Podcast Beta
Questions and Answers
What is essential for ensuring the veracity and accuracy of the DNP project outcomes?
Which aspect is emphasized for successful DNP project design and implementation?
Which of the following methodologies is NOT typically included in DNP project approaches?
What drives the design choice for a DNP project?
Signup and view all the answers
In the context of DNP projects, what is a critical factor evaluated by the doctoral project team during the approval process?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the primary focus of Quality Improvement (QI) methodologies in DNP projects?
Signup and view all the answers
Which QI methodology involves assessing risks before implementing new procedures?
Signup and view all the answers
How does qualitative inquiry contribute to DNP projects?
Signup and view all the answers
What is a key characteristic of the Plan-Do-Study-Act (PDSA) cycle in QI?
Signup and view all the answers
What aspect is essential for aligning the QI model with DNP project aims?
Signup and view all the answers
What is a significant purpose of Program Evaluation in project development?
Signup and view all the answers
Which of the following models is NOT commonly utilized in healthcare Program Evaluation?
Signup and view all the answers
In the context of Program Evaluation, what is primarily assessed alongside stakeholder engagement?
Signup and view all the answers
What type of evaluation is emphasized throughout the DNP project implementation?
Signup and view all the answers
Which parameter is generally not emphasized across the majority of Program Evaluation models?
Signup and view all the answers
What distinguishes an Evidence-Based Practice (EBP) project from a Quality Improvement (QI) project?
Signup and view all the answers
Which of the following is a common step across all types of DNP projects?
Signup and view all the answers
Which project type would most likely be initiated in response to a needs assessment?
Signup and view all the answers
What is a primary outcome of Evidence-Based Practice (EBP) initiatives?
Signup and view all the answers
What method is primarily utilized to appraise the quality of evidence in DNP projects?
Signup and view all the answers
Which data collection method is especially suitable for gathering input from stakeholders regarding a Quality Improvement opportunity in a younger population?
Signup and view all the answers
What type of data collection method would be most appropriate for an elderly population when conducting a structured interview?
Signup and view all the answers
Which of these methods is NOT commonly utilized for qualitative data collection in Quality Improvement projects?
Signup and view all the answers
What is a significant advantage of using electronic health records (EHRs) in data collection for clinical outcomes evaluation?
Signup and view all the answers
In the context of DNP projects, which factor is essential when selecting a data collection method?
Signup and view all the answers
What is a crucial administrative aspect of data collection for a DNP project?
Signup and view all the answers
Which group of professionals might assist with analyzing complex data during a DNP project?
Signup and view all the answers
What is an important factor to consider when developing newly created assessment instruments?
Signup and view all the answers
What should be included in the project protocol books for a DNP project?
Signup and view all the answers
Which consideration is essential for the pilot testing of newly developed instruments?
Signup and view all the answers
Which method is considered reliable for verifying data entries in a DNP project?
Signup and view all the answers
What is a primary function of software like NVivo and Atlas in qualitative data management?
Signup and view all the answers
What factors should drive the choice of statistical software for a DNP project?
Signup and view all the answers
Which best describes the primary purpose of examining qualitative data during the data collection process?
Signup and view all the answers
Which characteristic is NOT a feature of the data entry process in DNP projects?
Signup and view all the answers
What is emphasized in the structured format for papers or presentations during the dissemination phase of a project?
Signup and view all the answers
Which aspect should not be included in the discussion section of a project report?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the role of stakeholder engagement during the dissemination of project findings?
Signup and view all the answers
What should be the focus when reporting project findings in a systematic way?
Signup and view all the answers
In organizing data outcomes, which aspect is typically stressed in relation to the goals of a QI or EBP project report?
Signup and view all the answers
Study Notes
DNP Project Design
- DNP projects are diverse and can take on many forms.
- The design of a DNP project should be chosen based on the clinical question and the type of inquiry.
- The DNP project team works with the student to determine the best design to guide the project and ensure rigor.
Common DNP Project Designs
-
Observational and Non-experimental Designs
- Exploratory, descriptive, or correlational designs are used for clinical inquiry.
- These designs are useful for determining the characteristics or needs of a unique population.
- Descriptive and correlational projects can also be used to assess behaviors of healthcare professionals, patients, communities, and systems.
-
Intervention/Change-Oriented Designs
-
Research Design:
- Experimental designs (including randomized controlled trials and quasi-experimental studies) are used to initiate change via an intervention.
- Quasi-experimental studies are practical and measure change in health-related outcomes after treatment or intervention.
-
Quality Improvement Design:
- Quality improvement (QI) projects use research designs like observational studies, longitudinal studies, and randomized controlled trials to improve practice settings.
-
Research Design:
Congruence Among Design, Methods, and Analysis
- Data collection methods and analysis should align with the project aims and design.
