Analysis of Primary Sources and Pigafetta's Chronicle

Choose a study mode

Play Quiz
Study Flashcards
Spaced Repetition
Chat to Lesson

Podcast

Play an AI-generated podcast conversation about this lesson
Download our mobile app to listen on the go
Get App

Questions and Answers

Which aspect of a primary source does external criticism primarily address?

  • The truthfulness of the events described.
  • The document's authenticity. (correct)
  • The author's personal biases.
  • The accuracy of the content's details.

Why is it important to consider the context of a primary source's production?

  • To disregard any potential biases present.
  • To ensure the source is free from any subjective interpretations.
  • To understand how the author's background and time period influenced their writing. (correct)
  • To quickly validate the source’s historical accuracy.

What challenge does translating historical texts, like Pigafetta's chronicle, present to historians?

  • Ensuring the translated text is longer than the original to avoid omissions.
  • Finding equivalent meanings when translating between languages. (correct)
  • Guaranteeing the translated text contains no errors.
  • Eliminating the need for any further interpretation of the events.

Why is Pigafetta's account of the first voyage around the world considered a 'classic work of writing'?

<p>It provides a firsthand account of events during a significant historical expedition. (C)</p> Signup and view all the answers

Pigafetta's descriptions of the natives encountered during Magellan's voyage are based on what?

<p>His individual judgement and cultural perspective. (A)</p> Signup and view all the answers

Why did Magellan rename the Ladrones Islands as the Marianas Islands?

<p>Due to the theft of important items from the Galleon. (B)</p> Signup and view all the answers

What action demonstrated the initial friendly interaction between Magellan and the King of Mazaua?

<p>The exchange of gifts and expression of a desire for brotherhood. (A)</p> Signup and view all the answers

What was the significance of Magellan explaining the cross, crown, and nails to the two kings after the Easter Sunday Mass?

<p>To convey the religious and imperial authority of Spain and its emperor. (D)</p> Signup and view all the answers

What decision was made that resulted in the first Catholic mass being held in the Philippines?

<p>The indigenous leader's willing agreement to plant a cross. (D)</p> Signup and view all the answers

What triggered the battle between Magellan's forces and Lapulapu's warriors on Mactan?

<p>Lapulapu's refusal to obey the King of Zubu and align with Magellan. (A)</p> Signup and view all the answers

Flashcards

Primary Sources

Materials such as documents, memoirs, accounts and events written or produced at the period of the incident.

External Criticism

Examines the authenticity of the document, ensuring it was not created or fabricated.

Internal Criticism

Examines the truthfulness, accuracy, and veracity of the content based on available evidence.

Who was Antonio Pigafetta?

Italian nobleman who chronicled Magellan's voyage, providing insights into precolonial Philippines.

Signup and view all the flashcards

Humunu Island

Magellan's fleet reached this island (now Homonhon), marking the "first signs of gold."

Signup and view all the flashcards

Balangay

Long boats full of people seen in Mazzava (Mazaua), showcasing local maritime technology.

Signup and view all the flashcards

March 31, 1521

Island where Magellan ordered a mass to celebrate Easter Sunday.

Signup and view all the flashcards

Significance of the Cross

The king's emperor wants to plant this cross in their island.

Signup and view all the flashcards

Blood Compact

Symbolic ceremony of friendship between Magellan and the King of Zubu, ensuring peaceful relations.

Signup and view all the flashcards

Who was Lapulapu?

Datu of Mactan who fought against Magellan's forces, resisting the King of Zubu's orders.

Signup and view all the flashcards

Study Notes

  • Historical sources are primary tools for understanding, including lucid interpretation, because they contain historical facts.
  • Primary sources are materials like documents, memoirs, and subjective accounts from the period of the incident.

Analyzing Primary Sources

  • Primary sources undergo external criticism to examine the authenticity of the document or evidence.
  • Internal criticism is applied to determine the truthfulness, veracity, and accuracy of the content.
  • Both criticisms intersect to examine the source's context and production conditions, considering the author's background and the period.

Pigafetta's Chronicle

  • Pigafetta's book is a primary source as he chronoicled events he witnessed during Magellan's voyage.
  • The original Italian text losses details during translation to english
  • Pigafetta, an Italian nobleman, accompanied Ferdinand Magellan and his chronicles became a "classic work of writing" known as "Interpretations of the New World.”
  • The book contains important details about precolonial Philippines from Pigafetta's perspective during Magellan's expedition.
  • "The First Voyage Around the World by Magellan" (PRIMO VIAGGIO INTORNO AL MONDO) was published after Pigafetta's return to Italy.
  • Pigafetta wrote firsthand observations and impressions of the Far East, including the Visayas Islands.
  • His accounts became a lesson of human experience and tinted as baptizers of names among a number of islands.
  • The “Ladrones Islands”, now called the Marianas Islands, are located south-east of Japan, west-southeast of Hawaii, north of New Guinea, and east of the Philippines.
  • Pigafetta describes natives of Ladrones Islands as “people of sticks with fishbone in the end and has no arms, very poor, indigenous and were great thieves.”

