8.5 Coalescent Theory: Gene Trees and Genealogies

Choose a study mode

Play Quiz
Study Flashcards
Spaced Repetition
Chat to Lesson

Podcast

Listen to an AI-generated conversation about this lesson
Download our mobile app to listen on the go
Get App

Questions and Answers

What is the primary focus of coalescent theory?

  • Examining the genealogical relationships of gene copies within a population to understand drift. (correct)
  • Predicting the future allele frequencies in a population.
  • Analyzing the effects of natural selection on phenotypic traits.
  • Modeling the migration patterns of different species.

How do gene trees differ from species trees or population trees?

  • Species trees are hypothetical models, while gene trees are based on empirical observations.
  • Gene trees are constructed using morphological data, while species trees rely on genetic sequence data.
  • Gene trees depict the genealogical relationships for a single locus, while species trees represent the branching descent of species or populations. (correct)
  • Gene trees represent the evolutionary history of multiple species, while species trees focus on a single gene.

In the context of coalescent theory, what does the term 'coalescent point' refer to?

  • The specific location where different populations of a species intersect.
  • The ancestral gene copy from which two or more distinct gene copies are descended. (correct)
  • The point in time when a population experiences its maximum size.
  • The point in the genome where mutations are most likely to occur.

Consider a population of diploid organisms. According to coalescent theory, what happens when tracing the ancestry of gene copies backward in time?

<p>Gene copies coalesce, meaning they are derived from the same ancestral gene copy. (A)</p>
Signup and view all the answers

What is a major advantage of the coalescent approach in population genetics?

<p>It is amenable to mathematical modeling, allowing for quantitative analysis of genetic drift. (B)</p>
Signup and view all the answers

What is the approximate probability that any particular pair of gene copies shares a common ancestor in the previous generation in a Wright-Fisher population of N diploid individuals?

<p>$1/(2N)$ (C)</p>
Signup and view all the answers

In a neutral coalescent model for a diploid Wright-Fisher population of size N, what is the average time to coalescence for a randomly chosen pair of gene copies?

<p>2N generations. (A)</p>
Signup and view all the answers

In the coalescent process for a neutral locus, where do most of the coalescent events between pairs of gene copies occur?

<p>Shortly before the present. (D)</p>
Signup and view all the answers

How does population size affect coalescent times?

<p>Coalescence occurs more rapidly in small populations compared to large populations. (B)</p>
Signup and view all the answers

What does the 'bugs-in-a-box' metaphor represent in the context of coalescent theory?

<p>A stochastic process that runs forward in time, analogous to coalescence. (C)</p>
Signup and view all the answers

In the 'bugs-in-a-box' metaphor, what does the act of one bug eating another represent?

<p>A coalescent event. (A)</p>
Signup and view all the answers

Consider a neutral locus in a population. How do allelic differences arise among a set of gene copies?

<p>Allelic differences arise by mutation subsequent to the coalescent point for the set of gene copies. (D)</p>
Signup and view all the answers

If all the gene copies in a population coalesce recently, what can be inferred about the total amount of genetic variation in the population?

<p>The amount of variation will be lower. (C)</p>
Signup and view all the answers

For a neutral locus, what two separate processes determine the distribution of variation?

<p>The coalescent tree formation and the mutation process along the coalescent tree. (D)</p>
Signup and view all the answers

How does the strength of genetic drift relate to the coalescent time at a neutral locus?

<p>Stronger drift leads to a more recent coalescent time. (A)</p>
Signup and view all the answers

If two randomly selected alleles are separated by an average of 4N generations and the mutation rate is μ per locus per generation, how many mutations are expected to differentiate the alleles on average?

<p>4Nμ. (B)</p>
Signup and view all the answers

What can researchers infer from coalescent times obtained from patterns of genetic variation?

<p>Historical demographic parameters such as population size over time. (A)</p>
Signup and view all the answers

How does positive selection influence the coalescent time of a new allele?

<p>It leads to a more recent coalescent time. (A)</p>
Signup and view all the answers

Why do alleles under balancing selection often have coalescent points further in the past compared to neutral or positively selected alleles?

<p>Balancing selection maintains multiple alleles in the population for an extended period. (C)</p>
Signup and view all the answers

Consider a population where a new allele arises and is subject to positive selection. What is the expected effect on neutral variation at the locus under selection?

<p>Decreased neutral variation due to a more recent coalescent point. (D)</p>
Signup and view all the answers

In a population experiencing balancing selection at a particular locus, what is the expected long-term outcome regarding the alleles under selection?

