Podcast
Questions and Answers
What is the correct formula for the traditional equally-weighted three-factor apportionment?
What is the correct formula for the traditional equally-weighted three-factor apportionment?
- App't Factor = 1/4(Sales Factor) + 1/2(Payroll Factor) + 1/4(Property Factor)
- App't Factor = 1/3(Sales Factor) + 1/3(Payroll Factor) + 1/3(Property Factor) (correct)
- App't Factor = 2/5(Sales Factor) + 1/5(Payroll Factor) + 2/5(Property Factor)
- App't Factor = 1/2(Sales Factor) + 1/4(Payroll Factor) + 1/4(Property Factor)
Which of the following factors is NOT typically included in the apportionment formula?
Which of the following factors is NOT typically included in the apportionment formula?
- Payroll Factor
- Sales Factor
- Property Factor
- Revenue Factor (correct)
In a double-weighted sales factor formula, how is the apportionment factor calculated?
In a double-weighted sales factor formula, how is the apportionment factor calculated?
- App't Factor = 3/4(Sales Factor) + 1/8(Payroll Factor) + 1/8(Property Factor)
- App't Factor = 2/4(Sales Factor) + 1/4(Payroll Factor) + 1/4(Property Factor) (correct)
- App't Factor = 1/2(Sales Factor) + 1/2(Payroll Factor)
- App't Factor = 1/3(Sales Factor) + 1/3(Payroll Factor) + 1/3(Property Factor)
What is the correct definition of the payroll factor in the context of apportionment?
What is the correct definition of the payroll factor in the context of apportionment?
When is a taxpayer entitled to apportion their income?
When is a taxpayer entitled to apportion their income?
Which method requires that all sales of combined group members be treated as a single entity for apportionment?
Which method requires that all sales of combined group members be treated as a single entity for apportionment?
Under the Joyce rule, how are sales from entities with no stand-alone nexus treated?
Under the Joyce rule, how are sales from entities with no stand-alone nexus treated?
Which state's application of the unitary business concept requires a two-year holding period?
Which state's application of the unitary business concept requires a two-year holding period?
In the context of combined reporting, what principle does not have a 'bright-line' definition?
In the context of combined reporting, what principle does not have a 'bright-line' definition?
What is the basis of the historic development of the unitary business principle?
What is the basis of the historic development of the unitary business principle?
Which test is primarily subjective and has had its definitions developed through case law?
Which test is primarily subjective and has had its definitions developed through case law?
What distinguishes the Joyce and Finnigan rules regarding combined reporting?
What distinguishes the Joyce and Finnigan rules regarding combined reporting?
Which of the following is a requirement in New York's application of the unitary business concept?
Which of the following is a requirement in New York's application of the unitary business concept?
In California, how is the location of benefit from a service determined when the customer is an individual?
In California, how is the location of benefit from a service determined when the customer is an individual?
What does 'throwback rules' entail regarding sales of tangible property?
What does 'throwback rules' entail regarding sales of tangible property?
How is the location of benefit determined for business customers in California?
How is the location of benefit determined for business customers in California?
Which of the following accurately describes the throw-out rules?
Which of the following accurately describes the throw-out rules?
What does 'look-through rules' imply for services delivered electronically?
What does 'look-through rules' imply for services delivered electronically?
Which situation indicates that the presumption of benefit location for a service is overcome?
Which situation indicates that the presumption of benefit location for a service is overcome?
Why could throwback rules potentially cause businesses to be taxed at multiples of their earned income in a state?
Why could throwback rules potentially cause businesses to be taxed at multiples of their earned income in a state?
What does the term 'benefit of a service is received' generally mean?
What does the term 'benefit of a service is received' generally mean?
What is defined as 'Business Income' according to UDITPA § 1(a)?
What is defined as 'Business Income' according to UDITPA § 1(a)?
Which of the following is categorized as 'Nonbusiness Income'?
Which of the following is categorized as 'Nonbusiness Income'?
According to MTC Regulation § IV.I (a), how is business income defined?
According to MTC Regulation § IV.I (a), how is business income defined?
What type of income provides an exception to the classification as 'Business Income'?
What type of income provides an exception to the classification as 'Business Income'?
Which of the following elements must be present for income to be classified as 'Business Income'?
