Podcast
Questions and Answers
During a hijacking, a hijacker shoots and injures a passenger. What crime or crimes are committed?
During a hijacking, a hijacker shoots and injures a passenger. What crime or crimes are committed?
- Violation of the anti-hijacking law and a separate charge for physical injuries.
- Attempted murder and violation of the anti-hijacking law.
- Violation of the anti-hijacking law only.
- Violation of the anti-hijacking law, with the physical injuries absorbed as a qualifying circumstance. (correct)
If hijackers plant explosives on a plane with the intent to detonate it, what is the legal consequence regarding the act of planting explosives?
If hijackers plant explosives on a plane with the intent to detonate it, what is the legal consequence regarding the act of planting explosives?
- It constitutes a separate charge of destructive arson, in addition to the anti-hijacking law.
- It constitutes a separate charge of illegal possession of explosives, in addition to the anti-hijacking law.
- It will qualify the penalty under the anti-hijacking law and is not punishable as a separate crime. (correct)
- It results in multiple charges including violation of the anti-hijacking law, murder, and illegal possession of explosives.
Outside of the four enumerated crimes, how are other acts during a hijacking legally classified?
Outside of the four enumerated crimes, how are other acts during a hijacking legally classified?
- They are treated as mitigating circumstances, potentially reducing the penalty.
- They are merely qualifying circumstances that lead to a higher penalty for the hijacking itself. (correct)
- They are considered separate offenses, each carrying its own penalty.
- They are disregarded if the main crime of hijacking is proven.
Which of the following crimes against the fundamental laws of the State can be committed by any person, not just public officers?
Which of the following crimes against the fundamental laws of the State can be committed by any person, not just public officers?
A public officer, acting outside their official capacity, commits arbitrary detention. Are they liable under Article 124?
A public officer, acting outside their official capacity, commits arbitrary detention. Are they liable under Article 124?
A private citizen conspires with a public officer to commit a violation of domicile. Can the private citizen be held liable?
A private citizen conspires with a public officer to commit a violation of domicile. Can the private citizen be held liable?
Two individuals are disturbing a religious worship service, one is a government official and another is a private citizen. Who among them could be charged for Interruption of Religious Worship?
Two individuals are disturbing a religious worship service, one is a government official and another is a private citizen. Who among them could be charged for Interruption of Religious Worship?
A judge maliciously issues a search warrant without probable cause. What crime is committed?
A judge maliciously issues a search warrant without probable cause. What crime is committed?
What condition must be met regarding witnesses in a treason case, according to the law?
What condition must be met regarding witnesses in a treason case, according to the law?
In what scenario is a simple declaration of 'I’m guilty' insufficient during a trial for treason?
In what scenario is a simple declaration of 'I’m guilty' insufficient during a trial for treason?
Which of the following circumstances is considered inherent in the crime of treason and, therefore, not an aggravating factor?
Which of the following circumstances is considered inherent in the crime of treason and, therefore, not an aggravating factor?
Under what condition is acceptance of a public office under an enemy power NOT considered treasonous?
Under what condition is acceptance of a public office under an enemy power NOT considered treasonous?
What is the determining factor for an alien to be held liable for treason in the Philippines?
What is the determining factor for an alien to be held liable for treason in the Philippines?
Which of the following acts would be considered 'giving aid or comfort' to the enemy in the context of treason?
Which of the following acts would be considered 'giving aid or comfort' to the enemy in the context of treason?
A group of citizens planned to overthrow the current administration during peacetime. Their goal was solely to replace the officials, not to deliver the Philippines to a foreign enemy. Would this be considered treason?
A group of citizens planned to overthrow the current administration during peacetime. Their goal was solely to replace the officials, not to deliver the Philippines to a foreign enemy. Would this be considered treason?
A person performed ministerial functions in a puppet government during wartime. These actions had a negligible impact, neither benefiting the enemy nor harming Filipinos. Would this be considered treason?
A person performed ministerial functions in a puppet government during wartime. These actions had a negligible impact, neither benefiting the enemy nor harming Filipinos. Would this be considered treason?
What constitutes 'delay' under Article 125 of the Revised Penal Code?
