Podcast
Questions and Answers
What does Article 107.1 TFEU state about state aid?
What does Article 107.1 TFEU state about state aid?
- It allows all forms of state aid without restrictions.
- It exempts specific types of state aid from legal scrutiny.
- It mandates that state aid always promote competition.
- It restricts state aid that distorts competition and affects trade. (correct)
Which type of aid is explicitly compatible with the common market according to Article 107.2 TFEU?
Which type of aid is explicitly compatible with the common market according to Article 107.2 TFEU?
- Aid granted to all businesses regardless of their impact.
- Aid having a social character, granted to individual consumers. (correct)
- Aid provided for training programs in any industry.
- Aid to support the production of luxury goods.
What is the purpose of Article 108 regarding individual exemptions?
What is the purpose of Article 108 regarding individual exemptions?
- To promote state aid to increase national competition.
- To outline the procedures for individual exemptions of state aid. (correct)
- To describe the process for granting all forms of state aid.
- To prevent any forms of state aid in the EU.
Which of the following is NOT categorized under compatible state aid in Article 107.2 TFEU?
Which of the following is NOT categorized under compatible state aid in Article 107.2 TFEU?
What is the focus of Article 109 in relation to state aid?
What is the focus of Article 109 in relation to state aid?
What is an example of prohibited conduct under antitrust law?
What is an example of prohibited conduct under antitrust law?
Which article addresses the concept of abuse of dominant position?
Which article addresses the concept of abuse of dominant position?
How is the term 'undertaking' defined in antitrust law?
How is the term 'undertaking' defined in antitrust law?
What does Regulation 139/2004 primarily control?
What does Regulation 139/2004 primarily control?
Which of the following best describes 'State aids' under EU law?
Which of the following best describes 'State aids' under EU law?
In the context of antitrust law, what does the term 'economic activity' refer to?
In the context of antitrust law, what does the term 'economic activity' refer to?
Which aspect of antitrust law does the case C-882/19 Sumal, S.L. v Mercedes Benz Trucks España, S.L. relate to?
Which aspect of antitrust law does the case C-882/19 Sumal, S.L. v Mercedes Benz Trucks España, S.L. relate to?
What does 'controlled conduct' typically refer to in antitrust law?
What does 'controlled conduct' typically refer to in antitrust law?
What are the three possible decisions made during Phase 1 of the CNMC review process according to the procedure?
What are the three possible decisions made during Phase 1 of the CNMC review process according to the procedure?
Which of the following is NOT a criterion for the appraisal of concentrations under Article 10 LDC?
Which of the following is NOT a criterion for the appraisal of concentrations under Article 10 LDC?
What happens if a concentration is not authorised or is subject to conditions?
What happens if a concentration is not authorised or is subject to conditions?
Which of the following factors relates to the economic efficiencies derived from a merger?
Which of the following factors relates to the economic efficiencies derived from a merger?
Which alternative criteria may the Council of Ministers consider according to Art. 10.4 LDC?
Which alternative criteria may the Council of Ministers consider according to Art. 10.4 LDC?
Which statement accurately describes the relationship between the structure of relevant markets and merger control?
Which statement accurately describes the relationship between the structure of relevant markets and merger control?
Which of the following elements is NOT part of the definition of State aid under Article 107 TFEU?
Which of the following elements is NOT part of the definition of State aid under Article 107 TFEU?
What is a potential factor that could reduce barriers to entry in markets according to the merger control criteria?
What is a potential factor that could reduce barriers to entry in markets according to the merger control criteria?
What is implied by the term 'selectivity of the measure' in the context of State aid?
What is implied by the term 'selectivity of the measure' in the context of State aid?
What aspect of competition does Article 10 LDC specifically NOT focus on during the review process?
What aspect of competition does Article 10 LDC specifically NOT focus on during the review process?
Which factor indicates that State aid may exist?
Which factor indicates that State aid may exist?
What does the term 'State origin' include?
What does the term 'State origin' include?
How can State aid affect competition?
How can State aid affect competition?
What is meant by 'affects trade between Member States' in the context of State aid?
What is meant by 'affects trade between Member States' in the context of State aid?
Which type of funding is considered a part of State resources?
Which type of funding is considered a part of State resources?
What is the significance of economic benefits derived from State aid?
What is the significance of economic benefits derived from State aid?
What is a primary criterion for evaluating competition within the common market?
What is a primary criterion for evaluating competition within the common market?
What action can the Commission take if a concentration has been implemented in contravention of a decision?
What action can the Commission take if a concentration has been implemented in contravention of a decision?
Which of the following operations is considered a concentration according to the merger regulations?
Which of the following operations is considered a concentration according to the merger regulations?
What is the minimum market share for a merger to have national dimension in Spain?
What is the minimum market share for a merger to have national dimension in Spain?
Which factor does NOT typically contribute to the assessment of competition in a market?
