Podcast
Questions and Answers
What does the concept of abuse in a dominant position primarily influence?
What does the concept of abuse in a dominant position primarily influence?
- Consumer purchasing decisions
- The intentions of the undertaking
- The market structure (correct)
- The quality of products
Which of the following best defines 'competition on the merits'?
Which of the following best defines 'competition on the merits'?
- Competition determined by customer preferences
- Competition based on trader’s performance (correct)
- Competition based solely on market share
- Competition involving unethical practices
Which defense allows a dominant undertaking to justify potentially abusive conduct?
Which defense allows a dominant undertaking to justify potentially abusive conduct?
- Economic necessity defense
- Efficiency defense (correct)
- Consumer protection defense
- Market entry defense
Which of the following is NOT a requirement for conduct to be considered objectively justified?
Which of the following is NOT a requirement for conduct to be considered objectively justified?
What does the term 'objective necessity defense' imply?
What does the term 'objective necessity defense' imply?
Which of the following represents the criteria for legally assessing dominant conduct?
Which of the following represents the criteria for legally assessing dominant conduct?
How is 'abuse' characterized in the context of market competition?
How is 'abuse' characterized in the context of market competition?
What is the purpose of the ECJ's analytical frameworks related to dominant undertakings?
What is the purpose of the ECJ's analytical frameworks related to dominant undertakings?
Which of the following represents a legal barrier to entry in a market?
Which of the following represents a legal barrier to entry in a market?
What is the primary criterion used to assess market dominance according to the content?
What is the primary criterion used to assess market dominance according to the content?
What does countervailing buyer power allow customers to do?
What does countervailing buyer power allow customers to do?
Which of the following is NOT a type of barrier to entry?
Which of the following is NOT a type of barrier to entry?
In the context of the ECJ's definition, what does 'market power' refer to?
In the context of the ECJ's definition, what does 'market power' refer to?
Which factor can diminish a customer’s countervailing buyer power?
Which factor can diminish a customer’s countervailing buyer power?
What percentage of market share indicates a rebuttable presumption of dominance according to ECJ practice?
What percentage of market share indicates a rebuttable presumption of dominance according to ECJ practice?
How do economies of scale provide a competitive advantage?
How do economies of scale provide a competitive advantage?
What does the special responsibility of a dominant undertaking entail?
What does the special responsibility of a dominant undertaking entail?
Which case established that a 40% market share is unlikely to indicate dominance?
Which case established that a 40% market share is unlikely to indicate dominance?
What is the impact of customer loyalty on market competition?
What is the impact of customer loyalty on market competition?
What can be considered a financial barrier to entry?
What can be considered a financial barrier to entry?
What does the concept of 'super-dominance' refer to?
What does the concept of 'super-dominance' refer to?
What is one way a buyer can exert countervailing power?
What is one way a buyer can exert countervailing power?
Which of the following elements is NOT part of the definition of a dominant position?
Which of the following elements is NOT part of the definition of a dominant position?
What is implied by the phrase 'the difference with market shares of competitors is very important'?
What is implied by the phrase 'the difference with market shares of competitors is very important'?
What is prohibited under Article 102 TFUE in relation to dominant positions?
What is prohibited under Article 102 TFUE in relation to dominant positions?
Which of the following is a potential form of abusive conduct mentioned in Article 102 TFUE?
Which of the following is a potential form of abusive conduct mentioned in Article 102 TFUE?
What type of practices does Article 2 LDC specifically focus on?
What type of practices does Article 2 LDC specifically focus on?
Which of the following actions could be considered abusive conduct under Article 2 LDC?
Which of the following actions could be considered abusive conduct under Article 2 LDC?
According to Article 102 TFUE, what does it mean to apply dissimilar conditions to equivalent transactions?
According to Article 102 TFUE, what does it mean to apply dissimilar conditions to equivalent transactions?
What is a potential sanction for infringing antitrust laws related to abusive conducts?
What is a potential sanction for infringing antitrust laws related to abusive conducts?
Which of the following actions is NOT considered as abusive under the definitions provided?
Which of the following actions is NOT considered as abusive under the definitions provided?
What could the guidance from the Commission provide regarding Article 102 TFUE?
What could the guidance from the Commission provide regarding Article 102 TFUE?
What is the concept of pure bundling?
What is the concept of pure bundling?
What is an example of predation in business practices?
What is an example of predation in business practices?
What does the term 'refusal to supply' encompass?
What does the term 'refusal to supply' encompass?
What characterizes margin squeezing in market competition?
What characterizes margin squeezing in market competition?
What is a key feature of conditional rebates?