What constitutes 'delay' under Article 125 of the Revised Penal Code?
Under what condition can a person's rights under Article 125 be waived?
Under what condition can a person's rights under Article 125 be waived?
What action satisfies the requirement of 'delivery' of a detained person to judicial authority, according to legal interpretations?
What action satisfies the requirement of 'delivery' of a detained person to judicial authority, according to legal interpretations?
What is the effect of filing an information in court on an illegal detention?
What is the effect of filing an information in court on an illegal detention?
To be valid, a waiver of rights under Article 125 should have which of the following characteristics?
To be valid, a waiver of rights under Article 125 should have which of the following characteristics?
A police officer arrests an individual without a warrant for allegedly committing a serious offense. The individual requests a preliminary investigation and executes a valid waiver under Article 125. According to Judge Pimentel, what is the maximum allowable length of this waiver?
A police officer arrests an individual without a warrant for allegedly committing a serious offense. The individual requests a preliminary investigation and executes a valid waiver under Article 125. According to Judge Pimentel, what is the maximum allowable length of this waiver?
In what scenario does Article 125 not apply?
In what scenario does Article 125 not apply?
If a police officer arrests someone under a warrant of arrest, within what time frame must the officer turn over the arrested person to the judicial authority?
If a police officer arrests someone under a warrant of arrest, within what time frame must the officer turn over the arrested person to the judicial authority?
Which scenario constitutes a violation of domicile?
Which scenario constitutes a violation of domicile?
In which situation would a public officer not be liable for violating domicile when entering a private residence?
In which situation would a public officer not be liable for violating domicile when entering a private residence?
Which of the following scenarios would constitute a violation of neutrality by a Filipino citizen, assuming the Philippines has declared neutrality in an ongoing conflict between two foreign nations?
Which of the following scenarios would constitute a violation of neutrality by a Filipino citizen, assuming the Philippines has declared neutrality in an ongoing conflict between two foreign nations?
In a time of peace, an individual performs unauthorized acts that provoke a foreign country. These acts could potentially lead to war involving the Philippines. What crime has been committed?
In a time of peace, an individual performs unauthorized acts that provoke a foreign country. These acts could potentially lead to war involving the Philippines. What crime has been committed?
What is the primary legal principle that the crime of violation of domicile seeks to protect?
What is the primary legal principle that the crime of violation of domicile seeks to protect?
Which of the following actions would not constitute 'against the will of the owner' in the context of trespass to dwelling?
Which of the following actions would not constitute 'against the will of the owner' in the context of trespass to dwelling?
In the context of 'inciting to war,' which action would most likely be considered giving motives for reprisals?
In the context of 'inciting to war,' which action would most likely be considered giving motives for reprisals?
The Philippines is not involved in an ongoing war between two other countries. A regulation has been issued enforcing this neutrality. What element must be present for a person to be found guilty of violating neutrality?
The Philippines is not involved in an ongoing war between two other countries. A regulation has been issued enforcing this neutrality. What element must be present for a person to be found guilty of violating neutrality?
A police officer searches a person outside of their home without a warrant. The person is not arrested. What crime, if any, did the officer commit?
A police officer searches a person outside of their home without a warrant. The person is not arrested. What crime, if any, did the officer commit?
Which circumstance would not be considered an aggravating factor in a violation of domicile case?
Which circumstance would not be considered an aggravating factor in a violation of domicile case?
During a war in which the Philippines is involved, a citizen begins communicating with someone in the hostile country. Under what circumstances is this considered correspondence with a hostile country?
During a war in which the Philippines is involved, a citizen begins communicating with someone in the hostile country. Under what circumstances is this considered correspondence with a hostile country?
A foreign spy performs an act of espionage against the Philippines while physically located in another country. Can the spy be prosecuted in the Philippines?
A foreign spy performs an act of espionage against the Philippines while physically located in another country. Can the spy be prosecuted in the Philippines?
In which scenario would the defense of 'waiver of privacy' likely be successful in a trespass to dwelling case?
In which scenario would the defense of 'waiver of privacy' likely be successful in a trespass to dwelling case?
Which of the following accurately describes the difference between prosecuting crimes against the law of nations versus crimes against national security?