- This congruence ensures the accuracy and veracity of the DNP project outcome(s).
- The DNP project team evaluates the congruence of design, methods, and analysis during the project approval process.
DNP Project Approaches
- DNP projects often involve:
- Quality Improvement (QI)
- Program Development/Evaluation
- Evidence-Based Practice (EBP) Initiatives
- Health Policy
- The research methodologies of quantitative and qualitative research are also utilized.
Quality Improvement Models
- Plan-Do-Study-Act (PDSA), Lean Methodology, and Six Sigma are common QI approaches.
- Root Cause Analysis (RCA) identifies root causes of problems using a retrospective approach and focuses on system process breakdowns.
- Failure Mode Effect Analysis (FMEA) is a proactive prevention approach that assesses new programs, procedures, or policies to anticipate potential consequences.
- QI emphasizes data-driven, rapid cycle change and aligns with the purpose and aims of a DNP project.
Qualitative Inquiry
- Qualitative inquiry is useful for understanding phenomena when little is known or there's a gap in practice knowledge.
- It provides a holistic understanding of phenomena, captures real-world context, and generates evidence for practice.
- Ethnography, grounded theory, phenomenology, and narrative research are types of qualitative inquiry.
Mixed Methods
- Mixed methods combine quantitative and qualitative data collection.
- Focus groups and interviews are commonly used to gather opinions and beliefs from stakeholders.
Program Development & Evaluation (PD/PE)
- PD/PE serves as complementary functions.
- Program Development uses evidence-based approaches to assess and develop program components to address healthcare problems.
- Program Development projects emphasize formative evaluation and use various methods/tools to achieve successful outcomes.
Program Evaluation
- Continuous assessment of a program's performance at all phases of development
- Aims to gather evidence on the effectiveness and efficiency of project, program, or policy activities
- Refines program processes, operations, and the overall strategy
Types of Program Evaluation Models
- Logic model (Millar et al., 2001)
- Centers for Disease Control and Prevention framework for public health programs (CDC, 1999)
- Balanced Scorecard (Kaplan & Norton, 1992)
- Context-Input-Process-Product (CIPP) model (Stufflebeam, 1983)
Program Evaluation Parameters
- Stakeholder engagement
- Available resources
- Planned activities
- Outputs
- Outcomes
- Impact of the program
Evidence-Based Practice (EBP)
- A decision-making approach that integrates clinical expertise, patient preferences, and the best scientific evidence to guide healthcare interventions
- Emphasizes knowledge integration into contemporary healthcare practice
- EBP projects involve a systematic process, including a critical appraisal of the literature and consideration of the organization's culture and resource needs
Health Policy Analysis
- Focuses on healthcare quality, cost, and access within a specific topic or population group
- Examines policy at the macro- or microsystem level
- Uses data to guide analysis through metrics
- Involves systematic assessment that weighs the benefits and liabilities of a policy
DNP Project Diversity
- DNP projects are diverse, using different methodologies, but share interprofessional collaboration and a data-driven, outcome-evaluating process.
DNP Project Initiating Factors
- Quality Improvement (QI) projects begin when there's a care or outcome gap.
- Evidence-Based Practice (EBP) projects are initiated due to a lack of evidence impacting a clinical issue.
- Program Development/Evaluation projects arise from needs assessments, identifying the need for new or evaluating existing programs.
- Health Policy projects analyze the impact of policy on a population and explore alternative solutions.
- Research projects address practice-based questions or test hypotheses.
DNP Project Commonalities
- All projects involve:
- Systematic literature reviews
- Critical appraisal of evidence quality
- Data collection and analysis
- Systems and stakeholder engagement
- Implementation competencies
- Project evaluation for effectiveness and sustainability
DNP Project Differences
- The last step differs based on project type:
- Research: New data is applied to practice, potentially supporting EBP.
- EBP: Continued practice change is the goal.
- QI: An ongoing improvement approach, monitored for iterative improvements.
- Program Development/Evaluation: Data-driven improvements, sustainability planning.
- Health Policy: Advocacy for policy development or revision.
Dynamic vs. Static DNP Projects
- Dynamic: QI and EBP projects are ongoing and evolving.
- Static: Research and program implementation/evaluation are considered completed and less dynamic.
Interconnectedness of DNP Approaches
- EBP can uncover QI opportunities and provide data for program development/evaluation.
- QI provides contextual data for EBP, potential research needs, and program development.
- Program Evaluation can identify needs for QI, EBP, and new research.
- Research can guide program development and identify gaps in evidence needing research.
- Policy Analysis can highlight the need for QI, provide data for EBP, identify research gaps, and suggest program development/evaluation.