Which of the following elements must be present for income to be classified as 'Business Income'?
What is a potential source of controversy regarding business income at the state level?
What is a potential source of controversy regarding business income at the state level?
Which of the following is NOT considered business income under UDITPA?
Which of the following is NOT considered business income under UDITPA?
What must a transaction achieve to satisfy the economic substance doctrine?
What must a transaction achieve to satisfy the economic substance doctrine?
Which of the following best characterizes the nature of Nonbusiness Income?
Which of the following best characterizes the nature of Nonbusiness Income?
Which of the following best characterizes the totality of circumstances test?
Which of the following best characterizes the totality of circumstances test?
What is the main inquiry of the substance over form doctrine?
What is the main inquiry of the substance over form doctrine?
Which of the following doctrines primarily involves evaluating the taxpayer's motives?
Which of the following doctrines primarily involves evaluating the taxpayer's motives?
When might the substance over form doctrine typically be raised?
When might the substance over form doctrine typically be raised?
What is a common application of the business purpose doctrine?
What is a common application of the business purpose doctrine?
In which case did the substance over form doctrine originate?
In which case did the substance over form doctrine originate?
Which of the following concepts overlaps with the economic substance doctrine?
Which of the following concepts overlaps with the economic substance doctrine?
What methodology do states rely on to divide the taxable income of a unitary business?
What methodology do states rely on to divide the taxable income of a unitary business?
What did the United States Supreme Court rule regarding unfair apportionment?
What did the United States Supreme Court rule regarding unfair apportionment?
What is the purpose of the internal consistency test in the fair apportionment prong?
What is the purpose of the internal consistency test in the fair apportionment prong?
What may a taxpayer petition for if the statutory method does not fairly reflect their business activity in the state?
What may a taxpayer petition for if the statutory method does not fairly reflect their business activity in the state?
Which case established the necessity for fair apportionment of profits earned in a state?
Which case established the necessity for fair apportionment of profits earned in a state?
What does the external consistency test evaluate in fair apportionment?
What does the external consistency test evaluate in fair apportionment?
What constitutional principle limits a state's ability to choose an apportionment method?
What constitutional principle limits a state's ability to choose an apportionment method?
What aspect differentiates statutory fair apportionment from constitutional fair apportionment?
What aspect differentiates statutory fair apportionment from constitutional fair apportionment?
Flashcards
Three-factor formula
Three-factor formula
A traditional formula for apportioning income, combining sales, payroll, and property factors equally.
Apportionment formula
Apportionment formula
A method used to divide a business's income among different states where it operates to calculate the tax liability for each state.
Sales Factor
Sales Factor
A component of the apportionment formula, calculated by dividing sales within a state by total sales everywhere.
Payroll Factor
Payroll Factor
Signup and view all the flashcards
Property Factor
Property Factor
Signup and view all the flashcards
Business Income
Business Income
Signup and view all the flashcards
Non-Business Income
Non-Business Income
Signup and view all the flashcards
UDITPA § 1(a)
UDITPA § 1(a)
Signup and view all the flashcards
UDITPA § 1(e)
UDITPA § 1(e)
Signup and view all the flashcards
MTC Regulation § IV.I (a)
MTC Regulation § IV.I (a)
Signup and view all the flashcards
MTC Regulation § IV.I (c)
MTC Regulation § IV.I (c)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Unitary Business
Unitary Business
Signup and view all the flashcards
Extraordinary Transactions
Extraordinary Transactions
Signup and view all the flashcards
Benefit of Service
Benefit of Service
Signup and view all the flashcards
California Service Sales
California Service Sales
Signup and view all the flashcards
Throw-Back Rules
Throw-Back Rules
Signup and view all the flashcards
Throw-Back Impact
Throw-Back Impact
Signup and view all the flashcards
Throw-Out Rules
Throw-Out Rules
Signup and view all the flashcards
Look-Through Rules
Look-Through Rules
Signup and view all the flashcards
Express Scripts
Express Scripts
Signup and view all the flashcards
Net Income
Net Income
Signup and view all the flashcards
What is the 'Joyce' rule?
What is the 'Joyce' rule?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What is the 'Finnigan' rule?
What is the 'Finnigan' rule?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What is the unitary business principle?