Which of the following accurately describes the difference between prosecuting crimes against the law of nations versus crimes against national security?
A private individual enters someone's home against the owner's explicit wishes. What crime has been committed?
A private individual enters someone's home against the owner's explicit wishes. What crime has been committed?
During peacetime, a private citizen in the Philippines publishes a series of articles online that are highly critical of a foreign government, and these articles are alleged to be inciting to war. What is the most important factor in determining whether this action constitutes the crime of inciting to war?
During peacetime, a private citizen in the Philippines publishes a series of articles online that are highly critical of a foreign government, and these articles are alleged to be inciting to war. What is the most important factor in determining whether this action constitutes the crime of inciting to war?
A private individual, acting in concert with a public officer who has the authority to detain, unlawfully detains a person. Under what circumstances would the private individual NOT be held liable for arbitrary detention?
A private individual, acting in concert with a public officer who has the authority to detain, unlawfully detains a person. Under what circumstances would the private individual NOT be held liable for arbitrary detention?
A public officer with the authority to detain individuals apprehends a person based on a reasonable suspicion of a crime. However, it is later discovered that the person is completely innocent. Is the public officer liable for arbitrary detention?
A public officer with the authority to detain individuals apprehends a person based on a reasonable suspicion of a crime. However, it is later discovered that the person is completely innocent. Is the public officer liable for arbitrary detention?
Which of the following scenarios would most likely constitute arbitrary detention?
Which of the following scenarios would most likely constitute arbitrary detention?
What is the critical distinction between arbitrary detention and illegal detention?
What is the critical distinction between arbitrary detention and illegal detention?
A public officer with detention authority is presented with conflicting information regarding a potential crime. They detain a suspect while they investigate further. Which factor would be most critical in determining if the detention is arbitrary?
A public officer with detention authority is presented with conflicting information regarding a potential crime. They detain a suspect while they investigate further. Which factor would be most critical in determining if the detention is arbitrary?
A person is detained due to violent insanity. Under what condition would this detention be considered arbitrary?
A person is detained due to violent insanity. Under what condition would this detention be considered arbitrary?
A public officer receives a tip that an escaped prisoner is hiding in a specific location. They raid the location and detain all occupants while they search for the escapee. Under which circumstances would the detention of the occupants be considered arbitrary?
A public officer receives a tip that an escaped prisoner is hiding in a specific location. They raid the location and detain all occupants while they search for the escapee. Under which circumstances would the detention of the occupants be considered arbitrary?
Which situation exemplifies a delay in the delivery of detained persons to the proper judicial authorities, thus constituting a form of arbitrary detention?
Which situation exemplifies a delay in the delivery of detained persons to the proper judicial authorities, thus constituting a form of arbitrary detention?
Flashcards
Crimes Against Laws of Nations
Crimes Against Laws of Nations
Crimes that can be prosecuted anywhere because they are against humanity.
Inciting to War
Inciting to War
A crime where unlawful acts provoke a war involving the Philippines or expose citizens to reprisals.
Violation of Neutrality
Violation of Neutrality
The act of violating regulations issued to enforce neutrality when the Philippines is not involved in a war.
