Code Review Questions on Functions and Error Handling
15 Questions
0 Views

Choose a study mode

Play Quiz
Study Flashcards
Spaced Repetition
Chat to lesson

Podcast

Play an AI-generated podcast conversation about this lesson

Questions and Answers

What is the purpose of the add2Nums function in this code?

  • To store all numbers from the input into an array.
  • To combine two strings and return their total as a string. (correct)
  • To read numbers from a file and output their sum.
  • To convert an array of integers into a string format.

    • What would happen if numbers.txt does not exist or cannot be opened?

  • The program would read from a default input until EOF.
  • The program would continue executing without any output.
  • The program would output an error message and terminate. (correct)
  • The program would initialize `total` to zero and proceed.

    • What kind of value does the function strRevToArray return?

  • An integer representing the length of the input string.
  • It does not return a value at all. (correct)
  • A pointer to an array of characters.
  • A reversed version of the input string.

    • Why is using an array advantageous over integer variables when performing operations on very large sums?

    <p>Arrays allow for manipulation of data that exceeds the capacity of standard integer types.</p> Signup and view all the answers

    What potential issue can arise when summing large numbers using standard integer types instead of arrays?

    <p>Risk of integer overflow leading to incorrect results.</p> Signup and view all the answers

    Why does the program store string values in reverse order when summing large numbers?

    <p>To simplify the addition algorithm by aligning digits from least significant to most significant.</p> Signup and view all the answers

    In what way does the design choice of reversing the array values impact the construction of the final answer string?

    <p>The final answer is built backwards and then reversed back to normal.</p> Signup and view all the answers

    What is a potential downside of reversing the string values in the arrays for addition?

    <p>It may lead to confusion in interpreting the results of the addition.</p> Signup and view all the answers

    What role does the boolean flag variable serve in the code?

    <p>It ensures that leading zeros are removed from the output.</p> Signup and view all the answers

    In the context of this program, why is a carry-over necessary during the addition process?

    <p>To handle situations where the sum exceeds single-digit representation.</p> Signup and view all the answers

    What is the significance of the way strings are reversed in the addition process?

    <p>It mimics arithmetic operations performed from right to left.</p> Signup and view all the answers

    What issue could arise from the use of eof() in the loop that reads numbers from the file?

    <p>It may skip the last number if not followed by a newline.</p> Signup and view all the answers

    Match the following functions or blocks of code with their descriptions:

    <p>strRevToArray = Reverses a string and stores it in an integer array add2Nums = Adds two large numbers represented as strings main function = Reads numbers from a file and sums them return statement in add2Nums = Constructs the final answer string for output</p> Signup and view all the answers

    Match the following variables with their roles in the program:

    <p>MAX = Defines the maximum size for the number array carryOver = Stores the carry value during addition total = Holds the cumulative sum of the numbers read from the file flag = Indicates when a non-zero digit has been found for the answer</p> Signup and view all the answers

    Match the following aspects of the code with their importance:

    <p>Reversing strings for addition = Facilitates processing digits from least to most significant Using an array for sums = Allows representation of large numbers beyond standard limits The final answer construction = Ensures the correct order of the summed number is displayed The input file reading = Enables handling of multiple large numbers efficiently</p> Signup and view all the answers

