Podcast
Questions and Answers
What is a key limitation of machine learning in decision making?
What is a key limitation of machine learning in decision making?
- Machine learning is always more accurate than human decision making.
- It can sometimes yield decisions based on outdated prejudices. (correct)
- Machine learning relies solely on human judgment.
- It does not consider statistical patterns in data.
How do traditional human decision-makers differ from automated systems in terms of ethical considerations?
How do traditional human decision-makers differ from automated systems in terms of ethical considerations?
- Humans often disregard ethical implications entirely.
- Humans may consider factors like moral culpability, unlike machines. (correct)
- Automated systems prioritize moral relevance over predictive accuracy.
- Automated systems account for emotional intelligence in decision making.
In the context of machine learning, which of the following aspects can lead to unjust outcomes?
In the context of machine learning, which of the following aspects can lead to unjust outcomes?
- Ignoring patterns in training data.
- The incorporation of diverse data points.
- Prioritizing predictive accuracy in all scenarios.
- The reliance on historical data reflecting prejudices. (correct)
What do decision-making systems that rely on machine learning risk when automated decisions are made?
What do decision-making systems that rely on machine learning risk when automated decisions are made?
What is one reason judges avoid using statistical data about young defendants in sentencing?
What is one reason judges avoid using statistical data about young defendants in sentencing?
Which area is mentioned as employing machine learning for consequential decision-making?
Which area is mentioned as employing machine learning for consequential decision-making?
What is suggested about the nature of data used for machine learning in decision-making?
What is suggested about the nature of data used for machine learning in decision-making?
What is the primary concern related to using machine learning in college admissions?
What is the primary concern related to using machine learning in college admissions?
What is a significant risk associated with automating the decision-making process?
What is a significant risk associated with automating the decision-making process?
What is a common criticism regarding the implementation of machine learning in decision-making?
What is a common criticism regarding the implementation of machine learning in decision-making?
What might organizations do when they shift from a human-based decision-making model to an automated one?
What might organizations do when they shift from a human-based decision-making model to an automated one?
How can machine learning be utilized to improve traditional decision-making processes?
How can machine learning be utilized to improve traditional decision-making processes?
Which of the following describes a detrimental effect of automating eligibility determinations for benefits?
Which of the following describes a detrimental effect of automating eligibility determinations for benefits?
What does the term 'criteria weighting' refer to in predictive decision-making?
What does the term 'criteria weighting' refer to in predictive decision-making?
What is a potential drawback of arbitrary decision-making in areas like admissions and lending?
What is a potential drawback of arbitrary decision-making in areas like admissions and lending?
Why might a person feel devalued when faced with an automated decision-making process?
Why might a person feel devalued when faced with an automated decision-making process?
In what scenario might machine learning be applied to automate informal decision-making processes?
In what scenario might machine learning be applied to automate informal decision-making processes?
How can machine learning improve decision-making compared to human judgment?
How can machine learning improve decision-making compared to human judgment?
What method can employers use to validate the effectiveness of educational qualifications on job performance?
What method can employers use to validate the effectiveness of educational qualifications on job performance?
What does research indicate about the accuracy of data-driven decisions versus human judgment?
What does research indicate about the accuracy of data-driven decisions versus human judgment?
Which factor is crucial for ensuring fairness in high-stakes decisions such as loan approvals?
Which factor is crucial for ensuring fairness in high-stakes decisions such as loan approvals?
What advantage does identifying relevant details provide in a decision-making context?
What advantage does identifying relevant details provide in a decision-making context?
In the context of loan approvals, what is a benefit of automated underwriting compared to traditional methods?
In the context of loan approvals, what is a benefit of automated underwriting compared to traditional methods?
What role does historical evidence play in understanding the relevance of various factors in decision-making?
What role does historical evidence play in understanding the relevance of various factors in decision-making?
Flashcards are hidden until you start studying
Study Notes
Introduction to Decision-Making and Automation
- Success and wellbeing are influenced by external decisions, such as school admissions and job offers.
- Inconsistent decision-making can hinder personal goals and limit access to opportunities.
- Good decision-making should incorporate relevant evidence, moving beyond arbitrary rules.
Role of Statistics and Machine Learning
- Statistical models improve decision-making accuracy compared to human intuition and expertise.
- A 2002 study indicated that automated loan underwriting was more accurate and less racially biased than human decision-making.
- Machine learning aims to identify relevant factors for decision-making, often revealing insights that humans may overlook.
Risks of Automation
- Automation risks reducing accountability and can dehumanize interactions with bureaucracies.
- Software may obscure who is responsible for decisions, complicating dispute processes for individuals affected.
- Individuals may feel disrespected by automated systems that do not allow for correction or contextual explanations.
Historical Context of Decision-Making
- Concerns about automated decision-making are not exclusive to machine learning; traditional software has similar risks.
- Machine learning operationalizes pre-existing and informal decision-making but relies heavily on high-quality historical data.
- Historical data often reflects societal biases and stereotypes, which can perpetuate discrimination through automated systems.
Human versus Automated Decision-Making
- Human decision-makers consider moral relevance and may avoid purely predictive calculations.
- Automated systems can yield absurd decisions, particularly if based on flawed or biased data.
- Comparison of human and machine decision-making should consider moral and justice implications, not just predictive accuracy.
Applications of Machine Learning
- Machine learning influences significant decisions in criminal justice, job application processes, lending, and insurance underwriting.
- Risk assessment scores in the criminal justice system can inform critical legal decisions such as bail and parole.
- The increasing reliance on machine learning necessitates awareness of potential biases and problematic outcomes in its application.
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.