Magellan's Arrival and Interactions

  • Ten days after reaching Zamal (Samar), Magellan settled in a nearby uninhabited island.
  • On March 18, 1521, nine men from Samar brought food, drinks, and gifts.
  • Magellan received fresh fish, palm wine, two coconuts, rice (humai), and other food supplies.
  • Pigafetta described coconut trees, their fruit, and uses in fastening boats.

Encounters and Exchanges

  • Pigafetta described the terrain and the locals' willingness to show different islands.
  • Magellan's fleet reached Humunu Island, renamed as the "Archipelago of St. Lazarus" with "first signs of gold”.
  • Pigafetta saw two indigenous boats named balangay in Mazzava (Mazaua) and the King sent gold and ginger to Magellan, who declined it.
  • Magellan sent an interpreter to request food and clarify his friendly intentions.
  • The King provided food, and Magellan gifted robes, red caps, knives, and mirrors.
  • Leaders expressed desires to become friends and brothers, showcasing weapons, armor, maps, and charts.
  • Pigafetta wrote of visiting the brother of the King on another island where they saw gold mines.
  • Part of the King's Balangay was made of gold, with the King adorned with silk, gold, and a golden dagger.

Mass Celebration and Alliances

  • Kings Raha Siagu, and Raha Kalambu were present.
  • On March 31, 1521, Magellan ordered a Mass to celebrate Easter Sunday with the Kings sending pigs for the feast.
  • The kings offered offerings, kissed the cross, and kneeled during consecration.
  • Magellan explained the significance of the cross and crown, symbolizing his emperor's desire to plant the cross in their island.
  • The Datu allowed the planting of the cross, believing in its protective benefits.
  • This event was the first Eucharistic Catholic celebration in the Philippines.

Exploration of New Islands

  • Magellan sought food supplies and then arrived to Leyte called Ceylon Island, then to Bohol and Zubu (now Cebu).
  • Raja Kalambo guided Magellan to Zubu, impressed by its civilization and richness.
  • The king of Zubu implemented the tributary system where entrants to his port had to obey and pay.
  • Magellan offered friendship instead of tribute to the king of Zubu.

Friendship and Conversion

  • Magellan and the king of Zubu underwent a blood compact.
  • Visitors offered gifts to the Datu's family as customary practice.
  • Magellan evangelized, highlighting Christianity's values of respect and love.
  • Many natives of Zubu embraced Christianity, including the Datu, who was baptized Carlos in honor of the King of Spain.
  • Magellan named the Datu's son Fernand and a Muslim native Christopher.
  • Those who opposed baptism were ostracized and had their houses burned.
  • Magellan gifted the queen an image of Sto. Niño (Holy Infant Jesus) and insisted on one god to be worshipped, ordering idols to be burned.
  • Refusal to burn idols led to a healing ceremony, with Magellan's priest administering baptism and anointing of the sick.

Battle Of Mactan

  • On April 16, 1521, Zula sought Magellan's help against Lapulapu, who defied the King of Zubu.
  • Magellan went to Mactan with three boats full of his sixteen men each.
  • Magellan instructed the King of Zubu not to join the battle to observe European weaponry.
  • Over 1,500 Mactan warriors attacked Magellan's forces, who were divided into squads.
  • Despite firing at distance, the attack persisted with arrows and spears.
  • Warriors targeted legs and arms with arrows, resulting in Magellan's death.
  • Magellan was stricken thrice with poisoned arrows, leading to his demise in battle.
  • Natives were successful in their attacks, and the men in charge of burning houses were also targeted.

Aftermath

  • The people of Mactan refused to return Magellan's body and kept it as a symbol of victory.
  • Surviving crew negotiated with the Datu of Mactan but failed to retrieve Magellan's body
  • Datu of Cebu, invited the crew for a gathering and intended to present jewels for the King of Spain, but an attack occurred, resulting in some being slain.
  • Juan Serrano was kept for ransom but remaining crew left hearing distress
  • Juan Sebastian Elcano and 17 survivors reached San Lucar de Barrameda, Spain, on September 6, 1522 and who received recognition from Emperor Charles V.
  • Elcano was granted a coat-of-arms with a globe and the title "Primus Circundedisti Me" ("You went around me first").
  • Pigafetta stated the voyage covered 14,460 leagues, about 81,449 kilometers.

Studying That Suits You

Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.

Quiz Team

Related Documents

More Like This

Use Quizgecko on...
Browser
Browser