Podcast
Questions and Answers
Who was appointed by the United Nations in 2023 to their high-level advisory body on artificial intelligence?
Who was appointed by the United Nations in 2023 to their high-level advisory body on artificial intelligence?
- Sir Geoffrey Hinton
- Dr. Fei-Fei Li
- Professor Nick Bostrom
- Dame Wendy Hall (correct)
What is one way suggested to engage with policymakers?
What is one way suggested to engage with policymakers?
- By publishing a book
- By signing up for mailing lists (correct)
- By organizing a community protest
- By creating an online petition
Which of the following questions is NOT suggested for evaluating a policy proposal?
Which of the following questions is NOT suggested for evaluating a policy proposal?
- Will it actually work?
- Is it impactful? (correct)
- Is it legal?
- Is it affordable?
What is a critical consideration when proposing a new policy?
What is a critical consideration when proposing a new policy?
Which organization is associated with a policy brief on National AI Strategy?
Which organization is associated with a policy brief on National AI Strategy?
What is the primary focus when identifying policy?
What is the primary focus when identifying policy?
Which of the following represents a type of policy decision that is made occasionally?
Which of the following represents a type of policy decision that is made occasionally?
Which example represents evidence that can influence policy?
Which example represents evidence that can influence policy?
In the context of policymaking, regulations for new technology are derived from which type of evidence?
In the context of policymaking, regulations for new technology are derived from which type of evidence?
What is a key requirement before attempting to influence policymakers?
What is a key requirement before attempting to influence policymakers?
What should researchers focus on when identifying a policy decision to influence?
What should researchers focus on when identifying a policy decision to influence?
Which group is NOT typically identified as a key influencer in policy decisions?
Which group is NOT typically identified as a key influencer in policy decisions?
Which method is NOT recommended when researchers are unsure about identifying policymakers?
Which method is NOT recommended when researchers are unsure about identifying policymakers?
What should policymakers consider regarding research contributions?
What should policymakers consider regarding research contributions?
What framework is suggested for winning at policy?
What framework is suggested for winning at policy?
Which entity is part of the UK’s local government system?
Which entity is part of the UK’s local government system?
What is an essential element of policy-making theory?
What is an essential element of policy-making theory?
What is a common misconception about the role of research in policy-making?
What is a common misconception about the role of research in policy-making?
What is a key consideration when preparing evidence for engagement with stakeholders?
What is a key consideration when preparing evidence for engagement with stakeholders?
Which approach increases the likelihood of stakeholder engagement?
Which approach increases the likelihood of stakeholder engagement?
What is a recommended strategy for engaging stakeholders during meetings?
What is a recommended strategy for engaging stakeholders during meetings?
What should you consider when looking for a 'hook' in your engagement strategy?
What should you consider when looking for a 'hook' in your engagement strategy?
Which method is NOT a means of reaching stakeholders mentioned in the content?
Which method is NOT a means of reaching stakeholders mentioned in the content?
Why is it important to know counter-arguments when preparing for stakeholder interactions?
Why is it important to know counter-arguments when preparing for stakeholder interactions?
What is crucial for following up with potential contacts after an initial meeting?
What is crucial for following up with potential contacts after an initial meeting?
How can smaller meetings, like social seminars, impact stakeholder engagement?
How can smaller meetings, like social seminars, impact stakeholder engagement?
What is a key element that a policy brief must include?
What is a key element that a policy brief must include?
What should the language of a policy brief primarily focus on?
What should the language of a policy brief primarily focus on?
Which of the following describes the primary purpose of a policy brief?
Which of the following describes the primary purpose of a policy brief?
What is often highlighted in a policy brief to attract policymakers' attention?
What is often highlighted in a policy brief to attract policymakers' attention?
Which of the following statements best describes how to design an engagement plan?
Which of the following statements best describes how to design an engagement plan?
Why is it important to seek recommendations from stakeholders?
Why is it important to seek recommendations from stakeholders?
What does it mean to become a 'usual suspect' in public policy engagement?
What does it mean to become a 'usual suspect' in public policy engagement?
What is essential to prepare when planning your approach for a policy brief?
What is essential to prepare when planning your approach for a policy brief?
What is the primary purpose of a policy brief?
What is the primary purpose of a policy brief?
Which element is not typically included in a well-structured policy brief?
Which element is not typically included in a well-structured policy brief?