<p>The alleles will persist in a balanced polymorphism for an extended period. (A)</p>
Signup and view all the answers

Which of the following scenarios will most likely lead to a gene genealogy with a coalescent point far from the present?

<p>A new allele arises and is maintained by balancing selection. (D)</p>
Signup and view all the answers

If a researcher observes a locus with significantly less neutral variation than expected under neutrality, what evolutionary force is most likely acting on that locus?

<p>Positive selection. (B)</p>
Signup and view all the answers

How can researchers use coalescent models to learn about the demographic history of a population?

<p>By analyzing current levels of genetic variation to infer coalescent times. (C)</p>
Signup and view all the answers

Which of the following statements best describes the relationship between gene trees and species trees?

<p>A gene tree often provides a good approximation for a species tree, but gene trees for different loci will not necessarily agree with one another or with the species tree. (A)</p>
Signup and view all the answers

In the context of coalescent theory, what is the significance of the shape of the coalescent tree?

<p>It reflects the demographic history and selective pressures experienced by the population. (D)</p>
Signup and view all the answers

Suppose a population of lizards on an isolated island has 250 diploid individuals. According to coalescent theory, approximately how many generations would it take, on average, for two randomly chosen gene copies at a neutral locus to coalesce?

<p>500 generations. (B)</p>
Signup and view all the answers

Consider a locus in a population of birds. Researchers find evidence that a particular allele at this locus is under balancing selection. How would this affect their interpretation of the locus's gene genealogy?

<p>The gene genealogy would show a more distant coalescent point. (B)</p>
Signup and view all the answers

In a theoretical population that perfectly fits the Wright-Fisher model, a scientist samples 10 gene copies from a large population (N) of diploid individuals. The probability that any particular pair of these gene copies shares a common ancestor in the immediate previous generation is approximately 1/(2N). Given this, which one of the following accurately describes the likelihood of multiple coalescent events occurring simultaneously?

<p>Very small, assuming N is large and k &lt;&lt; N, making the simultaneous occurrence of multiple coalescent negligible. (A)</p>
Signup and view all the answers

Suppose a scientist is studying two populations of fish. Population A has a constant size of 1,000 diploid individuals, while population B has a constant size of 500 diploid individuals. According to coalescent theory, what differences would the scientist expect to observe in the coalescent trees of these two populations?

<p>Population B's coalescent tree would show a more recent coalescent time. (D)</p>
Signup and view all the answers

Imagine a population of beetles where a new allele arises that confers resistance to a common pesticide. This allele quickly spreads through the population due to strong positive selection. According to coalescent theory, what would you expect to observe at the locus of this resistance allele, compared to a neutral locus in the same population?

<p>Reduced genetic diversity due to a more recent coalescent point. (D)</p>
Signup and view all the answers

Scientists are studying a gene in wild tomatoes. They find that two distinct alleles at this gene have persisted in the population for a very long time, with neither allele reaching fixation. Which evolutionary force is most likely responsible for this pattern, and how would it affect the gene genealogy at this locus?

<p>Balancing selection; the gene genealogy would show a more distant coalescent point. (D)</p>
Signup and view all the answers

Researchers are investigating a newly discovered population of butterflies. They analyze the genetic variation at several neutral loci and use coalescent models to estimate the historical population size. Based on this analysis, they conclude that the population experienced a severe bottleneck event in the past. What would be the most likely signature of this bottleneck in the coalescent trees of these loci?

<p>Reduced genetic diversity and a more recent coalescent point. (A)</p>
Signup and view all the answers

In applying coalescent theory to analyze the genetic history of a population, what critical assumption must be met to effectively separate the genealogical process from the mutational process at a given locus?

<p>The locus must be selectively neutral, ensuring that allele states do not influence genealogical descent. (C)</p>
Signup and view all the answers

Consider a scenario where a researcher aims to use coalescent theory to infer past demographic changes in a population of migratory birds, focusing on a set of neutral loci. However, gene flow between this population and a neighboring one is suspected but not well quantified. How might unmodeled gene flow influence the accuracy of coalescent-based demographic inferences?

<p>It could distort estimates of coalescent times, potentially leading to inaccurate inferences about population bottlenecks or expansions. (C)</p>
Signup and view all the answers

Two research groups are studying the same population of penguins, but analyze different sets of genetic markers. Group A focuses on microsatellites, which have a high mutation rate, while Group B examines single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs), with a much lower mutation rate. How might this difference in marker choice affect their coalescent-based analyses of the penguin population's history?