What is the unitary business principle?
Signup and view all the flashcards
Fair Apportionment?
Fair Apportionment?
Signup and view all the flashcards
Unitary Business Tests
Unitary Business Tests
Signup and view all the flashcards
State Statutory Application
State Statutory Application
Signup and view all the flashcards
Historical Development of the Unitary Business Principle
Historical Development of the Unitary Business Principle
Signup and view all the flashcards
Constitutional Fair Apportionment
Constitutional Fair Apportionment
Signup and view all the flashcards
Commerce Clause
Commerce Clause
Signup and view all the flashcards
Complete Auto 4-prong test
Complete Auto 4-prong test
Signup and view all the flashcards
Burden of Proof
Burden of Proof
Signup and view all the flashcards
Alternative Apportionment
Alternative Apportionment
Signup and view all the flashcards
Economic Substance Doctrine
Economic Substance Doctrine
Signup and view all the flashcards
Totality of Circumstances
Totality of Circumstances
Signup and view all the flashcards
Substance Over Form
Substance Over Form
Signup and view all the flashcards
Business Purpose Doctrine
Business Purpose Doctrine
Signup and view all the flashcards
Sham Transaction
Sham Transaction
Signup and view all the flashcards
Step Transaction Doctrine
Step Transaction Doctrine
Signup and view all the flashcards
Disjunctive Test
Disjunctive Test
Signup and view all the flashcards
Overlap of Doctrines
Overlap of Doctrines
Signup and view all the flashcards
Study Notes
Table of Contents
- State and Local Tax Sources (page 2)
- Basic Elements in the Analysis of Taxes (page 2)
- Jurisdiction to Tax – Analytical Framework (page 2)
- U.S. Statutes (page 5)
- State Constitution (page 5)
- Nexus (page 5)
- Computation of State Tax Liability (page 5)
- Fair Apportionment (Third Prong) (page 5)
- Weighing of Factors (page 6)
- Apportionment (page 6)
- Business vs. Nonbusiness Income (page 7)
- Special Problems with the Sales Factor (page 9)
- Sales of TPP (page 11)
- Cost of Performance Sourcing: Focus on the Service in Terms of Sourcing (page 12)
- Market-Based Sourcing (page 13)
- Unitary Business Principle (page 15)
- Overview of the Unitary Business Principle (page 15)
- Historical Development (page 16)
- U.S. Supreme Court Tests for Unity (page 16)
- Modern US Supreme Court Decisions (page 16)
- Special Issues in Unitary Taxation (page 18)
- Versions of Unitary Combined Reporting Tax (page 18)
- Forced Combination (page 21)
- Corporate Income Tax Base; Filing Methods (page 19)
- State Corporate Income Tax Base (page 19)
- Common Nonconformity Issues (page 19)
- Return Filing Methods (page 20)
- Payments to Related Entities (page 21)
- Constitutional Distortion and Equitable Apportionment (page 23)
- What is “fair apportionment”? (page 23)
- Corporate Income Tax Planning State Challenges (page 25)
- Economic Substance Doctrine (page 25)
- Substance Over Form Doctrine (page 26)
- Business Purpose Doctrine (page 26)
- Sham Transaction (page 26)
- Step Transaction (page 27)
- Areas of Uncertainty (page 31)
- Federal Codification (2010) (page 31)
- State Codification (page 31)
- Sales and Use Taxes (page 32)
- Who is liable for sales and use tax? (page 32)
- Taxable Incident: What is a sale? (page 33)
- Taxable incident: What is a use? (page 33)
- Jurisdictional Requirement (sourcing): Where is it taxable? (page 33)
- What is taxable? (page 33)
- What items are generally subject to Sales and Use Tax? (page 34)
- Bundling and Mixed Transactions (page 35)
- Streamlined Sales and Use Tax Agreement (page 37)
- Registration and Reporting Requirements (page 37)
- Sale Tax Audits & Litigation (page 37)
- Evaluating a Company's Position and Potential Exposure (page 38)
- Gross Receipts Taxes (page 38)
- Key Issues (page 39)
- Payments to Related Entities (page 40)
- Computation of State Tax Liability (page 40)
- Invoking Alternative Apportionment (page 37)
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.