Podcast
Questions and Answers
What is the CSI Effect?
What is the CSI Effect?
What do CSI effect studies examine?
What do CSI effect studies examine?
Unintended consequences from the use of technology
The CSI effect raises the state's burden of proof because of the expectation of forensic evidence.
The CSI effect raises the state's burden of proof because of the expectation of forensic evidence.
True
In general cases, _____% expect DNA evidence.
In general cases, _____% expect DNA evidence.
Signup and view all the answers
In murder cases, _____% expect DNA evidence.
In murder cases, _____% expect DNA evidence.
Signup and view all the answers
In assault cases, _____% expect DNA evidence.
In assault cases, _____% expect DNA evidence.
Signup and view all the answers
In rape cases, _____% expect DNA evidence.
In rape cases, _____% expect DNA evidence.
Signup and view all the answers
Which types of crimes do people generally not expect DNA evidence?
Which types of crimes do people generally not expect DNA evidence?
Signup and view all the answers
What type of evidence is most expected?
What type of evidence is most expected?
Signup and view all the answers
Scientific evidence is expected in all cases.
Scientific evidence is expected in all cases.
Signup and view all the answers
Jurors give less credibility to forensic experts.
Jurors give less credibility to forensic experts.
Signup and view all the answers
Prosecutors must compensate for a lack of evidence due to the CSI effect.
Prosecutors must compensate for a lack of evidence due to the CSI effect.
Signup and view all the answers
Jurors will acquit in cases where if CSI did not exist, they would have charged.
Jurors will acquit in cases where if CSI did not exist, they would have charged.
Signup and view all the answers
What percentage of jurors discount eye-witness testimony?
What percentage of jurors discount eye-witness testimony?
Signup and view all the answers
Jurors may see a lack of forensic testing as sloppy police work.
Jurors may see a lack of forensic testing as sloppy police work.
Signup and view all the answers
Jurors requested relevant forensic evidence.
Jurors requested relevant forensic evidence.
Signup and view all the answers
What percentage of respondents indicated job changes because of the CSI effect?
What percentage of respondents indicated job changes because of the CSI effect?
Signup and view all the answers
More of their time was dedicated to discussing forensic evidence.
More of their time was dedicated to discussing forensic evidence.
Signup and view all the answers
Jurors spent less time familiarizing themselves with forensic tests.
Jurors spent less time familiarizing themselves with forensic tests.
Signup and view all the answers
What percentage of respondents believe jurors have unrealistic expectations of forensic evidence?
What percentage of respondents believe jurors have unrealistic expectations of forensic evidence?
Signup and view all the answers
Who examined the perception of the CSI effect on jury expectation and decision?
Who examined the perception of the CSI effect on jury expectation and decision?
Signup and view all the answers
What was the focus of the Hayes-Smith and Levett study?
What was the focus of the Hayes-Smith and Levett study?
Signup and view all the answers
Those who watched crime shows were more likely to favor the defendant than those who did not.
Those who watched crime shows were more likely to favor the defendant than those who did not.
Signup and view all the answers
Jurors have more understanding of science based on their educational background.
Jurors have more understanding of science based on their educational background.
Signup and view all the answers
What is the greatest success of DNA evidence?
What is the greatest success of DNA evidence?
Signup and view all the answers
What is key to solving a crime?
What is key to solving a crime?
Signup and view all the answers
The odds of solving a crime depend on the presence of DNA evidence.
The odds of solving a crime depend on the presence of DNA evidence.
Signup and view all the answers
Study Notes
CSI Effect Overview
- The CSI Effect refers to jurors’ unrealistic expectations regarding forensic evidence due to crime television shows.
- Heightened interest in forensic science stems from dramatic portrayals in media.
Juror Expectations
- General expectation of DNA evidence in 20% of all cases.
- Expectations vary by crime type:
- 45% for murder cases
- 30% for assault cases
- 70% for rape cases
- No expectation of DNA evidence in breaking and entering, theft, and gun-related crimes.
Types of Evidence Anticipated
- Ballistic evidence is primarily expected in weapon-related crimes.
- Fingerprint evidence is considered the most anticipated type of forensic evidence.
- Scientific evidence is expected across all types of cases.
Impact on Higher Education
- Increased number of students majoring in forensic science influenced by the CSI Effect.
Juror Credibility Perception
- Jurors may give less credibility to forensic experts, contrary to common belief.
- They often discount eyewitness testimony and perceive a lack of forensic testing as indicative of sloppy police work.
- Jurors may request irrelevant forensic evidence, reflecting their skewed expectations.
Changes in Legal Processes
- Prosecutors must adapt to jurors’ heightened expectations and compensate for the perceived lack of forensic evidence.
- Jurors are more likely to acquit individuals in cases where they expect forensic evidence that is not provided.
Job and Process Changes
- 85.5% of respondents report changes in their job roles due to the CSI Effect, dedicating more time to forensic evidence discussions.
- More time is spent on jury selection (voir dire) due to these changing expectations.
Perceptions of Evidence
- Nearly 70% believe jurors possess unrealistic expectations regarding forensic evidence and police work.
- Examination of attitudes towards crime shows highlights changes in jury decision-making.
Studies and Findings
- Hayes-Smith and Levett studied the interaction between jurors’ crime show viewing habits and the impact on trial decisions.
- Findings indicate that those who watch crime shows tend to favor defendants more than those who don’t.
Understanding of Science
- Jurors' comprehension of scientific evidence varies based on their educational and science background.
- Higher educational achievement and familiarity with STEM are correlated with a better understanding of forensic evidence.
DNA and Crime Resolution
- DNA is rarely decisive in solving crimes and primarily aids in exonerating the wrongfully convicted.
- Successful crime resolution often hinges on information about specific suspects rather than just DNA presence.
Conclusion on Crime Solving
- The likelihood of resolving a crime is determined more by the crime’s characteristics than the existence of DNA evidence.
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.
Description
Explore the concept of the CSI Effect through this quiz. Learn how popular television shows influence jurors' expectations of forensic science and the implications of these beliefs on the justice system. Ideal for students and professionals interested in forensic psychology.