<p>Group A would likely infer systematically older coalescent times compared to Group B, due to the faster accumulation of mutations. (D)</p>
Signup and view all the answers

What is the primary application of gene trees in the context of coalescent theory?

<p>To understand the process of genetic drift in populations by examining the genealogical relationships of a single locus. (A)</p>
Signup and view all the answers

In coalescent theory, what does tracing the ancestry of gene copies backward in time reveal?

<p>That gene copies coalesce, meaning they are derived from a common ancestral gene copy. (D)</p>
Signup and view all the answers

What does a coalescent tree represent?

<p>The branching pattern of relatedness among gene copies in a population. (B)</p>
Signup and view all the answers

In a mathematical model of the coalescent process for a neutral locus, what does the model primarily predict?

<p>The distribution of times until coalescence and the distribution of gene tree topologies. (D)</p>
Signup and view all the answers

Consider a neutral locus in a large Wright-Fisher population of N diploid individuals. What is the chance that any particular pair of gene copies shares a common ancestor in the previous generation?

<p>1/(2N) (C)</p>
Signup and view all the answers

In the coalescent process for a neutral locus, where do most of the coalescent events between pairs of gene copies occur relative to the present?

<p>Mostly close to the present. (A)</p>
Signup and view all the answers

How does population size affect coalescent times, assuming a Wright-Fisher population of constant size?

<p>Smaller populations have shorter coalescent times. (A)</p>
Signup and view all the answers

In the 'bugs-in-a-box' metaphor, what does a coalescent event correspond to?

<p>One bug eating another bug. (C)</p>
Signup and view all the answers

According to coalescent theory, how do allelic differences arise among a set of gene copies at the same locus?

<p>By mutation subsequent to the coalescent point for the set of gene copies. (B)</p>
Signup and view all the answers

Researchers can infer coalescent times from patterns of genetic variation and thereby estimate which historical demographic parameters?

<p>Historical demographic parameters such as population size over time. (B)</p>
Signup and view all the answers

How does positive selection influence the coalescent time of a new allele compared to a neutral allele?

<p>Positive selection leads to a more recent coalescent time. (D)</p>
Signup and view all the answers

What does the randomness associated with the particular genealogical history and the randomness associated with where mutations arise along this coalescent tree contribute to?

<p>The pattern of variation that we see at a neutral locus. (B)</p>
Signup and view all the answers

In a population that perfectly fits the Wright-Fisher model, a scientist is studying two neutral loci, Locus A and Locus B. Locus A exhibits a higher level of genetic diversity than Locus B. According to coalescent theory, what inference can be made regarding the effective population size experienced at these loci?

<p>Locus A has experienced a larger effective population size than Locus B. (D)</p>
Signup and view all the answers

Flashcards

Coalescent Theory

An approach that integrates phylogenetic thinking with population genetics to understand drift and variation.

Species Trees/Population Trees

Historical patterns of branching descent for a group of species or populations.

Gene Trees

Genealogical relationships for a single locus.

Coalescent Point

A point where two or more distinct gene copies are descended from the same ancestral gene copy.

Signup and view all the flashcards

Coalescent Tree

The branching pattern of relatedness among gene copies in a population.

Signup and view all the flashcards

Mathematical Model of Coalescent Process

A model that tells us the distribution of times until coalescence and also the distribution of gene tree topologies that arise at a neutral locus.

Signup and view all the flashcards

Average Time to Coalescence

The average time to coalescence for any randomly chosen pair of gene copies in a diploid Wright–Fisher population of size N.

Signup and view all the flashcards

Bugs-in-a-Box Metaphor

A metaphor for thinking about coalescence as a stochastic process where bugs eat each other until only one remains.

Signup and view all the flashcards

Allelic Differences and Coalescence

Differences among a set of gene copies must have arisen by mutation after the coalescent point.

Signup and view all the flashcards

Coalescent Process for Neutral Locus

Can be separated into the genealogical history and the mutational process.

Signup and view all the flashcards

Sources of Randomness in Variation

The randomness associated with the genealogical history, and the randomness associated with where mutations arise along this coalescent tree.

Signup and view all the flashcards

Effect of Selection on Coalescent Trees

Drives alleles quickly to fixation, leading to a more recent coalescent time.