What is a key feature of conditional rebates?
What is meant by multi-product rebates?
What is meant by multi-product rebates?
What is self-preferencing in the context of market competition?
What is self-preferencing in the context of market competition?
What is the primary goal of bundling practices in the marketplace?
What is the primary goal of bundling practices in the marketplace?
What is generally required to prove exclusionary abuse under Article 102?
What is generally required to prove exclusionary abuse under Article 102?
Which of the following is an example of a naked restriction?
Which of the following is an example of a naked restriction?
Which conduct does NOT have a specific legal test under the 2024 Proposal?
Which conduct does NOT have a specific legal test under the 2024 Proposal?
What presumption can be made once exclusionary conduct is established?
What presumption can be made once exclusionary conduct is established?
Which conduct is typically associated with tying practices?
Which conduct is typically associated with tying practices?
What is a characteristic of exclusive dealing agreements?
What is a characteristic of exclusive dealing agreements?
What does predatory pricing aim to achieve?
What does predatory pricing aim to achieve?
Which action exemplifies self-preferencing?
Which action exemplifies self-preferencing?
What is the main purpose behind the guidance on enforcement priorities for Article 82?
What is the main purpose behind the guidance on enforcement priorities for Article 82?
What is a margin squeeze in the context of exclusionary conduct?
What is a margin squeeze in the context of exclusionary conduct?
Flashcards
Dominant Position
Dominant Position
A company's dominant position in the market that allows them to dictate prices or conditions to their competitors.
Abuse
Abuse
Any practice by a company that unfairly harms its competitors through their dominant position.
Abusive Conduct
Abusive Conduct
Practices like setting unfair prices, restricting supply, or discriminating against certain customers.
Article 102 TFUE
Article 102 TFUE
Signup and view all the flashcards
Examples of Abusive Conduct (Article 102 TFUE)
Examples of Abusive Conduct (Article 102 TFUE)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Article 2 LDC
Article 2 LDC
Signup and view all the flashcards
Supplementary Obligations (Article 102 TFUE)
Supplementary Obligations (Article 102 TFUE)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Sanctions for Infringement
Sanctions for Infringement
Signup and view all the flashcards
Jurisprudence Concept of Dominance
Jurisprudence Concept of Dominance
Signup and view all the flashcards
Market Share
Market Share
Signup and view all the flashcards
Market Share Threshold for Dominance
Market Share Threshold for Dominance
Signup and view all the flashcards
Rebuttable Presumption of Dominance
Rebuttable Presumption of Dominance
Signup and view all the flashcards
Special Responsibility
Special Responsibility
Signup and view all the flashcards
Criteria for Assessing Dominance
Criteria for Assessing Dominance
Signup and view all the flashcards
Difference in Market Shares
Difference in Market Shares
Signup and view all the flashcards
Potential Competition
Potential Competition
Signup and view all the flashcards
Barriers to Entry
Barriers to Entry
Signup and view all the flashcards
Legal Barriers to Entry
Legal Barriers to Entry
Signup and view all the flashcards
Financial Barriers to Entry
Financial Barriers to Entry
Signup and view all the flashcards
Economies of Scale
Economies of Scale
Signup and view all the flashcards
Economies of Scope
Economies of Scope
Signup and view all the flashcards
Opportunity Costs
Opportunity Costs
Signup and view all the flashcards
Countervailing Buyer Power
Countervailing Buyer Power
Signup and view all the flashcards
Intention in Abuse
Intention in Abuse
Signup and view all the flashcards
Competition on the Merits
Competition on the Merits
Signup and view all the flashcards
What is Article 102 TFEU?
What is Article 102 TFEU?
Signup and view all the flashcards
Specific Legal Tests for Article 102
Specific Legal Tests for Article 102
Signup and view all the flashcards
Objective Justification as a Defense
Objective Justification as a Defense
Signup and view all the flashcards
Objective Necessity Defense
Objective Necessity Defense
Signup and view all the flashcards
Efficiency Defense
Efficiency Defense
Signup and view all the flashcards
Examples of Objective Justification
Examples of Objective Justification
Signup and view all the flashcards
What is a Dominant Position?
What is a Dominant Position?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What is Abuse (in EU competition law)?
What is Abuse (in EU competition law)?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What is Abusive Conduct?
What is Abusive Conduct?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What is 'Tying' in EU competition law?
What is 'Tying' in EU competition law?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What are 'Multi-product rebates'?
What are 'Multi-product rebates'?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What is 'Self-preferencing'?
What is 'Self-preferencing'?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What is 'Refusal to Supply'?
What is 'Refusal to Supply'?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What is 'Predatory pricing'?
