arthur C. Pigou (1877–1959) and Ronald Coase (1910–2013) reintroduced environmental concerns into economics, particularly regarding externalities.
Arthur C. Pigou
- Expanded on Marshall's work focusing on market failures and externalities.
- Introduced Pigovian taxes as a policy tool.
Ronald Coase
- Argued that well-defined property rights can mitigate externalities, highlighting transaction costs.
- The ultimate outcome (optimal use/distribution) is not affected by legal framework, if the price system works without cost.
- Coase recognized limits of market-based bargaining
Limits of Coasian Bargaining
- Difficulties with coordinating large groups/multiple polluters hinder market solutions for pollution.
- Special regulations may be more suitable than market transfers in situations of multiple actors or environmental harm.
From First Best to Second Best
- Pigovian taxation and Coase negotiation lead to socially optimized balances.
- The optimal pollution level is determined by economic reasoning in a 'first-best' world.
Second-Best Solutions to Pollution Issues
- Alternative resource and pollution control models are introduced to address complexities and uncertainties involved in cost-effectiveness.
- These include predetermined standards and negotiated permits systems.
Environmental Economics
- Environmental economics applies general neoclassical economic theory to natural resources.
- In classical theory, nature acted as the framework for economic activity.
- Subsequently, nature becomes a component within the economic system.
Economics and the Environment: Very Brief Clarification
- Environmental economics uses neoclassical methodology to address pollution issues.
- Natural resources economics is a separate aspect focusing on resource depletion.
- Ecological economics transcends the conventional framework, encompassing relationships between economics and ecology.
Environmental Economics (Continued)
- Environmental economics primarily focuses on market-based assessment of environmental regulation.
- O. Godard considers market failure necessary for environmental problems.
- Two sides to the market: identification of anomalies, and solution to these anomalies based on a perfect market assumption.
How do Environmental Problems Come into Existence?
- The mechanisms yielding environmental problems are identified as market failures.
- Current environmental policy issues and solutions are considered as aspects of sustainable society.
The Ecological Economics' View
- The perspective depicts the economy within the framework of bio-geo-chemical cycles in which the economy is embedded.
- Nature is the source of economic flows and a lens for their analysis.
- Measures favoring physical aspects over monetary ones are prioritized.
Ecological Economics: A Few Research Streams
- Research streams investigate measures for accounting for ecosystem value.
- Macro-level modeling of economy and ecosystems is considered.
- Strategies for achieving sustainability are explored.
Alternatives to Environmental Economics
- The Limits to Growth model (Club of Rome) questions the ability of current economic activities to sustain population growth without triggering societal collapse.
Modelling the Energy Transition
- The MEDEAS model incorporates factors like energy availability, consumption, and climate impacts.
Some ‘Heterodox’ Approaches
- The critique of 'successful cost transfers', the pervasive nature of externalities, and the role of capitalism in generating them are discussed.
- Production, thermodynamics, and the finite nature of resources are considered.
Ostrom and the Commons
- Ostrom's work challenges the common resource tragedy.
- Ostrom highlights the potential for community-based resource management.
- Important principles of community-based resource management including clear boundaries, participation of affected parties, rule-respect, graduated sanctions, etc.
- The dynamic interrelationships between institutions, communities, and resources are emphasized.
- Nature's role in local contexts and maintaining sustainability is highlighted.
Ecological Economics: Some Basic Tenets
- The economy is inherently intertwined with biophysical cycles.
- Nature acts as the fundamental framework for economic flows.
- Methodological critiques of mainstream economics are offered.
Ecological Economics: A Few Research Streams
- Research concerning ecosystem valuation, macro-level modeling, and strategies for sustainability are examined.
Concluding Discussion
- Overall assessment of the different perspectives.
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.
Related Documents
Description
Test your knowledge on the topics of economics and the environment covered in the 'Topics in Economics and Environment' course at IHEC Brussels. This quiz focuses on key concepts such as market interactions, economic diagrams, and foundational theories. Get ready to assess your understanding of the interconnectedness of these two fields!
