Docetism and Marcion

Choose a study mode

Play Quiz
Study Flashcards
Spaced Repetition
Chat to Lesson

Podcast

Play an AI-generated podcast conversation about this lesson
Download our mobile app to listen on the go
Get App

Questions and Answers

How did Marcion differentiate between the God of the Old Testament and the God of the New Testament, and what implications did this have on his view of Jesus?

Marcion believed the God of the Old Testament was the creator of the material world, which he viewed as evil, while the God of the New Testament was the good God. Consequently, he removed mentions of Jesus's physicality, suggesting Jesus was not truly born of a woman.

Explain the core belief of Docetism and why it was considered a heresy in the early Church.

Docetism is the belief that Jesus was not truly human and only appeared to be so. This was considered a heresy because it undermined the reality of the Incarnation and Jesus's atoning sacrifice.

What was Apollinarius's understanding of Christ's nature, and what problem was he trying to solve with his Christology?

Apollinarius believed that Jesus was God in flesh but did not have a human soul. He was trying to resolve the perceived conflict between Jesus's divinity and the possibility of temptation, arguing that if Jesus had a soul, his soul and divinity would be in constant conflict.

How did Ignatius of Antioch emphasize the importance of Jesus's physical body and why was this significant in the context of early Christian beliefs?

<p>Ignatius of Antioch emphasized Jesus's physical body by expressing concern for its fate, desiring it to be consumed by wild animals as a form of sacrifice. This was significant because it countered Docetic views prevalent at the time and affirmed the reality of Jesus's incarnation and physical suffering.</p> Signup and view all the answers

Describe the concept of Recapitulation as it relates to Jesus and Adam, according to Irenaeus.

<p>Recapitulation suggests that Jesus, as the second Adam, reverses the disobedience and imperfection of the first Adam through his obedience, virtue, and perfection, 'summing up' humanity in himself.</p> Signup and view all the answers

How did the rise of monasticism in the 4th century pose a challenge to the authority of bishops?

<p>Monasticism provided an alternative form of religious life that was attractive to many, allowing individuals to separate themselves from the authority of bishops they disagreed with, particularly those who were seen as politically appointed.</p> Signup and view all the answers

Explain the significance of the Council of Constantinople's decision to rank Constantinople as the 'new Rome' in 381.

<p>The decision to elevate Constantinople in the church hierarchy was significant because it challenged the traditional authority of Rome and Alexandria, leading to rivalries and political tension among the major sees.</p> Signup and view all the answers

What actions did Ambrose of Milan take that demonstrated the growing power and influence of the church relative to the state in the late 4th century?

<p>Ambrose excommunicated Emperor Theodosius for his involvement in a massacre and required him to perform public penance before being allowed to attend mass, demonstrating the church's ability to hold even the emperor accountable.</p> Signup and view all the answers

How did Origen's theology influence monasticism, and why did figures like Epiphanius criticize this influence?

<p>Origen's theology, with its emphasis on the spiritual over the physical, heavily influenced the theology in monasteries. Epiphanius criticized this influence because he was concerned with Arianism and saw Platonism as highly influential, which in turn influenced Origen.</p> Signup and view all the answers

What led to John Chrysostom's exile from Constantinople?

<p>John Chrysostom's exile was caused by a combination of factors: his unpopularity in Constantinople, his overreach in the jurisdiction of other bishops, his criticism of the emperor's wife, and Theophilus using the Tall Brothers to imply John might be a heretic.</p> Signup and view all the answers

Flashcards

Docetism

The belief that Jesus was not truly human; the body is bad, only the spiritual is good.

Marcion's Antithesis

Suggests the God of the Old Testament was evil and material, while Jesus represents a good God, removing mentions of it.

Ignatius of Antioch

Concerned with Jesus' physical body, desiring to be eaten by wild animals as a eucharistic liturgy.

Origen's View

Argued that humanity could not be saved if Jesus did not take on the human form.

Signup and view all the flashcards

Recapitulation

Doctrine of summing up. Just as in Adam all die, in Christ all shall be made alive. Jesus is the second Adam.

Signup and view all the flashcards

Monasticism

The idea of monks and nuns, becoming very popular and threatened the bishops power in the 4th century.