Correspondence with Hostile Country
Correspondence with Hostile Country
Signup and view all the flashcards
Inciting to war element A
Inciting to war element A
Signup and view all the flashcards
Inciting to war element B
Inciting to war element B
Signup and view all the flashcards
Violation of neutrality element A
Violation of neutrality element A
Signup and view all the flashcards
Correspondence with hostile country element A
Correspondence with hostile country element A
Signup and view all the flashcards
Treason Witness Rule
Treason Witness Rule
Signup and view all the flashcards
Treason Confession
Treason Confession
Signup and view all the flashcards
Treason Definition
Treason Definition
Signup and view all the flashcards
Allegiance
Allegiance
Signup and view all the flashcards
Inherent Circumstances
Inherent Circumstances
Signup and view all the flashcards
Treason & War
Treason & War
Signup and view all the flashcards
Giving Aid or Comfort
Giving Aid or Comfort
Signup and view all the flashcards
Treason Location
Treason Location
Signup and view all the flashcards
Explosives on Aircraft
Explosives on Aircraft
Signup and view all the flashcards
Hijacking Consequence
Hijacking Consequence
Signup and view all the flashcards
Bomb Threat in Hijacking
Bomb Threat in Hijacking
Signup and view all the flashcards
Arbitrary Detention
Arbitrary Detention
Signup and view all the flashcards
Delay in Delivery
Delay in Delivery
Signup and view all the flashcards
Delaying Release
Delaying Release
Signup and view all the flashcards
Expulsion
Expulsion
Signup and view all the flashcards
Violation of Domicile
Violation of Domicile
Signup and view all the flashcards
Private Person Liability
Private Person Liability
Signup and view all the flashcards
Arbitrary Detention Classes
Arbitrary Detention Classes
Signup and view all the flashcards
Arbitrary Detention Elements
Arbitrary Detention Elements
Signup and view all the flashcards
Definition of Detention
Definition of Detention
Signup and view all the flashcards
Barangay Chairman Authority
Barangay Chairman Authority
Signup and view all the flashcards
Legal Grounds for Detention
Legal Grounds for Detention
Signup and view all the flashcards
Without Legal Grounds
Without Legal Grounds
Signup and view all the flashcards
Who can be guilty of Arbitrary Detention?
Who can be guilty of Arbitrary Detention?
Signup and view all the flashcards
Article 125 Definition
Article 125 Definition
Signup and view all the flashcards
Article 125 Waiver
Article 125 Waiver
Signup and view all the flashcards
Delivery of Detained Person
Delivery of Detained Person
Signup and view all the flashcards
Filing Doesn't Cure Illegality
Filing Doesn't Cure Illegality
Signup and view all the flashcards
Waiver Purpose
Waiver Purpose
Signup and view all the flashcards
Waiver Length
Waiver Length
Signup and view all the flashcards
Warrant Exception
Warrant Exception
Signup and view all the flashcards
Warrant Return Time
Warrant Return Time
Signup and view all the flashcards
Aggravating Circumstance: Nighttime
Aggravating Circumstance: Nighttime
Signup and view all the flashcards
Aggravating Circumstance: Failure to Return
Aggravating Circumstance: Failure to Return
Signup and view all the flashcards
Violation of Domicile: Against the Owner's Will
Violation of Domicile: Against the Owner's Will
Signup and view all the flashcards
Primary Object of Domicile Law
Primary Object of Domicile Law
Signup and view all the flashcards
Private Individual Enters Against Will
Private Individual Enters Against Will
Signup and view all the flashcards
Public Officer Searches Outside Dwelling Illegally
Public Officer Searches Outside Dwelling Illegally
Signup and view all the flashcards
Officer Breaks In After Notice
Officer Breaks In After Notice
Signup and view all the flashcards
Study Notes
- Crimes against national security include treason, conspiracy and proposal to commit treason, misprision of treason, and espionage.
- Crimes against the law of nations include inciting war or giving motives for reprisals, violation of neutrality, corresponding with a hostile country, flight to the enemy's country, and piracy.
- These crimes can be prosecuted even if committed outside Philippine territory, provided the offender is within Philippine territory or is brought there via extradition treaty.
- In the case of crimes against the law of nations, the offender can be prosecuted wherever they are found, as these crimes are regarded as committed against humanity.
Treason (Article 114)
Elements:
- The offender owes allegiance to the Government of the Philippines.
- There is a war in which the Philippines is involved.
- The offender either levies war against the government or adheres to the enemies, giving them aid and comfort.
- Levying war involves a breach of allegiance, actual assembling of men, and the purpose of executing a treasonable design.
- Adhering to the enemies involves a breach of allegiance, adherence, and giving aid or comfort to the enemy. Requirements of levying war
- Actual assembling of men.
- Intent to execute a treasonable design by force.
- Intent to deliver the country, in whole or in part, to the enemy, and collaboration with a foreign entity.
- Success is not required; the actual assembly of men and execution of treasonable design by force are what matter.
- Treason requires two witnesses testifying to the same overt act; testimonies must refer to the same act, place, and time, and cannot be proved by circumstantial evidence or extrajudicial confession.
