A Misfortune by Anton Chekhov

Podcast

Play an AI-generated podcast conversation about this lesson

Questions and Answers

How did Sofya Petrovna feel about Ilyin's situation?

Indifferent

Sympathetic (correct)

Joyful

Angry

Sofya Petrovna felt triumphant and powerful in the presence of Ilyin.

True

What allowed Sofya Petrovna to think about her situation more clearly?

Her ideas grew clearer and her spirits rose.

Sofya Petrovna was amused by the cutting jests of _____.

Ilyin Signup and view all the answers

What song did Sofya Petrovna sing that reflected her feelings about old age?

'And old age comes nearer and nearer.' Signup and view all the answers

What did Sofya Petrovna's husband think about her feelings?

He believed she was lying. Signup and view all the answers

Sofya Petrovna felt a strong, overpowering desire when she was alone.

True Signup and view all the answers

What did Sofya recognize about her actions during the gathering?

She realized she had behaved badly and foolishly. Signup and view all the answers

Sofya Petrovna referred to herself as an '____' for her weakness.

immoral wretch Signup and view all the answers

Sofya Petrovna is in love with Ilyin.

True Signup and view all the answers

What is the name of the protagonist's husband?

Andrey Ilyitch Signup and view all the answers

What does Sofya Petrovna ask Ilyin to do?

Stay away from her Signup and view all the answers

Sofya Petrovna has a daughter named _____.

Varya Signup and view all the answers

Sofya Petrovna feels proud of her interaction with Ilyin.

False Signup and view all the answers

How does Ilyin feel about his behavior towards Sofya?

He considers it criminal and immoral. Signup and view all the answers

What does Sofya Petrovna do to prove she is still a good wife and mother after her encounter with Ilyin?

She prepares dinner for her husband and cares for her daughter. Signup and view all the answers

What is Ilyin's main struggle?

To fight his feelings for Sofya Signup and view all the answers

The story was written by _____.

Anton Chekhov Signup and view all the answers

Study Notes

Characters

Sofya Petrovna: The wife of notary Lubyantsev, a beautiful woman in her mid-twenties facing a moral dilemma.
Ilyin: A young lawyer infatuated with Sofya, battling between his feelings and the principles of morality.

Setting

Time: Late afternoon, approximately five o'clock.
Place: A wooded area near a railway embankment, with a striking church visible in the background.

Themes

Love and Temptation: The complex emotions of desire versus loyalty, as Ilyin pursues Sofya despite her marital commitments.
Moral Conflict: Sofya’s struggle between her feelings for Ilyin and her love and responsibilities towards her husband and daughter.
Nature of Relationships: The dynamics of friendship and love, highlighted by Ilyin's inability to accept platonic relations after confessing his love.

Plot Summary

Sofya and Ilyin encounter each other during a stroll, prompting a serious conversation about Ilyin's romantic advances.
Sofya insists on maintaining their friendship and refuses to accept Ilyin's pursuit, emphasizing her commitment to family.
Despite her words, Ilyin struggles with his romantic feelings, expressing anguish over his inability to walk away.

Key Moments

Ilyin's emotional breakdown as he kneels before Sofya, signifying the intense power of his feelings and his desperation.
Sofya's internal conflict becomes apparent as she feels flattered by Ilyin’s affection, despite her attempts to push him away.
The symbolic moment of the goods train passing, representing the monotonous reality of life contrasting with their tumultuous feelings.

Symbolism

Clouds & Nature: Reflect the internal emotional landscape of the characters; the tranquil setting contrasts with their turbulent feelings.
Train: Represents departure and the journey's end, foreshadowing the potential consequences of their actions.

Sofya’s Realization

Post-encounter, Sofya reflects on her actions with guilt and shame, acknowledging her weakness in the face of temptation.
She attempts to reaffirm her role as a devoted wife and mother, leading to a resolve to avoid Ilyin in the future.

Conflict and Resolution

Sofya’s conflicting feelings about her husband Andrey and Ilyin lead to confusion about her identity and values.
Despite her initial verbal commitments to staying away from Ilyin, her actions and thoughts show ongoing inner turmoil.

Conclusion

Ilyin's emotional state deteriorates as he grapples with his love for Sofya, leading to a cycle of despair.
The narrative ends with an air of unresolved tension, reflecting the complexities of human emotion and societal expectations regarding love and marriage.### Emotional Conflict and Youthful Egoism
Sofya Petrovna feels a twinge of heartache, recognizing her influence over Ilyin, who is visibly unhappy.
Instead of confronting Ilyin, she revels in her power and attention from him, showcasing youthful pettiness and egoism.

Evening of Revelry

Enjoys the party atmosphere characterized by laughter, singing, and flirtation, oblivious to Ilyin's struggles.
Amusement stems from past memories and present interactions, including Ilyin's witty remarks and an amusing pin on his cravat.

Tension with Ilyin

Ilyin expresses deep affection, attempting to woo Sofya, while she maintains her distance, initially repulsing his advances.
His emotional declarations and physical closeness stir conflicting feelings within her, highlighting her internal struggle.

Confrontation with Self

After retreating from Ilyin, Sofya experiences feelings of weakness and guilt for her behavior, reflecting on her moral standing and past actions.
She grapples with an oppressive desire that manifests following Ilyin's embrace, leading to self-loathing and internal critique.

Struggle with Desire

Sofya's thoughts transition from guilt to acknowledgment of her desires and temptations, revealing a profound conflict between her values and instincts.
She chastises herself for her perceived immorality and the fleeting nature of her struggles, feeling more like a slave to her desires than a determined individual.

Relationship with Andrey Ilyitch

Expresses her wish to leave with her husband, Andrey, indicating her growing emotional discontent and connection to Ilyin.
Andrey's lack of concern and dismissive attitude about her feelings demonstrates a disconnect in their marriage, failing to recognize her turmoil.

Decision and Resolution

Unable to gain Andrey's support for a walk, Sofya's resolve strengthens in the face of overwhelming desire.
Her departure into the night symbolizes a search for freedom and an escape from societal and personal constraints, despite her self-condemnation.

Theme of Immorality and Conformity

Sofya continuously labels herself as immoral, revealing internalized societal judgments about women's desires and agency.
The juxtaposition of her secret longing and the public façade emphasizes the struggle women face between societal expectations and personal autonomy.

Studying That Suits You

Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.

Description

Explore Anton Chekhov's short story 'A Misfortune', which delves into the life of Sofya Petrovna, the wife of a notary, as she encounters a lawyer in a picturesque setting. The narrative unfolds against the backdrop of nature, revealing deeper themes of human emotion and societal norms. Join this quiz to test your understanding of the text and its nuances.