Signup and view all the flashcards

John Chrysostom

Was very popular, a good speaker from Antioch, He took over bishop duties in Constantinople, before being ousted.

Signup and view all the flashcards

Jesus' physicality

Early Christian writing shows his physicality. John opens with the idea that Jesus is human and god.

Signup and view all the flashcards

Apostles creed

Sets out the idea that Jesus was human. Reflective of what everyone was fighting about at the time. After being resurrected, Jesus did human activites.

Signup and view all the flashcards

Study Notes

  • Incarnation is the concept of the logos (divine word/reason) becoming flesh in Jesus.
  • Many in the Roman Empire accepted Jesus as God, but questioned his human existence.
  • Greeks and Romans proposed Jesus only appeared human to comfort the apostles.

Docetism

  • Docetism was a prevalent early church heresy.
  • Docetists believed Jesus was not human, only divine
  • They adhered to the idea that the body is bad, and only the spiritual is good.

Marcion

  • Marcion, condemned in 144, first spoke of a list of the New Testament.
  • He wrote Antithesis
  • Marcion saw contradictions between the Old and New Testaments.
  • He believed the God of the Old Testament (the creator) was different from the God of the New Testament.
  • The God of the Old Testament was bad because material is the source of all evil.
  • The God of the New Testament was good, and Jesus represents the good God.
  • Marcion removed mentions of the Jewish God and Jesus' physical birth from his scriptures.
  • Marcion was a Docetist and most Gnostics were also Docetist.

Gnostics

  • They thought Jesus' human form was possessed by God (the Christ).
  • An example of this is Jesus' baptism in the Jordan where Christ would leave during unholy act like using the bathroom.

Manichaeans

  • The Manichaeans were also Docetists
  • By 300, Manichaean missionaries spread their belief
  • The Manichaeans hated the body, believed the human spirit was trapped within it and Jesus was not important to their teachings.
  • Early Christian writings, like the Gospel of John, emphasize Jesus' physicality.
  • The Apostle's Creed, used around 300 in baptisms, asserts Jesus' humanity.
  • Reflective of the debates at the time and notes Jesus' human actions after resurrection.

Apostolic Fathers

  • Ignatius of Antioch (died 107) was connected with John and concerned with Jesus's physical body.
  • Ignatius was excited about his execution under Trajan.
  • He wrote letters to churches affirming Jesus as both God and human, and viewed his death as a sacrifice.
  • Denying Jesus's physical reality equates to denying his spiritual reality.

Origen

  • Origen (died 254) stated that human persons couldn't be saved unless the lord had taken on the human person.
  • The flesh is the fulcrum (the pivot) of salvation.

Apollinarius

  • Apollinarius (c. 310-382) belonged to the arian of Word Flesh Christology
  • Word-flesh Christology (WFC) studies Christ as logos with human flesh instead of a human soul
  • The soul animates the body, separating upon death.
  • Apollinarius, a Syrian bishop, tried to explain WFC, believing Jesus was God in flesh without a human soul.
  • He thought a human soul, being the source of temptation, would contradict Jesus' divinity.
  • WFC was trying to align with the Nicene Creed.
  • The logos 'divinised' the flesh and even if the logos left, the flesh was changed.

Arguments against WFC from the Cappadocian Fathers

  • WFC is Docetism, because divinised flesh suggests Jesus isn't human.
  • WFC is what it means to be human: body and soul.
  • Recapitulation doctrine is that, like Adam, all die, but in Christ, all shall be made alive: Jesus is the second Adam.
  • Adam was disobedient, sinful, and imperfect, while Jesus was obedient, virtuous, and perfect.
  • Adam has body and soul, demonstrating that Jesus must have body and soul.
  • Jesus overcomes death and forgives sins allowing humanity's souls to be restored because Jesus took a human soul himself.