Which factor does NOT typically contribute to the assessment of competition in a market?
What is considered a merger according to the legal definitions provided?
What is considered a merger according to the legal definitions provided?
What threshold must be reached for the turnover of all undertakings in Spain to trigger merger control?
What threshold must be reached for the turnover of all undertakings in Spain to trigger merger control?
Which statement accurately describes the role of consumer interests in merger analysis?
Which statement accurately describes the role of consumer interests in merger analysis?
What criteria must be met for a concentration to have a Community dimension?
What criteria must be met for a concentration to have a Community dimension?
What occurs during Phase 1 of the merger control process?
What occurs during Phase 1 of the merger control process?
Which of the following statements is true regarding the decision-making process at the end of Phase 2?
Which of the following statements is true regarding the decision-making process at the end of Phase 2?
What is the main consideration when determining if a concentration significantly impedes effective competition?
What is the main consideration when determining if a concentration significantly impedes effective competition?
What can happen if a concentration is declared compatible with conditions?
What can happen if a concentration is declared compatible with conditions?
What happens if a concentration does not fall within the scope of the merger control regulation?
What happens if a concentration does not fall within the scope of the merger control regulation?
Which regulation outlines the initial notification requirements for merger control?
Which regulation outlines the initial notification requirements for merger control?
Under what circumstances would a concentration be declared incompatible with the common market?
Under what circumstances would a concentration be declared incompatible with the common market?
Flashcards
What is an 'undertaking' in antitrust law?
What is an 'undertaking' in antitrust law?
Refers to any entity engaged in an economic activity, regardless of its legal status or financing. It's a broad concept encompassing businesses, organizations, and individuals involved in market transactions.
What are prohibited conducts?
What are prohibited conducts?
These are practices specifically prohibited by antitrust laws. They violate competition rules and can be punished by fines or other sanctions.
What are controlled conducts?
What are controlled conducts?
These are practices that antitrust authorities can monitor and regulate, but they're not inherently illegal. However, they can be restricted or modified to ensure fair competition.
What is collusion in the context of antitrust law?
What is collusion in the context of antitrust law?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What is abuse of dominant position?
What is abuse of dominant position?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What are mergers in the context of antitrust law?
What are mergers in the context of antitrust law?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What are state aids in the context of antitrust law?
What are state aids in the context of antitrust law?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What is the relevant market in antitrust law?
What is the relevant market in antitrust law?
Signup and view all the flashcards
Community Dimension in EU Merger Control
Community Dimension in EU Merger Control
Signup and view all the flashcards
Phase 1 (Initial Screening) in EU Merger Control
Phase 1 (Initial Screening) in EU Merger Control
Signup and view all the flashcards
Phase 2 (Full Proceedings) in EU Merger Control
Phase 2 (Full Proceedings) in EU Merger Control
Signup and view all the flashcards
Conditions in EU Merger Control
Conditions in EU Merger Control
Signup and view all the flashcards
Incompatible Merger
Incompatible Merger
Signup and view all the flashcards
Compatible Merger
Compatible Merger
Signup and view all the flashcards
Decision on Merger Compatibility
Decision on Merger Compatibility
Signup and view all the flashcards
Compatible Merger with Conditions
Compatible Merger with Conditions
Signup and view all the flashcards
EU Merger Control Criterion
EU Merger Control Criterion
Signup and view all the flashcards
EU Commission Powers in Mergers
EU Commission Powers in Mergers
Signup and view all the flashcards
What is a merger in Spanish Law?
What is a merger in Spanish Law?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What is an Acquisition in Spanish Law?
What is an Acquisition in Spanish Law?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What is a Joint Venture in Spanish Law?
What is a Joint Venture in Spanish Law?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What is an Example of an operation not considered a concentration in Spanish Law?
What is an Example of an operation not considered a concentration in Spanish Law?
Signup and view all the flashcards
When is a merger subject to Spanish control?
When is a merger subject to Spanish control?
Signup and view all the flashcards
Spanish Law on Mergers (LDC)
Spanish Law on Mergers (LDC)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Spanish Merger Control: CNMC Role
Spanish Merger Control: CNMC Role
Signup and view all the flashcards
Phase 1: Decision Points
Phase 1: Decision Points
Signup and view all the flashcards
Phase 2: In-Depth Review
Phase 2: In-Depth Review
Signup and view all the flashcards
Council of Ministers' Final Say
Council of Ministers' Final Say
Signup and view all the flashcards
Economic Criteria
Economic Criteria
Signup and view all the flashcards
General Interest Criteria
General Interest Criteria
Signup and view all the flashcards
Concentration Operation: Conditions and Outcomes
Concentration Operation: Conditions and Outcomes
Signup and view all the flashcards
Concentration Operation: CNMC Review
Concentration Operation: CNMC Review
Signup and view all the flashcards
State Aid (EU)
State Aid (EU)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Art. 107.1 TFEU (General Rule)
Art. 107.1 TFEU (General Rule)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Art. 107.2 TFEU (Legal Exemption)
Art. 107.2 TFEU (Legal Exemption)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Art. 107.3 TFEU (Criteria for Individual Exemption)
Art. 107.3 TFEU (Criteria for Individual Exemption)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Art. 108 TFEU (Procedure for Individual Exemptions)
Art. 108 TFEU (Procedure for Individual Exemptions)
Signup and view all the flashcards
What is State Aid?
