Podcast
Questions and Answers
If a unilateral mistake is known to the other party, the mistaken party can ______________ the contract.
If a unilateral mistake is known to the other party, the mistaken party can ______________ the contract.
escape
According to the caveat emptor rule, the buyer must ______________.
According to the caveat emptor rule, the buyer must ______________.
beware
A unilateral mistake refers to a situation where one party to the contract is mistaken, while the other party is ______________.
A unilateral mistake refers to a situation where one party to the contract is mistaken, while the other party is ______________.
aware
The case of Smith v Hughes illustrates that a unilateral mistake as to the terms of the contract prevents ______________.
The case of Smith v Hughes illustrates that a unilateral mistake as to the terms of the contract prevents ______________.
Signup and view all the answers
Frustration occurs when a contract becomes impossible to fulfill due to a ______________ change in circumstances.
Frustration occurs when a contract becomes impossible to fulfill due to a ______________ change in circumstances.
Signup and view all the answers
In the case of Smith v Hughes, the rule of ______ applies, which means the buyer has full opportunity of inspecting and forming his own judgement.
In the case of Smith v Hughes, the rule of ______ applies, which means the buyer has full opportunity of inspecting and forming his own judgement.
Signup and view all the answers
A common mistake will render the contract ______ as if there was never a contract.
A common mistake will render the contract ______ as if there was never a contract.
Signup and view all the answers
For a common mistake to be considered, the mistake must be ______ fundamental so as to render the expected contractual performance ‘essentially different’ or ‘impossible’.
For a common mistake to be considered, the mistake must be ______ fundamental so as to render the expected contractual performance ‘essentially different’ or ‘impossible’.
Signup and view all the answers
In the case of a common mistake, the party invoking the mistake cannot be at ______.
In the case of a common mistake, the party invoking the mistake cannot be at ______.
Signup and view all the answers
The doctrine of ______ applies if the contract contains no provision that covers the situation.
The doctrine of ______ applies if the contract contains no provision that covers the situation.
Signup and view all the answers
Study Notes
Mistake
- A unilateral mistake occurs when one party to a contract is mistaken, and the other party may or may not know about the mistake
- In cases of unilateral mistake, the mistaken party can escape the contract if the other party knows about the mistake (Smith v Hughes)
- However, if the other party does not know about the mistake, there is no relief for the mistaken party
- A unilateral mistake can be either pure (unknown to the other party) or known (the other party knows about the mistake)
Types of Mistake
- Mistake as to terms: a party is mistaken about the terms of the contract
- Known: prevent agreement (Smith v Hughes)
- Unknown: no relief
- Mistaken assumption: a party makes an incorrect assumption about a fact
- No relief, even if the other party knows about the mistake (Smith v Hughes)
- Caveat emptor rule: buyer beware, and the buyer has full opportunity to inspect and form their own judgment
Cases
- Smith v Hughes: unilateral mistaken assumption, no relief even if the other party knows about the mistake
- The buyer is responsible for inspecting and forming their own judgment, and the seller is not liable for the buyer's mistake
- Digilandmall: known unilateral mistake as to the terms of the contract prevents agreement
- The Great Peace: common mistake, contract is rendered void if the mistake is so fundamental that it renders the expected contractual performance impossible
- The Peerless: cross-purposes mistake, may result in no contract
Common Mistake
- Occurs when both parties make the same mistaken assumption
- Test for common mistake: was the mistake so fundamental that it rendered the expected contractual performance impossible or essentially different?
- Effect: contract is rendered void as if there was never a contract
- No relief for common mistake if the terms of the contract govern the eventuality
Cross-Purposes Mistake
- Occurs when both parties are mistaken, but in different ways
- May result in no contract (The Peerless)
- Basis for the judgment: mistake as to terms = lack of agreement / no meeting of the minds, mistaken assumption = akin to common mistake
Effect of Mistake
- Contract is 'void' = there was never a contract
Frustration
- Occurs after the contract formation
- Contract discharged if 'radically different' (Davis Contractors v Fareham UDC)
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.
Description
Test your understanding of contract law, specifically unilateral mistakes, common mistakes, and frustration of contracts. Learn about key cases like Smith v Hughes, The Great Peace, and Davis Contractors v Fareham UDC.