- An example: one witness saw arms landed and loaded, and another saw the arms unloaded, is insufficient to convict.
- Treason can also be proven by the confession of the accused in open court during arraignment, pre-trial, or trial.
- Saying "I'm guilty" is insufficient; specific acts constituting treason must be stated; withdrawing a plea of "not guilty" during arraignment is unnecessary.
- Treason is a breach of allegiance to the government and can be permanent or temporary, depending on citizenship.
- Evident premeditation, superior strength, and treachery are not aggravating circumstances in treason, as they are inherent.
- Treason cannot be committed in times of peace, only during war or actual hostilities, but no formal declaration of war is needed.
- Acceptance of public office or performing ministerial functions under the enemy is not treasonous unless it involves policy determination, discretion harmful to Filipinos, or is disadvantageous to them.
- Filipino citizens can commit treason outside the Philippines, but aliens must commit it within the Philippines.
- Only Filipino citizens or permanent resident aliens can be held liable.
- Giving aid or comfort is a material element that enhances the enemy's forces.
- Acts strengthening or weakening either side in a war are considered giving aid or comfort.
- Adherence and giving aid or comfort must concur.
- Adherence means intellectually or emotionally favoring the enemy and harboring disloyal convictions.
- Adherence can be proven by one witness, the nature of the act, or the circumstances.
- When adherence is converted into aid and comfort, it takes a material form, such as giving information or supplying war materials.
- Treason is a continuing crime, and offenders can be prosecuted even after the war.
- Irresistible force or uncontrollable fear can be used as a defense.
- Killings and other common crimes charged as overt acts of treason cannot be regarded as separate or complex crimes.
- Common crimes committed within the act of levying war or giving aid are inherent to treason, so complexing is not possible.
- In treason, the offender intends to deliver the government to the enemy, whereas in rebellion, the intent is to replace the government with their own.
- In treason, allegiance to the government is repudiated with force, whereas in sedition, policies are disagreed with, and public peace is disturbed without aiming to overthrow the government.
Conspiracy to Commit Treason (Article 115)
- Elements include being in a time of war, two or more persons agreeing to levy war or aid the enemy, and deciding to commit it. Proposal to Commit Treason
- Being in a time of war.
- A person decides to levy war or aid the enemy and proposes its execution to others
- Mere agreement and decisions to commit treason is punishable, even without acceptance, but acceptance turns it into conspiracy.
- Unlike treason, conspiracy/proposal to commit treason does not require two witnesses.
Misprision of Treason (Article 116)
- Elements:
- The offender owes allegiance to the government and is not a foreigner.
- Knowledge of a conspiracy to commit treason against the government exists.
- The offender conceals or does not disclose and make known the conspiracy as soon as possible to the governor/fiscal or mayor/fiscal where they reside.
- Misprision of treason can be committed only by citizens, not aliens.
- The offender is punished as an accessory to the crime of treason.
- Criminal liability arises if the treasonous activity is at the conspiratorial stage.
- A crime of omission that is committed with intent (dolo) instead of negligence (culpa).
Espionage (Article 117)
- Espionage is entering specific locations without authorization, to obtain confidential information relating to defense of the Philippines:
- Offender enters warship, fort, or naval/military establishments or reservation.
- Without authority.
- Intention to obtain confidential information.
- It can also be committed by disclosing said information to a foreign power
Commonwealth Act No. 616
- Unlawfully obtaining/disclosing national defense information
- Disloyal acts/words in times of peace/war
- Conspiracy to violate above sections
- Harbouring violators of law
- Photographing military information
Crimes Against the Law of Nations
- Offenders relating to these can be prosecuted anywhere because these actions are against humanity.
- Trials against the offenders of "national security" crimes occur in the Philippines.
Inciting to War or Giving Motives for Reprisals (Article 118)
- Elements
- Offender performs unlawful or unauthorised acts.
- The performed acts provoke/give reason for war which involves Philippines.
- OR exposes Filipino citizens to reprisals on their persons/Property
Violation of Neutrality (Article 119)
Elements
- There is a war that the Philipinnes aren't involved in.