What is State Aid?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What is an 'undertaking' in the context of State Aids?
What is an 'undertaking' in the context of State Aids?
Signup and view all the flashcards
How can aid have a 'State origin'?
How can aid have a 'State origin'?
Signup and view all the flashcards
How can aid grant an 'advantage' to an undertaking?
How can aid grant an 'advantage' to an undertaking?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What makes State aid 'selective'?
What makes State aid 'selective'?
Signup and view all the flashcards
How does State aid affect 'competition'?
How does State aid affect 'competition'?
Signup and view all the flashcards
How does State aid affect 'trade between Member States'?
How does State aid affect 'trade between Member States'?
Signup and view all the flashcards
How does State aid affect trade even if a recipient isn't involved cross-border trade?
How does State aid affect trade even if a recipient isn't involved cross-border trade?
Signup and view all the flashcards
Study Notes
Lesson 3: Introduction to Antitrust Law
- This lesson covers prohibited and controlled conduct in antitrust law.
- Prohibited conducts include collusion (art. 101 TFEU; art. 1 LDC) and abuse of dominant position (art. 102 TFEU; art. 2 LDC).
- Controlled conducts include mergers (Regulation 139/2004; art. 7-10 LDC) and state aids (art. 107-109 TFEU; art. 11 LDC).
Concept of "Undertaking"
- An undertaking is a key concept in antitrust law, defined by the European Court of Justice (ECJ).
- An undertaking encompasses any entity engaged in economic activity, regardless of legal form or financing.
- Spanish Law, aligns with the ECJ's definition in its additional provisions.
- It's an autonomous concept in EU law that applies to all competition law areas (collusion, dominant position, mergers, and state aids). This includes both public and private actions.
Relevant Market
- The relevant market is defined for each specific antitrust case.
- The Commission and national courts utilize it to determine the boundaries of competition between undertakings.
- The Commission uses this concept to identify competitors and to evaluate market power.
- It helps assess how a specific conduct impacts competition including in cases of suspected collusion or abuse of dominant position. It also helps analyzing concentrations in merger cases.
- The definition encompasses product and geographic dimensions.
- It's a core concept in EU and Spanish competition law.
- Essential for evaluating the impact of a specific act on competition in a given sector.
EU Merger Control
- EU merger control is governed by Regulation 139/2004, with related regulations like those for horizontal merger assessments.
- A concentration happens when undertakings merge, acquire control, or form joint ventures. Certain types of business transactions, such as temporary security holdings and insolvency proceedings, aren't considered concentrations.
- A concentration triggers EU-level scrutiny if the combined worldwide turnover of all undertakings surpasses a threshold (EUR 5000 million), and the combined Community-wide turnover of at least two of the undertakings exceeds another threshold (EUR 250 million).
- The process involves notifications, initial assessments (Phase I), and potentially further in-depth examinations (Phase II).
- Decisions will be rendered if the concentration is compatible or incompatible with the common market. Compatible decisions may come with conditions to mitigate potential anti-competitive impacts
- The EU Commission has significant powers to intervene. The EU Commission may impose measures to reverse the concentration to safeguard competition.
Spanish Merger Control
- Spanish merger control is guided by the Spanish Law, and related texts.
- It defines concentrations similarly to the EU regulation (merger, acquisition, joint ventures).
- It establishes criteria for determining whether a transaction is a concentration, differing in some areas from the EU guidelines.
- A distinct threshold for the national dimension of a concentration exists.
- The regulatory body in Spain is CNMC.
- The process has similar phases as with EU mergers.
EU State Aids
- EU state aids are regulated by Articles 107-109 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union.
- State aid is any form of aid granted by a member state or via state resources, distorting competition.
- Aid granted to undertakings, have a state origin, is selectively advantageous, and impacts trade among member states is assessed.
- Several categories of state aids are exempt, such as those related to social, environmental, economic support to lagging regions and others.
- The specific rule and exemptions are defined in the relevant Regulation and the EU Commission has the power for further specific control of state aid.
Spanish State Aids
- Spanish state aids are governed by the Spanish Law (LDC), with considerations similar to EU's criteria.
- The Spanish National Competition Commission (CNMC) plays a significant role in monitoring and potentially evaluating issues.
- The CNMC has limited powers but may issue reports and provide recommendations.
- The Spanish National Competition Commission also receives and revises reports of state aid from autonomous communities.
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.