When analyzing the political context for a policy brief, which of the following should be considered?
When analyzing the political context for a policy brief, which of the following should be considered?
What distinguishes a recommendation from an implication in a policy brief?
What distinguishes a recommendation from an implication in a policy brief?
What is a recommended length for a policy brief?
What is a recommended length for a policy brief?
What aspect should be prioritized when writing the key messages in a policy brief?
What aspect should be prioritized when writing the key messages in a policy brief?
In preparing a policy brief, which type of data is most beneficial for framing the issue?
In preparing a policy brief, which type of data is most beneficial for framing the issue?
Which question is key for policymakers considering the evidence presented in a policy brief?
Which question is key for policymakers considering the evidence presented in a policy brief?
Flashcards
What is policy?
What is policy?
A set of plans or ideas about what to do in certain situations, officially agreed upon by a group, organization, government, or political party.
What is policy? (Costigan definition)
What is policy? (Costigan definition)
Decisions about what to do in different circumstances.
Policy is about decisions
Policy is about decisions
Understanding which decision needs to be influenced is crucial for effective policy work.
Types of policy decisions (common)
Types of policy decisions (common)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Evidence vs Policy
Evidence vs Policy
Signup and view all the flashcards
Policy Rationale
Policy Rationale
Signup and view all the flashcards
Policy Objectives
Policy Objectives
Signup and view all the flashcards
Policy Evaluation
Policy Evaluation
Signup and view all the flashcards
Policy Implementation
Policy Implementation
Signup and view all the flashcards
Policy Monitoring
Policy Monitoring
Signup and view all the flashcards
Policy Appraisal
Policy Appraisal
Signup and view all the flashcards
Policy Feedback
Policy Feedback
Signup and view all the flashcards
Influencers of Policy Decisions
Influencers of Policy Decisions
Signup and view all the flashcards
Identifying Key Stakeholders
Identifying Key Stakeholders
Signup and view all the flashcards
Policy Evaluation Criteria
Policy Evaluation Criteria
Signup and view all the flashcards
UN AI Advisory Body
UN AI Advisory Body
Signup and view all the flashcards
Engaging in Policy Development
Engaging in Policy Development
Signup and view all the flashcards
Influencing Policymakers
Influencing Policymakers
Signup and view all the flashcards
What is a policy brief?
What is a policy brief?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What makes a policy brief effective?
What makes a policy brief effective?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What is the ideal length of a policy brief?
What is the ideal length of a policy brief?
Signup and view all the flashcards
How should a policy brief be structured?
How should a policy brief be structured?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What is essential for a policy brief?
What is essential for a policy brief?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What is the core of a policy brief?
What is the core of a policy brief?
Signup and view all the flashcards
Why is an executive summary important?
Why is an executive summary important?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What is the target audience for a policy brief?
What is the target audience for a policy brief?
Signup and view all the flashcards
Identify stakeholders & desired action
Identify stakeholders & desired action
Signup and view all the flashcards
Prepare evidence for engagement
Prepare evidence for engagement
Signup and view all the flashcards
Create clear and concise "policy briefs"
Create clear and concise "policy briefs"
Signup and view all the flashcards
Plan for personalized stakeholder engagement
Plan for personalized stakeholder engagement
Signup and view all the flashcards
Contextualize evidence for engagement
Contextualize evidence for engagement
Signup and view all the flashcards
Anticipate and address counterarguments
Anticipate and address counterarguments
Signup and view all the flashcards
Listen actively and be adaptable
Listen actively and be adaptable
Signup and view all the flashcards
Seek recommendations for next steps
Seek recommendations for next steps
Signup and view all the flashcards
Pace of change
Pace of change
Signup and view all the flashcards
Implementation
Implementation
Signup and view all the flashcards
Political context
Political context
Signup and view all the flashcards
Framing the issue
Framing the issue
Signup and view all the flashcards
Realistic recommendations
Realistic recommendations
Signup and view all the flashcards
Policy brief
Policy brief
Signup and view all the flashcards
Policy brief purpose
Policy brief purpose
Signup and view all the flashcards
Policy brief characteristics
Policy brief characteristics
Signup and view all the flashcards
Study Notes
Identifying and Influencing Policymakers
- A policy is a set of ideas or a plan for dealing with specific situations, officially agreed upon by a group (e.g., people, business, government, political party).