Data Collection Methods
- DNP projects involve collecting new data (surveys, interviews) or analyzing existing data (EHRs, national registries)
- Data collection methods must align with the study design and project purpose
-
Major data collection methods:
- Self-reporting: surveys or structured interviews
- Direct observation: observing and recording behavior or events
- Physiological measures: collecting data on biological processes (e.g., blood pressure, heart rate)
- Prospective logs or tracking sheets: real-time data collection in QI projects
- Process flow diagrams and cause-and-effect diagrams: structuring data collection in QI initiatives
- Data extraction from EHRs or registries: evaluating clinical outcomes, costs, service usage patterns
- Qualitative data methods: focus groups or individual interviews with open-ended questions
- Storytelling and written narratives: collecting qualitative data
-
Data collection method selection factors:
- Suitability for project goals
- Feasibility and practicality in the clinical setting
- Target population needs
-
Strengths and limitations of data collection methods:
- Surveys: versatile but prone to bias
- Direct observation: objective but vulnerable to observer bias
- EHR data extraction: economical and efficient but limited by missing data points
- Focus groups: facilitate clarification of participant responses but may be influenced by group dynamics and confidentiality concerns
- Quantitative data measures: choose tools with documented reliability, validity, sensitivity, and precision
- Bio-physiological measures: report precision (coefficient of variation) and sensitivity (lowest limit of detection)
Data Analysis and Evaluation
- Multiple measurement methods: required to capture relevant data for QI, EBP, program evaluation
- Economic measures: incorporate cost savings or burden for QI, EBP, and program development/evaluation projects
-
Process and Impact Evaluation:
- Process evaluation: assesses the implementation of a program or initiative (e.g., enrollment, adherence to interventions)
- Impact evaluation: assesses the long-term benefits of the project's goals
- Evidence-based guideline development: requires a systematic process for searching and evaluating relevant literature
-
AGREE II instrument: used for assessing rigor in guideline development
- Includes systematic search strategy, evidence assessment, and recommendation decision-making
- Appraising evidence: determines the level and grade of evidence for practice guideline components
- Guideline assessment: includes analyzing benefits and risks, expert review, feasibility, appropriateness, and meaningfulness
DNP Project Data Collection
- Resources for Data Collection: Reliable and valid surveys and tools can be adapted for DNP projects. Multiple online resources house previously tested survey questions from large multicenter studies. Additionally, national registries provide valuable data for DNP projects.
Team Collaboration in Data Collection
- Team Involvement: Data collection involves collaborators for instrument development, participant recruitment, and data collection.
- Setting and Permissions: Data collection may occur in various settings, requiring permission from organizational leadership and staff engagement.
- Expert Consultation: Consultation with PhD-prepared statisticians or researchers may be needed for instrument construction, complex analyses, and data mining.
- Information Technology Specialists: Their expertise is important for data retrieval and DNP projects.
Administrative Aspects of Data Collection
- Procedures and Forms: Procedures and forms should be developed for data collection, encompassing surveys, chart abstraction tools, checklists, tracking sheets, and scripted interview guides.
- Assessment Instruments: Instruments should be visually appealing, legible, and logically formatted, ensuring ease of use.
- Instrument Pilot Testing: Pilot testing is essential to evaluate user-friendliness, clarity, and time requirements for completion.
- Participant Recruitment and Consent: Procedures for recruiting, screening, and obtaining consent from participants need to be established.
- Project Protocol Books and Gantt Charts: These tools are beneficial for all personnel involved in the study.
- Project Meetings: Regular meetings to review procedures before study commencement are recommended.
- Training and Evaluation of Team Members: Training sessions are essential for project team members, including investigators, project assistants, and system staff.
- Periodic Evaluation of Team Performance: Ongoing evaluations of team members ensure fidelity of the intervention or innovation.
- QI Projects and Staff Engagement: QI projects may involve large groups of staff. A series of meetings to review processes and engage staff may be necessary.
- Site Visits for Collaboration: Site visits encourage collaboration and provide opportunities for personnel to ask questions and alert the DNP student to emerging issues.
Qualitative Data Collection
- Smaller Groups: Qualitative data collection uses smaller groups of subjects, typically requiring one investigator and one assistant.
- Purposive Recruitment: Subjects are recruited purposively to engage the specific participant types needed.
- Informed Consent and Confidentiality: Informed consent is essential. Group commitment to confidentiality is required for focus groups.
- Data Collection Methods: Open-ended questions or interviews are commonly employed, with responses recorded on audiotapes.
- Investigator and Assistant Roles: The investigator facilitates the discussion while the assistant observes nonverbal behaviors and takes field notes.
Data Management
- Data Security: Data security is vital in clinical inquiry projects. Participants are assigned ID numbers, and a master list of participants with IDs is securely stored.