Signup and view all the flashcards

Positive Selection

Natural selection quickly drives the new allele to fixation

Signup and view all the flashcards

Balancing Selection

Two alleles both persist indefinitely in a balanced polymorphism

Signup and view all the flashcards

Study Notes

Coalescent Theory

  • Integrates phylogenetic thinking with population genetics to understand drift and its influence on variation.
  • Examines genealogical relationships within a population to track gene copy spread and observe drift in action.

From Species Trees to Gene Trees

  • Species/population trees represent historical branching of species or populations.
  • Gene trees represent genealogical relationships for a single locus.
  • Gene trees infer descent with modification at a specific locus.
  • Phylogenies built from single genetic loci are gene trees, reflecting the history of that gene, not necessarily the population.
  • Gene trees may differ from species trees, and phylogenetic methods find species trees most consistent with multiple gene trees.

Gene Genealogies

  • Genealogical diagrams show which gene copy derived from which ancestral copy.
  • Focus is on genealogy of genes, not individuals, so the individual in which the gene resides is ignored.
  • Gene copies coalesce when two or more distinct copies descend from the same ancestral copy.
  • The coalescent point is the most recent common ancestor of specified gene copies.
  • Coalescent trees show the branching pattern of relatedness among gene copies in a population.

Dynamics of the Coalescent Process

  • Coalescent approach allows for mathematical modeling, treating genealogy as a stochastic process backward in time.
  • With k gene copies sampled from N diploid individuals, the probability of any pair sharing a common ancestor in the previous generation is 1/2N.
  • Probability of a coalescent event occurring in a single generation is approximately k(k– 1)/4N.
  • The average waiting time for the first coalescent event is 4N/(k[k– 1]).
  • The average time to coalescence for any randomly chosen pair of gene copies is 2N generations.
  • The average time to coalescence of a larger group of gene copies is approximately 4N generations.
  • Most coalescent events occur "early," or shortly before the present.
  • The expected time for the population to coalesce down to two parental lineages is 2N generations.
  • The final coalescent event between two lineages takes on average another 2N generations.
  • Coalescent times are averages, with substantial variation around the mean, leading to different loci having different coalescent times.
  • Coalescent times depend on population demography; smaller populations coalesce faster than larger ones.

The Bugs in a Box Analogy

  • This metaphor uses cannibalistic bugs in a box to explain the coalescent process running forward in time.
  • Bugs represent gene copies, and one bug eating another represents a coalescent event.
  • The process continues until only one bug remains, signifying complete population coalescence.
  • Cannibalism occurs more rapidly early on when there are many bugs, analogous to early coalescent events.
  • The time until only one bug remains varies due to randomness.

The Coalescent Process and Genetic Variation

  • Allelic differences among gene copies arise by mutation after their coalescent point.
  • Knowing the coalescent tree shape and mutation locations reveals variation in the current population.
  • The deeper the coalescent point, the more variation is expected in the population.
  • The genealogical history of a neutral locus can be separated from the mutational process.

Neutral Alleles and Genetic Variation

  • Variation at a neutral locus results from two processes: coalescent tree formation and mutation along the tree branches.
  • For neutral loci, gene copies are equally likely to leave descendants, regardless of allelic state.
  • Coalescent process indicates the strength of genetic drift in eliminating genetic variation.
  • Small populations have more recent coalescent times and less variation.
  • The pattern of variation is influenced by randomness in genealogical history (coalescent tree) and mutation occurrence on the tree.

Mathematical Relationships

  • With random alleles separated by 4N generations and a mutation rate of μ, expect 4Nμ mutations.
  • Variation around this average is due to randomness in genealogical history and the mutation process.
  • Coalescent models infer coalescent times from genetic variation, estimating historical demographic parameters like population size.

Selection and Coalescent Gene Trees

  • Selective processes influence the shape of coalescent trees.
  • Selection drives alleles quickly to fixation, leading to a more recent coalescent time.
  • Neutral alleles drift to fixation, but most are lost.
  • Positively selected alleles quickly replace others, creating a more recent coalescent point, thus less neutral variation.
  • Balancing selection, like overdominance, maintains polymorphisms, leading to a coalescent point further in the past.

Studying That Suits You

Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.

Quiz Team

More Like This

Tree Growth Manipulation Study
8 questions

Tree Growth Manipulation Study

SimplerPersonification avatar
SimplerPersonification
Gene Expression and Protein Synthesis
71 questions
Gene Expression-Transcription POGIL Flashcards
27 questions
Molecular Biology of the Gene Study Notes
26 questions
Use Quizgecko on...
Browser
Browser