    Study Notes

    Code Review Questions

    • Input Validation: Is there adequate input validation for the numbers.txt file? What happens if the file doesn't exist, is empty, or contains non-numeric strings? The code should check for file existence and handle potential std::ifstream errors. It needs to ensure each line read from numbers.txt is a valid 50-digit number. Input validation for numbers.txt is crucial to prevent unexpected behaviors. Checks for file existence, empty files, and non-numeric content are essential; exception handling is important for std::ifstream errors. Ensuring each line is precisely a 50-digit numeric value is required.
    • Error Handling: How are potential errors (e.g., overflow during addition) handled in the add2Nums function? Does the code provide informative error messages to the user? The code should explicitly address potential overflow during addition. Overflow detection should be used with clear, informative error messages when large numbers are involved. The code should include detailed error handling for potential overflow conditions during addition. This may involve checking the result against maximum possible values. Informative error messages should guide users on erroneous inputs.
    • strRevToArray Function: What is the purpose of this function? What are its inputs and outputs? How does it handle empty strings or strings longer than the MAX limit? Is the reversed array used correctly in the add2Nums function? How does it manage potential memory issues or invalid input? Why use an array to store digits instead of integer variables? The function reverses the input string and stores each digit in an integer array. This facilitates right-to-left addition. MAX limits the number of digits per input, which must be checked. Error checks for MAX length strings are crucial. The code must explicitly manage string length to prevent buffer overflows. Use of an array facilitates handling large numbers. Potential errors or invalid strings should be explicitly handled through error conditions or exceptions.
    • add2Nums Function: Does the function correctly perform the addition of two numbers represented as strings? Does it handle potential carry-overs in addition properly? What are the limits and potential overflow issues? Is there any potential for integer representation issues? How are the inputs processed effectively to operate like decimals (e.g., 12345, 87463 etc)? The function takes two string numbers and reverses them, converts them to integer arrays, adds digits in a loop and handles carryovers. The function processes carryover values, which requires checking for potential carry-overs. Error handling for addition overflow should be considered. Input validation to prevent integer representation issues and overflow in results is essential. The function needs validation of the inputs before using them, preventing unexpected behavior and errors. The function must handle carry-overs correctly for proper addition. Consider using arbitrary-precision arithmetic if standard integers might not be sufficient.
    • String Management: How are string lengths managed, and does the code handle possible issues stemming from string processing (e.g., input string lengths exceeding available memory)? Does it address potential allocation errors? The code likely allocates space for strings up to MAX size. Overflow or underflows must be checked. Input validation is important to determine if inputs are within the permitted length limits. Preventing potential crashes due to memory errors is vital.
    • Efficiency: Are there ways to improve the efficiency of the add2Nums function? Does the code avoid unnecessary memory allocations? The addition process may be inefficient for extremely large numbers. Alternatives to improve efficiency include the use of arbitrary-precision arithmetic libraries.
    • General Design: Explore alternative approaches for storing/managing the input numbers. Could these help to simplify the logic and improve clarity? Using arbitrary-precision arithmetic libraries may be preferable to handling large numbers with arrays.
    • File I/O: Is the file being properly closed after use? Is there sufficient error checking for cases such as insufficient file permissions? The file should be closed using in.close() to release resources after use. The code should include error checking for file opening failures, using exceptions where appropriate.
    • Input limitations: What are the potential input limitations and possible edge cases (e.g., very large numbers, empty input lines.) Are there limits on the size of input numbers? How does the code behave if a single input number overflows? A check for valid file lengths, as well as error handling where needed, are vital for reliable operation. Input from numbers.txt must be checked for valid format and adherence to the MAX input specification (e.g. 50 digits). The limits of the MAX size need thorough checking as well. Extreme numbers, empty lines in numbers.txt and invalid format should be checked against.
    • Clarity and Readability: Is the code well-commented and easy to follow? Are variable names descriptive and meaningful? Are there areas where the code could be better formatted for readability? Using meaningful variable names improves clarity. Comments clarify complex parts and design decisions.
    • Robustness: Could the code be made robust and handle unexpected input or errors? Robust input handling is essential. Error checking and handling is critical. add2Nums should explicitly handle unexpected edge cases. Prevent malformed input and unexpected value formats when reading from the file.
    • Correctness: Is there a way to test or verify that the addition logic within the add2Nums function is correct? Use unit tests to compare calculations for smaller numbers, including test cases with various condition. Evaluate whether the output correctly meets the expected results.
    • Array Usage (Digits): Why is an array used to store the digits of a number instead of integers? Arrays give flexibility for storing and adding digits efficiently.
    • Reversal in strRevToArray: Why are string values reversed into arrays? Reversing facilitates right-to-left addition, a standard mathematical approach.

    Additional Feedback from a Code Reviewer

    • Error handling: The code lacks robust error handling. Thorough error handling is needed for conditions such as file not found, invalid input, or overflow.
    • Memory Management: The code could benefit from better memory management practices. Dynamic memory allocation should be used for managing large numbers to prevent memory overflow and allocation failures. Carefully consider potential memory leaks that can arise from dynamic allocation issues. Validate user input and allocate memory only when needed.
    • String Validation: Input validation for checking malformed or erroneous data in the input file is missing. Basic validation is required before use.
    • Algorithm Efficiency: For very large numbers, iterative string addition is inefficient compared to potentially specialized large number libraries. Algorithms that efficiently handle large integers should be considered, especially for substantial string data.
    • Clarity: Comments and variable names are insufficient. More detailed comments explaining each function's purpose and the logic behind the addition algorithm, especially for complex components, are essential.

    Studying That Suits You

    Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.

    Quiz Team

    Description

    This quiz focuses on evaluating code quality, particularly in the context of input validation and error handling for functions like add2Nums and strRevToArray. You'll explore how various scenarios are managed, including edge cases and potential memory issues. Test your understanding and identify key areas of improvement.

    More Like This

    Use Quizgecko on...
    Browser
    Open
    Browser
    Browser