What is 'Predatory pricing'?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What is 'Margin squeeze'?
What is 'Margin squeeze'?
Signup and view all the flashcards
Bundling
Bundling
Signup and view all the flashcards
Predation
Predation
Signup and view all the flashcards
Refusal to Supply
Refusal to Supply
Signup and view all the flashcards
Margin Squeeze
Margin Squeeze
Signup and view all the flashcards
Conditional Rebates
Conditional Rebates
Signup and view all the flashcards
Multi-Product Rebates
Multi-Product Rebates
Signup and view all the flashcards
Self-Preferencing
Self-Preferencing
Signup and view all the flashcards
Other Abusive Conduct
Other Abusive Conduct
Signup and view all the flashcards
Study Notes
Lesson 5: Antitrust Law (3): Abusive Conducts
- The lesson covers dominant position, abuse, frequent abusive conducts, and sanctions for infringement.
Article 102 TFUE
- Abuse by one or more undertakings of a dominant position within the internal market is prohibited, affecting trade between member states.
- Dominant position abuse can consist of directly or indirectly imposing unfair purchase or selling prices, limiting production/markets, applying dissimilar conditions, or making contract conclusion contingent on accepting unrelated obligations.
- Guidance on the enforcement priorities for abusive exclusionary conduct by dominant undertakings is relevant.
Article 2 LDC
- Any abuse by one or more undertakings of their dominant position in all or part of the national market is prohibited.
- Possible abuses include imposing unfair trading or service conditions and limiting/restricting production or tech development, thereby prejudicing undertakings or consumers.
- Abusive practices may involve unjustified refusal to satisfy purchase demands or using dissimilar conditions in equivalent transactions.
- Making contracts subject to unnecessary supplemental obligations is also considered an instance of possible abuse.
1. Dominant Position
-
Dominant position is defined by ECJ in United Brands case, emphasizing economic strength allowing a company to behave independently of competitors, customers and ultimately consumers.
-
To prevent effective competition is a crucial part of this definition
-
Economic strength is connected to market power.
-
Dominant undertakings have a special responsibility to avoid harming genuine undistorted competition.
-
Criteria like market share and potential competition are also assessed.
-
Market Share:
- A high percentage of sales usually indicates a dominant position.
- The EC generally considers a market share under 40% non-dominant, although the 2024 proposal may change that.
- A share above 50% suggests a dominant position (Akzo v Commission), and above 70% is a clear indication of dominance (Hilti v Commission).
-
Potential Competition: Pressure can come from undertakings not yet in the market, if the conditions are attractive to them. Factors like legal barriers, financial barriers, economies—of-scale, opportunity costs, difficulties in accessing raw materials and consumer preferences (loyalties) can play a vital role in potential competition.
-
Countervailing buyer power: The ability of customers to switch suppliers or vertically integrate can counter the dominant position.
-
Structure of the undertaking: vertical integration, financial strength, technical superiority, and pre/post-sales services can give them an advantage.
2. Abuse
- Abuse is objectively related to the behaviour of a dominant undertaking in a particular market that affects the degree of competition or its growth.
- Intention is irrelevant in this context.
- The conduct has to be assessed objectively.
- A standard has been developed to evaluate whether a conduct can be legitimately viewed as a competition-based response, in respect of price, quality or innovation.
- Dominant undertakings are required to apply different legal tests depending on the specific behaviour; guidelines help in that regard.
Objective Justification
- A dominant undertaking’s conduct might be justified as necessary, i.e. objectively necessary ("objective necessity defense") or beneficial if it produces efficiencies that outweigh potential negative impacts on competition.
Exploitative and Exclusionary Abuses
- Exploitative abuses directly harm the customers of dominant undertakings through things like unfair pricing or trading conditions.
- Exclusionary abuses aim to restrict competition or exclude competitors from the market.
Frequent Abusive Practices
- Article 102 of the TFUE and Article 2 of the LDC list practices like unfairly setting purchase/selling prices, limiting production, applying dissimilar conditions, or making contract obligations unrelated to the main subject of the contract as possible cases of abuse.
Specific Forms of Exclusionary Abuses
- The guidelines list particular exclusionary conduct such as exclusive dealing, tying, predatory pricing and margin squeeze. These have specific legal tests for assessing their acceptability.
- These guidelines are crucial to understand the type of conducts that are problematic in relation to the abusive exclusionary conduct by a dominant enterprise.
Sanction for Infringement
- Abusive practices aren't exempt. Appropriate measures, like cessation orders and fines, may be imposed for infringements, but structural remedies (divestiture) are less frequent.
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.