Council of Constantinople

  • 381 Council of Constantinople (#1) declared “Constantinople is the new Rome”.
  • Ranking of the churches included: Rome, Alexandria and Antioch, and Jerusalem
  • Each behaved as if they had large areas of jurisdiction. Top 3 had authority outside of their specific city.
  • The addition of Constantinople into the ranking (below Rome and above Alexandria) caused issues.
  • In 330, the capital of Roman Empire was moved to Constantinople.
  • The west was expansive, whereas the east had lost expansion to the Persians and was confined to well-established civilisation.
  • The west was often overrun by barbarian invasions.
  • Emperors after Constantine responded in 2 ways: relying on barbarian generals and focused on defending and preserving the eastern half of the empire.
  • Reaches its height in 395 when Theodosius dies and splits the empire
  • The lunatic son sent to the west, and the smart son sent to the east.
  • In the 4th and 5th centuries, the Christian clergy expands (takes over) roles formally done by civil authorities of the empire.
  • There were lots of fights between church and state.
  • Ambrose of Milan (374-397), originally wasn't Christian, was a lawyer and general, and known for his writing of hymns.
  • He excommunicated Emperor Theodosius for his involvement in a massacre.
  • Ambrose demanded public penance before Theodosius could attend mass.
  • A period of doubt that the church must submit to the state was Established
  • Before the 381 council, Constantinople was Arian.
  • When Theodosius becomes emperor, he's determined to get rid of the Arians by establishing the Nicaean orthodoxy.
  • In a lead up to the council, they had been arguing in Antioch over who the bishop of Antioch was for 20 years.
  • Theodosius had to decide who the new bishop of Constantinople (Gregory the theologian), who then supported someone for Antioch, and is ran out of Constantinople.
  • Nectarius was chosen as the bishop of constantinople (early 380s).
  • The Origenist controversy, stemmed from the Arian controversy, led to a Platonist purge of the church.

Monasticism

  • Monasticism became popular in the 4th century and threatened the bishops power.
  • Pachomius (died 348) established his first monastery and thought that people who want to follow Jesus in the monastic way should live in community together.
  • At the time of his death there are 11 monastery in Egypt that could hold around 1000 people each.
  • Many of the people who lived there were ex. Army.
  • Pachomius made the monasteries like roman barracks, he believed that monkhood was spiritual warfare.
  • Threat to the bishop because people like monks and if they don't like what the bishop is doing they can physically separate themselves from the bishop.
  • People didn't like the politically appointed bishops.
  • The theology in the monasteries was heavily influenced by Origen
  • Bishop of Cyprus Epiphanius (died 403), was concerned with Arianism and saw Platonism as highly influential for Arianism.
  • He wrote a book “The medicine chest for the cure of all heresies”.
  • He targets Origen because of his emphasis on the spiritual over the physical because he says Origen is still a living influence over certain Egyptian monks.
  • Trained as a monk with the tall brothers
  • The origen issue had become a major issue for the school in Antioch but played a role in the political battle between Alexandria and Constantinople
  • Theophilius (in Alexandria) had his own issued w/the tall brothers (theological and political).
  • He expelled them from Egypt (burned all their stuff and kicked them out).
  • They went to Constantinople to complain.
  • Bishop in Const after Nectarius was John Chrysostom (347-407).
  • John in Antioch was very popular, loved asceticism, and a reformer.
  • Took over the sea of Constantinople (everyone thinks this is a political appointment but John makes it holy).
  • He removes priests that Nectarian appointed stopped having feasts at the palace, telling dudes to be faithful, argues that private property is a result of Adams fall.
  • He criticizes the emperors wife for taking property from people.
  • he scandalised bishops in asia minor because he chastised them.
  • Theophilius implies that John might be a Origenist heretic, since he took in the Tall Brothers after they wre expelled by Theophilus.
  • John calls Theophilius to Constantinople.
  • John then in 403 calls the synod of the oak.
  • They depose John and then they go to the emperor who authorises the ridding of him (exiles John).
  • Johns supporters riot.
  • After this, there is an earthquake (seen as divine sign).
  • Emperor and his wife get freaked out and all John back.
  • Theophilius writes a pamphlet saying that John is Satan in the form of an angel.
  • John insults the emperors wife again after this and he is kicked out again
  • John's supporters riot again and set fire to the cathedral, John is exiled
  • Pope Innocent I rebilitates John to exercise roman authority over the east.
  • Bishop of Constantinople accepts John as a saint.

Studying That Suits You

Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.

Quiz Team

Related Documents

More Like This

Use Quizgecko on...
Browser
Browser