- Competent authority issued a regulation enforcing neutrality.
- The offender contradicts this regulation
- Can occur with malicious intent (dolo) or negligence (culpa)
Correspondence with Hostile Country (Article 120)
Elements
- There is time of war which the Philippines is involved in.
- An offender makes correspondence with an enemy country led by enemy troops.
- Circumstances qualifying the offense:
- Notice/information is useful to the enmey.
- An offender is intending to aid the enemy.
- Ciphers negates the need for prohibition.
Flight to Enemy's Country (Article 121)
Elements
- It is a time of war involving the Philippines
- The offender (citizen/resident alien) must owe allegiance to the government.
- The offender attempts to flee or journey to enemy country.
- Competent authority prohibited it.
Piracy (Article 122)
- By attacking or seizing a vessel on high seas/Philippine waters
- Seizing entire/part vessel's cargp, equiptment, belongings on board
- the offending party aren't passengers or vessel crew
Hi-jacking Laws
Four situations governed by anti hi-jacking law:
- Usurping / seizing control of aircraft of Philippine registry while it is in flight.
- Usurping / seizing control of aircraft of foreign registry while within Philippine territory.
- Loading on board a public utility passenger aircraft in the Philippines a corrosive, explosive, poisonous
- Loading/shipping any flammable, corrosive, explosive, or poisonous substance to a cargo aircraft is not consistent to Air Transportation Office rules.
Crimes Against Fundamental Law of the State
- Under Title Two, the perpetrators are public officials, except when it comes " offending the religious" feelings as articulated in Article 133 where it applies to everyone.
- Private citizens may partake in the crime through association as a private entity conspiring with a public officer, or being an accessory or accomplice.
Arbitrary Detention
- According to Article 124.
Elements
- That the offending party is Public officer or employee, authorized duties to arrest /detain.
- That the offending party detains someone "Physical Constraint"'.
- That such Confine lacked legally justifiable grounds A person can be "Detained" when they re under watch & restrained from free will & movement.
- Valid Legal grounds for detention*
- Commission of crime.
- Mental Insanity/illness needed compulsory confinement.
- Escapade from custody.
An "Arbitrary Detention" offence can occur through clear recklessness/ Negligence
- (People vs. Misa)* . Periods of Detention penalized:
- Detention/exceedding for three days.
- Detention for more than three days but not more than 15 days.
- Detention for more than 15 days not more than 6 months.
- Detention surpassing 6 months.
"Continuous crime" isnt the same of" Continuing Crime/Activity" example Ramos vs Enrile Distinction between Arbitrary + Illegal Detention
- Arbitrary Detention
- The offenders incharge are "Public office"
- The appointed officers has a responsibility authorize the party .2 .Illegal Detention.
- Here the Principal Offender acts of"Private capacity" for beyond scope/authorities. The offender, even if he is a public officer, does not include as his function the power to arrest and detain a person, unless he conspires with a public officer committing arbitrary detention Article 125
Delay in Delivery of Detained
- PERSONS*.Legal elements exist
- The offender is Public office'
- That is detained in legal grounds - He fails to facilitate such person of judgement.
- Fails-Deliver person +judgement Authorities with
- 12hrsLight sentences
- 18hrsCorrectional sentences
- 36hrsCapital punishment/severe sentences.
Delaying Release
ELEMENTS: a. That the offender is a public officer or employee b. That there is a judicial or executive order for the release of a prisoner or detention prisoner, or that there is a proceeding upon a petition for the liberation of such person C. 1 .he service of the notice of such order to the prisoner, or 2. the performance of such judicial or executive order for the release of the prisoner, or 3. the proceedings upon a petition for the release of such person
Article 127 Expulsion
- The perpetrators needs to be "Public Office" That he expels any person from the Philippines, or compels a person to change his residence That the offender is not authorized to do so by law
Violation of Dwelling Article
- Must be public Office Elements that has no jurisdiction to over rule enter dwelling
- without judge verdict
3acts
- entering any dwelling against the will of the owner thereof searching papers or other effects found therein without the previous consent of such owner refusing to leave the premises, after having surreptitiously entered said dwelling and after having been required to leave the same
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.