- Policy decisions can be about starting an action, stopping an action, or changing the method of doing something.
- Policy decisions sometimes involve preventing or halting actions already planned or considered.
- Policymakers cover a range of entities: UK National Government, National Parliament, Local Government, Devolved Assemblies, International Organisations, and Governments/Parliament's in other countries.
- Key influencers in a particular policy decision include civil servants, directors/deputy directors, learned bodies (e.g. RCGP), those affected by the decision (i.e., the public), Parliament (e.g., APPGs, Select Committees), politicians, and PPS (Parliamentary Private Secretaries).
- Key members of a typical government department include the Secretary of State, other ministers, Permanent Secretary, and civil servants (Director-General, Director, Deputy Director).
- Resources available to help find policymakers (e.g., government departments, representatives) include online tools, such as gov.uk, which provides relevant contact information, news, publications, and areas of responsibility. Specific details include the names of ministers, senior civil servants, latest news, publications, and areas of responsibility within government agencies.
- The UK government has departments focused on AI, including the Department for Science, Innovation, and Technology (DSIT), and the Office for AI.
- The UK Parliament scrutinizes the work of the government and makes new laws, as well as providing policy recommendations to the government.
- Parliament includes select committees, bill committees, all-party parliamentary groups, individual MPs, the libraries of both houses (Commons and Lords), and the Parliamentary Office of Science and Technology.
- Local Government focuses on sub-national policy decisions and service delivery.
- International organizations also have a role in policy creation, as evidenced by the appointment of Dame Wendy Hall to the United Nations' advisory body on artificial intelligence. A variety of websites and resources can help explore issues for international and global organizations.
Policy Brief Structure & Elements
- Policy briefs are concise, standalone documents focusing on a specific issue, summarizing evidence, highlighting solutions, and suggesting policy changes.
- Policy briefs are written for non-specialists.
- They often follow a structured format, including a summary of key points, policy recommendations, a wider context, quotes or visuals, author background, and links to further reading.
- Policy briefs should contain clear, accessible language, avoiding jargon or emotive language. They should be concise, easy to understand, and focus on providing actionable solutions.
- Policy briefs should have a clear, well-defined structure (e.g., with clear sections), and key messages should be presented up front.
- Recommendations are what the author thinks should happen, whereas implications outline the expected policy changes following a recommendation.
- Writing a policy brief requires understanding the target audience (policymakers), their likely questions, and any existing perspectives on the issue.
- Effective policy briefs have a clear and concise aim, such as changing/revising a policy, raising awareness about an issue, or persuading the audience about the urgency of a problem and need for change.
- The brief should also consider the wider context, cost implications, the impacts on people, and what regions are most affected.
Dissemination and Engagement
- Policy briefs can be distributed through various channels (e.g., websites, social media, meetings, presentations).
- Building a profile through social media can help policymakers discover your expertise and engagement with relevant topics.
- Engage policymakers in person, or via roundtables, webinars, or seminars.
- Any correspondence sent requires a compelling, clear request.
- Use social media channels for dissemination, and building an online presence.
- It is important to identify and analyze stakeholders, and to create tailored strategies for each target audience.
Considerations for Policymakers
- Policymakers face deadlines, the need to understand the bigger picture, and the importance of real-world implications.
- Policymakers are influenced by emerging issues, the pace of change, issues in relation to implementation, their values, any pre-existing views, research requirements, financial limitations, and potential consequences.
- When considering a new policy, policymakers may focus on real-world problems, timing, pace of change, implementation, emerging issues, research requirements, budget constraints, and relevant values.
Structuring a Successful Engagement Strategy
- A successful strategy typically involves comprehensive research, a well-defined purpose, and effective communication.
- Comprehensive research (i.e., examining white and green papers, government reports, parliamentary inquiries, Hansard library materials, and third-sector/NGO reports, public discourse, media and public opinion) is needed to support your suggestions.
- A strong approach analyzes political contexts, current realities, and any competing narratives, frames the issue clearly, shows the need for change, and highlights the advantages of your proposals. The proposal should offer realistic solutions with practical implementations.
- Policy briefs are one tool within a broader engagement strategy. Effective strategies are not limited to single channels, but a combination of approaches. Effective engagement focuses on understanding the audience, identifying best practices, and maintaining ongoing communication with them.
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.