- Data Collection Tools and Protected Health Information: Data collection tools should be devoid of identifying information and stored separately from the master list.
- Data Management Strategies for Efficiency and Accuracy: These strategies include tracking participant responses, maintaining a project log, and creating a data codebook.
- Data Codebook: The codebook includes the name or label for each data item, its level of measurement, and its numeric coding scheme.
- Missing Data: Procedures for retrieving missing data should be developed. Decisions about the amount of missing data warranting record exclusion should be made.
- Variant Data: New codes may be created for unique data entries, using "other" labels for distinct data points.
- Collaboration with Experts: The DNP student should work with statisticians or researchers to address complex data interpretation issues.
- Project Log Documentation: Decisions made about data management issues should be entered into the project log for consistency in evaluation of all data forms.
Data Entry
- Data from collection forms are coded using the schema established in the codebook after being reviewed, verified, and cleaned.
- Coded data are then entered into a statistical program such as SPSS, Intellectus Statistics, SAS, Stata, or Microsoft Excel.
- Data entry is a time-consuming process and prone to errors, so verification is essential through visual comparison or double data entry.
- Qualitative data includes audiotapes, field notes, and written narratives.
- Voice over Internet Protocol (VoIP) technology has increased the use of virtual interviews and videoconferencing.
- Verification often occurs during data collection, with researchers confirming interpretations with participants.
- Management of qualitative data involves transcribing audiotaped interviews into text and using software like NVivo, Atlas, Zoom, and Microsoft Teams.
Data Analysis
- Data analysis transforms numerical data into meaningful information.
- The first step is to evaluate data distributions for normality using histograms and frequency distributions.
- If distributions are normal, parametric analyses can be used.
- If distributions are not normal, variables can be transformed to achieve normality, otherwise nonparametric analyses should be used.
- Descriptive analysis uses measures of central tendency (mean, median, mode) and variation (range and standard deviation) to provide an overall picture of data.
- Relationships between variables are examined using scatter plots, chi-square tests, Pearson or Spearman rank-order correlations, depending on the measurement level of the variables.
- Additional analyses can include regression, t-tests, ANOVA, or non-parametric tests based on the project aim and data type.
- QI data can be analyzed using histograms, scatter plots, pie charts, line graphs, frequencies, and descriptive statistics.
- Changes in the dependent variable can be measured with traditional statistical analyses.
- Control and run charts, Pareto charts, or value stream maps, congruent with the project plan, can be created using Excel with QI macros.
- Qualitative data analysis involves identifying themes and patterns in transcribed interviews or written narratives.
- Software like NVivo, Atlas, or Zoom can be used to support these analyses.
- Qualitative data are analyzed inductively to understand a phenomenon rather than providing a specific answer.
- After analyzing data, findings are interpreted, their meaning explored, and implications for practice considered.
- Limitations of the data are also evaluated, including biases and errors, and potential improvements for future research.
- This phase requires dedicated thinking time and consultation with the DNP team and other researchers.
Dissemination of Findings
- Sharing research findings is crucial, whether through publications, presentations, or sharing with relevant stakeholders.
- Project outcomes should be disseminated to relevant audiences, including the specific setting or population studied, and policymakers if data influence policy.
Dissemination Formats
- A structured format is recommended for sharing project data, particularly for experimental and observational research, program evaluations, QI reports, and EBP initiatives.
- Guidelines for specific formats can be found in helpful resources.
Structure of Papers and Presentations
- Papers and presentations typically start with an introduction and background to establish the project's need and significance in nursing practice or healthcare delivery.
- The methods section details the project design, the sample or population studied, Institutional Review Board (IRB) or quality council approval, and data collection and measurement protocols.
- The findings section reports participant responses, sample characteristics, or clinical settings, followed by organized data outcomes related to the clinical issue, program goals, or improvement process.
- Focusing on the major points and summarizing key outcomes is sufficient.
- Unanticipated findings should be noted if relevant.
Discussion Section
- The discussion section gives meaning to the findings and highlights their implications for practice and future change or improvement.
- The discussion should cover the major findings and implications, followed by other important results.
- Comparing data to other studies and improvement processes is encouraged.
- The limitations of the data should be summarized, and next steps for future innovation should be presented.
DNP Doctoral Projects
- DNP projects represent the culminating scholarly product in DNP programs, showcasing the synthesis of the student's academic work and the achievement of essential DNP competencies.
- DNP projects address patient, systems, or population issues with an emphasis on enhancing health and healthcare outcomes.
- Projects should make a substantive contribution to nursing practice and are professionally disseminated to provide a foundation for continued practice scholarship.
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.
Description
This quiz explores the various designs of DNP projects, focusing on observational and change-oriented designs. Participants will learn how to choose the best design based on clinical questions and inquiry types while ensuring research rigor.
